In situ bipolar electroporation for localized cell loading with reporter dyes and investigating gap junctional coupling

Electroporation is generally used to transfect cells in suspension, but the technique can also be applied to load a defined zone of adherent cells with substances that normally do not permeate the plasma membrane. In this case a pulsed high-frequency oscillating electric field is applied over a small two-wire electrode positioned close to the cells. We compared unipolar with bipolar electroporation pulse protocols and found that the latter were ideally suited to efficiently load a narrow longitudinal strip of cells in monolayer cultures. We further explored this property to determine whether electroporation loading was useful to investigate the extent of dye spread between cells coupled by gap junctions, using wild-type and stably transfected C6 glioma cells expressing connexin 32 or 43. Our investigations show that the spatial spread of electroporation-loaded 6-carboxyfluorescein, as quantified by the standard deviation of Gaussian dye spread or the spatial constant of exponential dye spread, was a reliable approach to investigate the degree of cell-cell coupling. The spread of reporter dye between coupled cells was significantly larger with electroporation loading than with scrape loading, a widely used method for dye-coupling studies. We conclude that electroporation loading and dye transfer is a robust technique to investigate gap-junctional coupling that combines minimal cell damage with accurate probing of the degree of cell-cell communication.     

Decreasing the thresholds for electroporation by sensitizing cells with local cationic anesthetics and substances that decrease the surface negative electric charge

The recently described method of cell electroporation by flow of cell suspension through localized direct current electric fields (dcEFs) was applied to identify non-toxic substances that could sensitize cells to external electric fields. We found that local cationic anesthetics such as procaine, lidocaine and tetracaine greatly facilitated the electroporation of AT2 rat prostate carcinoma cells and human skin fibroblasts (HSF). This manifested as a 50% reduction in the strength of the electric field required to induce cell death by irreversible electroporation or to introduce fluorescent dyes such as calcein, carboxyfluorescein or Lucifer yellow into the cells. A similar decrease in the electric field thresholds for irreversible and reversible cell electroporation was observed when the cells were exposed to the electric field in the presence of the non-toxic cationic dyes 9-aminoacridine (9-AAA) or toluidine blue. Identifying non-toxic, reversibly acting cell sensitizers may facilitate cancer tissue ablation and help introduce therapeutic or diagnostic substances into the cells and tissues.     

Effective conductivity of a suspension of permeabilized cells: a theoretical analysis

During the electroporation cell membrane undergoes structural changes, which increase the membrane conductivity and consequently lead to a change in effective conductivity of a cell suspension. To correlate microscopic membrane changes to macroscopic changes in conductivity of a suspension, we analyzed the effective conductivity theoretically, using two different approaches: numerically, using the finite elements method; and analytically, by using the equivalence principle. We derived the equation, which connects membrane conductivity with effective conductivity of the cell suspension. The changes in effective conductivity were analyzed for different parameters: cell volume fraction, membrane and medium conductivity, critical transmembrane potential, and cell orientation. In our analysis we used a tensor form of the effective conductivity, thus taking into account the anisotropic nature of the cell electropermeabilization and rotation of the cells. To determine the effect of cell rotation, as questioned by some authors, the difference between conductivity of a cell suspension with normally distributed orientations and parallel orientation was also calculated, and determined to be <10%. The presented theory provides a theoretical basis for the analysis of measurements of the effective conductivity during electroporation.     

Reversible and irreversible electroporation of cell suspensions flowing through a localized DC electric field

Experiments on reversible and irreversible cell electroporation were carried out with an experimental setup based on a standard apparatus for horizontal electrophoresis, a syringe pump with regulated cell suspension flow velocity and a dcEF power supply. Cells in suspension flowing through an orifice in a barrier inserted into the electrophoresis apparatus were exposed to defined localized dcEFs in the range of 0–1000 V/cm for a selected duration in the range 10–1000 ms. This method permitted the determination of the viability of irreversibly electroperforated cells. It also showed that the uptake by reversibly electroperforated cells of fluorescent dyes (calcein, carboxyfluorescein, Alexa Fluor 488 Phalloidin), which otherwise do not penetrate cell membranes, was dependent upon the dcEF strength and duration in any given single electrical field exposure. The method yields reproducible results, makes it easy to load large volumes of cell suspensions with membrane non-penetrating substances, and permits the elimination of irreversibly electroporated cells of diameter greater than desired. The results concur with and elaborate on those in earlier reports on cell electroporation in commercially available electroporators. They proved once more that the observed cell perforation does not depend upon the thermal effects of the electric current upon cells. In addition, the method eliminates many of the limitations of commercial electroporators and disposable electroporation chambers. It permits the optimization of conditions in which reversible and irreversible electroporation are separated. Over 90% of reversibly electroporated cells remain viable after one short (less than 400 ms) exposure to the localized dcEF. Experiments were conducted with the AT-2 cancer prostate cell line, human skin fibroblasts and human red blood cells, but they could be run with suspensions of any cell type. It is postulated that the described method could be useful for many purposes in biotechnology and biomedicine and could help optimize conditions for in vivo use of both reversible and irreversible electroporation.     

Rapid optimization of electroporation conditions for plant cells,protoplasts, and pollen

The optimization of electroporation conditions for maximal uptake of DNA during direct gene transfer experiments is critical to achieve high levels of gene expression in transformed plant cells. Two stains, trypan blue and fluorescein diacetate, have been applied to optimize electroporation conditions for three plant cell types, using different square wave and exponential wave electroporation devices. The different cell types included protoplasts from tobacco, a stable mixotrophic suspension cell culture from soybean with intact cell walls, and germinating pollen from alfalfa and tobacco. Successful electroporation of each of these cell types was obtained, even in the presence of an intact cell wall when conditions were optimized for the electroporation pulse. The optimal field strength for each of these cells differs, protoplasts having the lowest optimal pulse field strength, followed by suspension cells and finally germinating pollen requiring the strongest electroporation pulse. A rapid procedure is described for optimizing electroporation parameters using different types of cells from different plant sources.     

High-efficiency loading, transfection, and fusion of cells by electroporation in two-phase polymer systems.

A method to concentrate drugs, DNA, or other materials with target cells in two-phase polymer systems for high-efficiency electroloading is described. The two-phase polymer system is utilized for cell and loading material selection, as well as for cell aggregation before electrofusion. The phase mixing of several water-soluble polymers is characterized, and the polyethylene glycol-Dextran (PEG m.w. 8,000 + Dextran m.w. 71,000) mixture is selected to illustrate the advantage of the two-phase systems. Fluorescently labeled Dextran or DNA is loaded into Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) and JTL cells, using electroporation in either the two-phase polymer system or the conventional single-phase suspension. The loading efficiency is 4 to 30 times higher for the two-phase system, with the best advantage at lower applied field range. Transfections of CHO, COS, Melan C, and JTL lymphoid cells using pSV-beta-galactosidase (for CHO and COS), pBK-RSV-tyrosinase, and pCP4-fucosidase plasmids, respectively, by electroporation in the two-phase polymer system and the conventional single-phase electroporation method, are compared. The former method is far superior to the latter in terms of efficiency. The threshold and optimal field strengths for the former are significantly lower than those for the latter method, so the former method is more favorable in terms of equipment requirement and safety. Electrofusion efficiency in the two-phase system is comparable to that in polyethylene glycol suspension alone and is a significant improvement from the conventional electrofusion method with dielectrophoresis. The two-phase polymer method is, therefore, a valuable technique for gene delivery to a limited cell source, as in ex vivo gene therapy.     

Comparison of plasmid DNA versus PCR amplified gene of insert DNA for nucleofection in Kasumi-1 cells

Plasmid electroporation, or its optimized version nucleofection, is an important technique for gene transfection of cells in suspension. However, substantial cell death and/or low transfection efficiency are still common for some cell lines. By using enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) as a reporter, we compared the use of PCR amplified EGFP (PaEGFP) and its parental plasmid (pEGFP-N2) for nucleofection in Kasumi-1 cells. We found that PaEGFP induced significantly lower cell death but had similar transfection efficiency compared to its parent plasmid (pEGFP-N2). Most importantly, contrary to the pEGFP-N2-nucleofected cells, the PaEGFP-nucleofected cells subsequently grew properly. Tests in other cell lines also implied that PaEGFP indeed induced consistently less cell death, but transfection efficiencies varied, being good in suspension cell lines but lower in adhesive cell lines. We suggest that direct transfection with PCR amplified genes can be a simple and useful approach for optimization of electropulse-based transfection not only of Kasumi-1 cells, but also may be useful for other cell lines that are difficult to transfect in suspension.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s10616-013-9683-y) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

High-efficiency gene transfection by in situ electroporation of cultured cells

It is demonstrated in this study that high-efficiency gene transfection can be obtained by directly electroporating cultured mammalian cells in their attached state using a pulsed radio-frequency (RF) electric field. A plasmid DNA containing the reporter gene beta-gal was introduced into COS-M6 cells and CV-1 cells using this in situ electroporation method. At the optimal electric field strength (1.2 kV/cm), we found that over 80% of the M6 cells took up and expressed the beta-gal gene with a cell survival rate of about 50%. In contrast, the transfection efficiency was less than 20% when the M6 cells were electroporated in suspension. It was shown that CV-1 cells could also be electroporated highly efficiently using the in situ method. Furthermore, we have measured the time required to express the beta-gal gene after the plasmid DNA was introduced. We found that the percentage of cells expressing beta-gal reached a peak value about 10 h after electroporation. This time-course was the same for both attached and suspended cells, suggesting that the observed difference in transfection efficiency was mainly the result of effects of the detachment treatment on the electroporation process rather than on the gene expression.     

Use of electroporation to introduce biologically active foreign genes into primary rat hepatocytes.

A method is described for introducing and expressing cloned genes in isolated hepatocytes. Primary rat hepatocytes isolated by collagenase perfusion were transfected in suspension with plasmid pSV2CAT by electroporation. Forty-eight hours later, soluble extracts from transfected hepatocytes showed chloramphenicol acetyltransferase activity comparable to that obtained in rat hepatoma cell line H4AzC2 by calcium phosphate or DEAE-dextran transfection. The latter two methods could not be used successfully for primary hepatocytes because of cytotoxicity of these reagents. This indicates that electroporation is a useful method to obtain transient expression of foreign genes in primary epithelial cells, such as rat hepatocytes, which are difficult to maintain in cell culture.     

Assessment of electroporation by flow cytometry

BACKGROUND: Electroporation accomplishes transient permeabilization of cells and thus aids in the uptake of drugs. The method has been employed clinically in the treatment of dermatological tumors with bleomycin. The conditions of electroporation are still largely empirical and information is lacking as to the interrelationships among voltage pulse height, pulse number and toxicity, cell permeation, drug uptake, and effects on drug toxicity. We used propidium iodide (PI) and flow cytometry to define cell permeation into cytoplasmic and nuclear compartments to determine the improvements of drug toxicity that can be accomplished by electroporation. METHODS: Human squamous carcinoma cells of defined TP53 status and normal human epithelial cells were subjected to electroporation using a square wave pulse generator in the range of 0-5,000 V/cm. Flow cytometry served to establish entry of the drug reporter, PI, into the cytoplasm and nucleus. A dye staining method served to establish cell survival and to determine the toxicity of bleomycin alone, electroporation alone, and electroporation with bleomycin. RESULTS: The electric field intensity (EFI) required to produce 50% permeabilization (EP(50)) is cell type dependent. The EP(50) varied from 1,465 to 2,027 V/cm. An EFI below 900 V/cm is growth stimulatory whereas an EFI in excess of 1,000 V/cm is growth inhibitory. An EFI of 1,000 V/cm is sufficient to increase bleomycin toxicity by a factor of 2-3. A differential electroporation efficiency is observed between normal and tumor cells. CONCLUSIONS: Tumor cells can be targeted preferentially at electroporation voltages where normal cells are less permeable.     

Single-cell electroporation

Electroporation is a widely used method for the introduction of polar and charged agents such as dyes, drugs, DNA, RNA, proteins, peptides, and amino acids into cells. Traditionally, electroporation is performed with large electrodes in a batch mode for treatment of a large number of cells in suspension. Recently, microelectrodes that can produce extremely localized electric fields, such as solid carbon fiber microelectrodes, electrolyte-filled capillaries and micropipettes as well as chip-based microfabricated electrode arrays, have proven useful to electroporate single cells and subcellular structures. Single-cell electroporation opens up a new window of opportunities in manipulating the genetic, metabolic, and synthetic contents of single targeted cells in tissue slices, cell cultures, in microfluidic channels or at specific loci on a chip-based device.     

Design and Implementation of a Microelectrode Assembly for Use on Noncontact In Situ Electroporation of Adherent Cells

In situ electroporation of adherent cells provides significant advantages with respect to electroporation systems for suspension cells, such as causing minimal stress to cultured cells and simplifying and saving several steps within the process. In this study, a new electrode assembly design is shown and applied to in situ electroporate adherent cell lines growing in standard multiwell plates. We designed an interdigitated array of electrodes patterned on copper with printed circuit board technology and covered with nickel/gold. Small interelectrode distances were used to achieve effective electroporation with low voltages. Epoxy-based microseparators were constructed to avoid direct contact with the cells and to create more uniform electric fields. The device was successful in the electropermeabilization of two different adherent cell lines, C2C12 and HEK 293, as assessed by the intracellular delivery of the fluorescent dextran FD20S. Additionally, as a collateral effect, we observed cell electrofusion in HEK 293 cells, thus making this device also useful for performing cell fusion. In summary, we show the effectiveness of this minimally invasive device for electroporation of adherent cells cultured in standard multiwell plates. The cheap technologies used in the fabrication process of the electrode assembly indicate potential use as a low-cost, disposable device.     

Tissue electroporation: quantification and analysis of heterogeneous transport in multicellular environments

Although electroporation is gaining increased attention as a technology to enhance clinical chemotherapy and gene therapy of tissues, direct measurements of electroporation-mediated transport in multicellular environments are lacking. In this study, we used multicellular tumor spheroids of DU145 prostate cancer cells as a model tissue to measure the levels and distribution of molecular uptake in a multicellular environment as a function of electrical and other parameters. These measurements, and subsequent analysis, were used to test the hypothesis that cells in a multicellular environment respond to electroporation in a heterogeneous manner that differs from isolated cells in suspension due to differences in cell state, local solute concentration, and local electric field. In support of the hypothesis, molecular uptake was consistently lower for cells within spheroids than cells in dilute suspension and was spatially heterogeneous, with progressively less uptake observed for cells located deeper within spheroid interiors. Reduced uptake and heterogeneity can be explained quantitatively by accounting for the effects of cell size on transmembrane voltage and cell volume, limited extracellular solute reservoir, heterogeneous field strength due to influence of neighboring cells, and diffusional lag times.     

In vivo single-cell electroporation for transfer of DNA and macromolecules

Single-cell electroporation allows transfection of plasmid DNA or macromolecules into individual living cells using modified patch electrodes and common electrophysiological equipment. This protocol is optimized for rapid in vivo electroporation of Xenopus laevis tadpole brains with DNA, dextrans, morpholinos and combinations thereof. Experienced users can electroporate roughly 40 tadpoles per hour. The technique can be adapted for use with other charged transfer materials and in other systems and tissues where cells can be targeted with a micropipette. Under visual guidance, an electrode filled with transfer material is placed in a cell body-rich area of the tadpole brain and a train of voltage pulses applied, which electroporates a nearby cell. We show examples of successfully electroporated single cells, instances of common problems and troubleshooting suggestions. Single-cell electroporation is an affordable method to fluorescently label and genetically manipulate individual cells. This powerful technique enables observation of single cells in an otherwise normal environment.     

Targeting the kinesin Eg5 to monitor siRNA transfection in mammalian cells

RNA interference, the inhibition of gene expression by double-stranded RNA, provides a powerful tool for functional studies once the sequence of a gene is known. In most mammalian cells, only short molecules can be used because long ones induce the interferon pathway. With the identification of a proper target sequence, the penetration of the oligonucleotides constitutes the most serious limitation in the application of this technique. Here we show that a small interfering RNA (siRNA) targeting the mRNA of the kinesin Eg5 induces a rapid mitotic arrest and provides a convenient assay for the optimization of siRNA transfection. Thus, dose responses can be established for different transfection techniques, highlighting the great differences in response to transfection techniques of various cell types. We report that the calcium phosphate precipitation technique can be an efficient and cost-effective alternative to Oligofectamine in some adherent cells, while electroporation can be efficient for some cells growing in suspension such as hematopoietic cells and some adherent cells. Significantly, the optimal parameters for the electroporation of siRNA differ from those for plasmids, allowing the use of milder conditions that induce less cell toxicity. In summary, a single siRNA leading to an easily assayed phenotype can be used to monitor the transfection of siRNA into any type of proliferating cells of both human and murine origin.     

Transient expression of fluorescent fusion proteins in protoplasts of suspension cultured cells

Transient expression of fluorescent fusion proteins in plant cells has dramatically facilitated our study of newly identified genes and proteins. This protocol details an in vivo transient expression system to study the subcellular localization and dynamic associations of plant proteins using protoplasts freshly prepared from Arabidopsis or tobacco BY-2 suspension cultured cells. The method relies on the transformation of DNA constructs into protoplasts via electroporation. The whole protocol is comprised of three major stages: protoplast generation and purification, transformation of DNA into protoplasts via electroporation and incubation of protoplasts for protein analysis. Similar to stably transformed cell lines, transformed protoplasts are compatible with protein localization studies, pharmaceutical drug treatment and western blot analysis. This protocol can be completed within 11-24 h from protoplast production to protein detection.     

Optimizing Electroporation Conditions in Primary and Other Difficult-to-Transfect Cells

Electroporation is a valuable tool for nucleic acid delivery because it can be used for a wide variety of cell types. Many scientists are shifting toward the use of cell types that are more relevant to in vivo applications, including primary cells, which are considered difficult to transfect. The ability to electroporate these cell types with nucleic acid molecules of interest at a relatively high efficiency while maintaining cell viability is essential for elucidating the pathway(s) in which a gene product is involved. We present data demonstrating that by optimizing electroporation parameters, nucleic acid molecules can be delivered in a highly efficient manner. We display transfection results for primary and difficult-to-transfect cell types including human primary fibroblasts, human umbilical vein endothelial cells, Jurkat cells, and two neuroblastoma cell lines [SK-N-SH (human) and Neuro-2A (mouse)] with plasmid DNAs and siRNAs. Our data demonstrate that by determining proper electroporation conditions, glyceraldehyde phosphate dehydrogenase mRNA was silenced in Jurkat cells when compared with negative control siRNA electroporations as early as 4 h post-transfection. Other experiments demonstrated that optimized electroporation conditions using a fluorescently labeled transfection control siRNA resulted in 75% transfection efficiency for Neuro-2A, 93% for human primary fibroblasts, and 94% for HUVEC cells, as analyzed by flow cytometry.     

Localized electroporation: a method for targeting expression of genes in avian embryos

Avian embryos are a popular model for cell and developmental biologists. However, analysis of gene function in living embryos has been hampered by difficulties in targeting the expression of exogenous genes. We have developed a method for localized electroporation that overcomes some of the limitations of current techniques. We use a double-barreled suction electrode, backfilled with a solution containing a plasmid-encoding green fluorescent protein (GFP) and a neurophysiological stimulator to electroporate small populations of cells in living embryos. As many as 600 cells express GFP 24-48 h after electroporation. The number of cells that express GFP depends on the number of trains, the pulse frequency and the voltage. Surface epithelial cells and cells deep to the point of electroporation express GFP. No deformities result from electroporations, and neurons, neural crest, head mesenchyme, lens and otic placode cells have been transfected. This method overcomes some of the disadvantages of viral techniques, lipofection and in vivo electroporation. The method will be useful to biologists interested in tracing cell lineage or making genetic mosaic avian embryos.     

Optimized delivery of fluorescently labeled proteins in live bacteria using electroporation

Studying the structure and dynamics of proteins in live cells is essential to understanding their physiological activities and mechanisms, and to validating in vitro characterization. Improvements in labeling and imaging technologies are starting to allow such in vivo studies; however, a number of technical challenges remain. Recently, we developed an electroporation-based protocol for internalization, which allows biomolecules labeled with organic fluorophores to be introduced at high efficiency into live E. coli (Crawford et al. in Biophys J 105 (11):2439–2450, 2013). Here, we address important challenges related to internalization of proteins, and optimize our method in terms of (1) electroporation buffer conditions; (2) removal of dye contaminants from stock protein samples; and (3) removal of non-internalized molecules from cell suspension after electroporation. We illustrate the usability of the optimized protocol by demonstrating high-efficiency internalization of a 10-kDa protein, the ω subunit of RNA polymerase. Provided that suggested control experiments are carried out, any fluorescently labeled protein of up to 60 kDa could be internalized using our method. Further, we probe the effect of electroporation voltage on internalization efficiency and cell viability and demonstrate that, whilst internalization increases with increased voltage, cell viability is compromised. However, due to the low number of damaged cells in our samples, the major fraction of loaded cells always corresponds to non-damaged cells. By taking care to include only viable cells into analysis, our method allows physiologically relevant studies to be performed, including in vivo measurements of protein diffusion, localization and intramolecular dynamics via single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer.     

Introduction of unlabeled proteins into living cells by electroporation and isolation of viable protein-loaded cells using dextran-fluorescein isothiocyanate as a marker for protein uptake.

Commonly, microinjection has been the method of choice for introducing proteins into living cells. Viable cells containing an introduced protein can be then identified providing that the protein is fluorochrome conjugated. This approach is applicable only for adherent cells, and the number of cells that can be analyzed is small. In this study, we have established that electroporation can be used to load proteins into large numbers of cells with high efficiency. Furthermore, we have developed a method for the isolation of protein-loaded cells using fluorescein isothiocyanate-dextran (dextran-FITC) as a molecular marker for protein uptake. The essential features of this method are that dextran-FITC is included in the electroporation medium and, thus, is cointroduced with the protein of interest. Purification of cells containing dextran-FITC using fluorescence-activated cell sorting yields a population which is composed almost entirely of cells containing the protein of interest.