Failure of PFC inhibition assays to distinguish idiotypically between clonotypes that are readily distinguishable by RIA analysis

Two different hemolytic plaque assay protocols that are commonly used to quantitate idiotype-positive antibody-secreting cells have been compared to a standard radioimmunoassay (RIA) to test for their ability to discriminate between related, but idiotypically distinct, clonotypes. The idiotype proband used in this analysis is the individual specific idiotype associated with the dextran-binding myeloma protein M104E (M104E IdI). Antibodies specific for this private idiotype (anti-M104E IdI) were purified by a combination of adsorption and affinity chromatography of the immunoglobulin fraction isolated from the sera of rabbits repeatedly immunized with M104E. The same affinity-purified anti-M104E IdI antibodies were used in the hemolytic plaque assays and in the RIA. In one of the plaque assays, the putative idiotype-positive antibody-forming cells were scored by lysis of target erythrocytes to which the anti-idiotype had been covalently coupled. In the other plaque assay, the idiotype-positive cells were determined indirectly by anti-idiotype inhibition of PFC produced on dextran-coupled target erythrocytes. The fidelity of these two assays to quantitate the M104E private idiotype expression in individual BALB/c mice after a single immunization with dextran B-1355S was determined by comparing the plaque assay data to the data generated by a double-antibody, post-precipitation RIA of either the antibodies in the serum or of monoclonal antibodies produced by hybridomas. Our data indicate that both plaque assay protocols reflect an overestimate of the actual expression of M104E private idiotype. By using a library of dextran-specific hybridomas (that have been characterized in an RIA with respect to their M104E IdI cross-reactivity), we have shown that the PFC overestimate of the M104E expression observed in dextran-immune mice is due to the inability of both plaque assay protocols to distinguish between dextran-specific clonotypes that express idiotypes cross-reactive with, but not identical to, the 104E IdI. We conclude that the plaque assay should be used only in conjunction with an RIA to estimate the idiotype expression. This is especially true in situations where closely related cross-reactive idiotype families exist.     

Usefulness of IgG4 subclass antibodies for diagnosis of human clonorchiasis

The present study analyzed serum IgG subclass antibody reaction to major antigenic bands of Clonorchis sinensis to investigate improvement of its serodiagnosis. Of the four subclass antibodies, IgG1 and IgG2 antibodies were produced but not specific, IgG3 antibody was least produced, and IgG4 antibody was prominent and specific. The serum IgG antibody reaction to any of 43-50, 34-37, 26-28, and 8 kDa bands was found in 65.5% of 168 egg positive cases while IgG4 antibody reaction was found in 22.0% of them. The positive rates of IgG and IgG4 antibodies were directly correlated with the intensity of infection. All of the sera from heavily infected cases over EPG 5,000 showed positive reaction for specific IgG and IgG4 antibodies. The specific serum IgG4 antibody disappeared within 6 months after treatment. The bands of 35 kDa and 67 kDa cross-reacted with IgG antibodies but not with IgG4 antibodies in sera of other trematode infections. The present findings suggest that serum IgG4 antibody reaction to 8 kDa band is specific but not sensitive. Any method to increase its sensitivity is required for improved serodiagnosis.     

Isotype concentrations of human antibodies to group A meningococcal polysaccharide

Antibodies to meningococcal group A polysaccharide (MenA) in the sera of 34 vaccinated adults were quantitated by an isotype-resolving solid-phase RIA (IgA, IgM, IgG1, IgG2, IgG3, and IgG4). All individuals had antibodies before vaccination. The geometric mean concentration was 2.9 micrograms/ml. Two weeks after vaccination the mean antibody concentration had trebled. Average proportions of the three isotypes were then as follows: IgA 15%, IgM 48%, IgG 37%. No differences were found between individuals who had been immunized with the polysaccharide 7 to 8 yr earlier and "primary responders." The subclass composition of IgG antibodies was determined in the 24 postvaccination samples with a definite IgG response (greater than 2-fold increase). IgG1 was the predominant subclass in antibodies of some sera and IgG2 in others, but the average proportions of both subclasses were nearly the same. IgG3 and IgG4 were only found in occasional sera, but when present, each subclass accounted for up to 6%. Although the ratio of kappa and lambda chains could not be determined, there was evidence to suggest that it was higher in anti-MenA antibodies than in antibodies to protein antigens.     

Mapping the idiotopes of a monoclonal anti-myoglobin antibody with syngeneic monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies: detection of a common idiotope

A panel of syngeneic monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies was prepared by immunizing A.SW mice with keyhole limpet hemocyanin-coupled A.SW monoclonal anti-myoglobin (HAL 19, IgG1) and screening the cloned hybridomas for production of IgG2 binding to idiotype but not to certain other anti-myoglobin antibodies of the same subclass in an ELISA. With these antibodies, we identified three nonoverlapping idiotopes, based on three clusters of monoclonal anti-idiotopes that mutually inhibit within each cluster, but not between clusters (Cluster I: S2, S6, S8; Cluster II: S5, S7; Cluster III: S9). Only Cluster II antibodies block the binding of myoglobin to HAL 19 and so identify a binding site-related idiotope(s). Binding of both Cluster II monoclonals (S5 and S7) to Hal 19 is inhibited by a rabbit anti-idiotype that we previously reported detects a common cross-reactive anti-myoglobin idiotope in immune sera. However, only one of these, S7, and not S5, identifies an idiotope that is present on 20 to 30% of A.SW anti-myoglobin antibodies in immune sera and ascites. The panel of syngeneic monoclonal anti-idiotype antibodies also detects new idiotopes not detected by the rabbit anti-idiotype. The development of a panel of syngeneic monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies to different clusters of idiotopes on the same antibody molecule, including one that identifies a major common idiotope in immune sera, should allow the analysis of possible idiotype network regulation in vivo and in vitro in a completely syngeneic system.     

Human immunoglobulin-G subclass distribution in response to vaccination withVibria cholerae vaccine and procholeragenoid

Immunoglobulin-G (IgG) subclass-specific antibody to cholera toxin andVibrio cholerae lipopolysaccharide in 26 individuals vaccinated withV. cholerae whole cells and procholeragenoid was investigated. An ELISA assay with monoclonal IgG subclass-specific antibodies was employed. The response to vaccination was found to be predominantly of the IgGl (100%) and IgG2 (73%) subclass. The magnitude of the IgG response was greater for the antitoxic compared with the antilipopolysaccharide vaccine component. IgG subclass antibodies evoked in response to immunization had no influence on the overall IgG subclass serum concentrations.     

Helper T lymphocytes from xid and normal mice support anti-phosphocholine antibody responses with equivalent T15, 511, and 603 idiotypic composition

We have examined the idiotypic composition of secondary adoptive transfer antibody responses to phosphocholine (PC) supported by KLH-primed helper T cells derived from normal mice or xid mice. CBA/N x BALB/c F1 male xid mice have diminished anti-PC responses and virtually undetectable levels of the T15 idiotype; xid mice do express the 511 and 603 idiotypes. Nonetheless, we find helper T cells derived from such mice are indistinguishable from T cells primed in a normal environment in their ability to cooperate with B cells producing anti-PC antibody bearing the T15, 511, or 603 idiotype markers. This result is in contrast to a previously published report from this laboratory. T cells from xid mice did support more IgG PFC than normal T cells, but serum IgG anti-PC antibody levels were similar in both groups. The IgM anti-PC response was predominantly of the T15 idiotype, whereas the 511 idiotype was associated with a minor fraction of IgG1 antibodies. The majority of the secondary IgG "anti-PC" antibody response bore none of the idiotypic markers associated with PC-binding myeloma or hybridoma antibodies, and was directed against phenyl-PC rather than PC. The phenomenon of T15 clonal dominance in the anti-PC response therefore is largely confined to the IgM response. We would conclude that the idiotype levels in the T cell priming environment do not influence the subsequent ability of such primed T cells to support anti-PC antibody responses.     

Serological Study of Bartonella henselae in Cat Scratch Disease in Japan

It has become clear that Bartonella henselae is a common cause of cat scratch disease (CSD). The indirect fluorescence antibody (IFA) test for detection of IgG and IgM antibodies to B. henselae concerning CSD showed that 5 (50%) of 10 patients with CSD had a serum IgG antibody titer of 1:128 or more and that 2 (20%) patients had a serum IgM antibody titer of 1:20 or more. One of 7 asymptomatic members of patients' families (14%) had IgG antibody to B. henselae at a titer of 1:256. IgM antibody to B. henselae was not detected in sera from the patients' families. Both IgG and IgM antibodies to B. henselae were not detected in sera from the healthy control group. These data suggest that B. henselae may be a cause of CSD in Japan.     

Idiotypic analysis of a monoclonal anti-Sm antibody. II. Strain distribution of a common idiotypic determinant and its relationship to anti-Sm expression

The idiotypes borne by Y2, a monoclonal anti-Sm antibody of MRL-lpr/lpr mouse strain origin, were investigated to elucidate genetic mechanisms in this autoantibody response. An anti-Y2 anti-idiotypic antiserum was raised in a rabbit and was rendered specific for idiotype by extensive absorption with globulins of the B6 and BALB/c strains as well as the BALB/c myeloma UPC 10. By using a sensitive assay for idiotype by inhibition ELISA, the Y2 determinant was found to be commonly expressed in sera of MRL-lpr/lpr and MRL-+/+ mice. Moreover, sera of several normal strain mice also bore the idiotype and, in mice bearing the lpr gene, idiotype levels were increased 1.5 to fivefold, even in the absence of a serum anti-Sm response. The relationship of this idiotype to anti-Sm expression was further assessed by determining the idiotype content of affinity-purified anti-Sm antibodies from MRL-lpr/lpr mice. Anti-Sm from serum pools or individual animals showed no significant enrichment of the Y2 idiotype in comparison to unselected MRL-lpr/lpr IgG. These results suggest that the Y2 idiotype defines only a minor component of the anti-Sm autoantibody response, and that most antibodies with this determinant express other antigenic specificities.     

Preferential expression of the systemic lupus erythematosus-associated idiotype 8.12 in sera containing monoclonal immunoglobulins

The 8.12 idiotype defines a population of anti-DNA antibodies present in the serum of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus. As part of our studies to elucidate the genetic origin and structural features of anti-DNA antibodies, we examined monoclonal immunoglobulin (Ig)-containing sera from 706 patients for expression of the 8.12 idiotype. We found 41 such sera to have significant 8.12 reactivity (greater than 4 SD above the mean of normal controls) and demonstrated that in 24 of these sera (8 IgM, 14 IgG, and 2 IgA) this reactivity could be localized to the monoclonal protein. In addition, 12 of the 8.12-reactive monoclonal Ig (11 IgG and 1 IgA) bind dsDNA. In the other 17 sera, the 8.12 reactivity could be attributed to polyclonal antibody. These findings provide further evidence that the serum monoclonal Ig frequently express the antigenic and idiotypic reactivities of autoantibodies. Furthermore, these data support the contention that anti-DNA specificity may result from somatic diversification of germ-line Ig gene sequences.     

Control of allergic reactivity in human filariasis. Predominant localization of blocking antibody to the IgG4 subclass.

Patients with chronic helminth infections, despite having abundant basophils and mast cells specifically sensitized with antiparasite IgE and often exposed repeatedly to parasite Ag, rarely manifest allergic symptoms. This control of clinical allergic reactivity likely results from Ag-specific IgG "blocking antibodies" shown previously to be abundant in the sera of such patients. In the present study we used two approaches to determine in which of the four IgG subclasses this blocking activity was localized. First, specific antifilarial antibodies of each of the four IgG subclasses were quantified in the sera of 28 patients with Bancroftian filariasis and correlated with the levels of blocking activity in these sera (determined by histamine release assays). A significant correlation with blocking activity was seen only for antibodies of the IgG4 subclass, and, indeed, the correlation was especially strong in the group of totally asymptomatic patients (but with microfilariae circulating in the blood) in whom blocking antibody levels were highest. Interestingly, however, if the analysis excluded these asymptomatic microfilaremic patients and focused instead on those with lymphatic inflammatory pathology (who had relatively low levels of both serum blocking activity and specific IgG4 antibodies), then the small amount of blocking activity found in these sera correlated only with the levels of IgG1 subclass antibodies. The second approach utilized selective depletion of IgG4 (by anti-IgG4 affinity columns) from the sera of three microfilaremic patients with high levels of blocking activity and demonstrated clearly that removal of IgG4 abolished the majority of the blocking activity in these sera (53, 78, and 81%). These two sets of findings demonstrate a predominant role for specific IgG4 antibodies in blocking IgE-mediated allergic responses to the parasite Ag in vitro, but they also indicate that in some situations IgG1 antibodies can block such reactions. Furthermore, the correlation demonstrated between patients' clinical presentations and the levels of both their specific IgG4 antibodies and serum blocking activity suggests that these antibodies play a similar role in vivo as well.     

The IgE and IgG subclass responses of mice to four helminth parasites

To investigate whether the formation of IgE is linked in vivo to an IgG subclass, mice were infected with four helminth parasites, Nippostrongylus brasiliensis (Nbr), Mesocestoides corti, Taenia crassiceps and Trichinella spiralis, and the changes in the serum levels of the different Ig isotypes as well as the antibody response to M. corti and T. crassiceps antigen extracts were determined by radioimmunoassays. All four parasites induced a concomitant increase of the IgE and IgG1 serum levels and usually a decrease of the IgG2a level. They also induced an increase of the IgM level but had little effect on the IgG2b, IgG3, and IgA serum levels. The specific antibodies to an M. corti antigen extract were mainly of the IgG1 subclass, whereas it was of both IgG1 and IgG2a subclasses to T. crassiceps. Injections of dead M. corti induced an increase of all IgG subclasses and similar levels of IgG1 and IgG2a anti-parasite antibodies. Subcutaneous instead of intraperitoneal infection with T. crassiceps induced higher IgG2a than IgG1 levels and 10-fold lower IgE levels than the natural ip infection; however, despite the greater IgG2a polyclonal response, anti-parasite antibodies were predominantly of the IgG1 subclass. The data demonstrate that natural infection with four different helminth parasites induces a concomitant polyclonal IgG1 and IgE response. These in vivo observations corroborate the recent in vitro findings demonstrating that interleukin-4 induces lipopolysaccharide-activated murine B cells to secrete both IgG1 and IgE, suggesting that the regulation of these two isotypes is linked.     

Functional activity of different IgG subclass antibodies against type b capsular polysaccharide of Haemophilus influenzae

The biologic activity of different human IgG subclass antibodies directed against the Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) capsular polysaccharide (PRP) was compared by using an in vitro complement-mediated bactericidal assay and an in vivo passive protection assay in infant rats. An IgG pool was made by Sephacryl S-300 chromatography of sera from adults immunized with PRP vaccine. An IgG2 subclass fraction was prepared by column immunoabsorption of the IgG pool with anti-IgG1 monoclonal antibody. An IgG1 subclass fraction was eluted from the affinity matrix. IgG1, IgG2, IgG3, and IgG4 concentrations in the fractions were measured by solid-phase competitive radioimmunoassays, and anti-PRP antibody was measured by a modified Farr assay. Each fraction was greater than 90% pure IgG2 or IgG1, respectively. There were no significant differences in the minimal anti-PRP antibody concentrations required to kill 50% of Hib cells in vitro (IgG, 0.22; IgG1, 0.21; and IgG2, 0.42 microgram/ml). Similarly, equivalent amounts of anti-PRP antibody of the IgG1 or IgG2 fractions protected against bacteremia (IgG1, 0.12; IgG2, 0.24 microgram per rat). IgG absorbed to remove anti-PRP antibody was neither bactericidal nor protective. Thus IgG1 and IgG2 anti-PRP antibody have equivalent functional activities against Hib as determined by these biologic assays.     

The effects of a stable analogue of PGE1 on the IgG subclass response to particulate bovine tubular basement membrane in the brown-Norway rat

The IgG subclass and the IgM isotype response to immunization with particulate bovine tubular basement membrane (TBM) and adjuvants was studied in Brown-Norway rats receiving daily injections of a stable analogue of PGE1 (M-PGE1). M-PGE1 slightly reduced the average quantity of circulating TBM antibody as well as the average quantity of eluted IgG per gram of renal tissue as compared to controls. However, M-PGE1 did not qualitatively affect the distribution of the IgG subclass or IgM isotype response to TBM. The IgG response, which occurred predominantly in the IgG1 and IgG2a subclasses, increased from Days 8 to 14 after immunization, while the IgM response decreased over the same time period. The percentage of TBM antibody in the IgG2b subclass was markedly decreased as compared to the percentage of IgG2b antibody in total IgG. A substantial heterogeneity in the IgG subclass response was noted among individual rats with IgG1 constituting from 46 to 82% of circulating TBM antibody. Although no correlation between the IgG subclass response and the severity of tubulointerstitial nephritis was noted, heterogeneity in the IgG subclass response to autoantigens may, nevertheless, theoretically play an important role in the pathogenesis of autoimmune inflammatory phenomena.     

Importance of antibody isotype in monoclonal anti-idiotype therapy of a murine B cell lymphoma. A study of hybridoma class switch variants

An initial panel of four syngeneic monoclonal antibodies directed against the idiotype of a murine B cell lymphoma was used to treat this tumor in vivo. The antibody in the panel of the IgG2a isotype was more effective in treatment than the other antibodies, which were of the IgG1 and IgG2b isotypes. To independently assess the role of antibody isotype in mediating antitumor effects, switch variant hybridoma families were isolated from the hybridomas secreting the less effective IgG1 and IgG2b antibodies. A family isolated from an IgG1-secreting parent consisted of IgG1-, IgG2b-, and IgG2a-secreting members, and an IgG2a variant was isolated from an IgG2b-secreting parent for another family. Antibody members of each family differed only in heavy chain composition and were the same with respect to their light chains and their affinity and specificity for idiotype. The IgG2a members of both families were superior to the other members in inhibiting tumor growth with an order of effectiveness of IgG2a greater than IgG1 greater than IgG2b. These in vivo results paralleled the abilities of these different isotype antibodies to mediate antibody-dependent cellular cytolysis in vitro. For the IgG2b----IgG2a family, in vivo treatment with the IgG2a member given i.p. after i.p. tumor challenge at one-tenth the dose of the IgG2b member was still superior to the latter. At one-hundredth the dose of the IgG2b, the IgG2a was still superior to the latter when the antibodies were given i.p. and tumors subcutaneously. These data and those showing that the clearance of these antibodies from the serum differed in only a relatively minor way indicate that the IgG2a antibodies in this system had greater antitumor effects primarily by virtue of their greater capacity for host effector interaction.     

IgG antibody responses in early experimental sparganosis and IgG subclass responses in human sparganosis

Antigenic components in the crude extracts of Spirometra mansoni plerocercoid were analyzed in early experimental infections and in IgG subclass observed in clinical sparganosis. By IgG immunoblot, sera obtained serially from experimental mice, fed 5 spargana each, were reacted with the crude extracts. Protein bands at 36-26 kDa and 103 kDa showed positive reactions since two weeks after infection. In a differential immunoblot, in which a monospecific antibody against sparganum chymase at 36 kDa was pre-treated, the reactions at 36-26 kDa disappeared, indicating that the sparganum chymase and its degradation products invoked IgG antibody reactions. When 69 patients sera of human sparganosis were examined for their IgG subclass responses, IgG4 levels showed the highest reaction which was followed by IgG1. The IgG4 antibody also reacted mainly with 36-31 kDa protease. These results indicate that 36 kDa chymase of S. mansoni plerocercoid is the main antigenic component inducing IgG antibody response in early stage of experimental sparganosis and for specific IgG subclass reactions in human sparganosis.     

Subpopulations of antibodies to phosphocholine in human serum

We investigated the heterogeneity of anti-phosphocholine (PC) antibodies present in human serum taken from individuals before and after immunization with a multivalent pneumococcal vaccine. The fine specificity of IgM, IgG, and IgA anti-PC antibodies was determined in an ELISA by using phosphocholine or p-nitrophenyl phosphocholine (NPPC) to inhibit binding of antibody to PC-histone. We identified two populations specific for PC that differed in their binding properties. One population is inhibited by NPPC much better than by PC and is most evident in IgG antibodies. The second population has similar avidity for PC and NPPC and is consistently associated with the IgM and IgA isotypes as well as with IgG. The IgG antibodies in both populations were predominantly of the IgG2 subclass. Both populations were found in serum samples taken before immunization with pneumococcal vaccine, suggesting that they had been stimulated through prior environmental contacts with PC-containing antigens. Previously, we found populations with similar fine specificity patterns in the murine response to PC. The two murine antibody populations have been shown to derive from different immunoglobulin variable region genes. The presence of comparable antibody populations in the human suggests the possibility that these two fine specificity families have been conserved in evolution.     

Subclass distribution of human antibodies to Haemophilus influenzae type b capsular polysaccharide

The polysaccharide (PS) capsule of Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) is a "simple" antigen, polyribosylribitolphosphate. Although similar carbohydrate antigens have been reported to elicit IgG antibodies relatively restricted to the IgG2 subclass in man, we report here that Hib PS elicits substantial quantities of both IgG1 and IgG2 serum antibodies in most individuals. Because the determination of IgG subclass distribution can be technically difficult, we used four different approaches to establish our finding. First, we used an IgG subclass-specific, antigen-specific "sandwich assay." Second, we measured IgG subclasses of purified antibodies to Hib PS. Third, we showed that significant amounts of IgG anti-PS can be absorbed with a monoclonal anti-IgG1 affinity column. Fourth, we showed that IgG1 and IgG2 fractions of immune sera have clonally restricted anti-Hib PS antibodies that are easily distinguishable by their isoelectric points. The data indicate that both IgG1 and IgG2 contribute substantially to the IgG antibody response of most adults to immunization with Hib PS.     

Immunoglobulin G subclasses of anti-thyroid peroxidase autoantibodies in human autoimmune thyroid diseases

A distribution of immunoglobulin G (IgG) subclass of anti-thyroid peroxidase (TPO) autoantibodies was studied to know whether anti-TPO autoantibodies are closely implicated in the pathogenesis of human autoimmune thyroid diseases. As a result of analyzing 14 patients' sera, 7 with Graves' disease and 7 with Hashimoto's thyroiditis, anti-TPO autoantibodies were found to consist of mainly IgG1 subclass. Percentages of both IgG1 and IgG2 subclasses in IgG class of autoantibodies corresponded to those in the normal serum composition, whereas IgG3 subclass was scarcely contained in anti-TPO autoantibodies and IgG4 subclass markedly increased. It was thought that anti-TPO autoantibodies had a capability to lyse thyroid follicular cells by the mechanism of antibody-dependent complement-mediated cytolysis, because IgG1 and IgG2 subclasses of antibodies can fix complement and TPO locates in apical membrane surface of thyroid follicular cells. Comparing Graves' disease with Hashimoto's thyroiditis, mean percentages of both IgG1 and IgG2 subclasses of 2 groups were statistically different. Namely, sera of patients with Graves' disease had higher and lower mean percentages of IgG1 and IgG2 subclasses of autoantibodies, respectively, than those with Hashimoto's thyroiditis, though no plausible explanation for these differences can be offered at the present time.     

Thermodynamic Stability and Functional Activity of Tumor-Associated Antibodies

Tumor-associated antibodies of human IgG1 subclass were eluted from cell-surface antigens of human carcinoma cells and studied by differential scanning calorimetry and binding to local conformational probes, protein A from Staphylococcus aureus and a monoclonal antibody targeted to the CH2 domain of the Fc fragment. At pH 2.0-7.0, we observed virtually identical enthalpies of thermal unfolding for IgG1 from normal human sera and tumor-associated IgG1. The exact values of calorimetric enthalpy (h) at pH 7.0 were 6.1 and 6.2-6.3 cal/g for IgG1 from normal serum and IgG1 from carcinoma cells, respectively. The affinity constants of protein A binding to the CH2–CH3 domain interface demonstrated differences between serum IgG1 and tumor associated IgG1 that did not exceed 3-8-fold. The binding affinity toward the anti-CH2 monoclonal antibody determined for serum IgG1 and IgG1 from carcinoma cells differed not more than 2.5-fold. The thermodynamic parameters of IgG1 from carcinoma cells strongly suggest that protein conformational stability was essentially unaltered and that the Fc fragment of the tumor-derived IgG1 preserved its structural integrity.