The alternative respiration pathway in plants: Role and regulation

In the past few years, knowledge of the nature and regulation of the alternative oxidase in plant mitochondria has increased greatly. The protein has been characterized and mechanisms that regulate its activity have been described. The consequences of these regulatory mechanisms are that in vivo the cytochrome pathway and the alternative pathway may compete for electrons. The implications for the interpretation of the 'Bahr and Bonner' inhibitor titrations, formerly used to estimate the partitioning of electrons over the two pathways, are discussed.
It is proposed that activation and engagement of the alternative oxidase may keep Q reduction levels low in order to prevent harmful high levels of free radical production. A model is presented for the regulation of alternative oxidase protein induction, involving a signalling function of active oxygen species.     

Regulation of alternative oxidase activity in higher plants

Plant mitochondria contain two terminal oxidases: cytochrome oxidase and the cyanideinsensitive alternative oxidase. Electron partioning between the two pathways is regulated by the redox poise of the ubiquinone pool and the activation state of the alternative oxidase. The alternative oxidase appears to exist as a dimer which is active in the reduced, noncovalently linked form and inactive when in the oxidized, covalently linked form. Reduction of the oxidase in isolated tobacco mitochondria occurs upon oxidation of isocitrate or malate and may be mediated by matrix NAD(P)H. The activity of the reduced oxidase is governed by certain other organic acids, notably pyruvate, which appear to interact directly with the enzyme. Pyruvate alters the interaction between the alternative oxidase and ubiquinol so that the oxidase becomes active at much lower levels of ubiquinol and competes with the cytochrome pathway for electrons. These requirements for activation of the alternative oxidase constitute a sophisticated feed-forward control mechanism which determines the extent to which electrons are directed away from the energy-conserving cytochrome pathway to the non-energy conserving alternative oxidase. Such a mechanism fits well with the proposed role of the alternative oxidase as a protective enzyme which prevents over-reduction of the cytochrome chain and fermentation of accumulated pyruvate.     

The alternative oxidase in roots of poa annua after transfer from high-light to low-light conditions

The activity of the alternative pathway can be affected by a number of factors, including the amount and reduction state of the alternative oxidase protein, and the reduction state of the ubiquinone pool. To investigate the importance of these factors in vivo, we manipulated the rate of root respiration by transferring the annual grass Poa annua L. from high-light to low-light conditions, and at the same time from long-day to short-day conditions for four days. As a result of the low-light treatment, the total respiration rate of the roots decreased by 45%, in vitro cytochrome c oxidase capacity decreased by 49%, sugar concentration decreased by 90% and the ubiquinone concentration increased by 31%, relative to control values. The absolute rate of oxygen uptake via the alternative pathway, as determined using the 18O-isotope fractionation technique, did not change. Conversely, the cytochrome pathway activity decreased during the low-light treatment; its activity increased upon addition of exogenous sugars to the roots. Interestingly, no change was observed in the concentration of the alternative oxidase protein or in the reduction state of the protein. Also, there was no change in the reduction state of the ubiquinone pool. In conclusion, the concentration and activity of the alternative oxidase were not changed, even under severe light deprivation.     

Metabolic regulation of leaf respiration and alternative pathway activity in response to phosphate supply

In this study the question whether the alternative respiratory pathway acts as an electron bypass for the cytochrome pathway under conditions of growth on limited phosphorus in leaves of bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.), tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) and Gliricidia sepium Walp was investigated. The oxygen isotope fractionation technique was used to assess the in vivo activities of the cytochrome and alternative respiratory pathways in the absence of added inhibitors. The response of respiration to low phosphorus supply varied among species. Growth at low phosphorus reduced cytochrome pathway activity in bean and tobacco. Alternative pathway activity increased only in bean leaves in response to low phosphorus and not in tobacco. In the case of G. sepium, cytochrome pathway activity remained unchanged whereas the alternative pathway activity increased with low nutritional phosphorus. At low phosphorus, alternative oxidase protein levels increased in the leaves of bean and G. sepium but not in tobacco, suggesting a dependence of alternative pathway activity on protein level. Alternative pathway activity was also not correlated with soluble carbohydrate concentration in bean or tobacco at any phosphorus level. These results show that the alternative pathway does not always act as an electron bypass in response to the downstream restriction of the cytochrome pathway imposed by low phosphorus supply. These results suggest that factors in addition to cellular carbohydrate level and adenylate control can act to regulate alternative pathway activity.     

The effect of pH on the alternative oxidase activity in isolated Acanthamoeba castellanii mitochondria

Mitochondria of Acanthamoeba castellanii possess a cyanide-resistant GMP-stimulated ubiquinol alternative oxidase in addition to the cytochrome pathway. In a previous work it has been observed that an interaction between the two ubiquinol-oxidizing pathways exists in intact A. castellanii mitochondria and that this interaction may be due to a high sensitivity of the alternative oxidase to matrix pH. In this study we have shown that the alternative oxidase activity reveals a pH-dependence with a pH optimum at 6.8 whatever the reducing substrate may be. The GMP stimulation of alternative oxidase is also strongly dependent on pH implicating probably protonation/deprotonation processes at the level of ligand and protein with an optimum pH at 6.8. The ubiquinone redox state-dependence of alternative oxidase activity is modified by pH in such a way that the highest activity for a given ubiquinone redox state is observed at pH 6.8. Thus pH, binding of GMP, and redox state of ubiquinone collaborate to set the activity of the GMP-stimulated alternative oxidase in isolated A. castellanii mitochondria. The high pH sensitivity of the alternative oxidase could link inactivation of the cytochrome pathway proton pumps to activation of the alternative oxidase with acceleration of redox free energy dissipation as a consequence.     

Molecular Genetic Alteration of Plant Respiration (Silencing and Overexpression of Alternative Oxidase in Transgenic Tobacco)

The alternative oxidase (AOX) of plant mitochondria is encoded by the nuclear gene Aox1. Sense and antisense DNA constructs of Nicotiana tabacum Aox1 were introduced into tobacco, and transgenic plants with both increased and decreased levels of mitochondrial AOX protein were identified. Suspension cells derived from wild-type and transgenic plants were grown in heterotrophic batch culture. Transgenic cells with increased AOX protein had an increased capacity for cyanide-resistant, salicylhydroxamic acid-sensitive respiration compared to wild-type cells, whereas transgenic cells with decreased AOX protein had a decreased capacity for such respiration. Thus, genetic alteration of the level of AOX protein was sufficient to alter the capacity for electron transport through the alternative pathway. Under our standard growth conditions, "antisense" cells with dramatically reduced levels of AOX protein had growth and respiration rates similar to the wild type. However, whereas wild-type cells were able to grow under conditions that severely suppressed cytochrome pathway activity, antisense cells could not survive this treatment. This suggests that a critical function of AOX may be to support respiration when the cytochrome pathway is impaired. The much higher level of AOX protein in "sense" cells compared to the wild type did not appreciably alter the steady-state partitioning of electrons between the cytochrome path and the alternative pathway in vivo, suggesting that this partitioning may be subject to additional regulatory factors.     

Role of sugars and organic acids in regulating the concentration and activity of the alternative oxidase in Poa annua roots

Detached roots of Poa annua were used to study alternative oxidase protein expression upon the addition of sucrose, glucose, fructose, inositol, mannitol, citrate or malate, at a concentration of 1 or 10 mM for 24 h. After 24 h the capacity of cytochrome c oxidase was decreased equally in all treatments. Only citrate induced the expression of the alternative oxidase, especially at a concentration of 1 mM (15-fold). The activity of the alternative pathway (measured with the (18)O-fractionation technique) was not affected by the addition of sucrose for 24 h as compared with time zero. However, after the addition of citrate or mannitol the activity of the alternative pathway decreased to almost zero. The discrepancy between the large increase in alternative oxidase protein concentration when citrate was applied and the concomitant decrease in alternative pathway activity is discussed.     

The Regulation of Electron Partitioning between the Cytochrome and Alternative Pathways in Soybean Cotyledon and Root Mitochondria

The regulation of electron partitioning between the cytochrome (Cyt) and alternative pathways in soybean (Glycine max L. cv Ransom) mitochondria in the absence of added inhibitors has been studied using the oxygen isotope fractionation technique. This regulation can depend on several factors, including the amount of alternative oxidase protein, the redox status of the alternative oxidase regulatory sulfhydryl-disulfide system, the degree of activation by [alpha]-keto acids, and the concentration and redox state of the ubiquinone pool. We studied electron partitioning onto the alternative pathway in mitochondria isolated from etiolated and light-grown cotyledons and roots to ascertain how these factors interact in different tissues. In light-grown cotyledon mitochondria there is some partitioning to the alternative pathway in state 4, which is increased dramatically by either pyruvate or dithiothreitol. In etiolated cotyledon mitochondria, the alternative pathway shows little ability to compete for electrons with the Cyt pathway under any circumstances. In root mitochondria, control of alternative pathway activity is exercised by both the ubiquinone pool and the regulatory sulfhydryl-disulfide system. In addition, oxygen isotope fractionation by the Cyt and alternative pathways in mitochondria were identical to the fractionation for the respective pathways seen in intact tissue, suggesting that residual respiration is not present in the absence of inhibitors.     

The alternative respiratory pathway mediates carboxylate synthesis in white lupin cluster roots under phosphorus deprivation

Plant adaptations associated with a high efficiency of phosphorus (P) acquisition can be used to increase productivity and sustainability in a world with a growing population and decreasing rock phosphate reserves. White lupin (Lupinus albus) produces cluster roots that release carboxylates to efficiently mobilize P from P‐sorbing soils. It has been hypothesized that an increase in the activity of the alternative oxidase (AOX) would allow for the mitochondrial oxidation of NAD(P)H produced during citrate synthesis in cluster roots at a developmental stage when there is a low demand for ATP. We used the oxygen‐isotope fractionation technique to study the in vivo respiratory activities of the cytochrome oxidase pathway (COP) and the alternative oxidase pathway (AOP) in different root sections of white lupins grown hydroponically with and without P. In parallel, AOX protein levels and internal carboxylate concentrations were determined in cluster and non‐cluster roots. Higher in vivo AOP activity was measured in cluster roots when malate and citrate concentrations were also high, thus confirming our hypothesis. AOX protein levels were not always correlated with in vivo AOP activity, suggesting post‐translational regulation of AOX.     

Measurements of in Vivo Ubiquinone Reduction Levels in Plant Cells

A method is described for the determination of in vivo ubiquinone (UQ) reduction levels in nongreen tissues by extraction and subsequent detection of ubiquinone-10 and ubiquinol-10 with high-performance liquid chromatography. In Petunia hybrida cell suspensions UQ reduction remained at a stable level of about 60%, despite the changing conditions during the batch culture (from excess sugar to starvation) and the concomitant variations in respiration. Also, in the presence of uncoupler, which causes a large increase in respiration via both the cytochrome pathway and the alternative pathway, UQ reduction levels stayed at 60%. In mitochondria isolated from these cells, activity of the alternative pathway was only observed at UQ reduction levels higher than 80%. It is proposed that in vivo the relationship between UQ reduction and the activity of the alternative oxidase is modulated by mechanisms such as thiol modifications and accumulation of organic acids. Accordingly, pyruvate concentration in P. hybrida cells increased in the presence of uncoupler.     

工业真菌中的交替氧化酶

真菌是现代微生物发酵产业的主力军之一。交替呼吸途径(Alternative respiration pathway,ARP),以其非磷酸化电子传递途径,起到了能量溢流(Energy overflow)的作用,调节细胞能量代谢,平衡碳代谢和电子传递,有利于代谢产物的积累。此外,交替呼吸对真菌的抗逆反应和条件致病菌的生理作用也都具有非常重要的影响。交替氧化酶(Alternative oxidase,AOX)是线粒体中交替呼吸途径的末端氧化酶,广泛存在于高等植物及部分真菌和藻类中。由于交替氧化酶对水杨氧肟酸(Salicylhydroxamic acid,SHAM)敏感而对细胞色素呼吸抑制剂氰化物不敏感,交替氧化酶AOX介导的交替呼吸途径又被称为抗氰呼吸途径(Cyanide-resistant respiration,CRR)。近年来,研究交替呼吸途径和交替氧化酶已成为细胞呼吸代谢领域的热门课题。本文主要对真菌交替呼吸途径和交替氧化酶的结构与其在工业真菌体内功能的最新研究进展作一简要的综述。     

"Tissue" transglutaminase contributes to the formation of disulphide bridges in proteins of mitochondrial respiratory complexes

In this study we provide the first in vivo evidences showing that, under physiological conditions, "tissue" transglutaminase (TG2) might acts as a protein disulphide isomerase (PDI) and through this activity contributes to the correct assembly of the respiratory chain complexes. Mice lacking TG2 exhibit mitochondrial energy production impairment, evidenced by decreased ATP levels after physical challenge. This defect is phenotypically reflected in a dramatic decrease of motor behaviour of the animals. We propose that the molecular mechanism, underlying such a phenotype, resides in a defective disulphide bonds formation in ATP synthase (complex V), NADH-ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex I), succinate-ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex II) and cytochrome c oxidase (complex IV). In addition, TG2-PDI might control the respiratory chain by modulating the formation of the prohibitin complexes. These data elucidate a new pathway that directly links the TG2-PDI enzymatic activity with the regulation of mitochondrial respiratory chain function.     

The Role of the Alternative Oxidase in Stabilizing the in Vivo Reduction State of the Ubiquinone Pool and the Activation State of the Alternative Oxidase

A possible function for the alternative (nonphosphorylating) pathway is to stabilize the reduction state of the ubiquinone pool (Q_r/Q_t), thereby avoiding an increase in free radical production. If the Q_r/Q_t were stabilized by the alternative pathway, then Q_r/Q_t should be less stable when the alternative pathway is blocked. Q_r/Q_t increased when we exposed roots of Poa annua (L.) to increasing concentrations of KCN (an inhibitor of the cytochrome pathway). However, when salicylhydroxamic acid, an inhibitor of the alternative pathway, was added at the same time, Q_r/Q_t increased significantly more. Therefore, we conclude that the alternative pathway stabilizes Q_r/Q_t. Salicylhydroxamic acid increasingly inhibited respiration with increasing concentrations of KCN. In the experiments described here the alternative oxidase protein was invariably in its reduced (high-activity) state. Therefore, changes in the reduction state of the alternative oxidase cannot account for an increase in activity of the alternative pathway upon titration with KCN. The pyruvate concentration in intact roots increased only after the alternative pathway was blocked or the cytochrome pathway was severely inhibited. The significance of the pyruvate concentration and Q_r/Q_t on the activity of the alternative pathway in intact roots is discussed.     

The alternative oxidase of Yarrowia lipolytica mitochondria is unable to compete with the cytochrome pathway for electrons

The activity of the cyanide-resistant alternative oxidase (pathway) of Y. lipolytica mitochondria was studied as a function of the activity of the major, cyanide-sensitive, cytochrome pathway. The contribution of the alternative oxidase to the total respiration of mitochondria was evaluated by measuring the rate of oxygen consumption in the presence of cyanide (an inhibitor of the cytochrome pathway). The potential activity of the cytochrome pathway was evaluated spectrophotometrically, by measuring the oxidation rate of cytochrome c by ferricyanide, which accepts electrons from complex III (cytochrome c) of this pathway. The oxidation of succinate by mitochondria in the presence of ferricyanide and cyanide was accompanied by oxygen consumption due to the transfer of electrons through the alternative pathway. The subsequent addition of ADP or FCCP (an uncoupler of oxidative phosphorylation in the cytochrome pathway) completely inhibited the consumption of oxygen by the mitochondria. Under these conditions, the inhibition of the alternative pathway by benzohydroxamic acid failed to affect the transfer of electrons from cytochrome c to ferricyanide. Benzohydroxamic acid did not influence the rate of ferricyanide reduction by the cytochrome pathway occurring in controlled state 4, nor could it change the phosphorylation quotient ATP/O upon the oxidation of various substrates. These findings indicate that the alternative pathway is unable to compete with the cytochrome respiratory chain for electrons. The alternative pathway transfers only electrons that are superfluous for the cytochrome chain.     

Sulfide-Resistant Respiration in Leaves of Elodea canadensis Michx: Comparison with Cyanide-Resistant Respiration

The rate of dark O₂ uptake of Elodea canadensis leaves was titrated with either cyanide or sulfide in the presence and in the absence of 5 millimolar salicylhydroxamic acid (SHAM), an inhibitor of the alternative oxidase. The inhibition of O₂ uptake by SHAM alone was very small (3-6%), suggesting that actual respiration mainly occurred through the cytochrome pathway. O₂ uptake was slightly stimulated by cyanide at concentrations of 50 micromolar or higher, but in the presence of SHAM respiration was strongly suppressed. The effects of sulfide on O₂ uptake were similar to those of cyanide, except that the percent stimulation of O₂ uptake by sulfide alone was somewhat higher than that of cyanide. However, the estimates of the capacity of the alternative pathway were similar with both inhibitors. Another difference is that maximal inhibition of respiration in the presence of SHAM was observed with lower concentrations of sulfide (50 micromolar) than cyanide (250 micromolar). The results suggest that sulfide can be used as a suitable inhibitor of cytochrome c oxidase in studies with intact plant tissues, and that sulfide does not apparently inhibit the alternative oxidase.     

Mitochondrial electron transport regulation of nuclear gene expression. Studies with the alternative oxidase gene of tobacco.

We have isolated a cDNA representing the tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L. cv Bright Yellow) nuclear gene Aox1, which encodes the alternative oxidase of plant mitochondria. The clone contains the complete coding region (1059 base pairs) of a precursor protein of 353 amino acids with a calculated molecular mass of 39.8 kD. A putative transit peptide contains common signals believed to be important for import and processing of mitochondrially localized proteins. We have studied changes in Aox1 gene expression in tobacco in response to changes in cytochrome pathway activity. Inhibition of the cytochrome pathway by antimycin A resulted in a rapid and dramatic accumulation of Aox1 mRNA, whereas the level of mRNAs encoding two proteins of the cytochrome pathway did not change appreciably. This was accompanied by a dramatic increase in alternative pathway capacity and engagement in whole cells. Respiration under these conditions was unaffected by the uncoupler p-trifluoromethoxycarbonylcyanide (FCCP). When inhibition of the cytochrome pathway was relieved, levels of Aox1 mRNA returned to control levels, alternative pathway capacity and engagement declined, and respiration could once again be stimulated by FCCP. The results show that a mechanism involving changes in Aox1 gene expression exists whereby the capacity of the alternative pathway can be adjusted in response to changes in the activity of the cytochrome pathway.     

Respiratory pathways in aged soybean seeds

Respiratory activities in soybean seeds (Glvcine max (L.) Merr. cv. Chippewa 64) have been examined in the first minutes after water imbibition and after three hours of imbibition, using either particles or intact axes. Cyanide and azide were utilized as inhibitors of the cytochrome oxidase pathway of respiration, and SHAM inhibitions were interpreted as effects on the alternative pathway, since in unaged axes inhibitions by SHAM were obtained only when respiratory activity had either been restricted with inhibitors of the cytochrome oxidase pathway or expanded by an uncoupler (CCCP). From the experiments with these inhibitors, it is suggested that unaged seeds utilize both respiration pathways in the cotyledon but only the cytochrome pathway in the axis. Accelerated aging causes a marked deterioration of respiration, especially that through the cytochrome pathway, and there is an associated engagement of the alternative pathway in the seed axis. It is suggested that the lowering of respiratory activity and the shift in respiratory pathways may play a major role in the decline of germinability and vigor.     

Interactions Between the Cytochrome Pathway and the Alternative Oxidase in Isolated Acanthamoeba castellanii Mitochondria

The steady-state activity of the two quinol-oxidizing pathways of Acanthamoeba castellanii mitochondria, the phosphorylating cytochrome pathway (i.e. the benzohydroxamate(BHAM)-resistant respiration in state 3) and the alternative oxidase (i.e. the KCN-resistant respiration), is shown to be fixed by ubiquinone (Q) pool redox state independently of the reducing substrate (succinate or exogenous reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH)), indicating that the active Q pool is homogenous. For both pathways, activity increases with the Q reduction level (up to 80%). However, the cytochrome pathway respiration partially inhibited (about 50%) by myxothiazol decreases when the Q reduction level increases above 80%. The decrease can be explained by the Q cycle mechanism of complex III. It is also shown that BHAM has an influence on the relationship between the rate of ADP phosphorylation and the Q reduction level when alternative oxidase is active, and that KCN has an influence on the relationship between the alternative oxidase activity and the Q reduction level. These unexpected effects of BHAM and KCN observed at a given Q reduction level are likely due to functional connections between the two pathways activities or to protein–protein interaction.     

Mitochondrial Respiratory Chain Complex Patterns from Acanthamoeba castellanii and Lycopersicon esculentum: Comparative Analysis by BN-PAGE and Evidence of Protein–Protein Interaction Between Alternative Oxidase and Complex III

We have previously shown that a kinetic interplay exists between the cytochrome pathway and the alternative oxidase in mitochondria from amoeba Acanthamoeba castellanii . Native interaction analyses using blue native gel electrophoresis coupled to denaturating electrophoresis and immunodetection have indicated associations between alternative oxidase and oxidative phosphorylation complexes in both amoeba and tomato mitochondria. These associations are dependent on the expression level of alternative oxidase according to the physiological state in both organisms. Alternative oxidase associates broadly with large complexes of the respiratory chain when it is expressed in large amount, i.e., in ripe tomato and exponentially growing amoeba. On the contrary, alternative oxidase interacts specifically with complex III even if expression of the oxidase is low, i.e., in green tomato and stationary phase amoeba. This specific interaction represents a higher level of regulation driven by protein-protein interactions leading to a direct kinetic interplay between the cytochrome pathway and alternative oxidase in both plant and amoeba mitochondria.