The effect of different antioxidants on glutathione turnover in human cell lines and their interaction with hydrogen peroxide

BACKGROUND: Glutathione plays crucial roles in antioxidant defence and glutathione deficiency contributes to oxidative stress and may therefore play a key role in the pathogenesis of many diseases. The objectives of the present study were to evaluate the effects on glutathione turnover of thiol and non-thiol antioxidants in human cell cultures and if any of the antioxidant had a short-term cellular effect against different levels of hydrogen peroxide. METHODS: We have investigated the effect on the total glutathione amount in HeLa and hepatoma cell cultures of thiol antioxidants in comparison with non-thiol antioxidants, such as a copper chelator, Vitamin C, and a flavonoid. Furthermore, we have investigated the short-term (within 24h) interaction of the different antioxidants with hydrogen peroxide. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION: Lipoic acid and quercetin (Quer) were the two antioxidants that showed the highest stimulation of glutathione synthesis in cell cultures as judged by the total glutathione amount. However, no antioxidant protected against hydrogen peroxide present in concentrations that lowered cell protein. This finding may be attributed to the fact that it is necessary to incubate cell cultures with antioxidants or small doses of oxidants for a period before the cultures are exposed to hydrogen peroxide in order to enhance the antioxidant defence. The presence of Quer and Vitamin C lowered cell protein and total glutathione even in cell cultures containing hydrogen peroxide in concentrations that did not lower cell protein. This finding might be attributed to pro-oxidant properties and formation of excess reactive oxygen species in the presence of Quer and Vitamin C.     

Organismal Aging and Oxidants beyond Macromolecules Damage

The relationship between oxidants and organismal aging was first articulated through the free radical theory of aging. One of the major predictions of the free radical theory of aging is that oxidative stress shortens organisms’ lifespan because of an increased level of oxidants, which are damaging to macromolecules. However, challenging the role of oxidants in age‐related diseases, there is now sufficient evidence that antioxidant supplements do not provide significant health benefits. Interestingly, in addition to an increase in oxidant‐mediated macromolecules damage, there is convincing experimental data to support the role of senescent cells in the process of aging. Here, the current knowledge regarding the role of oxidants and cellular senescence in organismal aging is reviewed and it is proposed that, in addition to the role of oxidants as inducers of macromolecular damage, oxidants may also function as regulators of signaling pathways involved in the establishment of cellular senescence. If this role for oxidants is established, it may be necessary to modify the free radical theory of aging from “Organisms age because cells accumulate reactive oxygen species‐dependent damage over time” to: “Organisms age because cells accumulate oxidants’‐dependent damage and oxidants’‐dependent senescent characteristics over time.”     

An antioxidant screening assay based on oxidant-induced growth arrest in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

This report describes a biological screening system to measure the antioxidant capacity of compounds using the oxidant-induced growth arrest response of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Alternative methods using the nonphysiological free radical compounds such as diphenylpicrylhydrazyl and azinobis ethylbenzothiaziline-6-sulphonate (ABTS) only provide an indication of the ability of a compound to scavenge oxidants. In contrast, this yeast-based method can also measure the ability of a compound to induce cellular resistance to the damaging effects of oxidants. The screening assay was established against a panel of six physiologically relevant oxidants ranging from reactive oxygen species (hydrogen peroxide, cumene peroxide, linoleic acid hydroperoxide), to a superoxide-generating agent (menadione), reactive nitrogen species (peroxynitrite) and a thiol-oxidizing agent (diamide). The antioxidants ascorbate and gallic acid displayed scavenging activity and induced the resistance of cells against a broad range of oxidants using this assay. Lipoic acid, which showed no scavenging activity and thus would not be detected as an antioxidant using a nonphysiological screen was, however, identified in this assay as providing resistance to cells against a range of oxidants. This assay is high throughput, in the format of a 96-well microtitre plate, and will greatly facilitate the search for effective antioxidants.     

Effect of DL-alpha-lipoic acid on mitochondrial enzymes in aged rats.

Mitochondrial dysfunction appears to contribute to some of the loss of function accompanying ageing. Mitochondria from aged tissue use oxygen inefficiently impairing ATP synthesis and results in increased oxidant production. A high flux of oxidants not only damages mitochondria, but other important cell biomolecules as well. In the present investigation, the levels of lipid peroxidation, oxidized glutathione, non-enzymatic antioxidants and the activities of mitochondrial enzymes were measured in liver and kidney mitochondria of young and aged rats before and after lipoic acid supplementation. In both liver and kidney increase in the levels of mitochondrial lipid peroxidation and oxidized glutathione and decrease in the levels of antioxidants and the activities of mitochondrial enzymes were observed in aged rats. DL-alpha-lipoic acid supplemented aged rats showed a decrease in the levels of lipid peroxidation and oxidized glutathione and increase in the levels of reduced glutathione, vitamins C and E and the activities of mitochondrial enzymes like isocitrate dehydrogenase, alpha-ketoglutarate dehydrogenase, succinate dehydrogenase, NADH-dehydrogenase and cytochrome-c-oxidase. Thus, lipoic acid reverses the age-associated decline in endogenous low molecular weight antioxidants and mitochondrial enzymes and, therefore, may lower the increased risk of oxidative damage that occurs during ageing. From our results it can be concluded that lipoic acid supplementation enhances the activities of mitochondrial enzymes and antioxidant status and thereby protects mitochondria from ageing.     

Assessment of chronological lifespan dependent molecular damages in yeast lacking mitochondrial antioxidant genes

The free radical theory of aging states that oxidative damage to biomolecules causes aging and that antioxidants neutralize free radicals and thus decelerate aging. Mitochondria produce most of the reactive oxygen species, but at the same time have many antioxidant enzymes providing protection from these oxidants. Expecting that cells without mitochondrial antioxidant genes would accumulate higher levels of oxidative damage and, therefore, will have a shorter lifespan, we analyzed oxidative damages to biomolecules in young and chronologically aged mutants lacking the mitochondrial antioxidant genes: GRX2, CCP1, SOD1, GLO4, TRR2, TRX3, CCS1, SOD2, GRX5, and PRX1. Among these mutants, ccp1Δ, trx3Δ, grx5Δ, prx1Δ, mutants were sensitive to diamide, and ccs1Δ and sod2Δ were sensitive to both diamide and menadione. Most of the mutants were less viable in stationary phase. Chronologically aged cells produced higher amount of superoxide radical and accumulated higher levels of oxidative damages. Even though our results support the findings that old cells harbor higher amount of molecular damages, no significant difference was observed between wild type and mutant cells in terms of their damage content.     

The effects of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species during yeast replicative ageing

Free radicals are considered the most important cause of cellular ageing. We have investigated ageing process in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. We have compared the wild type strain with the mutant cells with constitutively active Ras oncogen, which generates increased amounts of free radicals. Increased generation of oxygen-derived free radicals resulted in the Ras mutant cells accumulation of lipofuscin-like pigments during ageing. Ageing wild type cells did not accumulate lipofuscin-like pigments. This is quite unique feature among known biological models. It may be caused by increased concentration of alpha tocopherol (the most prominent lipophilic antioxidant) in the wild type cells. In contrast, the Ras mutant cells contained decreased levels of alpha tocopherol even in the young cells. This observation indicates that the increased free radical generation can overwhelm the endogenous antioxidant system. We have documented the involvement of nitrogen-derived free radicals in the yeast metabolism. Protein nitrotyrosine, a marker of the reactive nitrogen species, has significantly increased in the senescent Ras mutant cells. The wild type cells contained basic level of nitrotyrosine corresponding to its concentration found in non-activated mammalian macrophages.     

Enhancement of cytotoxicity of hydrogen peroxide by hyperthermia in chinese hamster ovary cells: role of antioxidant defenses

Regional hyperthermia has potential for human cancer treatment, particularly in combination with systemic chemotherapy or radiotherapy. The mechanisms involved in heat-induced cell killing are currently unknown. Hyperthermia may increase oxidative stress in cells, and thus, oxidative stress could have a role in the mechanism of cell death. We use hydrogen peroxide as a model oxidant to improve understanding of interactions between heat and oxidative stress. Heat increased cytotoxicity of hydrogen peroxide in Chinese hamster ovary cells. Altered levels of cellular antioxidants should create an imbalance between prooxidant and antioxidant systems, thus modifying cytotoxic responses to heat and to oxidants. We determine the involvement of the two cellular antioxidant defenses against peroxides, catalase and the glutathione redox cycle, in cellular sensitivity to heat, to hydrogen peroxide, and to heat combined with the oxidant. Defense systems were either inhibited or increased. For inhibition studies, intracellular glutathione was diminished to less than 15% of its initial level by treatment with L-buthionine sulfoximine (1 mM, 24 h). Inhibition of catalase was achieved with 3-amino-1,2,4-triazole (20 mM, 2 h), which caused a 80% decrease in endogenous enzyme activity. To increase antioxidants, cells were pretreated with the thiol-containing reducing agents, N-acetyl-L-cysteine, 2-oxo-4-thiazolidine carboxylate, and 2-mercaptoethane sulfonate. These compounds increased intracellular glutathione levels by 30%. Catalase activity was increased by addition of exogenous enzyme to cells. We show that levels of glutathione and catalase affect cellular cytotoxic responses to heat and hydrogen peroxide, either used separately or in combination. These findings are relevant to mechanisms of cell killing at elevated temperatures and suggest the involvement of oxidative stress.     

Endogenous antioxidant changes in the myocardium in response to acute and chronic stress conditions

Oxygen is a diradical and because of its unique electronic configuration, it has the potential to form strong oxidants (e.g. superoxide radical, hydrogen peroxide and hydroxyl radical) called oxygen free radicals or partially reduced forms of oxygen (PRFO). These highly reactive oxygen species can cause cellular injury by oxidizing lipids and proteins as well as by causing strand breaks in nucleic acids. PRFO are produced in the cell during normal redox reactions including respiration and there are various antioxidants in the cell which scavenge these radicals. Thus in order to maintain a normal cell structure and function, a proper balance between free radical production and antioxidant levels is absolutely essential. Production of PRFO in the myocardium is increased during variousin vivo as well asin vitro pathological conditions and these toxic radicals are responsible for causing functional, biochemical and ultrastructural changes in cardiac myocytes. Indirect evidence of free radical involvement in myocardial injury is provided by studies in which protection against these alterations is seen in the presence of exogenous administration of antioxidants. Endogenous myocardial antioxidants have also been reported to change under various physiological as well as pathophysiological conditions. It appears that endogenous antioxidants respond and adjust to different stress conditions and failure of these compensatory changes may also contribute in cardiac dysfunction. Thus endogenous and/or exogenous increase in antioxidants might have a therapeutic potential in various pathological conditions which result from increased free radical production.     

Total antioxidant capacity and nuclear DNA damage in keratinocytes after exposure to H2O2

Studies of oxidative stress have classically been performed by analyzing specific, single antioxidants. In this study, susceptibility to oxidative stress in the human keratinocyte cell line NCTC2544 exposed to hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) was measured by the TOSC (total oxyradical scavenging capacity) assay, which discriminates between the antioxidant capacity toward peroxyl radicals and hydroxyl radical. The generation of H2O2-induced DNA damage, total antioxidant capacity and levels of antioxidant enzymes (catalase, superoxide dismutase, glutathione reductase, glutathione S-transferase, glutathione peroxidase) were studied. Exposure to H2O2-induced DNA damage that was gradually restored while a significant reduction in cellular TOSC values was obtained independently of stressor concentrations and the degree of DNA repair. Whereas TOSC values and cell resistance to H2O2 showed a good relationship, the extent of DNA damage is independent from cellular total antioxidant capacity. Indeed, maximum DNA damage and cell mortality were observed in the first 4 h, whereas TOSC remained persistently low until 48 h. Catalase levels were significantly lower in exposed cells after 24 and 48 h. Keratinocytes exposed after 48 h to a second H2O2 treatment exhibited massive cell death. A possible linkage was observed between TOSC values and NCTC2544 resistance to H2O2 challenge. The TOSC assay appears to be a useful tool for evaluating cellular resistance to oxidative stress.     

Ginkgo biloba extract EGb 761 protects against mitochondrial aging in the brain and in the liver.

According to the free radical theory of aging, oxygen-derived free radicals causes the age-associated impairment at the cellular and tissue levels. The mitochondrial theory of aging points to mitochondria, and specially mitochondrial DNA, as the major targets of free radical attack upon aging. Thus, oxidative damage to mtDNA accumulate with age in human and rodent tissues and also is inversely related to maximum life span of mammals. Mitochondrial deficits, such as a decrease in mitochondrial membrane potential, occur upon aging due to oxidative damage. The age-related mitochondrial oxidative stress may be prevented by late onset administration of certain antioxidants, such as Ginkgo biloba extract EGb 761. These antioxidants may also delay the physiological impairment associated with aging.     

Free radical-mediated chain oxidation of low density lipoprotein and its synergistic inhibition by vitamin E and vitamin C

The oxidation of human low density lipoprotein (LDL) initiated by free radical initiator and its inhibition by vitamin E and water-soluble antioxidants have been studied. It was found that the kinetic chain length was considerably larger than 1, suggesting that LDL was oxidized by a free radical chain mechanism. Vitamin E acted as a lipophilic chain-breaking antioxidant. Water-soluble chain-breaking antioxidants such as ascorbic acid and uric acid suppressed the oxidation of LDL initiated by aqueous radicals but they could not scavenge lipophilic radicals within LDL to break the chain propagation. Ascorbic acid acted as a synergistic antioxidant in conjunction with vitamin E.     

Ageing free radicals and cellular stress

A number of theories have attempted to account for ageing processes in various species. Following the < rate of living > theory of Pearl, Harman suggested fifty years ago that the accumulation of oxidants could explain the alteration of physical and cognitive functions with ageing. Oxygen metabolism leads to reactive species, including free radicals, which tend to oxidize surrounding molecules such as DNA, proteins and lipids. As a consequence various functions of cells and tissues can be altered, leading to DNA instability, protein denaturation and accumulation of lipid byproducts. Oxidative stress is an adaptive process which is triggered upon oxidant accumulation and which comprises the induction of protective and survival functions. Experimental evidence suggests that the ageing organism is in a state of oxidative stress, which supports the free radical theory. A number of other theories have been proposed ; some of these are actually compatible with the free radical theory. Caloric restriction is among the best models to increase life span in many species. While the relationship between caloric restriction and corrected metabolic rate is controversial, the decrease in ROS production by mitochondria appears to be experimentally supported. The ROS and mitochondrial theories of ageing appear to be compatible. Genetic models of increased life span, particularly those affecting the Foxo pathway, are usually accompanied by an increased resistance to oxidative insult. The free radical theory is not consistent with programmed senescence theories involving the cell division dependent decrease in telomere length ; however, oxidants are known to alter telomere structure. An appealing view of the role of oxidative stress in ageing is the trade-off principle which states that a phenotypic trait can be evolutionarily conserved because of its positive effects on development, growth or fertility, and despite its negative effect on somatic functions and ageing. It is likely that most cellular stresses which comprise adaptive and toxic functions follow such a rule.     

Pharmacological antioxidant strategies as therapeutic interventions for COPD

Cigarette/tobacco smoke/biomass fuel-induced oxidative and aldehyde/carbonyl stress are intimately associated with the progression and exacerbation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Therefore, targeting systemic and local oxidative stress with antioxidants/redox modulating agents, or boosting the endogenous levels of antioxidants are likely to have beneficial effects in the treatment/management of COPD. Various antioxidant agents, such as thiol molecules (glutathione and mucolytic drugs, such as N-acetyl-L-cysteine and N-acystelyn, erdosteine, fudosteine, ergothioneine, and carbocysteine), have been reported to modulate various cellular and biochemical aspects of COPD. These antioxidants have been found to scavenge and detoxify free radicals and oxidants, regulate of glutathione biosynthesis, control nuclear factor-kappaB (NF-kappaB) activation, and hence inhibiting inflammatory gene expression. Synthetic molecules, such as specific spin traps like α-phenyl-N-tert-butyl nitrone, a catalytic antioxidant (ECSOD mimetic), porphyrins (AEOL 10150 and AEOL 10113), and a superoxide dismutase mimetic M40419, iNOS and myeloperoxidase inhibitors, lipid peroxidation inhibitors/blockers edaravone, and lazaroids/tirilazad have also been shown to have beneficial effects by inhibiting cigarette smoke-induced inflammatory responses and other carbonyl/oxidative stress-induced cellular alterations. A variety of oxidants, free radicals, and carbonyls/aldehydes are implicated in the pathogenesis of COPD, it is therefore, possible that therapeutic administration or supplementation of multiple antioxidants and/or boosting the endogenous levels of antioxidants will be beneficial in the treatment of COPD. This review discusses various novel pharmacological approaches adopted to enhance lung antioxidant levels, and various emerging beneficial and/or prophylactic effects of antioxidant therapeutics in halting or intervening the progression of COPD. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Antioxidants and Antioxidant Treatment in Disease.     

Alterations in superoxide dismutase, glutathione, and peroxides in the plasmodial slime mold Physarum polycephalum during differentiation

Changes in the level of antioxidant defenses and the concentration of free radical by-products were examined in differentiating (M3cVII and LU897 X LU863), non-differentiating (LU887 X LU897), and heterokaryon microplasmodia of the slime mold Physarum polycephalum during spherulation in salts-only medium. As differentiation proceeded, superoxide dismutase activity increased by as much as 46 fold; glutathione concentration and the rate of oxygen consumption decreased; cyanide-resistant respiration, hydrogen peroxide, and organic peroxide concentrations increased. The non-differentiating culture failed to exhibit any of these changes. A heterokaryon obtained by the fusion of differentiating and non-differentiating strains was observed to differentiate at a very retarded rate and to exhibit the changes observed in the spherulating strains at a correspondingly slower rate. These observations suggest that a free radical mechanism may be involved in the differentiation of Physarum microplasmodia into spherules.     

Mitochondria, oxidative stress and aging

In the eighties, Miquel and Fleming suggested that mitochondria play a key role in cellular aging. Mitochondria, and specially mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), are major targets of free radical attack. At present, it is well established that mitochondrial deficits accumulate upon aging due to oxidative damage. Thus, oxidative lesions to mtDNA accumulate with age in human and rodent tissues. Furthermore, levels of oxidative damage to mtDNA are several times higher than those of nuclear DNA. Mitochondrial size increases whereas mitochondrial membrane potential decreases with age in brain and liver.

Recently, we have shown that treatment with certain antioxidants, such as sulphur-containing antioxidants, vitamins C and E or the Ginkgo biloba extract EGb 761, protects against the age-associated oxidative damage to mtDNA and oxidation of mitochondrial glutathione. Moreover, the extract EGb 761 also prevents changes in mitochondrial morphology and function associated with aging of the brain and liver. Thus, mitochondrial aging may be prevented by antioxidants. Furthermore, late onset administration of certain antioxidants is also able to prevent the impairment in physiological performance, particularly motor co-ordination, that occurs upon aging.     

Assessment of antioxidative activity of extract from fermented grain food mixture using chemical and cellular systems

Fermented food is a rich source of antioxidants and micronutrients with the potential to prevent various human diseases. The increasing evidence indicates that in addition to its direct action, radical-scavenging antioxidants may modulate the cellular antioxidant system such as glutathione. In the present study, we investigated the antioxidant activity of Antioxidant Biofactor (AOB) extracts, a mixture of commercially available fermented grain food by using chemical and cellular experimental systems. In the former system, the total radical scavenging capacity was assessed from the bleaching of pyranine and pyrogallol red that is induced by free radicals generated from an azo initiator. In this assay system, the radical scavenging capacity per gram of AOB was estimated to be 95 micromol. On the other hand, the cytoprotective effect of AOB was also investigated on the basis of PC12 cell death induced by 6-hydroxydopamine. In this cellular system, AOB extract exhibited a cytoprotective effect only when the cells were pretreated with AOB. This pretreatment resulted in a significant increase in the levels of cellular glutathione as well as regulator of glutathione synthesis, such as the cystine/glutamate exchange transport system (xCT). This evidence suggests that AOB possesses both direct and indirect antioxidant activities to cope with oxidative insults.     

An epigenetic perspective on the free radical theory of development

The development of organisms requires concerted changes in gene activity. The free radical theory of development proposes that oxygen serves as a morphogen to educe development by influencing the production of metabolic oxidants such as free radicals and reactive oxygen species. One of the central tenets of this theory is that these metabolic oxidants influence development by altering the antioxidant capacity of cells by changing their production of glutathione (GSH). Here we extend on these principles by linking GSH production and oxygen sensing in the control of gene expression to establish the epigenotype of cells during development. We prescribe this novel role to GSH and oxygen during development because these metabolites influence the activity of enzymes responsible for initiating and perpetuating epigenetic control of gene expression. Increased GSH production influences epigenetic processes including DNA and histone methylation by limiting the availability of S-adenosylmethionine, the cofactor utilized during epigenetic control of gene expression by DNA and histone methyltransferases. Moreover, the recent discovery of histone demethylases that require oxygen as a cofactor directly links epigenetic processes to oxygen gradients during development.     

Antioxidants and oxidative stress in exercise

Strenuous exercise increases oxygen consumption and causes disturbance of intracellular pro-oxidant-antioxidant homeostasis. The mitochondrial electron transport chain, polymorphoneutrophil, and xanthine oxidase have been identified as major sources of intracellular free radical generation during exercise. Reactive oxygen species pose a serious threat to the cellular antioxidant defense system, such as diminished reserve of antioxidant vitamins and glutathione, and increased tissue susceptibility to oxidative damage. However, enzymatic and nonenzymatic antioxidants have demonstrated great adaptation to acute and chronic exercise. The delicate balance between pro-oxidants and antioxidants suggests that supplementation of antioxidants may be desirable for physically active individuals under certain physiological conditions by providing a larger protective margin.     

Cognitive impairment and oxidative stress in the elderly: results of epidemiological studies

Cognitive impairment is a major component of age-related dementing diseases and it has been suggested that it could share the same pathological pathways with neurodegenerative processes and cerebrovascular lesions. The free radical theory of ageing could be one of these pathways. Implication of free radical damage in processes related to cerebral ageing is a good argument in favour of the hypothesis that antioxidants may protect against cognitive impairment. Observational studies (mostly cross-sectional) of relationships between cognitive impairment and antioxidant status are based on the evaluation of dietary intake or on the levels of carotenoids, selenium and vitamins A, C and E in plasma or red blood cells. More convincing results were obtained on vitamin C and carotenoids. Despite some limitations, the comparison between results obtained in various populations is becoming increasingly informative and these studies argue for a protective effect of antioxidants on cognitive performance.