Rescue of an in vitro palate nonfusion model using interposed embryonic mesenchyme

The authors previously established an in vitro palate nonfusion model on the basis of a spatial separation between prefusion embryonic day 13.5 mouse palates (term gestation, 19.5 days). They found that an interpalatal separation distance of 0.48 mm or greater would consistently result in nonfusion after 4 days in organ culture. In the present study, they interposed embryonic palatal mesenchymal tissue between embryonic day 13.5 mouse palatal shelves with interpalatal separation distances greater than 0.48 mm in an attempt to "rescue" this in vitro palate nonfusion phenotype. Because no medial epithelial bilayer (i.e., medial epithelial seam) could potentially form, palatal fusion in vitro was defined as intershelf mesenchymal continuity with resolution of the medial edge epithelia bilaterally. Forty-two (n = 42) palatal shelf pairs from embryonic day 13.5 CD-1 mouse embryos were isolated and placed on cell culture inserts at precisely graded distances (0, 0.67, and 0.95 mm). Positive controls consisted of shelves placed in contact (n = 6). Negative controls consisted of shelves placed at interpalatal separation distances of 0.67 mm (n = 6) and 0.95 mm (n = 7) with no interposed mesenchyme. Experimental groups consisted of embryonic day 13.5 palatal shelves separated by 0.67 mm (n = 11) and 0.95 mm (n = 12) with interposed lateral palatal mesenchyme isolated at the time of palatal shelf harvest. Specimens were cultured for 4 days (n = 19) or 10 days (n = 23), harvested, and evaluated histologically. All positive controls at 4 and 10 days in culture showed complete histologic palatal fusion. All negative controls at 4 days and 10 days in culture remained unfused. Five of six palatal shelves separated at 0.67 mm interpalatal separation distance with interposed mesenchyme were fused at 4 days, and all five were fused at 10 days. At an interpalatal separation distance of 0.95 mm with interposed mesenchyme (n = 12), no palates (zero of four) were fused at 4 days, but seven of eight were fused at 10 days. These data suggest that nonfused palatal shelves can be "rescued" with an interposed graft of endogenous embryonic mesenchyme to induce fusion in vitro.     

An in vitro mouse model of cleft palate: defining a critical intershelf distance necessary for palatal clefting

It is unclear whether cleft palate formation is attributable to intrinsic biomolecular defects in the embryonic elevating palatal shelves or to an inability of the shelves to overcome a mechanical obstruction (such as the tongue in Pierre Robin sequence) to normal fusion. Regardless of the specific mechanism, presumably embryonic palatal shelves are ultimately unable to bridge a critical distance and remain unapproximated, resulting in a clefting defect at birth. We propose to use a palate organ culture system to determine the critical distance beyond which embryonic palatal shelves fail to fuse (i.e., the minimal critical intershelf distance). In doing so, we hope to establish an in vitro cleft palate model that could then be used to investigate the contributions of various signaling pathways to cleft formation and to study novel in utero treatment strategies.Palatal shelves from CD-1 mouse embryos were microdissected on day 13.5 of gestation (E13.5; term = 19.5 days), before fusion. Using a standardized microscope ocular grid, paired palatal shelves were placed on a filter insert at precisely graded distances ranging from 0 (in contact) to 1.9 mm (0, 0.095, 0.19, 0.26, 0.38, 0.48, 0.57, 0.76, 0.95, and 1.9 mm). A total of 68 paired palatal shelves were placed in serum-free organ culture for 96 hours (n = 68). Sample sizes of 10 were used for each intershelf distance up to and including 0.48 mm (n = 60). For intershelf distances of 0.57 mm and greater, two-paired palatal shelves were cultured (n = 8). All specimens were assessed grossly and histologically for palatal fusion.Palatal fusion occurred in our model only when intershelf distances were 0.38 mm or less. At 0.38 mm, eight of 10 palates appeared grossly adherent, whereas six of 10 demonstrated clear fusion histologically with resolution of the medial epithelial seam and continuity of the palatal mesenchyme. None of the 18 palates fused when placed at intershelf distances of 0.48 mm or greater.Using our selected intershelf distances as a guideline, we have established an approximate minimal critical intershelf distance (0.48 mm) at which we can reliably expect no palatal fusion. Culturing palatal shelves at intershelf distances of 0.48 mm or greater results in nonfusion or clefting in vitro. This model will allow us to study biomolecular characteristics of unfused or cleft palatal shelves in comparison with fused shelves. Furthermore, we plan to study the efficacy of grafting with exogenous embryonic mesenchyme or candidate factors to overcome clefting in vitro as a first step toward future in utero treatment strategies.     

Pathogenesis of cleft palate in TGF-beta3 knockout mice.

We previously reported that mutation of the transforming growth factor-beta3 (TGF-beta3) gene caused cleft palate in homozygous null (-/-) mice. TGF-beta3 is normally expressed in the medial edge epithelial (MEE) cells of the palatal shelf. In the present study, we investigated the mechanisms by which TGF-beta3 deletions caused cleft palate in 129 x CF-1 mice. For organ culture, palatal shelves were dissected from embryonic day 13.5 (E13.5) mouse embryos. Palatal shelves were placed singly or in pairs on Millipore filters and cultured in DMEM/F12 medium. Shelves were placed in homologous (+/+ vs +/+, -/- vs -/-, +/- vs +/-) or heterologous (+/+ vs -/-, +/- vs -/-, +/+ vs +/-) paired combinations and examined by macroscopy and histology. Pairs of -/- and -/- shelves failed to fuse over 72 hours of culture whereas pairs of +/+ (wild-type) and +/+ or +/- (heterozygote) and +/-, as well as +/+ and -/- shelves, fused within the first 48 hour period. Histological examination of the fused +/+ and +/+ shelves showed complete disappearance of the midline epithelial seam whereas -/- and +/+ shelves still had some seam remnants. In order to investigate the ability of TGF-beta family members to rescue the fusion between -/- and -/- palatal shelves in vitro, either recombinant human (rh) TGF-beta1, porcine (p) TGF-beta2, rh TGF-beta3, rh activin, or p inhibin was added to the medium in different concentrations at specific times and for various periods during the culture. In untreated organ culture -/- palate pairs completely failed to fuse, treatment with TGF-beta3 induced complete palatal fusion, TGF-beta1 or TGF-beta2 near normal fusion, but activin and inhibin had no effect. We investigated ultrastructural features of the surface of the MEE cells using SEM to compare TGF-beta3-null embryos (E 12. 5-E 16.5) with +/+ and +/- embryos in vivo and in vitro. Up to E13.5 and after E15.5, structures resembling short rods were observed in both +/+ and -/- embryos. Just before fusion, at E14.5, a lot of filopodia-like structures appeared on the surface of the MEE cells in +/+ embryos, however, none were observed in -/- embryos, either in vivo or in vitro. With TEM these filopodia are coated with material resembling proteoglycan. Interestingly, addition of TGF-beta3 to the culture medium which caused fusion between the -/- palatal shelves also induced the appearance of these filopodia on their MEE surfaces. TGF-beta1 and TGF-beta2 also induced filopodia on the -/- MEE but to a lesser extent than TGF-beta3 and additionally induced lamellipodia on their cell surfaces. These results suggest that TGF-beta3 may regulate palatal fusion by inducing filopodia on the outer cell membrane of the palatal medial edge epithelia prior to shelf contact. Exogenous recombinant TGF-beta3 can rescue fusion in -/- palatal shelves by inducing such filopodia, illustrating that the effects of TGF-beta3 are transduced by cell surface receptors which raises interesting potential therapeutic strategies to prevent and treat embryonic cleft palate.     

Tgf-beta3-induced palatal fusion is mediated by Alk-5/Smad pathway

Cleft palate is among the most common birth defects in humans, caused by a failure in the complex multistep developmental process of palatogenesis. It has been recently shown that transforming growth factor beta3 (Tgf-beta3) is an absolute requirement for successful palatal fusion, both in mice and humans. However, very little is known about the mechanisms of Tgf-beta3 signaling during this process. Here we show that putative Tgf-beta type I receptors, Alk-1, Alk-2, and Alk-5, are all endogenously expressed in the palatal epithelium. Activation of Alk-5 in the Tgf-beta3 (-/-) palatal epithelium is able to rescue palatal fusion, whereas inactivation of Alk-5 in the wild-type palatal epithelium prevents palatal fusion. The effect of Alk-2 is similar, but less pronounced. The induction of fusion by activation of Alk-5 or Alk-2 is stronger in the posterior parts of the palates at the embryonic day 14 (E14), while their activation at E13.5 also restores anterior fusion, reflecting the natural anterior-posterior direction of palate maturation in vivo. We also show that Smad2 is endogenously activated in the palatal midline epithelial seam (MES) during the fusion process. By using a mutant Alk-5 receptor that is an active kinase but is unable to activate Smads, we show that activation of Smad-independent Tgf-beta responses is not sufficient to induce fusion of shelves deficient in Tgf-beta3. Based on these observations, we conclude that the Smad2-dependent Alk-5 signaling pathway is dominant in palatal fusion driven by Tgf-beta3.     

Epithelial Wnt/β-catenin signaling regulates palatal shelf fusion through regulation of Tgfβ3 expression

The canonical Wnt/β-catenin signaling plays essential role in development and diseases. Previous studies have implicated the canonical Wnt/β-catenin signaling in the regulation of normal palate development, but functional Wnt/β-catenin signaling and its tissue-specific activities remain to be accurately elucidated. In this study, we show that functional Wnt/β-catenin signaling operates primarily in the palate epithelium, particularly in the medial edge epithelium (MEE) of the developing mouse palatal shelves, consistent with the expression patterns of β-catenin and several Wnt ligands and receptors. Epithelial specific inactivation of β-catenin by the K14-Cre transgenic allele abolishes the canonical Wnt signaling activity in the palatal epithelium and leads to an abnormal persistence of the medial edge seam (MES), ultimately causing a cleft palate formation, a phenotype resembling that in Tgfβ3 mutant mice. Consistent with this phenotype is the down-regulation of Tgfβ3 and suppression of apoptosis in the MEE of the β-catenin mutant palatal shelves. Application of exogenous Tgfβ3 to the mutant palatal shelves in organ culture rescues the midline seam phenotype. On the other hand, expression of stabilized β-catenin in the palatal epithelium also disrupts normal palatogenesis by activating ectopic Tgfβ3 expression in the palatal epithelium and causing an aberrant fusion between the palate shelf and mandible in addition to severely deformed palatal shelves. Collectively, our results demonstrate an essential role for Wnt/β-catenin signaling in the epithelial component at the step of palate fusion during palate development by controlling the expression of Tgfβ3 in the MEE.     

Nonneuronal expression of the GABA(A) beta3 subunit gene is required for normal palate development in mice

Cleft palate is one of the most common birth defects in humans, in which both genetic and environmental factors are involved. In mice, loss of the GABA(A) receptor beta3 subunit gene (Gabrb3) or the targeted mutagenesis of the GABA synthetic enzyme (Gad1) leads to cleft palate. These observations indicate that a GABAergic system is important in normal palate development. To determine what cell types, neuronal or nonneuronal, are critical for GABA signaling in palate development, we used the neuron-specific enolase promoter to express the beta3 subunit in Gabrb3 mutant mice. Expression of this construct was able to rescue the neurological phenotype, but not the cleft palate phenotype. Combined with the previous observation demonstrating that ubiquitous expression of the beta3 subunit rescued the cleft palate phenotype, a nonneuronal GABAergic system is implicated in palate development. Using immunohistochemistry, we detected GABA in the developing palate, initially in the nasal aspect of palatal epithelium of the vertical shelves; later in the medial edge epithelium of the horizontally oriented palatal shelves and in the epithelial seam during fusion. Based on these observations, we propose that GABA, synthesized by the palatal epithelium, acts as a signaling molecule during orientation and fusion of the palate shelves.     

Retinoic acid alters epithelial differentiation during palatogenesis.

Retinoids are teratogenic in humans and animals, producing a syndrome of craniofacial malformations that includes cleft palate. This study investigates the mechanism through which retinoic acid induces cleft palate. Murine palatogenesis after exposure to retinoic acid in utero is compared to normal development and to alterations observed after exposure in organ culture to retinoic acid or epidermal growth factor (EGF). Human embryonic palatal shelves were placed in the organ culture system and the responses to retinoic acid and EGF were compared to those of the murine palatal shelves. Growth factors play a role in normal development and are found in the embryonic palate. In other cell culture systems, retinoids alter the expression of EGF receptors. Our results suggest that in the medial epithelial cells of the palate, retinoic acid sustains the expression of the EGF receptor and the binding of EGF at a time when the expression in control medial cells has declined, and these control cells subsequently undergo programmed cell death. The continued DNA synthesis, proliferation, survival, and shift in phenotype of the medial cells is believed to interfere with the adhesion and fusion of opposing palatal shelves, resulting in cleft palate.     

Temporal and Spatial Expression of Hoxa-2 During Murine Palatogenesis

1. Mice homozygous for a targeted mutation of the Hoxa-2 gene are born with a bilateral cleft of the secondary palate associated with multiple head and cranial anomalies and these animals die within 24 hr of birth (Gendron-Maguire et al., 1993; Rijli et al., 1993; Mallo and Gridley, 1996). We have determined the spatial and temporal expression of the Hoxa-2 homeobox protein in the developing mouse palate at embryonic stages E12, E13, E13.5, E14, E14.5, and E15.2. Hoxa-2 is expressed in the mesenchyme and epithelial cells of the palate at E12, but is progressively restricted to the tips of the growing palatal shelves at E13.3. By the E13.5 stage of development, Hoxa-2 protein was found to be expressed throughout the palatal shelf. These observations correlate with palatal shelf orientation and Hoxa-2 protein may play a direct or indirect role in guiding the palatal shelves vertically along side the tongue, starting with the tips of the palatal shelves at E13, followed by the entire palatal shelf at E13.5.4. As development progresses to E14, the stage at which shelf elevation occurs, Hoxa-2 protein is downregulated in the palatal mesenchyme but remains in the medial edge epithelium. Expression of Hoxa-2 continues in the medial edge epithelium until the fusion of opposing palatal shelves.5. By the E15 stage of development, Hoxa-2 is downregulated in the palate and expression is localized in the nasal and oral epithelia.6. In an animal model of phenytoin-induced cleft palate, we report that Hoxa-2 mRNA and protein expression were significantly decreased, implicating a possible functional role of the Hoxa-2 gene in the development of phenytoin-induced cleft palate.7. A recent report by Barrow and Capecchi (1999), has illustrated the importance of tongue posture during palatal shelf closure in Hoxa-2 mutant mice. This along with our new findings of the expression of the Hoxa-2 protein during palatogenesis has shed some light on the putative role of this gene in palate development.     

TGF-beta3-induced palatogenesis requires matrix metalloproteinases

Cleft lip and palate syndromes are among the most common congenital malformations in humans. Mammalian palatogenesis is a complex process involving highly regulated interactions between epithelial and mesenchymal cells of the palate to permit correct positioning of the palatal shelves, the remodeling of the extracellular matrix (ECM), and subsequent fusion of the palatal shelves. Here we show that several matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs), including a cell membrane-associated MMP (MT1-MMP) and tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase-2 (TIMP-2) were highly expressed by the medial edge epithelium (MEE). MMP-13 was expressed both in MEE and in adjacent mesenchyme, whereas gelatinase A (MMP-2) was expressed by mesenchymal cells neighboring the MEE. Transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta3-deficient mice, which suffer from clefting of the secondary palate, showed complete absence of TIMP-2 in the midline and expressed significantly lower levels of MMP-13 and slightly reduced levels of MMP-2. In concordance with these findings, MMP-13 expression was strongly induced by TGF-beta3 in palatal fibroblasts. Finally, palatal shelves from prefusion wild-type mouse embryos cultured in the presence of a synthetic inhibitor of MMPs or excess of TIMP-2 failed to fuse and MEE cells did not transdifferentiate, phenocopying the defect of the TGF-beta3-deficient mice. Our observations indicate for the first time that the proteolytic degradation of the ECM by MMPs is a necessary step for palatal fusion.     

Medial edge epithelium transforms to mesenchyme after embryonic palatal shelves fuse

The disappearance of palatal medial edge epithelium (MEE) after fusion of secondary palatal shelves is often cited as a classical example of embryonic remodeling by programmed cell death. We reinvestigated this phenomenon in 16-day rat embryos, using light and electron microscopy. We confirm reports that the periderm of the two-layered MEE begins to slough after shelves assume horizontal positions. In vitro, peridermal cells are not able to slough and are trapped during the adhesion process. In vivo, however, surface cells shed before the shelves in the anterior palate adhere, allowing junctions to form between opposing basal epithelial cells. Midline seams so formed consist of two layers of basal cells, all of which appear healthy. Even though its cells are dividing, growth of the seam fails to keep pace with palatal growth and it thins to one layer of cells, and then breaks up into small islands. The basal lamina disappears and elongating MEE cells extend filopodia into adjacent connective tissue. Electron micrographs reveal transitional steps in loss of epithelial characteristics and gain of fibroblast-like features by transforming MEE cells. One such feature, observed with the aid of immunofluorescence, is the turn of the mesenchymal cytoskeletal protein, vimentin. No cell death or macrophages are observed after adhesion and thinning over most of the palate. These data indicate that MEE is an ectoderm that retains the ability to transform into mesenchymal cells. Epithelial-mesenchymal transformation may be expressed in other embryonic remodelings (R.L. Trelstad, A. Hayashi, K. Hayashi, and P.K. Donahue, 1982, Dev. Biol. 92, 27), resulting in heretofore unsuspected conservation of embryonic cell populations.     

Medial epithelial seam cell migration during palatal fusion

The mammalian secondary palate forms from two shelves of mesenchyme sheathed in a single-layered epithelium. These shelves meet during embryogenesis to form the midline epithelial seam (MES). Failure of MES degradation prevents mesenchymal confluence and results in a cleft palate. Previous studies indicated that MES cells undergo features of epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT) and may become migratory as part of the fusion mechanism. To detect MES cell movement over the course of fusion, we imaged the midline of fusing embryonic ephrin-B2/GFP mouse palates in real time using two-photon microscopy. These mice express an ephrin-B2-driven green fluorescent protein (GFP) that labels the palatal epithelium nuclei and persists in those cells through the time window necessary for fusion. We observed collective migration of MES cells toward the oral surface of the palatal shelf over 48 hr of imaging, and we confirmed histologically that the imaged palates had fused by the end of the imaged period. We previously reported that ephrin reverse signaling in the MES is required for palatal fusion. We therefore added recombinant EphA4/Fc protein to block this signaling in imaged palates. The blockage inhibited fusion, as expected, but did not change the observed migration of GFP-labeled cells. Thus, we uncoupled migration and fusion. Our data reveal that palatal MES cells undergo a collective, unidirectional movement during palatal fusion and that ephrin reverse signaling, though required for fusion, controls aspects of the fusion mechanism independent of migration.     

Differential expression of TGF beta isoforms in murine palatogenesis

We have studied the expression of genes encoding transforming growth factors (TGFs) beta 1, beta 2 and beta 3 during development of the secondary palate in the mouse from 11.5 to 15.5 days postcoitum using in situ hybridisation. The RNA detected at the earliest developmental stage is TGF beta 3, which is localised in the epithelial component of the vertical palatal shelf. This expression continues in the horizontal palatal shelf, predominantly in the medial edge epithelium, and is lost as the epithelial seam disrupts, soon after palatal shelf fusion. TGF beta 1 RNA is expressed with the same epithelial pattern as TGF beta 3, but is not detectable until the horizontal palatal shelf stage. TGF beta 2 RNA is localised to the palatal mesenchyme underlying the medial edge epithelia in the horizontal shelves and in the early postfusion palate. The temporal and spatial distribution of TGF beta 1, beta 2 and beta 3 RNAs in the developing palate, together with a knowledge of in vitro TGF beta biological activities, suggests an important role for TGF beta isoforms in this developmental process.     

Bulging medial edge epithelial cells and palatal fusion

The surface of the medial edge epithelium of embryonic day 12, 13 and 14 mouse palatal shelves was observed utilising Environmental Scanning Electron Microscopy (ESEM). This technique offers the advantage of visualisation of biological samples after short fixation times in their natural hydrated state. Bulging epithelial cells were observed consistently on the medial edge epithelium prior to palatal shelf fusion. Additionally, we have used ESEM to compare the morphology and surface features of palatal shelves from embryonic day 13 to 16 mouse embryos that are homozygous null (TGF-beta3 -/-), heterozygous (TGF-beta3 +/-) or homozygous normal (TGF-beta3 +/+) for transforming growth factor beta-3 (TGF-beta3). At embryonic day 15 and 16 most TGF-beta3 +/- and +/+ embryos showed total palatal fusion, whilst all TGF-beta3 null mutants had cleft palate: the middle third of the palatal shelves had adhered, leaving an anterior and posterior cleft. From embryonic day 14 to 16 abundant cells were observed bulging on the medial edge epithelial surface of palates from the TGF-beta3 +/- and +/+ embryos. However, they were never seen in the TGF-beta3 null embryos, suggesting that these surface bulges might be important in palatal fusion and that their normal differentiation is induced by TGF-beta3. The expression pattern of E-Cadherin, beta-catenin, chondroitin sulphate proteoglycan, beta-Actin and vinculin as assayed by immunocytochemistry in these cells shows specific variations that suggest their importance in palatal shelf adhesion.     

Retinoids and epidermal growth factor alter embryonic mouse palatal epithelial and mesenchymal cell differentiation in organ culture

The mechanism by which retinoids (RA) induce cleft palate is not known. During normal palatogenesis, the medial epithelia of opposing palatal shelves cease DNA synthesis, come into contact, adhere, and undergo programmed cell death (PCD). In organ cultures of day 12 embryonic mouse palatal shelves, epidermal growth factor (EGF) blocks PCD, and DNA synthesis continues. In the present study, the effects of trans-RA, 13-cis-RA, EGF, and combinations of EGF and RA on surface morphology, DNA synthesis, and cellular ultrastructure are determined for CD-1 embryonic mouse palatal shelves cultured on day 12 of gestation. DNA synthesis in the medial cells was sustained and PCD was blocked by EGF, trans-RA, and 13-cis-RA. Exposure to trans-RA, but not to 1-cis-RA, induced the medial epithelia to undergo hyperplasia, and addition of EGF enhanced the effect. In the presence of RA, particularly trans-RA, medial epithelial cells acquired nasal cell characteristics, and EGF enhanced this effect. Expansion of the mesenchymal extracellular spaces was blocked by trans-RA and to a lesser degree by 13-cis-RA. The RA-induced alterations in normal epithelial and mesenchymal cell differentiation may be relevant to the etiology of RA-induced cleft palate in vivo.     

Experimental induction of palate shelf elevation in glutamate decarboxylase 67-deficient mice with cleft palate due to vertically oriented palatal shelf

BACKGROUND: Gamma-aminobutyric acid is an inhibitory neurotransmitter, synthesized by two isoforms of glutamate decarboxylase (GAD), GAD65 and -67. Unexpectedly, inactivation of GAD67 induces cleft palate in mice. Reduction of spontaneous tongue movement resulting from decreased motor nerve activity has been related to the development of cleft palate in GAD67(-/-) fetuses. In the present study, development of cleft palate was examined histologically and manipulated with culture of the maxilla and partial resection of fetal tongue. METHODS: GAD67(-/-) mice and their littermates were used. Histological examination and immunohistochemistry were performed conventionally. Organ culture of the maxilla was carried out as reported previously. Fetuses were maintained alive under anesthesia and tips of their tongues were resected. RESULTS: Elevation of palatal shelves, the second step of palate formation, was not observed in GAD67(-/-) mice. In wild-type mice, GAD67 and gamma-aminobutyric acid were not expressed in the palatal shelves, except in the medial edge epithelium. During 2 days of culture of maxillae dissected from E13.5-E14.0 GAD67(-/-) fetuses, elevation and fusion of the palatal shelves were induced. When E13.5-15.5 mutant fetuses underwent partial tongue resection, the palatal shelves became elevated within 30 min. CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that the potential for palate formation is maintained in the palatal shelves of GAD67(-/-) fetuses, but it is obstructed by other, probably neural, factors, resulting in cleft palate.