Regulatory mechanisms in cytotoxic T lymphocyte development. II. Dissociation of in vitro cytotoxic T-lymphocyte and suppressor T-cell activities with L-ornithine

L-ornithine was found to differentially affect the induction of allospecific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) and suppressor T cells (Ts). At a concentration of 10 mM, ornithine inhibited the development of CTL in a mixed-leukocyte culture (MLC). This same population of cells suppressed the generation of CTL when irradiated and cocultured with fresh syngeneic lymphocytes and alloantigen. Suppression was mediated by Lyt-1-2+ cells and was antigen specific. Suppression was abrogated when IL-2 (10 U/ml) was added to the cocultures, but could not be reversed by increasing the antigen dose. Ornithine was not toxic to CTL precursors but rather arrested their development. Cells from MLC plus ornithine developed CTL activity within 2 days of transfer to secondary cultures in the absence of ornithine. Development of CTL effector cells (CTLe) was augmented by but did not require exogenous IL-2. Generation of CTLe from the MLC plus ornithine population was radiation sensitive and could be inhibited by reexposure to ornithine, even in the presence of IL-2. Thus, Lyt-1-2+ T cells allostimulated in vitro in MLC plus ornithine and lacking CTL activity convey radiation-resistant, antigen-specific suppression.     

Regulation of the cytotoxic activity of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes by helper cells and lymphokines

The cytotoxic activity of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) was maintained and augmented by transferring cells from a 5-day mixed lymphocyte culture MLC into a host culture (HC) containing indomethacin, freshly explanted normal spleen cells, and peritoneal cells which were syngeneic to the MLC cells. The MLC cells used in the transfer experiments were generated by culturing untreated H-2b splenic responders with irradiated H-2d stimulators, or were generated by culturing Lyt-2-depleted H-2b splenic responders with irradiated H-2d stimulators. The allo-CTL were found to be derived from the donor MLC (first culture) when unfractionated MLC cells were transferred into a host (second) culture and incubated for 5 days. In contrast, the allo-CTL were derived from host culture cells when Lyt-2-depleted MLC cells were transferred and the combined cultures incubated for 5 days. In the former case, the augmentation of MLC-derived cytotoxicity did not result from nonspecific expansion of all donor T cells; instead it was mediated by lymphokine(s), distinct from IL-2, produced by helper T cells generated in host culture, which appeared to selectively expand the antigen-specific CTL or to increase the cytotoxic activity of these CTL. The helper T cells were Thy-1+, L3T4+, and Lyt-2-. These findings indicate that antigen-nonspecific help was provided by helper cells or helper factors (lymphokines) generated in the host culture, which maintained and augmented the cytotoxic activity of the fully generated allo-CTL. This helper effect was also seen in the induction of primary allo-CTL responses which could be generated with fewer stimulating cells and with a stronger cytotoxic response at different R/S ratios tested. The generation of allo-CTL in second culture following transfer of Lyt-2-depleted MLC cells to host cultures appears to have involved antigen carryover from the MLC; however, antigen carryover alone was not sufficient. It appears that in the absence of Lyt-2+ suppressor T cells, antigen-specific help might be generated in donor cultures (Lyt-2-depleted MLC) which promoted or recruited the generation of antigen-specific CTL in host culture.     

Reversal of phorbol ester-mediated reduction of cloned T lymphocyte cytolysis by interleukin 2

During previous studies on the regulation of cloned T lymphocyte function, we observed that murine cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones progressively lose the ability to lyse appropriate target cells during prolonged (24 to 48 hr) incubation with the tumor promoter phorbol myristic acetate (PMA). We further observed that the cytolytic function of PMA-treated CTL clones can be restored by incubation with secondary MLC supernatant (2 degrees MLC SN), a potent source of cytokines. We now report our observations on the nature of the cytokine(s) responsible for recovery of CTL activity. Like 2 degrees MLC SN, the lectin-induced SN from a cloned helper T cell and the lectin-induced SN from a T cell hybridoma can restore cytolytic activity to cloned CTL treated with PMA. In contrast, supernatants from L929 cells, WEHI-3 cells, and P388D1 cells fail to restore cytolytic activity to similarly treated cloned CTL. These data suggest that IL 2 and/or gamma-IFN, but not CSF-1, CSF-GM, IL 3, or IL 1, can influence expression of cytolysis by cloned CTL. Furthermore, highly purified IL 2 can restore cytolytic activity, even when cytosine arabinoside is present to inhibit clonal expansion. Our studies indicate that cytolysis is a reversible function of cloned CTL, and that cytolysis may not necessarily represent an end-stage feature of CTL maturation. Our studies further show that IL 2 is both necessary and sufficient for resumption of cytolytic function by "deactivated" CTL. As such, these observations suggest that IL 2 can regulate not only T cell proliferation but also the expression of cytolysis by some cytolytic T cell populations.     

Cytolytic T lymphocyte clones that proliferate autonomously to specific alloantigenic stimulation. II. Relationship of the Lyt-2 molecular complex to cytolytic activity, proliferation, and lymphokine secretion

Previous analyses of the inhibitory effects of anti-Lyt-2 monoclonal antibodies (mAb) on cytolytic activity suggested that Lyt-2/3 antigens expressed on the surface of murine cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) are involved in antigen recognition. In the present study, we investigated the effects of anti-Lyt-2 mAb (in the absence of complement) on the functional activities of H-2K/D-specific Lyt-2+ CTL clones that proliferate to antigenic stimulation in the absence of helper T cells or added interleukin 2 (IL 2) and secrete lymphokines. For those clones that were inhibited in cytolysis by anti-Lyt-2 mAb, a parallel inhibition of antigen-dependent proliferation and lymphokine secretion (interferon, macrophage-activating factor) was observed. Inhibition of proliferation or lymphokine secretion could be overcome by the addition of IL 2 or lectin, respectively. Collectively, these results would strongly suggest that anti-Lyt-2 mAb were inhibiting CTL antigen recognition. Not all CTL clones, however, were inhibited in cytolysis by anti-Lyt-2 mAb, in which case proliferation and lymphokine secretion were similarly unaffected. This heterogeneity of Lyt-2+ CTL clones in their susceptibility to inhibition of cytolytic activity, proliferation, and lymphokine secretion by anti-Lyt-2 mAb is discussed in the context of a model proposing that Lyt-2/3 molecules function to stabilize the interaction between CTL receptors and the corresponding target/stimulating cell antigens. Such a stabilization may be required by CTL possessing few and/or low affinity receptors.     

Regulation of the production of immune interferon and cytotoxic T lymphocytes by interleukin 2

The activation of alloantigen-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors is dependent upon the presence of both macrophages and helper T cells or regulatory molecules derived from these facilitative cells. Three biochemically distinct helper factors have been identified: interleukin 1 (macrophage-derived), Interleukin 2 (T cell derived), and immune interferon. All 3 factors are found in supernatants of mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC), however, the removal of macrophages from these cultures completely ablates the production of these factors as well as the induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). The addition of IL 2 to these macrophage-depleted MLC restores the ability of responder T cells to: 1) bypass the requirement for macrophage soluble function, 2) produce immune interferon, and 3) generate CTL. The kinetics and dose response of immune interferon production in response to IL 2 correlates with the generation of CTL. The production of immune interferon as well as the generation of CTL requires T cells, alloantigen, and IL2. Furthermore, the induction of CTL by IL2 was neutralized by the addition of anti-immune interferon. These data suggest that: 1) the regulation of immune interferon production is based on a T to T cell interaction mediated by IL 2, and 2) immune interferon production may be required for IL 2 induction of CTL. These findings are consistent with the hypothesis that the induction of CTL involves a linear cell-factor interaction in which IL 1 (macrophage-derived) stimulates T cells to produce IL 2, which in turn stimulates other T cells to produce immune interferon and become cytotoxic.     

Lyt-2+ suppressor T cells are resistant to anti-Lyt-2 antibody blocking

Lyt-2 molecules play a role in antigen recognition by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). In an attempt to determine whether Lyt-2 molecules play a similar role in suppressor T cell (Ts) functions, the effect of anti-Lyt-2 antibodies on Ts generation and effector activity was studied. Allospecific Ts were induced in allogeneic mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC). Anti-Lyt-2 antibodies added to MLC in the absence of complement abolished CTL generation, but had no effect on concomitant induction of Ts. In a different experimental system, allospecific Ts were induced in cultures treated with pyrilamine, which blocks generation of CTL but allows differentiation of Ts. The addition of anti-Lyt-2 antibodies to pyrilamine-treated MLC resulted in unaffected induction of Ts. It was further demonstrated that the effector activity of Ts was as resistant to anti-Lyt-2 antibodies as their induction, in contrast to the cytolytic activity of CTL, which was inhibited by the same antibodies. Ts in the present experimental system were Lyt-2+ antigen-specific cells. It therefore appears that Lyt-2 molecules, although expressed on both CTL and Ts, are involved in CTL activity, but do not play an essential role in Ts function.     

Limiting dilution analysis of alloreactive cytotoxic precursor cells in aging mice

The quantitative minimal estimate of the frequency of alloantigen specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor cells (CTL-p) was determined in young and old C57BL/6 mice by limiting dilution analysis. Supernatant from phorbol myristate acetate-induced EL-4 cells was used as a source of IL 2 in these assays, which therefore were independent of the presence of the Lyt-2-, IL 2-producing cells known to be deficient in aging mice. These studies showed that 24-mo-old mice had approximately 10-fold fewer CTL-p than their young counterparts. Comparison of the limiting dilution assay (LDA) with IL 2-supplemented primary MLC shows that estimates of the frequency of CTL-p do not consistently agree with cytotoxic activity detected in the higher cell density primary MLC, and that the LDA is most likely a better estimate of the effect of age on the development of CTL.     

Monoclonal cytotoxic T lymphocyte hybridomas capable of specific killing activity, antigenic responsiveness, and inducible interleukin secretion

We have recently described the production of cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) hybridomas that grow continuously in culture, exhibiting constitutive, allospecific (anti-H-2b) killing activity. We now report on the response of these monoclonal CTL hybridomas to specific antigen (H-2Db) and to mitogenic lectins. Both specific antigen and T cell mitogens enhance hybridoma-mediated specific target cell killing. In addition, stimulated, but not unstimulated hybridoma cells secrete considerable amounts of IL 2 into the culture medium. Repeated cloning of the hybridomas provides strong evidence that both killing activity and IL 2 secretion can be attributed to one cell. Unfractionated Con A supernatants, containing IL 2 and other factors known to influence T cell responsiveness, or IL 2-containing media of stimulated hybridomas affect neither the growth nor the lytic activity of the hybridomas. Anti-LFA-1 monoclonal antibody, a potent inhibitor of CTL and CTL hybridoma-mediated target cell lysis, abolishes antigen- or mitogen-induced IL 2 secretion by the CTL hybridomas. Involvement of a single hybridoma receptor in antigen recognition (afferent and efferent) and in initiating IL 2 secretion is proposed. The CTL hybridomas displaying retarded killing activity before the antigenic or mitogenic stimulation appear to represent an intermediate stage in CTL differentiation, reminiscent of "memory" CTL.     

A murine cytotoxic T lymphocyte clone from the intestinal mucosa that is antigen specific for proliferation and displays broadly reactive inducible cytotoxic activity

Thy-1+, Lyt-1-,2+, asialo GM1+ cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones have been isolated from the intestinal mucosa of mice primed with alloantigens. Two different types of cytotoxic clones have been obtained. The first type is functionally similar to most splenic and lymph node-derived CTL clones in that they are strictly antigen specific with respect to proliferation and cytolytic activity. The second type of CTL clone has several unique characteristics. Although these clones are also antigen specific with regard to proliferation, they are not cytolytic under standard growth conditions in medium containing 4% rat concanavalin A-induced spleen cell supernatant. After culture for 4 days in the presence of high concentrations of interleukin 2, cells become activated and exhibit broad lytic potential. Moreover, during the activation process, these CTL begin to express a murine T cell surface antigen, CT-1, which is associated with activated cytotoxic cells. The findings reported in this report should now allow us to precisely define, both phenotypically and functionally, specific lymphocyte populations that make up the gut-associated lymphoid tissues. These data also describe a new type of effector CTL that differs from other cytotoxic cells reported to date, because it is antigen dependent for proliferation, but requires signals mediated by lymphokines for lytic activation.     

Derivation of cytotoxic T cell lines that express T cell receptor but exhibit reversible loss of stable antigen binding

Stable cell lines lacking cytotoxic activity against specific target cells were derived from highly active murine CTL clones by the omission of antigen from the culture for several weeks. Several independent CTL clones cultured in the absence of antigen showed a gradual decline in cytotoxic activity, resulting in complete loss by 5 to 10 wk. Such noncytotoxic (NC) cells lacked the ability to form stable conjugates with specific target cells, but were able to kill all target cells tested in the presence of Con A. It was shown by subcloning at limiting dilution that all cells in the starting population were cytolytically active, and that all cells in the NC population derived from such a clone were cytolytically inactive against target cells bearing an appropriate antigen under normal assay conditions. By using the monoclonal antibody F23.1, which reacted with the antigen receptors of two of the CTL clones, it was shown that the NC cells derived from these clones continued to express the receptor at normal levels. Levels of expression of Thy-1.2, Lyt-2.2, and LFA-1 were also similar in all cytotoxic cell lines and their noncytotoxic derivatives. The F23.1 antibody induced an increase in cytoplasmic free Ca2+ in both CTL and NC cells, and NC cells lysed F23.1 hybridoma cells in the absence of Con A. When cells expressing appropriate target cell antigen were added back to cultures of NC cells, cytotoxic activity of appropriate specificity was fully recovered in 2 wk. These results indicate that expression of an apparently functional antigen receptor alone is insufficient for stable binding of CTL to specific target cells, and that other factors dependent upon antigen stimulation may be involved in the recognition process. A difference in affinity for antigen between CTL and NC cells is suggested as a possible explanation for these observations.     

Distinct proliferative T cell clonotypes are generated in response to a murine retrovirus-induced syngeneic T cell leukemia: viral gp70 antigen-specific MT4+ clones and Lyt-2+ cytolytic clones which recognize a tumor-specific cell surface antigen

After immunization of B6 mice with the syngeneic retrovirus-induced T cell leukemia/lymphoma FBL-3, two major tumor-specific proliferative T cell clonotypes were derived. T cell clones derived from long-term lines propagated by in vitro culture with irradiated tumor cells and syngeneic spleen cells were exclusively of the Lyt-2+ phenotype. Such clones were cytolytic, retained their proliferative phenotype indefinitely when expanded by repeated cycles of reactivation and rest, and recognized a tumor-specific cell surface antigen in association with class I MHC molecules. This tumor cell antigen was not present on nontransformed virus-infected cells. Class II MHC-restricted MT4+ clones specific for the viral antigen gp70 were derived from lymph node T cells of FBL-3 tumor-immune mice only by in vitro culture with purified Friend virus in the presence of syngeneic splenic APC. Once derived, however, such clones could be stimulated in the presence of FBL-3 tumor cells and syngeneic spleen cells, demonstrating the reprocessing of tumor-derived gp70 antigen by APC in the spleen cell population. In contrast, no reprocessing of the tumor cell surface antigen by splenic APC for presentation to the class I MHC-restricted T cell clones could be demonstrated. Evidence is presented that FBL-3 T leukemia/lymphoma cells function as APC for Lyt-2+ class I MHC-restricted clones, and that no concomitant recognition of Ia molecules is required to activate these clones. Both Lyt-2+ and MT4+ clones were induced to proliferate in the presence of exogenous IL2 alone, but this stimulus failed to result in significant release of immune interferon. In contrast, antigen stimulation of both clones resulted in proliferation as well as significant immune interferon release. Immune interferon production is not required for the generation of MHC-restricted cell-mediated cytolytic function.     

Therapy of murine leukemia with cyclophosphamide and immune Lyt-2+ cells: cytolytic T cells can mediate eradication of disseminated leukemia

Several animal models have been developed in which the adoptive transfer of specifically immune syngeneic T cells has been shown to mediate the eradication of established tumors. In adoptive chemoimmunotherapy (ACIT) of disseminated FBL leukemia with cyclophosphamide and immune T cells, the major effector T cell has been shown to be a noncytolytic Lyt-1+2- T cell that mediates its therapeutic effect without the participation of CTL. Because studies in other models have suggested that CTL can mediate an anti-tumor effect, the efficacy of Lyt-2+ T cells rendered highly cytolytic before adoptive transfer in ACIT of disseminated FBL was examined. The results demonstrated that such CTL had a detectable but limited therapeutic effect in the treatment of FBL. Because this limited activity of transferred purified CTL might have reflected a requirement for helper T cells to produce IL 2 for promotion of the in vivo survival and proliferation of the CTL, the effect of administering IL 2 to tumor-bearing hosts after transfer of CTL was examined. A dose of IL 2 previously shown to induce in vivo proliferation of transferred T cells rendered CTL that were minimally effective alone curative in ACIT of FBL leukemia. Thus, either lymphokine-producing T cells or the lymphokines produced by these cells are necessary for the full expression of the in vivo therapeutic potential of CTL.     

Virus-specific memory T cells are Pgp-1+ and can be selectively activated with phorbol ester and calcium ionophore

Memory lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV)-immune cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursors (CTLp) can be stimulated to proliferate and to mediate specific cytotoxic activity following incubation with phorbol myristate acetate (PMA), calcium ionophore (CaI), and interleukin 2 (IL-2). This protocol can be used to selectively induced virus-specific CTL activity under both bulk culture and limiting dilution conditions, in the absence of added antigen. There is no concurrent stimulation of alloreactive CTLp. Proliferation of the effector Lyt-2+ population in medium containing PMA and CaI requires L3T4+ cells, which can be replaced by adding IL-2, and the development of cytotoxicity is totally IL-2 dependent. The LCMV-specific memory T cells are also characterized by the expression of the Pgp-1 (Ly24) glycoprotein. The availability of this marker, together with the capacity to selectively stimulate primed CTLp in the absence of antigen, should greatly facilitate the analysis of T-cell memory in virus infections.     

Regulatory mechanisms in cytotoxic T lymphocyte development. I. A suppressor T cell subset that regulates the proliferative stage of CTL development

The alloantigen-induced suppressor function of cells from 3-day mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) was studied. These cells, when co-cultured with normal syngeneic lymphocytes and cells of the same haplotype as the original inducing alloantigen, inhibited the generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). Suppression was mediated by a radiation-resistant Lyt-2+ T cell. The suppressor T cells appeared to act by inhibiting the clonal expansion of CTL precursors in the responder cell population, determined by limiting dilution analysis. Levels of endogenous interleukin 2 (IL 2) in co-cultures with suppressor T cells were diminished, and the addition of exogenous IL 2 to co-cultures cancelled the suppressor T cell effects. The suppressor cell population was shown to be capable of absorbing IL 2 from lymphokine preparations, and in contrast to mitogen-induced suppressor T cells, after exposure to IL 2 the allostimulated suppressor T cell remains active. The results are discussed in terms of possible modes of action of the suppressor T cell.     

Studies on cytotoxicity generated in human mixed lymphocyte culture

Summary High levels of cytotoxic activity against the natural killer (NK) cell-sensitive target K562 and the NK-resistant target UCLA-SO-M14 (M14) can be generated in vitro either by mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) or by culture of lymphocytes in interleukin 2 (IL2) (lymphokine activated killer (LAK) cells). The purpose of this study was to identify similarities and differences between MLC-LAK and IL2-LAK cells and allospecific cytotoxic T cells. Induction of cytotoxicity against K562 and M14 in both culture systems was inhibited by antibodies specific either for IL2 or the Tac IL2 receptor. Like NK effector cells, the precursors for the MLC-LAK cells were low density large lymphocytes. However these precursors differed from the large granular lymphocytes that mediated NK cytolysis in sensitivity to the toxic lysosomotropic agent L-leucine methyl ester (LME). The resistance of the MLC-LAK precursors to LME indicated that the precursors included large agranular lymphocytes. Although interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) is produced in MLC and in IL2 containing cultures, it is not required for induction of either type of cytotoxic activity. Neutralization of IFN-gamma in MLC-and IL2-containing cultures with specific antibodies had no effect on the induction of cytotoxic activities. Both allospecific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) and LAK activities were enhanced by IL2 and IFN-gamma at the effector cell stage. However, the mechanism of cytolysis was different in the two systems. NK- and MLC-induced LAK activities were independent of CD3-T cell receptor complex while CTL activity was blocked by monoclonal antibodies specific for the CD3 antigen. These results suggest that NK and the in vitro induced LAK cytotoxicities are a family of related functions that differ from CTL. Furthermore, MLC-induced and IL2-induced cytotoxicities against K562 and M14 appear to be identical.This work was supported by NIH grant CA34442     

Regulation of interleukin 2 receptor expression on murine cytotoxic T lymphocyte clones

We have previously reported that influenza virus-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones require antigen and exogenous growth factors for continued proliferation in culture. In this report we show that after stimulation with specific antigen, cloned CTL are capable of limited proliferation in response to interleukin 2 (IL 2) alone but with time these large blast-like cells revert to smaller, quiescent cells that are no longer responsive to IL 2. The IL 2-unresponsive CTL can not be driven to proliferate by supra-optimal concentrations of IL 2, and unresponsiveness correlates with decreased ability to absorb IL 2 from conditioned medium at 0 degrees C, suggesting that unresponsiveness is due to diminished IL 2 receptors. Stimulation of the unresponsive CTL with antigen leads to re-expression of the IL 2 receptor. Decreased absorbing capacity of the unresponsive cells could not be accounted for by their smaller surface area, and the IL 2-unresponsive cells seemed not to down-regulate all their immune functions, as they remained cytotoxic. These results provide a basis for the role of specific antigen in maintaining CTL clones in vitro. Furthermore, these results suggest that antigen-dependent CTL lines can be regulated and that antigen and IL 2 both play a role in their regulation.     

Positively selected Lyt-2+ and Lyt-2- mouse T lymphocytes are comparable, after Con A stimulation, in release of IL 2 and of lymphokines acting on B cells, macrophages, and mast cells, but differ in interferon production

Purified mouse T lymphocytes were separated into Lyt-2+ and Lyt-2- populations by the procedure of panning, in which a monoclonal rat anti-Lyt-2 antibody and dishes coated with affinity-purified mouse anti-rat Ig antibodies were used. The populations obtained were 95 to 99% pure as determined by immunofluorescence. Graded doses of these T cells were cultured with optimal mitogenic doses of concanavalin A and the 0 to 24 and 24 to 48-hr culture supernatants were collected. The dose-curve assays of the supernatants of Lyt-2+ and Lyt-2- cells showed comparable activity in interleukin 2 (IL 2) and T cell-replacing factor (TRF), assayed on antigen-stimulated culture of T-depleted spleen cells. Limiting dilution assays of IL 2-secreting precursor cells stimulated by Con A showed a high frequency of precursors in both populations, slightly higher among Lyt-2- cells. The supernatants also contained comparable levels of IPA (inducer of plasminogen activator production by the macrophages), MAF (macrophage-activating factor, assayed by induction of their cytolytic function), and MCGF (mast cells growth factor, assayed on a mast cell line). IPA and MAF were not produced with the same kinetics and in the same T cell concentration conditions as IL 2 and TRF. In contrast, interferon was principally produced by the Lyt-2+ cells.     

Induction of interleukin 3 but not interleukin 2 or interferon production in the syngeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction

The syngeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction (SMLR) was assayed in the medium containing syngeneic normal mouse serum (NMS), by using nylon-adherent stimulator cells and nonadherent responder T cells, which were prepared from murine spleens in the absence of fetal calf serum (FCS) to avoid any sensitization to xenogeneic protein antigens. The responder cells in this SMLR, without definite background proliferation, generated specific proliferative response to the syngeneic stimulator cells in a dose-related fashion. The SMLR was accompanied by production of interleukin 3 (IL 3) but not interleukin 2 (IL 2) or interferon (IFN). No cytotoxicity against the syngeneic or allogeneic target cells was induced. Correlating with no production of IL 2 or IFN, no natural killer (NK) activity was detected. The proliferation was not inhibited by addition of specific antiserum for IFN-gamma. In contrast, proliferation in the responder cells when incubated with allogeneic stimulator cells was inhibited by anti-IFN-gamma serum and accompanied by production of IL 2 and IFN as well as IL 3, and by augmentation of NK activity and generation of cytotoxic T cells. Cell surface analysis revealed that the cells producing IL 3 in this SMLR system were Thy-1+ Lyt-1+2- helper T cells. Cells responding to the SMLR culture fluids with DNA replication were Thy-1-Lyt-1-2- asialo GM1- no-marker cells, which were the same as a population responsible for partially purified IL 3. On the other hand, when the responder cells were exposed to FCS before culture and assayed for SMLR in the FCS-free NMS medium, variable levels of IL 2 production were induced in response to the stimulator cells. The responder cells generated a high background DNA replication in the absence of syngeneic stimulators, suggesting that this IL 2 production may result from the stimulation of T cells by FCS as a foreign antigen. Overall, these results suggest that the SMLR may be a cellular interaction, in which non-T cells stimulate Lyt-1+2- helper T cells to produce IL 3 but not IL 2 or IFN. This IL 3 can, in turn, induce proliferation of IL 3 responding cells, which appear to be early precursors in lymphocyte differentiation, but no proliferative response or activation of IL 2- and IFN-dependent mature T cells or NK cells.     

Inhibition of cytolytic T lymphocyte maturation with ornithine, arginine, and putrescine

L-Ornithine was shown to inhibit the development of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC). Lymphokines were unable to reverse the suppressive effect, and cytotoxic activity was not revealed by coupling ornithine-inhibited MLC cells to target cells with phytohemagglutinin (PHA). If addition of ornithine to MLC were delayed, sensitivity of CTL to inhibition was reduced after 24 hr and lost by 48 hr. Suppression of CTL development was not due to a toxic effect. MLC washed free of ornithine after 3 days produced detectable cytolytic activity within 24 hr of secondary culture, and to the same degree as the uninhibited MLC control within 48 hr. Cytotoxic cells generated in secondary cultures were Lyt-2+, did not kill the natural killer-sensitive YAC-1 cell line, and were shown to be antigen-specific by virtue of the findings that cytolysis and cold target inhibition were observed only with cells carrying the original, inducing H-2 haplotype. Cytolysis of target cells by normal CTL effector cells was not inhibited by L-ornithine. MLC depleted of accessory cells so that CTL activation was dependent upon addition of lymphokines remained susceptible to inhibition by ornithine. Our findings indicate that in the ornithine-inhibited MLC, CTL precursors undergo clonal expansion, but their maturation is arrested at a precytolytic stage. L-Arginine and putrescine also suppressed generation of CTL in primary MLC, and cells recovered from arginine- and putrescine-inhibited MLC developed control levels of CTL within 48 hr of secondary culture. Inhibition by putrescine was observed in tissue culture medium supplemented with human serum but not with fetal calf serum, presumably due to the presence of diamine oxidase activity in fetal calf serum. Similar to ornithine, the suppressive effects of arginine and putrescine on T lymphocytes were apparently selective for CTL because they did not inhibit mitogen activation with concanavalin A or the production of interleukin 2 and interleukin 3. These findings are consistent with a hypothesis that the inhibitory effects of ornithine, arginine, and putrescine are mediated by polyamines, and exerted on the differentiative stage of CTL development.     

Requirement for recognition of class II molecules and processed tumor antigen for optimal generation of syngeneic tumor-specific class I-restricted CTL

The roles of Class II-restricted L3T4+ T cells and of accessory cells (AC) during the in vitro generation of Class I-restricted Lyt-2+ cytotoxic T cells (CTL) specific for a Class II-negative syngeneic tumor cell line, FBL, was examined. Treatment of responder FBL-immune spleen cells with alpha L3T4 plus complement before culture, as well as the direct addition of alpha L3T4 to cultures, diminished the generation of FBL-specific CTL. The contribution of L3T4+ cells could be completely replaced by the addition of exogenous cytokines. The data demonstrate that the optimal generation of FBL-specific Lyt-2+ CTL requires the presence of L3T4+ cells, presumably to provide necessary lymphokines. FBL-specific CTL could not be generated from purified FBL-immune T cells in the absence of AC. Syngeneic Ia+ macrophages (M phi), added at the initiation of culture, restored the response of purified T cells. Pretreatment of M phi with ammonium chloride or chloroquine, or the addition of monoclonal alpha I-Ab antibody at the initiation of culture, inhibited the ability of M phi to reconstitute the CTL response. Finally, the addition of exogenous helper factors could replace M phi and reconstitute the FBL-specific response of AC-depleted immune T cells. These results suggest that during the generation of Lyt-2+ CTL to a syngeneic tumor expressing only Class I MHC antigens, Ia+ AC are required to biochemically process antigen released from the tumor cells and present this modified antigen to Class II-restricted T helper cells.