Interaction of rate of latent heat removal during freezing and rates of subsequent cooling and warming on survival of the blood protozoan, Babesia rodhaini

Babesia rodhaini parasites in murine blood containing 1.5 m DMSO were frozen at two rates, as judged by the duration of the “freezing plateau”, then cooled to ?196 °C and rewarmed at two rates to detect interactions between the duration of the plateau and rates of subsequent cooling and rewarming. Infectivity tests showed that fast and slow freezing (plateau times of about 1 sec and 30 sec, respectively) had similar effects on parasite survival when cooling was at 130 °C/min and warming was at 800 °C/min. However, when either the cooling rate was increased to 3500 °C/min or the warming rate was decreased to 2.3 °C/min, fast freezing decreased parasite survival more than did slow freezing. It is suggested that fast freezing accentuated the damaging effects of fast cooling and slow warming by increasing intracellular ice formation.     

Cryoprotection of murine lymphocyte subpopulations using a microprocessor-controlled cooling system

Single-cell suspensions of splenic lymphocytes from 5- to 6-month-old C57BL/6 mice were cryopreserved using cooling rates ranging from ?0.25 to ?10.0 °C/min with the microprocessor-controlled cooling system developed in our laboratory. The cells (30 × 10⁶ cells/ml) were suspended in RPMI 1640 containing 10% FCS and 10% DMSO, and a total volume of 1.75 ml was frozen. Fluorescein-diacetate staining identified viable cells in unfrozen controls and frozen-thawed suspensions. Functional capacity was assessed in vitro by the incorporation of [³H]thymidine by dividing cells activated with graded concentrations of the T-lymphocyte mitogens, PHA-P and Con A, and the B-lymphocyte mitogen, LPS. High percentages of viable cells were recovered after cooling at rates ranging from ?0.5 to ?5.0 °C/min, as compared with those of unfrozen control suspensions. Incorporation of [³H]thymidine by T and B cells reached similar levels after cooling at rates ranging from ?0.25 to ?5.0 °C/min, and the percentage incorporation of [³H]thymidine as compared with that of unfrozen cells was 80–100%, except for T lymphocytes activated with PHA-P after cooling at ?5.0 °C/min. The relative response of cell suspensions to T- and B-cell mitogens, the relative mitogenic index, was unchanged from that of unfrozen controls in suspensions cooled at all rates including two (?0.25 and ?10.0 °C/min), which permitted recovery of only 55% of unfrozen cells. The importance of the constant cooling rates and rapid compensation for heat released at the phase change using the microprocessor-controlled system and of precise determinations of cellular viability and function are discussed and related to the apparent protection conferred on subpopulations of murine lymphocytes using cooling rates ranging from ? 0.25 to ?10.0 °C/min.     

The effect of cooling and warming rate on cortical cell function of glycerolized rabbit kidneys

Experiments previously reported (I. A. Jacobsen, D. E. Pegg, H. Starklint, J. Chemnitz, C. J. Hunt, P. Barfort, and M. P. Diaper, Cryobiology19, 668, 1982) suggested that rabbit kidneys permeated with 2 M glycerol are least damaged during freezing and thawing if they are cooled very slowly (1 °C/ hr). Using similar techniques of glycerolization, cooling, storage at ?80 °C, rewarming, and deglycerolization, active cell function in cortical tissue slices prepared from such kidneys has now been studied. Oxygen uptake, tissue $\text{K}{}^{\mathrm{+}}\text{Na}{}^{\mathrm{+}}$ ratio after incubation, and slice/medium PAH ratio after incubation were measured. Kidneys cooled at 3.1 °C/min and warmed at 4.2 °C/min gave poor results in the previous studies and the lowest levels of cell function in the present experiments. Kidneys cooled at 1 °C/hr exhibited degrees of slice function that were dependent on warming rate: warming at 1 °C/min was better than warming at either 1 °C/hr or c.20 °C/min. These results refine the previously drawn conclusions, (loc cit) and indicate optimal cooling and warming rates for rabbit kidneys containing 2 M glycerol, in the region of 1 °C/hr cooling and 1 °C/min warming. These rates are much lower than have hitherto been used by others for any system. Some implications of these findings are discussed.     

An experimental study on the freezing of red blood cells with and without hydroxyethyl starch

Red blood cells were frozen in small capillaries down to ?196 °C at different linear cooling rates with or without the cryoadditive HES; the thawing rate was 3000 or 6500 °C/min. Hematocrit and hydroxyethyl starch concentration varied independently. The hemolysis of red blood cells was determined photometrically after 250-fold dilution and compared to totally hemolyzed samples. The typical U-shaped curves for hemolysis as a function of the cooling rate were obtained for all cell suspensions investigated. Relative optimum cooling rates were determined for the respective combinations of HES and hct. The results show that increasing hct causes an increased hemolysis; increased HES concentration C_HES reduces the optimum cooling rate B_opt; increased hct results in higher optimal cooling rates. The findings allow one to establish a linear correlation of the HES concentration and the optimum cooling rates when the dilution of the extracellular medium by the cell water efflux during freezing is taken into account. A comparison with results from larger volumes frozen (25 ml) shows that the established relationship between hematocrit, HES concentration, and optimal cooling rate remains valid.     

Cryogenic preservation of isolated islets of Langerhans: Two-step cooling

Rat islets of Langerhans were frozen to ?196 °C using a two-step freezing procedure. Islets isolated from the pancreases of Long Evans hooded rats were exposed to CMRL 1066 media containing 1 M dimethyl sulfoxide for 6 min at 4 °C. They were transferred directly to subzero holding baths ranging from ?20 to ?43 °C for 5 to 20 min prior to transfer to and storage in liquid nitrogen. After warming at ～7 °C/min, the islets were diluted with Hanks' balanced salt solution containing 10% fetal calf serum, washed, and cultured overnight. In general, maximum protection of the islets from the stress of cooling to ?196 °C was obtained after holding the islets at ?35 or ?40 °C for between 5 and 15 min. After thawing, islets frozen using an “optimized” two-step protocol released insulin in response to a glucose challenge at a rate equivalent to that of control islets.     

Intracellular freezing: effect of extracellular supercooling.

Human erythrocytes were frozen on the stage of a cryomicroscope at accurately controlled constant-cooling rates with varying degrees of extracellular supercooling. The formation of intracellular ice was detected by direct observation of the frozen cells through the microscope. A significant coupling effect was determined between the minimum cooling rate necessary to produce intracellular freezing and the extent of supercooling. Increased degrees of extracellular supercooling reduced the range of cooling rates for which water would freeze within the cell. Specific data points were obtained at ΔT_SC = 0, ?5, and ?12 °C for which the corresponding transition cooling rates were respectively ?845, ?800, and ?11 °C/min.An explanation for the occurrence of this phenomenon is presented based on the physiochemical processes that govern the freezing of a cell suspension.     

Cryopreservation of human peripheral blood stem cells: optimal cooling and warming conditions

Peripheral blood stem cells are being used to reconstitute human bone marrow function after ablative therapy of blast transformation of chronic myelogenous leukemia. Studies were undertaken to establish the optimum cooling and warming conditions of the preservation of colonyforming activity in the peripheral blood of patients with CML.The results show that maximum recovery of CFU-c activity occurs after cooling at 3 °C/min, an average of 50% better than the recovery following cooling at 1 °C/min. CFU-c recovery decreased with decreasing warming rate, but high recovery was obtained with warming rates as low as 10 °C/ min. Viable cell count did not correlate with CFU-c recovery, therefore it represents a poor index for quality control.These results suggest that for clinical purposes bulk samples in flat bags with high surface area to volume ratios, frozen at a rate of 3 °C/min and thawed as rapidly as possible, should give maximum recovery of stem cell activity.     

The effect of ice formation on the function of smooth muscle tissue stored at −21 or −60 °C

The mechanisms by which single cells are injured during freezing are relatively well understood, but it is likely that additional factors apply to tissues and organs, factors that may be responsible for the poor suecess of attempts to cryopreserve complex multicellular systems. One such factor may be the formation of extracellular ice.

This study was designed to discover whether ice formation as such is detrimental to the contractile recovery of pieces of mammalian smooth muscle after storage at subzero temperatures. Strips of taenia coli muscle were equilibrated with 2.56 M Me₂SO in a buffered solution, cooled at either 0.3 or 2 °C/min to ?21 °C and then held at this temperature in the frozen state. Other muscle strips were bathed in a solution the composition of which mimicked that of the unfrozen phase of the previous solution at ?21 °C; it contained 4.49 M Me₂SO and 1.75 times the normal concentration of salts, and muscles equilibrated with this solution were also cooled at either 0.3 or 2 °C/min to ?21 °C, and then held unfrozen for the same length of time.It was shown that exposure to ?21 °C and the increased concentration of solutes had little effect on the contractile recovery of the muscles, whereas ice formation was damaging. Furthermore, the rate of cooling had a marked effect upon functional recovery in the frozen muscles, and this could be correlated with the known effect of these cooling rates on the pattern of ice formation in the tissue. The effect was also seen in muscles frozen at ?60 °C. Improved buffering increased the functional recovery of all groups, but the effect of ice, and of cooling rate in the presence of ice, was confirmed. These findings may have significant implications for attempts to cryopreserve complex tissues and organs.     

Regeneration of Plants from Cell Suspensions Frozen at −20, −70 and −196°C

Cell suspensions of carrot, Datura, tobacco and soybean subjected to ?20°C, ?70°C and ?196°C in the presence of a suitable cryoprotective agent, and stored for various lengths of time have been revived. After revival these cells divided to form callus masses. Direct immersion in liquid nitrogen invariably killed the cells, whereas cooling at the rate of 1 or 2°C/min, or pre-freezing briefly at ?20 and ?70°C, followed by freezing at ?196°C retained the viability. Depending on the plant species up to 70% of the cell clumps could withstand ultra-cooling. Tobacco and Datura cell suspensions were more sensitive to cold treatment than were those of carrot. Actively growing cell suspensions containing small cell-clumps revived rapidly, while filtered cell-suspensions of free cells only occasionally survived. Calli of tobacco and carrot obtained from frozen suspensions have been regenerated into plants.     

Freeze-thaw survival of the free-living nematode Caenorhabditis briggsae.

Approximately 75% or more of the L2 and L3 juvenile stages of the free-living nematode Caenorhabditis briggsae survived freezing and thawing without loss of fertility. Optimum survival depended upon a combination of conditions: (1) pretreatment with 5% DMSO at 0 °C for 10 min, (2) 0.2 °C per minute cooling rate from 0 to ?100 °C prior to immersion into liquid nitrogen, and (3) a 27.6 °C per minute warming rate from ?196 °C to ?10 °C. Storage at ?196 °C for more than 100 days was without effect on viability or fertility. Some of the L4 (about 50%) and adult (about 3%) stages survive the routine freeze-thaw treatment. However, there was no recovery of either embryonic stages or embryonated eggs from ?196 °C under these standard conditions. Either very fast cooling (about 545 °C/min) or fast warming (about 858 °C/min) rates diminished survival of the L2 and L3 stages drastically.Scanning electron microscopy revealed that freeze-thaw survivors with aberrant swimming behavior had cuticular defects. In juvenile forms, the altered swimming motion was lost after a molt whereas as abnormal adults grew, sinusoidal movement resumed. In the L4 and adult forms the cuticular abnormalities lowered viability and fertility. It is concluded that survival of nematodes from a freeze-thaw cycle is contingent upon establishing specific cryobiological conditions by varying aspects of the procedure that gave high recoveries of L2 and L3 stages.     

Influence of various cooling and warming temperatures on survival after thawing of cryopreserved Plasmodium berghei

Heavy concentrations of viable P. berghei in the natural milieu [20% ($\text{v}\text{v}$) parasitized red blood cells, or 20% ($\text{w}\text{v}$) homogenate of splenic tissue in which malarial cells sequestered wer suspended in a serum-free, protective medium. Various rates of cooling are designated as low (1.3 °C/min) and intermediate (4 °C/ min) on exposure in cold gas evolving from liquid nitrogen refrigerant to ?70 °C, and this followed by direct immersion in the low temperature refrigerant (?196 °C). Cooling designated high was accomplished by abrupt immersion of the sealed vials with the live malaria-bearing tissue in the liquid nitrogen refrigerant. Rates of warming and thawing were designated low (after slow rewarming of frozen tissue in air at 25.5 °C) and high (after rapid rewarming and thawing in a water bath at 40 °C). Strip chart recordings were made of the complete cooling and freezing wave patterns of the suspending medium to ?70 ° C. The functional survivals of the freeze-thaw P. berghei malaria were measured by a special infectivity titration method.None of the cooling and freezing treatments adversely influenced the parasite survivals. Our data showed the optimum cooling velocity that maximally protected this highly lethal P. berghei strain within the host erythrocyte matrix was 1.3 ° C/min to ?70 to ?196 ° C. The functional survivals of two RBC stabilates with P. berghei, after retrieval from 25 days storage in the liquid nitrogen refrigerant, excelled by more than 100-fold the infectivity titer found by viability assay in the pool of the 0-days nonfrozen infected RBC.The precise factors favoring the maximal survivals of the freeze-thaw P. berghei are unclear. Several factors, singly or in combination, may have played key roles in protecting the living P. berghei from the freeze-thaw damage. These factors are: The composition of the suspending medium fortified by additions of bicarbonate, glucose, lactalbumin hydrolysate and yeastolate; the presence of naturally occurring peptide-containing materials surrounding the parasites in the host red cell milieu; and the protective glycerol agent. Any of these constituents singly or combined possess potential for reducing freeze-thaw injury to the parasites to produce maximal survivals.     

Viability of frozen rat granulocytes and granulocyte precursors

Mature rat polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs) were frozen to ?196 °C, thawed, and tested for functional viability using a variety of criteria. The assays for functional viability included: qualitative and quantitative nitroblue tetrazolium tests for phagocytic activity, fluorometric tests for membrane integrity, chemotaxis, and bactericidal activity. Maximal survival was obtained when mature PMNs were frozen in the presence of 10% dimethyl sulfoxide (Me₂SO) and 5% hydroxyethyl-starch (HES) for cells cooled at ~10 °C per minute, followed by rapid warming. Maximal survival was obtained for granulocyte precursor cells (as measured by CFU-c) after freezing in the presence of 10% Me₂SO and cooling at ~10 °C per minute. The principal new findings for mature PMNs were: (i) there was a synergistic effect between intra- and extracellular protective additives; (ii) the optimal cooling rate increases from approximately 0.3 to 10 °C per minute when an extracellular protective agent, such as HES is included in the freezing media; (iii) the zwitterion buffer Hepes has a small but consistently beneficial effect on survival; (iv) granulocytes obtained from peripheral blood consistently show a higher functional survival after freezing (95%) than do PMNs obtained from a glycogen-induced peritoneal exudate (70%); (v) neither serum, plasma, nor other macromolecules are needed in the postt-haw dilution media to obtain high survival; and (vi) cells frozen using an optimized two-step protocol survived as well as those frozen using a continuous cooling protocol.     

The effect of freeze rate,duration of phase transition,and warming rate on survival of frozen canine kidneys

The effect of cooling rate, warming rate, and duration of phase transition upon survival of frozen canine kidneys was investigated. In the present study, 11 kidneys out of 14 rapidly cooled (2–4 °C/min) to ?22 °C and thawed (70–110 °C/min) were viable following contralateral nephrectomy. The serum creatinine and BUN levels rose to a maximum of 8.4 and 30 mg%, respectively, on the eighth day post-contralateral nephrectomy. Average survival time was 10 days; however, two of the dogs in this group were allowed to survive, one for 3 months and one for over 2 years. Eight kidneys out of 16 slowly cooled (0.25–1.0 °C/min) and either rapidly or slowly warmed (20–30 °C/min) had function to produce small amounts of urine; however, they did not survive more than 5 days after contralateral nephrectomy.Cooling rates of 0.1 and 10 °C/min were too harmful to the kidney to have renal function after reimplantation.The minimum renal cell damage as assessed by LDH and GOT in the post-freeze perfusate was found in the 2–4 °C/min cooling rate following rapid warming (70 °–110 °C/min).Correlation of the duration of phase transition time to renal cell damage was linear for LDH and GOT (r = 0.93). This result suggests that the duration of phase transition time also is an important factor during the freezing process, affecting postthaw survival of canine kidneys.     

The effect of cooling and warming rates on the survival of cryopreserved L-cells

A tissue culture assay has been used to measure the survival of murine lymphoma cells (L-cells) after freezing and thawing in the presence of 2 M glycerol or 1.6 M dimethyl sulfoxide. The effect of variations in cooling rate (0.1 to 10.0 °C/min) and warming rate (0.3 to 200 °C/min) were studied. It was found that survival exhibited a peak at the “conventional” combination of slow cooling and rapid warming (~1 and 200 °C/ min, respectively). It was also shown, however, that a second peak of similar magnitude occurred when the cells were cooled and rewarmed at 0.2-0.3 °C/min. These results are interpreted on the basis of current theories of freezing injury, stressing the importance of damage produced by the recrystallization of intracellular ice and by solute loading. The ultraslow rates of cooling and rewarming which produced the second survival peak are practicable for whole organs, and their potential importance for organ cryopreservation is apparent.     

Visualization of freezing damage. II. Structural alterations during warming

There is a growing amount of indirect evidence which suggests that the loss in viability of rapidly cooled cells is due to recrystallization of intracellular ice. This possibility was tested by an evaluation of the formation of morphological artifacts in rapidly cooled cells to determine whether this process can account for the loss in viability. Samples of the common yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae were frozen at 1.8 or 1500 °C/min, and the structure of the frozen cells was examined by the use of freeze-fracturing techniques. Other cells cooled at the same rate were warmed to temperatures ranging from ?20 ° to ?50 °C and then rapidly cooled to ?196 °C, a procedure that should cause small ice crystals to coalesce by the process of migratory recrystallization. Cells cooled at 1500 °C/min and then warmed to temperatures above ?40 °C formed large intracellular ice crystals within 30 min, and appreciable recrystallization occurred at temperatures as low as ?45 °C. Cells cooled at 1.8 °C/min and warmed to temperatures as high as ?20 °C underwent little structural alteration. These results demonstrate that intracellular ice can cause morphological artifacts. The correlation between the temperature at which rapid recrystallization begins and the temperature at which the cells are inactivated indicates that recrystallization is responsible for the death of rapidly cooled cells.     

Survival of frozen-thawed human red cells as a function of cooling and warming velocities

Human red cells were equilibrated for 30 min at 20 °C in buffered saline containing 2 m glycerol and then frozen to ?196 °C at 0.27, 1.7, 59, 180, 480, 600, and 1300 °C/ min and warmed at 0.47, 1, 26, 160, and 550 °C/min. Cells frozen at 600 and 1300 °C/min responded in the classical fashion for cells containing intracellular ice; i.e., survivals were low when warming was slow (<10%), but increased progressively with increasing warming rate. The sensitivity to slow warming presumably reflects the recrystallization of intracellular ice. Cells frozen at 59 and 180 °C/ min yielded high survivals at all warming rates. This response is also consistent with the findings for other cells cooled just slowly enough to preclude intracellular ice. Cells frozen very slowly at 0.27 and 1.7 °C/ min, however, responded differently; survivals were considerably higher when warming was slow (0.47 or 1 °C/min) than when it was 26, 160, or 550 °C/min. This response is analogous to that observed recently by others in mouse embryos and in higher plant tissue-culture cells and to that observed for many years in higher plants. It also confirms previous observations of Meryman in human red cells. It may reflect osmotic shock from rapid dilution but, if so, the basis of the osmotic shock is uncertain.     

Effect of cooling rate on human and murine hemopoietic precursor cell recovery

The effect of cooling rate on recovery of human and murine hemopoietic precursor cells was studied. In the presence of 10% Me₂SO, a cooling rate of 7 °C/min from ?4 to ?30 °C was optimal for recovery of both human and murine precursor cells which give rise to colonies in diffusion chambers implanted in mice (CFU-DG). Cooling of human marrow at a rate between 3 and 7 °C/min resulted in the best CFU-C recovery, although no good correlation between the cooling rate and murine CFU-C recovery was demonstrated. These data suggest that recovery of the primitive hemopoietic precursor cells can be improved by changing the standard cryopreservation programs used presently. However, improved recovery of CFU-DG does not necessarily translate into faster reconstitution of hemopoiesis. No significant difference was observed in overall recovery of bone marrow cellularity in lethally irradiated mice following injection of untreated marrow and marrow cooled at a rate of 1 and 7 °C/min.     

Cryopreservation of cell line Paesun by a rapid cooling

The purpose of the present study was to clarify the possibility of a rapid cryopreservation for cell line Paesun by cooling in the range of 30–40 °C/min to vapor phase of −120 ∼-140 °C before immersion into liquid phase of liquid nitrogen using 10% Me₂SO. After thawing, these cells were examined with assaying viability by trypan blue exclusion staining and survival by cloning in monolayer; the percentages of cell and colony recovery obtained in rapid cooling had a tendency to be lower than that by slow cooling of 1 °C/min but there were no significant differences between them. In addition, post-thaw cells were examined by assaying proliferation and susceptibility to virus lines; there were no significant differences between before and after cryopreservation. In conclusion, these findings indicate that Paesun can be successfully cryopreserved by the rapid cooling rate of 30 °C–40 °C/min.     

Freezing mammalian embryos: A review of the techniques

This article reviews the literature on freezing mammalian oocytes and embryos, with emphasis on embryos of domestic animals. Mammalian embryos must be stored in a quiescent state to retain viability for long periods. This has been accomplished by freezing and storing the embryos at ?196°C. To freeze embryos, a cryoprotectant like dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) or glycerol was required, slow cooling (0.1 to 2.0°C/min) and warming (1 to 50°C/min) rates were used, enucleation or seeding the freezing medium was a necessity, and stepwise addition and removal of the cryoprotectant at room temperature seemed to be beneficial. Using the above parameters embryos have been frozen and stored at ?196°C for several years and upon thawing and transfer to a suitable recipient, viable offspring have developed. Initially embryo viability was low after freezing-thawing, but with refinement of freezing-thawing techniques has increased sufficiently so that freezing embryos is no longer a laboratory technique, but is applicable to field use.     

Viability of dry Trichoderma harzianum spores under storage

Spores of the potential biocontrol agent Trichoderma harzianum P1 were prepared without (M1) and with heat shock (40?°C for 90?min) after fermentation (M2), filtered into a paste and dried over silica gel. M1 and M2 exhibited high viability (55%) and similar initial trehalose contents (4.0 and 5.4%, respectively) after slow drying. No significant differences in viability were found between treatments during storage for 110 days under different temperatures, T (8, 33 and 42?°C) and water activities, a _w (0.03, 0.33 and 0.75). Viability of spores, after storage at a _w =0.03 were 100 and 70% for 8 and 33?°C, respectively. During storage, decrease in trehalose content and viability was faster at a _w =0.75 and 42?°C. Loss of viability was modeled by a first order kinetic model depending on 1/T and a _w . M2 (with heat shock) showed slightly higher trehalose contents than M1 which resulted in 100% viability after 52 days at 8?°C.