The scintillometric evaluation of DNA repair synthesis can be distorted by changes of thymidine pool radioactivity

The induction of DNA repair synthesis by UV radiation and methylmethane sulphonate (MMS) in mammalian cell lines of human (EUE, HeLa, FT, KB) and hamster (CHO, BHK) origin has been evaluated by means of autoradiography and the scintillometric procedure which implied the use of hydroxyurea (HU) to suppress DNA replication.While with UV radiation both methods produce concordant positive results, in the case of MMS the evidence of DNA repair synthesis obtained from the autoradiograms is occasionally accompanied by a lack of increase of DNA radioactivity in the treated cultures, as detected by scintillation counting. In such instances MMS is shown to reverse the enhancement of pool radioactivity in the cultures incubated with HU and even to reduce the radioactivity of thymidine pool below control values. By normalizing DNA radioactivities on the basis of pool variations, the discrepancy between autoradiography and scintillation counting is solved.The chromatographic analysis of thymidine pool components justifies the normalization procedure as it demonstrates that also in cultures treated with MMS or MMS + HU pool variations closely parallel the variations of thymidine triphosphate (dTTP) level.The normalization of DNA radioactivities based on the overall pool radioactivities gives an improved evaluation of the actual rate of DNA synthesis. It can be recommended for screening studies of DNA repair inducers because it allows one to correct false negative results without producing false positive data. Compared with the dTTP levels, overall pool radioactivities used as normalizing factors still produce an underestimate of DNA repair when high doses of MMS are applied to hamster cell cultures.     

DNA damage and repair induced in vitro by nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA) in human lymphocytes

In cultured human lymphocytes we determined the ability of nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA) to inhibit DNA replication and to stimulate DNA repair synthesis (UDS), as well as to influence the UDS induced by UV irradiation. In phytohemagglutinin-stimulated lymphocytes a strong inhibition of DNA replication was induced by NTA concentrations above 10(-3) M, which was accompanied by a marked cell lethality, whereas at lower doses the incorporation of tritiated thymidine (3H-TdR) into DNA or treated cells was slightly increased in comparison to untreated cells. When, after NTA pretreatment, UDS was determined by scintillation spectrometry or autoradiography in unstimulated G0 lymphocytes, UV-irradiated or unirradiated, an increased incorporation of 3H-TdR was observed, positively correlated with the NTA doses. This effect was only partially due to the expansion of the intracellular TdR pool as a consequence of the stimulation of 3H-TdR uptake by NTA. Even after normalization of the scintillometric data by the radioactivities of the soluble nucleotide fraction, significant increase of DNA repair synthesis was detected after treatment with 7.5 x 10(-3)-10(-2) M NTA.     

Repair replication and unscheduled DNA synthesis in mammalian cell lines showing differential sensitivity to alkylating agents

Repair replication has been measured by CsCl density gradient centrifugation in cell lines showing differential sensitivity to mono- and bifunctional alkylating agents. A correlation between cellular sensitivity as measured by the D₀ value and amount of repair replication was demonstrated after exposure of Yoshida cells to nitrogen mustard (HN2) and methylene dimethanesulphonate (MDMS). No differences in the amount of repair replication after methyl methanesulphonate (MMS) were observed in two L5178Y cell lines which differed in sensitivity by virtue of the shoulder size only. The Yoshida cell lines showed no difference in sensitivity to MMS and no difference in amount of repair replication. Incorporation of tritiated thymidine 9[³H]TdR) after drug treament was also measured by autoradiography. The qualitative differences observed between the two cell lines were similar to those obtained in density gradient experiments. The temporal pattern of [³H]TdR uptake indicated that the reduced repair replication observed in the sensitive line after HN2 and MDMS is not due to slower synthesis. The kinetics of [^3H]TdR incorporation differed for all three mutagens suggesting that different enzymes may be involved in each case.     

Comparative induction of unscheduled DNA synthesis by physical and chemical agents in non-proliferating primary cultures of rat hepatocytes

The incorporation of [³H]thymidine into DNA due to unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) induced by N-OH-2-acetylaminofluorene (N-OH-AAF), aflatoxin B₁ (AFB₁), ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) and ultra-violet light was quantitated by autoradiography and by scintillation spectrometry on acid precipitable macromolecules or DNA insolated by isopycnic banding in cesium chloride (CsCl). Dose-dependent increases in UDS due to N-OH-AAF and AFB₁ treatment were found. Only 2-fold increases at the highest dose levels were found, however, when incorporated [³H]thymidine was quantitated by scintillation spectrometry. Seven, 11, and 25-fold increases in UDS induced by AFB₁, N-OH-AAF and ultra-violet light, respectively, were found when incorporated [³H]thymidine was quantitated by autoradiography, indicating a high sensitivity for detecting ‘long patch’ repair by this technique. Scintillation spectrometry was completely ineffective in detecting EMS-induced UDS, whereas autoradiography demonstrated a small, but significant induction in [³H]thymidine incorporation at high dose levels. The non-proliferative nature of the primary hepatocyte prohibits the uniform radioactive prelabeling of DNA, necessary in other techniques, for the detection of ‘short patch’ repair induced by compounds such as EMS. Therefore, the sensitivity of the primary cultured rat hepatocyte in conjunction with UDS for detecting DNA damage caused by mutagens and carcinogens which induce ‘short patch’ repair may be limited to the autoradiographic analysis of the unscheduled incorporation of [³H]thymidine.     

DNA repair synthesis in guinea pig pancreatic slices following in vitro exposure to N-nitrosomethylurethane.

The incorporation of thymidine into DNA in the presence of hydroxyurea (HU) by guinea pig pancreatic slices following exposure to N-nitrosomethylurethane (NMUT) was used to follow DNA repair synthesis. HU was used to suppress normal replicative DNA synthesis. Slices from the duodenal segment of the pancreas were exposed for periods of 15 to 90 min to NMUT at concentrations of 2 to 20 mM, then incubated in tritiated thymidine ([H3]-TdR) free of carcinogen, and radioactivity in DNA was determined. NMUT induced a a dose- and time-dependent increase in HU-insensitive thymidine incorporation. This stimulated incorporation, which could be attributed to repair synthesis, occurred immediately following the treatment and was largely complete within 3 h.     

DNA nucleotide excision-repair synthesis is independent of perturbations of deoxynucleoside triphosphate pool size

We have investigated the effects of fluctuations in deoxynucleoside triphosphate (dNTP) pool size on DNA repair and, conversely, the effect of DNA repair on dNTP pool size. In confluent normal human skin fibroblasts, dNTP pool size was quantitated by the formation of [3H]TTP from [3H]thymidine; DNA repair was examined by repair replication in cultures irradiated with UV light. As defined by HPLC analysis, the [3H]TTP pool was formed within 30 min of the addition of [3H]thymidine and remained relatively constant for the next 6 h. Addition of 2-10 mM hydroxyurea (HU) caused a gradual 2-4-fold increase in the [3H]TTP pool as HU inhibited DNA synthesis but not TTP production. No difference was seen between the [3H]TTP pool size in cells exposed to 20 J/m2 and unirradiated controls, although DNA-repair synthesis was readily quantitated in the former. This result was observed even though the repair replication protocol caused an 8-10-fold reduction in the size of the [3H]TTP pool relative to the initial studies. In the UV excision-repair studies the presence of hydroxyurea did not alter the specific activity of [3H] thymidine 5'-monophosphate incorporated into parental DNA due to repair replication. These results suggest that fluctuations in the deoxynucleoside triphosphate pools do not limit the extent of excision-repair synthesis in human cells and demonstrate that DNA nucleotide excision-repair synthesis does not significantly diminish the size of the [3H]TTP pool.     

The role of DNA polymerases in DNA repair in Escherichia coli: DNA polymerase I-dependent repair following chemical alkylation of permeabilized bacteria.

Many mutagens and carcinogens damage DNA and elicit repair synthesis in cells. In the present study we report that alkylation of the DNA of Escherichia coli that have been made permeable to nucleotides by toluene treatment results in the expression of a DNA polymerase I-directed repair synthesis. The advantage of the system described here is that it permits measurement of only DNA polymerase I-directed repair synthesis and serves as a simple, rapid method for determining the ability of a given chemical to elicit “excision-repair” in bacteria.DNA ligation is intentionally prevented in our system by addition of the inhibitor nicotinamide mononucleotide. In the absence of DNA ligase activity, nick translation is extensive and an “exaggerated” repair synthesis occurs. This amplification of repair synthesis is unique for DNA polymerase I since it is not observed in mutant cells deficient in this polymerase. DNA ligase apparently controls the extent of nucleotide replacement by this repair enzyme through its ability to rejoin “nicks” thereby terminating the DNA elongation process.The nitrosoamides N-methyl-N-nitrosourea and N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea, as well as the nitrosoamidines N-methyl-N′-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine and N-ethyl-N′-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine, elicit DNA polymerase I-directed repair synthesis. Methyl methanesulphonate is especially potent in this regard, while its ethyl derivative, ethyl methanesulphonate, is a poor inducer of DNA polymerase I activity in permeabilized cells.     

Separate effect of hydroxyurea on the initiation and elongation of DNA synthesis in BHK cells

Summary BHK21/C₁ cells, starved for 30 h in serum deficient medium and treated for 15 h with 1 mm hydroxyurea (HU) in order to obtain a synchronous cell population in the G₁/S-boundary, incorporate a residual proportion of ³H-thymidine (dThd). This residual incorporation is due to semiconservative synthesis and may not be reduced by increasing the drug concentration without affecting the reversion capacity of the cells proportionally. As shown by autoradiographic analysis, the residual DNA synthesis does not correspond to ³H-dThd incorporation within a small number of resistant cells, but is located in the nuclei of a high proportion of cells with reduced density of silver grains. After treatment with 0.05 mm HU, however, the incorporation of ³H-dThd increases considerably over the control values. The determination of the radioactivity incorporated by µg DNA corresponding to nuclei in S phase indicates that this concentration of HU is also able to reduce the rate of DNA polymerization. Kinetic data on the appearance of this increased ³H-dThd incorporation and on the accumulation of labelled nuclei in cells growing at random and labelled continuously with the radioactive DNA precursor indicate that HU stimulates the cells to enter the S phase. The reported results are consistent with a mechanism of action of HU which affects initiation and elongation of DNA chains separately.     

The repair of methyl methanesulphonate-induced lesions in the DNA of a murine lymphoma cell

The introduction of single-strand breaks into the DNA of a murine lymphoma (L5178Y) cell treated in vivo with methyl methanesulphonate (MMS) and the behaviour of these breaks on post-treatment incubation were studied. A large proportion of single-strand breaks present after MMS treatment could be repaired as shown by sedimentation in alkaline sucrose. Two inhibitors of DNA synthesis, hydroxyurea and cytosine arabinoside affected the repair process differently-hydroxyurea had only a small effect while cytosine arabinoside blocked repair and at some doses allowed further degradation of the DNA. It was also found that the level of ‘repair replication’ in the presence of cytosine arabinoside was lower than that found in the presence of hydroxyurea.     

Consensus protein engineering on the thermostable histone-like bacterial protein HUs significantly improves stability and DNA binding affinity

Consensus-based protein engineering strategy has been applied to various proteins and it can lead to the design of proteins with enhanced biological performance. Histone-like HUs comprise a protein family with sequence variety within a highly conserved 3D-fold. HU function includes compacting and regulating bacterial DNA in a wide range of biological conditions in bacteria. To explore the possible impact of consensus-based design in the thermodynamic stability of HU proteins, the approach was applied using a dataset of sequences derived from a group of 40 mesostable, thermostable, and hyperthermostable HUs. The consensus-derived HU protein was named HUBest, since it is expected to perform best. The synthetic HU gene was overexpressed in E. coli and the recombinant protein was purified. Subsequently, HUBest was characterized concerning its correct folding and thermodynamic stability, as well as its ability to interact with plasmid DNA. A substantial increase in HUBest stability at high temperatures is observed. HUBest has significantly improved biological performance at ambience temperature, presenting very low K_d values for binding plasmid DNA as indicated from the Gibbs energy profile of HUBest. This K_d may be associated to conformational changes leading to decreased thermodynamic stability and, therefore, higher flexibility at ambient temperature.

     

Effects of inhibition of protein synthesis on DNA replication in cultured mammalian cells

We have investigated the effects of inhibiting protein synthesis on the overall rate of DNA synthesis and on the rate of replication fork movement in mammalian cells. In order to test the validity of using [³H]thymidine incorporation as a measure of the overall rate of DNA synthesis during inhibition of protein synthesis, we have directly measured the size and specific radioactivity of the cells' [³H]dTTP pool. In three different mammalian cell lines (mouse L, Chinese hamster ovary, and HeLa) nearly complete inhibition of protein synthesis has little effect on pool size (±26%) and even less effect on its specific radioactivity (±11%). Thus [³H]thymidine incorporation can be used to measure accurately changes in rate of DNA synthesis resulting from inhibition of protein synthesis.Using the assay of [³H]thymidine incorporation to measure rate of DNA synthesis, and the assay of [¹⁴C]leucine or [¹⁴C]valine incorporation to measure rate of protein synthesis, we have found that eight different methods of inhibiting protein synthesis (cycloheximide, puromycin, emetine, pactamycin, 2,4-dinitrophenol, the amino acid analogs canavanine and 5-methyl tryptophan, and a temperature-sensitive leucyl-transfer tRNA synthetase) all cause reduction in rate of DNA synthesis in mouse L, Chinese hamster ovary, or HeLa cells within two hours to a fairly constant plateau level which is approximately the same as the inhibited rate of protein synthesis.We have used DNA fiber autoradiography to measure accurately the rate of replication fork movement. The rate of movement is reduced at every replication fork within 15 minutes after inhibiting protein synthesis. For the first 30 to 60 minutes after inhibiting protein synthesis, the decline in rate of fork movement (measured by fiber autoradiography) satisfactorily accounts for the decline in rate of DNA synthesis (measured by [³H]thymidine incorporation). At longer times after inhibiting protein synthesis, inhibition of fork movement rate does not entirely account for inhibition of overall DNA synthesis. Indirect measurements by us and direct measurements suggest that the additional inhibition is the result of decline in the frequency of initiation of new replicons.     

The role of deoxynucleoside triphosphate pools in the inhibition of DNA-excision repair and replication in human cells by hydroxyurea

The effects of hydroxyurea (HU) on the DNA-excision repair process in human cells has been systematically examined. It is demonstrated that HU induces DNA single-strand break accumulation in a dose-dependent fashion in ultraviolet-irradiated and MMS-treated confluent but not log-phase fibroblasts and that these breaks are clearly the consequence of the inhibition by HU of the enzyme, ribonucleotide reductase. The breaks form rapidly, are stable for at least 10 h and largely disappear by 20 h. The production of these DNA-strand breaks is antagonized by a combined treatment of 10 microM deoxyadenosine, deoxycytidine and deoxyguanosine whereas thymidine potentiates strand-break formation at low HU concentrations. It is also confirmed that HU, while inhibiting replicative synthesis has no apparent inhibitory effect on unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) although the increased uptake of labeled DNA precursors into HU-treated cells makes it difficult to assess the actual effects on the repair-synthetic process. Analysis of the effects of HU on deoxynucleoside triphosphate pool levels and the demonstration of the failure of the HU block to replicative synthesis to be reversed by high (1 mM) concentrations of added deoxynucleosides lend support to the notion of compartmentalized dNTP pools for repair and replication.     

Deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate metabolism and the mammalian cell cycle. Effects of hydroxyurea on mutant and wild-type mouse S49 T-lymphoma cells

DNA precursor synthesis can be blocked specifically by the drug hydroxyurea (HU) which has therefore been used for anticancer therapy. High concentrations of HU, however, affect other processes than DNA synthesis; nevertheless, most studies on the biological action of HU have been made with concentrations at least one order of magnitude higher than those needed for cell-growth inhibition. In this study we characterized the effects of low concentrations of HU (i.e. concentrations leading to 50% inhibition of cell growth in 72 h) on cell cycle kinetics and nucleotide pools in mouse S49 cells with various defined alterations in DNA precursor synthesis. The effect of 50 microM HU on deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate pools was a 2-3-fold decrease in the dATP and dGTP pools, with no change in the dCTP pool and a certain increase in the dTTP pool. Addition of deoxycytidine or thymidine led to a partial reversal of the growth inhibition and cell-cycle perturbation caused by HU, and was accompanied by an increased level of the deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates. Addition of purine deoxyribonucleoside gave no protection, indicating that salvage of these nucleosides could not supply precursors for DNA synthesis in T-lymphoma cells. We observed a higher sensitivity to HU of cells lacking purine nucleoside phosphorylase or with a ribonucleotide reductase with altered allosteric regulation. Cells lacking thymidine kinase or deoxycytidine kinase were just as sensitive as wild-type cells.     

Reassociation of human lymphoblastoid cell DNA repair replicated following methyl methanesulfonate treatment

The reassociation rates of repair replicated DNA of two human lymphoblastoid cell lines, the WIL₂-A3 ‘normal’ line and the RAJI line of Burkitt's lymphoma, were examined using the DNA/DNA ‘C₀t’ hybridization technique. The cells were treated with methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), an alkylating agent and mutagen, to induce the repair.The incorporated repair replication radioactivity in highly repetitive sequences of WIL₂-A3 cell DNA reassociates as expected for a randomly distributed incorporation. The reassociation of repair radioactivity in sequences of fewer numbers of copies, however, is less than expected for a random distribution. It is less than that occurring for semiconservatively synthesized DNA of WIL₂-A3 cells co-incubated with the repair labeled DNA as an internal control.The observed difference could be due to an over-representation of repair replication radioactivity in DNA sequences with fewer copies. It is unlikely to be due to residual alkali labile damage resulting from MMS treatment, since a similar difference was not observed when semiconservatively labeled DNA from cells which had been treated with MMS for the same time and at the same concentration as in the repair experiments was substituted for repair replicated DNA in the reassociation reactions. Other possible causes of the apparent difference in the reassociation rates observed are discussed.     

Direction of DNA replication in mammalian cells

We have re-examined the direction of DNA synthesis in mammalian cells by means of pulse-labeling with [³H]thymidine and DNA autoradiography. Our results show that, whether or not the cells are treated with 5-fluoro-deoxyuridine, and whether they are labeled first with high specific activity [³H]thymidine and then with low, or vice versa, most (? 90%) of the unambiguous autoradiographic patterns can be explained by bidirectional replication but not by unidirectional replication.We also find that in autoradiographic experiments using two different specific activities of [³H]thymidine, obvious differences in grain density are obtained only when the difference in specific activity is threefold or more. Thus, the apparently contradictory findings of Lark et al. (1971) can be explained by the low difference in specific activity used by those authors.     

DNA-repair studies with sodium fluoride: comparative evaluation using density gradient ultracentrifugation and autoradiography

Sodium fluoride (NaF) was assayed for the induction of DNA-repair synthesis in WI-38 human diploid fibroblasts and in primary cultures of rat hepatocytes. DNA-repair synthesis in non-replicating DNA was measured by ultracentrifugation of density-labeled DNA in CsCl gradients. When this method was used, NaF did not induce DNA-repair synthesis in either of these cell types. However, when NaF was assayed for induction of unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) in rat hepatocytes by autoradiography, an increased net nuclear grain count was observed. Because the autoradiographic results were not confirmed by density-gradient ultracentrifugation of hepatocyte DNA, which is a more definitive technique, it is doubtful whether the autoradiographic results actually represent DNA-repair synthesis. Modifications of the UDS/autoradiography protocol to include more extensive washing resulted in no UDS response. Published reports (Hellung-Larsen and Klenow, 1969; Srivastava et al., 1981) describe the formation of precipitable complexes of Mg2+, F-, and [3H]thymidine triphosphate which suggests that autoradiographic measurement of UDS may lead to artifacts when testing NaF unless extensive washing of the cultures is employed.     

Binding and Cleavage of E. coli HUβ by the E. coli Lon Protease

The Escherichia coli Lon protease degrades the E. coli DNA-binding protein HUβ, but not the related protein HUα. Here we show that the Lon protease binds to both HUβ and HUα, but selectively degrades only HUβ in the presence of ATP. Mass spectrometry of HUβ peptide fragments revealed that region K18-G22 is the preferred cleavage site, followed in preference by L36-K37. The preferred cleavage site was further refined to A20-A21 by constructing and testing mutant proteins; Lon degraded HUβ-A20Q and HUβ-A20D more slowly than HUβ. We used optical tweezers to measure the rupture force between HU proteins and Lon; HUα, HUβ, and HUβ-A20D can bind to Lon, and in the presence of ATP, the rupture force between each of these proteins and Lon became weaker. Our results support a mechanism of Lon protease cleavage of HU proteins in at least three stages: binding of Lon with the HU protein (HUβ, HUα, or HUβ-A20D); hydrolysis of ATP by Lon to provide energy to loosen the binding to the HU protein and to allow an induced-fit conformational change; and specific cleavage of only HUβ.     

Size and specific radioactivity of the [h]thymidine triphosphate pool and DNA synthesis in the radicles of germinating cotton

By relating the specific radioactivity, size, and turnover of the labeled thymidine triphosphate pool to DNA synthesis, it was shown that the 32- to 38-hour interval of cotton seedling (Gossypium barbadense L.) germination was the peak period of DNA synthesis within the radicle tip during a total germination time of 48 hours at 35 C.     

Effects of DNA replication inhibitors on UV excision repair in synchronised human cells.

When HeLa cells are irradiated with UV and treated with the DNA synthesis inhibitors hydroxyurea (HU) and 1-beta-D-arabinofuranosylcytosine (ara C), DNA strand breaks accumulate at sites where excision repair of DNA damage has been inhibited after the incision step. This break accumulation occurs in mitotic, G1 and S phase cells. But UV-induced repair synthesis of DNA, as measured by [3H]thymidine incorporation into unreplicated DNA, is not inhibited by HU and ara C in G1 or S phase cells, even though replicative synthesis is virtually abolished. Repair and replication must therefore utilise different DNA precursor pools, or different DNA synthetic systems; and the action of Hu and ara C in causing strand break accumulation may occur at the ligation step of excision repair.     

The stability of the archaeal HU histone-like DNA-binding protein from Thermoplasma volcanium

The complete genome analysis of the archaeon Thermoplasma volcanium has revealed a gene assigned to encode the histone-like DNA-binding protein HU. Thermoplasma volcanium is a moderate thermophile growing around 60°C and it is adaptable to aerobic and anaerobic environment and therefore it is unique as a candidate for the origin of eukaryotic nuclei in the endosymbiosis hypothesis. The HU protein is the major component of the bacterial nuclei and therefore it is an important protein to be studied. The gene for HUTvo protein (huptvo) was cloned from the genomic DNA of T. volcanium and overexpressed in Escherichia coli. A fast and efficient purification scheme was established to produce an adequate amount of bioactive protein for biochemical and biophysical studies. Highly purified HUTvo was studied for its DNA-binding activity and thermostability. As studied by circular dichroism and high-precision differential scanning microcalorimetry, the thermal unfolding of HUTvo protein is reversible and can be well described by a two-state model with dissociation of the native dimeric state into denatured monomers. The ∆G versus T profile for HUTvo compared to the hyperthermophilic marine eubacterial counterpart from Thermotoga maritima, HUTmar, clearly shows that the archaeal protein has adopted a less efficient molecular mechanism to cope with high temperature. The molecular basis of this phenomenon is discussed. F. Orfaniotou and P. Tzamalis contributed equally to this work.