Redox-Bohr effect in electron/proton energy transduction: cytochrome c 3 coupled to hydrogenase works as a 'proton thruster' in Desulfovibrio vulgaris

 A central step in the metabolism of Desulfovibrio spp. is the oxidation of molecular hydrogen catalyzed by a periplasmic hydrogenase. However, this enzymatic activity is quite low at physiological pH. The hypothesis that, in the presence of the tetrahaem cytochrome c ₃, hydrogenase can maintain full activity at physiological pH through the concerted capture of the resulting electrons and protons by the cytochrome was tested for the case of Desulfovibrio vulgaris (Hildenborough). The crucial step involves an electron-to-proton energy transduction, and is achieved through a network of cooperativities between redox and ionizable centers within the cytochrome (redox-Bohr effect). This mechanism, which requires a relocation of the proposed proton channel in the hydrogenase structure, is similar to that proposed for the transmembrane proton pumps, and is the first example which shows evidence of functional energy transduction in the absence of a membrane confinement. Received: 2 April 1997 / Accepted: 23 May 1997     

A mechano-chemical model for energy transduction in cytochrome c oxidase: the work of a Maxwell's god

Cytochrome c3 has a central role in the energetics of Desulfovibrio sp., where it performs an electroprotonic energy transduction step. This process uses a network of cooperativities, largely based on anti-Coulomb components, resulting from a mechano-chemical energy coupling mechanism. This mechanism provides a model coherent with the data available for the redox chemistry of haem a of cytochrome c oxidase and its link to the activation of protons. A crucial feature of the model is an anti-Coulomb effect that sets the stage for a molecular ratchet, ensuring vectoriality for the redox-driven localised movement of protons across the membrane, against an electrochemical gradient.     

Functional properties of type I and type II cytochromes c3 from Desulfovibrio africanus

Type I cytochrome c(3) is a key protein in the bioenergetic metabolism of Desulfovibrio spp., mediating electron transfer between periplasmic hydrogenase and multihaem cytochromes associated with membrane bound complexes, such as type II cytochrome c(3). This work presents the NMR assignment of the haem substituents in type I cytochrome c(3) isolated from Desulfovibrio africanus and the thermodynamic and kinetic characterisation of type I and type II cytochromes c(3) belonging to the same organism. It is shown that the redox properties of the two proteins allow electrons to be transferred between them in the physiologically relevant direction with the release of energised protons close to the membrane where they can be used by the ATP synthase.     

Redox-Bohr and other cooperativity effects in the nine-heme cytochrome C from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans ATCC 27774: crystallographic and modeling studies

The nine-heme cytochrome c is a monomeric multiheme cytochrome found in Desulfovibrio desulfuricans ATCC 27774. The polypeptide chain comprises 296 residues and wraps around nine hemes of type c. It is believed to take part in the periplasmic assembly of proteins involved in the mechanism of hydrogen cycling, receiving electrons from the tetraheme cytochrome c3. With the purpose of understanding the molecular basis of electron transfer processes in this cytochrome, we have determined the crystal structures of its oxidized and reduced forms at pH 7.5 and performed theoretical calculations of the binding equilibrium of protons and electrons in these structures. This integrated study allowed us to observe that the reduction process induced relevant conformational changes in several residues, as well as protonation changes in some protonatable residues. In particular, the surroundings of hemes I and IV constitute two areas of special interest. In addition, we were able to ascertain the groups involved in the redox-Bohr effect present in this cytochrome and the conformational changes that may underlie the redox-cooperativity effects on different hemes. Furthermore, the thermodynamic simulations provide evidence that the N- and C-terminal domains function in an independent manner, with the hemes belonging to the N-terminal domain showing, in general, a lower redox potential than those found in the C-terminal domain. In this way, electrons captured by the N-terminal domain could easily flow to the C-terminal domain, allowing the former to capture more electrons. A notable exception is heme IX, which has low redox potential and could serve as the exit path for electrons toward other proteins in the electron transfer pathway.     

Redox-Bohr effect in the tetrahaem cytochrome c3 from Desulfovibrio vulgaris: a model for energy transduction mechanisms

 Using potentiometric titrations, two protons were found to participate in the redox-Bohr effect observed for cytochrome c ₃ from Desulfovibrio vulgaris (Hildenborough). Within the framework of the thermodynamic model previously presented, this finding supports the occurrence of a concerted proton-assisted 2e^– step, ideally suited for the coupling role of cytochrome c ₃ to hydrogenase. Furthermore, at physiological pH, it is shown that when sulfate-reducing bacteria use H₂ as energy source, cytochrome c ₃ can be used as a charge separation device, achieving energy transduction by energising protons which can be left in the acidic periplasmic side and transferring deenergised electrons to sulfate respiration. This mechanism for energy transduction, using a full thermodynamic data set, is compared to that put forward to explain the proton-pumping function of cytochrome c oxidase.     

Sulfate respiration in Desulfovibrio vulgaris Hildenborough. Structure of the 16-heme cytochrome c HmcA AT 2.5-A resolution and a view of its role in transmembrane electron transfer

The crystal structure of the high molecular mass cytochrome c HmcA from Desulfovibrio vulgaris Hildenborough is described. HmcA contains the unprecedented number of sixteen hemes c attached to a single polypeptide chain, is associated with a membrane-bound redox complex, and is involved in electron transfer from the periplasmic oxidation of hydrogen to the cytoplasmic reduction of sulfate. The structure of HmcA is organized into four tetraheme cytochrome c(3)-like domains, of which the first is incomplete and contains only three hemes, and the final two show great similarity to the nine-heme cytochrome c from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans. An isoleucine residue fills the vacant coordination space above the iron atom in the five-coordinated high-spin Heme 15. The characteristics of each of the tetraheme domains of HmcA, as well as its surface charge distribution, indicate this cytochrome has several similarities with the nine-heme cytochrome c and the Type II cytochrome c(3) molecules, in agreement with their similar genetic organization and mode of reactivity and further support an analogous physiological function for the three cytochromes. Based on the present structure, the possible electron transfer sites between HmcA and its redox partners (namely Type I cytochrome c(3) and other proteins of the Hmc complex), as well as its physiological role, are discussed.     

Effect of hydrogen-bond networks in controlling reduction potentials in Desulfovibrio vulgaris (Hildenborough) cytochrome C3 probed by site-specific mutagenesis

Cytochromes C3 isolated from Desulfovibrio spp. are periplasmic proteins that play a central role in energy transduction by coupling the transfer of electrons and protons from hydrogenase. Comparison between the oxidized and reduced structures of cytochrome C3 isolated from Desulfovibrio vulgaris (Hildenborough) show that the residue threonine 24, located in the vicinity of heme III, reorients between these two states [Messias, A. C., Kastrau, D. H. W., Costa, H. S., LeGall, J., Turner, D. L., Santos, H., and Xavier, A. V. (1998) J. Mol. Biol. 281, 719-739]. Threonine 24 was replaced with valine by site-directed mutagenesis to elucidate its effect on the redox properties of the protein. The NMR spectra of the mutated protein are very similar to those of the wild type, showing that the general folding and heme core architecture are not affected by the mutation. However, thermodynamic analysis of the mutated cytochrome reveals a large alteration in the microscopic reduction potential of heme III (75 and 106 mV for the protonated forms of the fully reduced and oxidized states, respectively). The redox interactions involving this heme are also modified, while the remaining heme-heme interactions and the redox-Bohr interactions are less strongly affected. Hence, the order of oxidation of the hemes in the mutated cytochrome is different from that in the wild type, and it has a higher overall affinity for electrons. This is consistent with the replacement of threonine 24 by valine preventing the formation of a network of hydrogen bonds, which stabilizes the oxidized state. The mutated protein is unable to perform a concerted two-electron step between the intermediate oxidation stages, 1 and 3, which can occur in the wild-type protein. Thus, replacing a single residue unbalances the global network of cooperativities tuned to control thermodynamically the directionality of the stepwise electron transfer and may affect the functionality of the protein.     

Redox linked conformational changes in cytochrome c3 from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans ATCC 27774

Cytochrome c3 from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans ATCC 27774 appears to be capable of receiving two protons and two electrons from hydrogenase for transport to the membrane, and converting electronic energy into proton motive force. Detailed studies of the mechanism require control both of the redox state and of the protonation state of the protein; hence, structure determination of the protein in solution by NMR is the preferred method. This work compares the structures of the protonated protein in the fully oxidized and fully reduced states as a first step toward elucidating the pH-dependent and redox-state-dependent conformational changes that drive the energy transduction. These high-resolution structures revealed significant localized differences upon change of redox state, even though the global folds of the two families of structures are similar. There are concerted redox-linked motions within the protein that bring E61 and K75 closer to heme II in the oxidized form. This is consistent with an electrostatically driven movement that may provide an important contribution to the previously measured positive cooperativity between hemes I and II. No significant conformational changes were observed that might be related to redox?Bohr effects; the families of structures represent mainly protonated forms, and therefore, pH dependence should not play a major role in the observed structural rearrangements.     

Electron transfer between periplasmic formate dehydrogenase and cytochromes c in Desulfovibrio desulfuricans ATCC 27774

Desulfovibrio spp. are sulfate-reducing organisms characterized by having multiple periplasmic hydrogenases and formate dehydrogenases (FDHs). In contrast to enzymes in most bacteria, these enzymes do not reduce directly the quinone pool, but transfer electrons to soluble cytochromes c. Several studies have investigated electron transfer with hydrogenases, but comparatively less is known about FDHs. In this work we conducted experiments to assess potential electron transfer pathways resulting from formate oxidation in Desulfovibrio desulfuricans ATCC 27774. This organism can grow on sulfate and on nitrate, and contains a single soluble periplasmic FDH that includes a cytochrome c (3) like subunit (FdhABC(3)). It has also a unique cytochrome c composition, including two cytochromes c not yet isolated from other species, the split-Soret and nine-heme cytochromes, besides a tetraheme type I cytochrome c (3) (TpIc (3)). The FDH activity and cytochrome composition of cells grown with lactate or formate and nitrate or sulfate were determined, and the electron transfer between FDH and these cytochromes was investigated. We studied also the reduction of the Dsr complex and of the monoheme cytochrome c-553, previously proposed to be the physiological partner of FDH. FdhABC(3) was able to reduce the c-553, TpIc (3), and split-Soret cytochromes with a high rate. For comparison, the same experiments were performed with the [NiFe] hydrogenase from the same organism. This study shows that FdhABC(3) can directly reduce the periplasmic cytochrome c network, feeding electrons into several alternative metabolic pathways, which explains the advantage of not having an associated membrane subunit.     

Structural basis for the network of functional cooperativities in cytochrome c(3) from Desulfovibrio gigas: solution structures of the oxidised and reduced states

Cytochrome c(3) is a 14 kDa tetrahaem protein that plays a central role in the bioenergetic metabolism of Desulfovibrio spp. This involves an energy transduction mechanism made possible by a complex network of functional cooperativities between redox and redox/protolytic centres (the redox-Bohr effect), which enables cytochrome c(3) to work as a proton activator. The three-dimensional structures of the oxidised and reduced Desulfovibrio gigas cytochrome c(3) in solution were solved using 2D (1)H-NMR data. The reduced protein structures were calculated using INDYANA, an extended version of DYANA that allows automatic calibration of NOE data. The oxidised protein structure, which includes four paramagnetic centres, was solved using the program PARADYANA, which also includes the structural paramagnetic parameters. In this case, initial structures were used to correct the upper and lower volume restraints for paramagnetic leakage, and angle restraints derived from (13)C Fermi contact shifts of haem moiety substituents were used for the axial histidine ligands. Despite the reduction of the NOE intensities by paramagnetic relaxation, the final family of structures is of similar precision and accuracy to that obtained for the reduced form. Comparison of the two structures shows that, although the global folds of the two families of structures are similar, significant localised differences occur upon change of redox state, some of which could not be detected by comparison with the X-ray structure of the oxidised state: (1) there is a redox-linked concerted rearrangement of Lys80 and Lys90 that results in the stabilisation of haem moieties II and III when both molecules are oxidised or both are reduced, in agreement with the previously measured positive redox cooperativity between these two haem moieties. This cooperativity regulates electron transfer, enabling a two-electron step adapted to the function of cytochromes c(3) as the coupling partner of hydrogenase; and (2) the movement of haem I propionate 13 towards the interior of the protein upon reduction explains the positive redox-Bohr effect, establishing the structural basis for the redox-linked proton activation mechanism necessary for energy conservation, driving ATP synthesis.     

A sequential electron transfer from hydrogenases to cytochromes in sulfate-reducing bacteria

A central step in the energy metabolism of sulfate-reducing bacteria is the oxidation of molecular hydrogen, catalyzed by a periplasmic hydrogenase. The resulting electrons are then transferred to various electron transport chains and used for cytoplasmic sulfate reduction. The complex formation between [NiFeSe] hydrogenase and the soluble periplasmic polyheme cytochromes from Desulfomicrobium norvegicum was characterized by cross-linking experiments, BIAcore and kinetics analysis. Analysis of electron transfer between [NiFeSe] hydrogenase and octaheme cytochrome c(3) (M(r) 26? omitted?000) pointed out that this cytochrome is reduced faster in the presence of catalytic amounts of tetraheme cytochrome c(3) (M(r) 13? omitted?000) isolated from the same organism. The activation of the hydrogenase-dependent reduction of polyheme cytochromes by cytochrome c(3) (M(r) 13? omitted?000), which is now described in both Desulfovibrio and Desulfomicrobium, is proposed as a general mechanism. During this process, cytochrome c(3) (M(r) 13? omitted?000) would act as an electron shuttle in between hydrogenase and the polyheme cytochromes and its conductivity appears to be an important factor.     

Simulation of electron-proton coupling with a Monte Carlo method: application to cytochrome c3 using continuum electrostatics.

A new method is presented for simulating the simultaneous binding equilibrium of electrons and protons on protein molecules, which makes it possible to study the full equilibrium thermodynamics of redox and protonation processes, including electron-proton coupling. The simulations using this method reflect directly the pH and electrostatic potential of the environment, thus providing a much closer and realistic connection with experimental parameters than do usual methods. By ignoring the full binding equilibrium, calculations usually overlook the twofold effect that binding fluctuations have on the behavior of redox proteins: first, they affect the energy of the system by creating partially occupied sites; second, they affect its entropy by introducing an additional empty/occupied site disorder (here named occupational entropy). The proposed method is applied to cytochrome c3 of Desulfovibrio vulgaris Hildenborough to study its redox properties and electron-proton coupling (redox-Bohr effect), using a continuum electrostatic method based on the linear Poisson-Boltzmann equation. Unlike previous studies using other methods, the full reduction order of the four hemes at physiological pH is successfully predicted. The sites more strongly involved in the redox-Bohr effect are identified by analysis of their titration curves/surfaces and the shifts of their midpoint redox potentials and pKa values. Site-site couplings are analyzed using statistical correlations, a method much more realistic than the usual analysis based on direct interactions. The site found to be more strongly involved in the redox-Bohr effect is propionate D of heme I, in agreement with previous studies; other likely candidates are His67, the N-terminus, and propionate D of heme IV. Even though the present study is limited to equilibrium conditions, the possible role of binding fluctuations in the concerted transfer of protons and electrons under nonequilibrium conditions is also discussed. The occupational entropy contributions to midpoint redox potentials and pKa values are computed and shown to be significant.     

The crystal structure of the hexadeca-heme cytochrome Hmc and a structural model of its complex with cytochrome c(3)

Sulfate-reducing bacteria contain a variety of multi-heme c-type cytochromes. The cytochrome of highest molecular weight (Hmc) contains 16 heme groups and is part of a transmembrane complex involved in the sulfate respiration pathway. We present the 2.42 A resolution crystal structure of the Desulfovibrio vulgaris Hildenborough cytochrome Hmc and a structural model of the complex with its physiological electron transfer partner, cytochrome c(3), obtained by NMR restrained soft-docking calculations. The Hmc is composed of three domains, which exist independently in different sulfate-reducing species, namely cytochrome c(3), cytochrome c(7), and Hcc. The complex involves the last heme at the C-terminal region of the V-shaped Hmc and heme 4 of cytochrome c(3), and represents an example for specific cytochrome-cytochrome interaction.     

The Tmc complex from Desulfovibrio vulgaris hildenborough is involved in transmembrane electron transfer from periplasmic hydrogen oxidation

Three membrane-bound redox complexes have been reported in Desulfovibrio spp., whose genes are not found in the genomes of other sulfate reducers such as Desulfotalea psycrophila and Archaeoglobus fulgidus. These complexes contain a periplasmic cytochrome c subunit of the cytochrome c(3) family, and their presence in these organisms probably correlates with the presence of a pool of periplasmic cytochromes c(3), also absent in the two other sulfate reducers. In this work we report the isolation and characterization of the first of such complexes, Tmc from D. vulgaris Hildenborough, which is associated with the tetraheme type II cytochrome c(3). The isolated Tmc complex contains four subunits, including the TpIIc(3) (TmcA), an integral membrane cytochrome b (TmcC), and two cytoplasmically predicted proteins, an iron-sulfur protein (TmcB) and a tryptophan-rich protein (TmcD). Spectroscopic studies indicate the presence of eight hemes c and two hemes b in the complex pointing to an alpha(2)betagammadelta composition (TmcA(2)BCD). EPR analysis reveals the presence of a [4Fe4S](3+) center and up to three other iron-sulfur centers in the cytoplasmic subunit. Nearly full reduction of the redox centers in the Tmc complex could be obtained upon incubation with hydrogenase/TpIc(3), supporting the role of this complex in transmembrane transfer of electrons resulting from periplasmic oxidation of hydrogen.     

Electron transfer mechanism and interaction studies between cytochrome C3 and ferredoxin

Ferredoxin, cytochrome c3 and hydrogenase are specific partners of the sulfate reduction pathway of Desulfovibrio desulfuricans Norway and might be exemplary for electron exchange mechanism studies. Cytochrome c3 contains four low redox potential haems for 13 000 molecular weight. Two ferredoxins isolated from the same bacteria are dimers of 6 000 molecular weight per subunit (Ferredoxin I: one (4 Fe-4S) cluster per subunit, ferredoxin II: two (4 Fe-4 S) clusters per subunit). The amino acid sequence of ferredoxin I is reported and compared to the ferredoxin II sequence. The structural characteristics of ferredoxins and cytochrome c3 should allow a discussion on the nature of the interaction. 1H-NMR spectra of ferredoxin I and cytochrome c3 in the absence and presence of ferredoxin are presented.     

Molecular basis for redox-Bohr and cooperative effects in cytochrome c3 from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans ATCC 27774: crystallographic and modeling studies of oxidized and reduced high-resolution structures at pH 7.6

The tetraheme cytochrome c3 is a small metalloprotein with ca. 13,000 Da found in sulfate-reducing bacteria, which is believed to act as a partner of hydrogenase. The three-dimensional structure of the oxidized and reduced forms of cytochrome c3 from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans ATCC 27774 at pH 7.6 were determined using high-resolution X-ray crystallography and were compared with the previously determined oxidized form at pH 4.0. Theoretical calculations were performed with both structures, using continuum electrostatic calculations and Monte Carlo sampling of protonation and redox states, in order to understand the molecular basis of the redox-Bohr and cooperativity effects related to the coupled transfer of electrons and protons. We were able to identify groups that showed redox-linked conformational changes. In particular, Glu61, His76, and propionate D of heme II showed important contributions to the redox-cooperativity, whereas His76, propionate A of heme I, and propionate D of heme IV were the key residues for the redox-Bohr effect. Upon reduction, an important movement of the backbone region surrounding hemes I and II was also identified, that, together with a few redox-linked conformational changes in side-chain residues, results in a significant decrease in the solvent accessibility of hemes I and II.     

Studies of the reduction and protonation behavior of tetraheme cytochromes using atomic detail

A comparative study of tetraheme cytochrome c3 molecules from several species was carried out using recently developed theoretical methods based on continuum electrostatics. The binding joint equilibrium of electrons and protons was simulated, revealing the complete thermodynamic aspects of electron-proton coupling in these molecules. The method yields excellent accuracy in terms of midpoint potentials, giving the correct reduction orders in all molecules examined, except for one heme site. The coupling between electrons and protons is shown to be present and significant at physiological pH in all cases. This phenomenon, known as the redox-Bohr effect, though of thermodynamic nature, is shown to have an intrinsic "dynamic" character at the molecular level (in the sense of the empty/occupied fluctuations at the microscopic level), with the binding states of redox and protonatable sites displaying both correlated averages and correlated fluctuations. The protonatable sites more directly involved in the redox-Bohr effect are identified using, among other properties, the statistical correlation between pairs of sites, which automatically reflects indirect effects mediated by other sites. Several sites are identified in this analysis. Propionate D of heme I seems to be the most interesting, generally showing a high correlation not only with its own heme, but also with heme II, corresponding to an indirect stabilization of the reduced forms of both hemes. Other interesting sites are the free histidines of two of the cytochromes and propionate D of heme IV, the latter being potentially associated with redox-induced structural changes. Among the set of cytochromes c3 analyzed in this study, significant differences are observed for several properties of the acidic cytochrome included in the set, from Desulfovibrio africanus, supporting the hypothesis of a different functional role.     

Functional properties of type I and type II cytochromes c3 from Desulfovibrio africanus

Type I cytochrome c₃ is a key protein in the bioenergetic metabolism of Desulfovibrio spp., mediating electron transfer between periplasmic hydrogenase and multihaem cytochromes associated with membrane bound complexes, such as type II cytochrome c₃. This work presents the NMR assignment of the haem substituents in type I cytochrome c₃ isolated from Desulfovibrio africanus and the thermodynamic and kinetic characterisation of type I and type II cytochromes c₃ belonging to the same organism. It is shown that the redox properties of the two proteins allow electrons to be transferred between them in the physiologically relevant direction with the release of energised protons close to the membrane where they can be used by the ATP synthase.     

Purification and characterization of cytochrome c3, ferredoxin, and rubredoxin isolated from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans Norway.

Different electron carriers of the non-desulfoviridin-containing, sulfate-reducing bacterium Desulfovibrio desulfuricans (Norway strain) have been studied. Two nonheme iron proteins, ferredoxin and rubredoxin, have been purified. This ferredoxin contains four atoms of non-heme iron and acid-labile sulfur and six residues of cysteine per molecule. Its amino acid composition suggests that it is homologous with the other Desulfovibrio ferredoxins. The rubredoxin is also an acidic protein of 6,000 molecular weight and contains one atom of iron and four cysteine residues per molecule. The amino acid composition and molecular weight of the cytochrome c3 from D. desulfuricans (strain Norway 4) are reported. Its spectral properties are very similar to those of the other cytochromes c3 (molecular weight, 13,000) of Desulfovibrio and show that it contains four hemes per molecule. This cytochrome has a very low redox potential and acts as a carrier in the coupling of hydrogenase and thiosulfate reductase in extracts of Desulfovibrio gigas and Desulfovibrio desulfuricans (Norway strain) in contrast to D. gigas cytochrome c3 (molecular weight, 13,000). A comparison of the activities of the cytochrome c3 (molecular weight, 13,000) of D. gigas and that of D. desulfuricans in this reaction suggests that these homologous proteins can have different specificity in the electron transfer chain of these bacteria.     

Structures of the intermediates in the catalytic cycle of mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase is the terminal complex of the respiratory chains in the mitochondria of nearly all eukaryotes. It catalyzes the reduction of molecular O₂ to water using electrons from the respiratory chain, delivered via cytochrome c on the external surface of the inner mitochondrial membrane. The protons required for water formation are taken from the matrix side of the membrane, making catalysis vectorial. This vectorial feature is further enhanced by the fact that the redox catalysis is coupled to the translocation of protons from the inside to the outside of the inner mitochondrial membrane. We are dealing with a molecular machine that converts redox free energy into a protonmotive force (pmf). Here, we review the current extensive knowledge of the structural changes in the active heme?copper site that accompany catalysis, based on a large variety of time-resolved spectroscopic experiments, X-ray and cryoEM structures, and advanced computational chemistry.