Triplet state of tryptophan in proteins. 2. Differentiation between tryptophan residues 62 and 108 in lysozyme.

We have used optically detected magnetic resonance (ODMR) to characterize the degree of solvent availability of the tryptophan residues in lysozyme that are likely to be responsible for the observed phosphorescence. From the phosphorescence spectra, ODMR zero-field splittings (zfs), and ODMR line widths, we concur with the X-ray structure [Blake, C. C., Mair, G. A., North, A. C. T., Phillips, D. C., & Sarma, V. R. (1967) Proc. R. Soc. London, ser. B 167, 365-377] that Trp-62 behaves as an exposed residue and Trp-108 is buried. In addition, we present evidence that ODMR can be used in conjunction with conventional phosphorescence to evaluate the degree of order in the microenvironments of tryptophan in a protein containing several tryptophans. By the specific modification of residues Trp-62 and Trp-108, we have identified those portions of the ODMR lines in the native enzyme that are due to those specific residues. Barring major enzyme conformational changes in the vicinity of unmodified tryptophan residues when Trp-62 or Trp-108 are selectively modified, we find that Trp-108 dominates both the phosphorescence and the ODMR signals in native lysozyme. The results are discussed in view of previous fluorescence findings.     

The circular dichroism of lysozyme.

The circular dichroism spectra of hen egg white lysozyme, and of lysozyme derivatives in which tryptophan residues 62 or 108, or both, are selectively oxidized, have been measured as a function of pH over the range of 200 to 310 nm. Neither Trp-62 nor Trp-108 is principally responsible for the positive rotational strength in the 280 to 300 nm region. The spectrum in the 200 to 230 nm region is nearly the same in the native protein and in the derivatives, and is little affected by binding of saccharide. These results are used to reinterpret the circular dichroism spectra of the lysozymes and alpha-lactalbumins.     

Optical properties of lysozyme. pH and saccharide binding difference spectra.

Difference spectra associated with changes in pH and with binding of saccharides have been recorded for hen egg white (HEW) lysozyme, turkey egg white (TEW) lysozyme, and for the derivatives of the hen protein in which Tre-62 or Trp-108 had been oxidized specifically to oxindolealanine to give the Oxa-62 or Oxa-108-proteins. Identical pH difference spectra were obtained for HEW, TEW, and Oxa-62-lysozymes. Oxidation of Trp-108 is reflected in both the high and low pH (pH 7 versus 5 and pH 2 versus 5) difference spectra. The magnitude of the low pH difference spectrum is enhanced by binding of saccharide for HEW and Oxa-62-lysozymes but not for TEW lysozyme. The shapes and magnitudes of saccharide binding difference spectra are affected by oxidation of residues 62 or 108. These results can be interpreted in terms of the perturbations responsible for the lysozyme difference spectra. The pH 7 versus 5 difference spectrum results from perturbation by Glu-35 of Trp-108 and another tryptophan, probably Trp-63. Perturbation of Trp-108 and one or more other tryptophan residues by several carboxylate groups is responsible for the low pH difference spectra of the unliganded HEW and TEW lysozyme molecules. Perturbation of Trp-108 makes a principal contribution to the saccharide-binding difference spectrum. Perturbation of the Oxa-108 chromophore by ionization of Glu-35 or by saccharide binding produces absorbance changes in the 250 to 265 nm region.     

Rates of structural fluctuations of lysozyme in the range of thermal unfolding transition

The hydrogen–deuterium exchange reaction for the tryptophan residues in lysozyme have been followed in 4.5M LiBr at pH 7.2 in the temperature range of the unfolding transition by measuring the transmittance change at 293 nm. The exchange reaction proceeded in three phases at low temperature for native protein. The first and the second phases were ascribed to the H-D exchange reactions of three relatively exposed tryptophan residues on the molecular surface. The third phase corresponded to the H-D exchange reaction of the three tryptophan residues buried in the interior of the molecule. The H-D exchange reaction proceeded in two phases near the melting temperature and in a single phase at high temperature, where almost all molecules are unfolded. The H-D exchange of three tryptophan residues buried in folded molecules was caused by fluctuation between the folded and unfolded structure of the protein molecule. The rates of such a fluctuation were determined from the rates of the exchange reaction at various temperatures. These rates agreed very well with those determined from the temperature-jump method. This means that a protein molecule in solution fluctuates between the N- and D-states at every temperature within the transition region, where the N-form is the tightly folded native structure and the D-form the randomly coiled chain. From measurements of thermal unfolding of ester-108-lysozyme and the binding constant of (NAG)₃ to ester-108-lysozyme, it was found that almost all cross-linked molecules are in the folded state near 50°C and pH 7.2 in 4.5M LiBr, where intact molecules are unfolded. We also studied the H-D exchange reaction of ester-108-lysozyme. In the temperature region of 43–50°C, about 70% of the exchangeable tryptophan residues of ester-108-lysozyme were exchanged within 1 s immediately after the mixing of D₂O, in spite of the fact that almost all molecules are in the folded state. This was considered the premelting of the surface of a corss-linked molecule.     

Proton NMR resonance assignments and surface accessibility of tryptophan residues of a dimeric phospholipase A2 from Trimeresurus flavoviridis

Proton NMR spectra of a dimeric phospholipase A₂ from Trimeresurus flavoviridis have been recorded. N-1 proton resonances of the tryptophan indole rings have been detected and assigned to specific positions, Trp-3/Trp-30, Trp-68 and Trp-108, by comparing the spectra of the enzyme derivatives with tryptophans oxidized to differing extents. Photo-CIDNP experiments have revealed that Trp-68 and Trp-108 are exposed while Trp-3 and Trp-30 are buried in the molecule. This is consistent with the X-ray crystal structure of a homologous phospholipase A₂ from Crotalus atrox where residues 3 and 30 are located at a dimer interface, but inconsistent with the results of stepwise oxidation of tryptophan residues.     

Tryptophan fluorescence lifetimes in lysozyme.

Tryptophan fluorescence lifetimes at pH 2 and pH 8 have been obtained for lysozyme and for lysozyme derivatives in which tryptophan-62 or tryptophan-108 or both are nonfluorescent. The lifetimes range from about 0.5 ns to 2.8 ns for the various emitting tryptophans. The tryptophan lifetimes appear to increase with exposure of tryptophan to solvent, but intramolecular contacts, probably with cystine residues, can considerably shorten the lifetime. Intertryptophanyl interactions can also affect fluorescence lifetimes. The trytophan-108 lifetime in lysozyme is shorter than in the derivative in which tryptophan-62 is oxidized; this is ascribed to energy transfer from tryptophan-108 to tryptophan-62. From the lifetime results the relative intensities emitted by specific tryptophans can be estimated, and these values also support the existence of intertryptophanyl energy transfer. The emission intensity from tryptophan-62 is greater in the presence of tryptophan-108, and the emission intensity of tryptophan-108 appears to be greater in the absence of tryptophan-62. Conformational effects accompanying chemical modification of tryptophan cannot be completely ruled out, however. The tryptophan-62 lifetime at pH 8 in lysozyme is shorter than in the derivatives, which might indicate a subtle conformational effect. Studies with tri-(N-acetyl-glucosamine)-protein complexes indicate that both the tryptophan lifetimes and the number of emitting tryptophans may be changing upon complexation. The results illustrate the usefulness and the limitations of lifetime measurements in understanding protein fluorescence.     

The pH dependence of binding of alpha,alpha'-dibromo-p-xylenesulfonic acid to lysozyme.

The chemical modification of lysozyme (I) has been accomplished with alpha, alpha'-dibromo-p-xylenesulfonic acid (DBX) at five different pH values. I was alkylated by DBX at room temperature (28 degrees C) with decrease in enzyme activity. The rate of inactivation depended upon the pH at which alkylation was carried out. The highest rate was seen at alkaline pH values; the lowest at more acidic pH values. Amino acid analyses showed that-two lysines and two tryptophan residues had been modified at pH 9; two lysines, one tryptophan and one methionine had reacted at pH 8. A histidine residue was bound at pH 6.5 together with a tryptophan residue. At the lower pH values (2.7, 4.5, 6.5), alkylation occurred with a single tryptophan residue each. Fluorescence and CD data both ruled out the participation of tryptophans 62 or 108. Labeling experiments showed that two residues of DBX-35S were bound per molecule of I at both pH9 and pH8; one residue of DBX was bound per molecule of I at the other pH values. Sedimentation coefficients were characteristic of native lysozyme. The stoichiometry of binding and residue modification indicated that intra-molecular cross links were established. The pH dependence of the cross-linking provides means to measure several allowed intra-molecular distances. The results presented here are consistent with the existence of side chain motion in lysozyme.     

Proton NMR resonance assignments and surface accessibility of tryptophan residues of a dimeric phospholipase A2 from Trimeresurus flavoviridis

Proton NMR spectra of a dimeric phospholipase A₂ from Trimeresurus flavoviridis have been recorded. N-1 proton resonances of the tryptophan indole rings have been detected and assigned to specific positions, Trp-3/Trp-30, Trp-68 and Trp-108, by comparing the spectra of the enzyme derivatives with tryptophans oxidized to differing extents. Photo-CIDNP experiments have revealed that Trp-68 and Trp-108 are exposed while Trp-3 and Trp-30 are buried in the molecule. This is consistent with the X-ray crystal structure of a homologous phospholipase A₂ from Crotalus atrox where residues 3 and 30 are located at a dimer interface, but inconsistent with the results of stepwise oxidation of tryptophan residues.     

Changes in conformation and immunological activity of ovalbumin during its modification with different acid anhydrides.

In order to probe the cause and nature of conformational changes induced by the chemical modification of amino groups in proteins, five acylated derivatives of ovalbumin namely 21% acetylated, 32% succinylated, 90% butyrated 92% succinylated, and 95% acetylated ovalbumins were prepared and their molecular and immunological properties were systematically investigated. As evidenced by the ultraviolet difference spectral, solvent perturbation, gel filtration, and viscosity data, acylation of the amino groups produced a definite conformational change in native ovalbumin whose extent was higher for higher degrees of chemical modification. The solvent pertubation data showed an exposure of 0.5 tryptophan and 3 tyrosine residues in native ovalbumin; the exposure increased to 1 tryptophan and about 5 tyrosine residues in the maximally modified proteins (i.e. 90% butyrated, 92% succinylated, and 95% acetylated ovalbumins). The Stokes radius (2.7 nm) and intrinsic viscosity (3.9 ml/g) of ovalbumin increased, respectively, to about 3.4 nm and 7.7 ml/g upon acylation of its 18 lysine residues; the intrinsic viscosity of 95% acetylated ovalbumin was 7.2 ml/g. The reduced viscosity of ovalbumin (4.2 ml/g) which remained unaltered on raising the pH to pH 11.2, increased to 7.9 ml/g on succinylation of 18 lysine residues. On raising the ionic strength from 0.15 to 1.0, the value decreased from 7.9 to 6.2 ml/g. These observations taken together with the fact that the intrinsic viscosities of 92% succinylated and 90% butyrated ovalbumins are identical, argue against the presently prevalent proposal that electrostatic effects alone are responsible for the disruption of native protein conformation during chemical modification. The immunological activity of ovalbumin towards rabbit anti-ovalbumin expectedly decreased with acylation of its amino groups but the three maximally modified ovalbumins retained 40% immunological activity. This taken along with the spectral and viscosity data showed substantial native structure (format) in the three maximally acylated derivatives. The rabbit antiserum against 95% acetylated ovalbumin did not cross-react with acetylated lysozyme and reacted poorly with the native and 92% succinylated ovalbumins suggesting that the antigenic make-up of the three maximally modified ovalbumins is different.     

Conformation, enzymic activity, and immunochemistry of a lysozyme derivative modified at tryptophan 123 by reaction with 2,3-dioxo-5-indolinesulfonic acid.

Reaction of hen egg-white lysozyme with 2,3-dioxo-5-indolinesulfonic acid (DISA) yielded a homogeneous derivative which was modified at a single tryptophan residue. The modification was located at Trp-123. The absorption spectrum of the derivative showed a new peak in the visible range with lambdamax at 365 nm. In addition, the absorption maximum in the ultraviolet which appears in lysozyme at 280 nm was shifted to 270 nm in the derivative and appreciably enhanced. In ORD measurements, the rotatory behaviors of lysozyme and its derivative were identical at the 233 nm negative minimum and the 199 nm positive extremum. CD measurements gave equal [theta] values for lysozyme and derivative at the two negative ellipticity bands at 208 and 220 nm. Although no conformational differences between lysozyme and derivative were observed by ORD and CD measurements, some changes were detectable by chemical methods. Accessibility to tryptic hydrolysis and susceptibility of the disulfide bonds to reduction were increased in the derivative relative to lysozyme. The lytic activity of the derivative, which retained the same pH optimum as native lysozyme, was greatly (50%) decreased, probably as a result of the slight conformational change. With several antisera to lysozyme, the native protein and its derivative had equal antigenic reactivities. The findings were instrumental in further delineation of an antigenic reactive site in lysozyme.     

Hydrogen-exchange kinetics of the indole NH proton of the buried tryptophan in the constant fragment of the immunoglobulin light chain

The constant fragment of the immunoglobulin light chain (type lambda) has two tryptophyl residues at positions 150 and 187. Trp-150 is buried in the interior, and Trp-187 lies on the surface of the molecule. The hydrogen-deuterium exchange kinetics of the indole NH proton of Trp-150 were studied at various pH values at 25 degrees C by 1H nuclear magnetic resonance. Exchange rates were approximately first order in hydroxyl ion dependence above pH 8, were relatively independent of pH between pH 7 and 8, and decreased below pH 7. On the assumption that the exchange above pH 8 proceeds through local fluctuations of the protein molecule, the exchange rates between pH 7 and 8 through global unfolding were estimated. The exchange rate constant within this pH range at 25 degrees C thus estimated was consistent with that of the global unfolding of the constant fragment under the same conditions as those reported previously [Kikuchi, H., Goto, Y., & Hamaguchi, K. (1986) Biochemistry 25, 2009-2013]. The activation energy for the exchange process at pH 7.8 was the same as that for the unfolding process by 2 M guanidine hydrochloride. The exchange rates of backbone NH protons were almost the same as that of the indole NH proton of Trp-150 at pH 7.1. These observations also indicated that the exchange between pH 7 and 8 occurs through global unfolding of the protein molecule and is rate-limited by the unfolding.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Identification of the tryptophan residue located in the calcium binding site of Trimeresurus flavoviridis phospholipase A2

When phospholipase A2 from the venom of Trimeresurus flavoviridis (the Habu snake) was oxidized with N-bromosuccinimide at pH 4.0, its activity decreased linearly with increase in the extent of oxidation of tryptophan residues. Oxidation of two of the four tryptophan residues caused an apparent loss of activity. The accessibilities of the tryptophan residues were analyzed with differently oxidized phospholipase A2 preparations and were determined to be in the following order: Trp-3 approximately Trp-30 greater than Trp-68 greater than Trp-108. The magnitude of the difference spectrum with a negative peak at 292 nm which is produced upon the binding of Ca2+ in the vicinity of tryptophan residue(s) decreased in a concave manner with increase in the extent of oxidation of tryptophan residues and was greatly diminished when 2 mol of tryptophan residues were oxidized. The activity and Ca2+-induced difference spectrum are thus related to either Trp-3 or Trp-30 or both. Des-octapeptide(1-8)-phospholipase A2 (L-fragment) is 14% as active as phospholipase A2 and is able to give a Ca2+-induced difference spectrum which is smaller than, but similar to, that of phospholipase A2. Its activity and the magnitude of the Ca2+-induced difference spectrum decreased along similar paths with increase in the amount of tryptophan residues oxidized, but in a manner indicating that two tryptophan residues are apparently responsible for the activity and the Ca2+-induced difference spectrum. The order of accessibility of the tryptophan residues of L-fragment was Trp-30 approximately Trp-108 greater than Trp-68. Trp-108, however, could be excluded from the residues located in the active site by reference to the tertiary structure of homologous Crotalus atrox phospholipase A2. Thus, Trp-30 is located in the Ca2+ binding site and is responsible for the activity of L-fragment. It is thus concluded that in phospholipase A2 Trp-30 is located in the Ca2+ binding site. From the concave decrease of relative magnitude of the Ca2+-induced difference spectrum and the linear decrease of relative activity upon oxidation of phospholipase A2, it may be assumed that both Trp-3 and Trp-30 are required to produce the Ca2+-induced difference spectrum, while only Trp-30 need be intact for activity. Anomalous binding of Ca2+ was observed for oxidized phospholipase A2.     

Effect of succinylation (3-carboxypropionylation) on the conformation and immunological activity of ovalbumin.

The epsilon-amino groups of ovalbumin were modified with succinic anhydride; as many as 16 lysine residues were succinylated (3-carboxypropionylated). The five succinylated derivatives thus prepared were homogeneous with respect to the extent of chemical modification as shown by electrophoretic and immunological data. Succinylation of the amino groups altered electrophoretic mobility and isoionic pH of ovalbumin in the expected direction. U.v.-absorption and fluorescence spectra suggested changes in the microenvironment of the chromophores in the modified proteins. The difference-spectral results showed greater exposure of tyrosine and tryptophan residues in the succinylated ovalbumin. Increase in susceptibility to tryptic digestion, Stokes radius and intrinsic viscosity of native ovalbumin, which was observed on successive increase in the chemical modification, demonstrated a conformational change that was proportional to the extent of modification. The loss of immunological reactivity caused by chemical modification also indicated a conformational change in succinylated ovalbumin. The fact that the intrinsic viscosity of maximally modified ovalbumin was less than one-third of that for the completely denatured protein in 6M-guanidinium chloride suggested that the modified protein contained significant residual native structure. The latter presumably accommodates some antigenic determinants accounting for 37% residual immunological activity observed with maximally succinylated ovalbumin.     

Viscosity and transient solvent accessibility of Trp-63 in the native conformation of lysozyme

We have measured the rates of isotope exchange at the nitrogen of the indole ring of Trp-63 of lysozyme and of L-tryptophan as a function of solution viscosity. We have used two cosolvents, glycerol and ethylene glycol, to modify the relative viscosity. We have derived the appropriate kinetic equations for the alternative possibilities that the exchange takes place either in solution or in the intact protein matrix. Because we chose to study the proton-catalyzed exchange reaction, the rate of it is not expected to be diffusion-limited. We confirmed this by measuring the exchange from tryptophan. These results and the known effects of glycerol and ethylene glycol on the solvation of indole allow us to predict that if the exchange reaction takes place in a protein matrix the effects of the two cosolvents when compared under isoviscous conditions should be identical. This is what we find for Trp-63 in lysozyme at 15, 20 and 26 degrees C. The slope of the linear plot of log k vs. log relative viscosity is 0.6. This strongly supports a model for conformational fluctuations where transient solvation takes place without major changes in protein folding. The most interesting feature of our findings is the fact that a slow reaction admittedly not diffusion-limited shows, when taking place in a protein matrix, a linear dependence on solution viscosity. We suggest that what we observe is the effect of damping of movement of the side chain expressed as a change in the friction along the reaction coordinate in the corresponding phase space. The presence of such effects stresses the validity and usefulness of Kramers model of rate processes for reactions taking place in a protein matrix. Such behavior is predicted by several of the recently proposed general mechanisms of enzyme catalysis.     

On the role of tryptophan residues in the mechanism of action of glyceraldehyde-3phosphate dehydrogenase as tested by specific modification.

A method is described to selectively modify one of the three tryptophan residues of the subunit of glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase from yeast. As modifying agent dimethyl (2-hydroxy-5-nitrobenzyl) sulfonium bromide was used. The residue which is modified by the procedure described has been identified as Trp-193. There are either one or two molecules of the modifying agent being added to this tryptophan side chain. The modification apparently does not cause a detectable conformational change of the protein as judged from the methods employed. However, the enzymatic activities in the dehydrogenase as well as in the esterase reactions are lost after the modification. It could be established that the modification rendered the enzyme unable to bind the oxidized coenzyme. Also the charge-transfer interaction between enzyme and coenzyme could no longer be observed.     

Self-association of lysozyme. Thermochemical measurements: effect of chemical modification of Trp-62, Trp-108, and Glu-35.

Heats of dilution and of saccharide binding for hen egg white lysozyme have been measured at 30 degrees, 0.1 ionic strength, and pH 7 over the range 3 to 95 mg of protein/ml. The concentration dependence of the apparent relative molar enthalpy of lysozyme derived from these results gives the thermodynamic parameters for the formation of an intermolecular contact in an indefinite (head-to-tail) self-association process as delta G 0 = -3.9 kcal/mol, delta H 0 = -6.4 kcal/mol, and delta S 0 = -8,3 e.u. Oxindolealanine-62-lysozyme does not undergo self-association reactions that can be detected calorimetrically. This derivative reacts with native lysozyme to form hybrid polymeric species with free energy and enthalpy of interaction similar to those for the polymers of native lysozyme. These results are consistent with the intermolecular contact in the self-assocaition of lysozyme being asymmetric (head-to-tail). The heat of dilution of the derivative of lysozyme in which Glu-35 is blocked as the ester with oxindolealanine-108 is like that observed for native lysozyme in acid solution and is independent of pH. The concentration difference spectrum that develops through self-association is of the shape expected for introduction of an indole chromophore into a charge-free region of the intermolecular contact. The foregoing results indicate that Glu-35 and Trp-62 are part of the contact, that perturbation of Trp-108 does not make a principle contribution to the concentration difference spectrum, and that no acid group other than Glu-35 is perturbed by self-association. There is a small change in the heat of (GlcNAc)3 binding over the range 0.005 to 0.034 M saccharide. These data give the value of -1 kcal/mol for the enthalpy change for formation of the 2:1 saccharide-enzyme complex (ES2) from ES and S.     

Engineered Tet repressor mutants with single tryptophan residues as fluorescent probes. Solvent accessibilities of DNA and inducer binding sites and interaction with tetracycline

Mutants of the Tn10-encoded Tet repressor containing single or no tryptophan residues were constructed by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. The Trp-75 to Phe exchange reduces the dissociation rate of the complex with the inducer tetracycline by a factor of 2. The Trp-43 to Phe exchange has no effect on inducer binding. The fluorescence emission spectra of both tryptophan residues are quenched to a different extent by binding of tetracycline: Trp-75 is quenched to zero and Trp-43 to only 50%. It is concluded that Trp-75 is in the vicinity of the inducer binding site. The different fluorescence emission spectra of both tryptophan residues depend on the native structure of Tet repressor. Quenching studies with iodide indicate that the DNA binding motif is solvent exposed in free repressor and moves towards the interior of the protein upon inducer binding. The inducer binding site is in the interior of the protein. The fluorescence of tetracycline is enhanced upon binding to Tet repressor. The excitation at 280 nm results mainly from the change in environment and in part from energy transfer from tryptophan to the drug.     

Raman spectra of chemically modified lysozyme. Oxindole derivatives.

The Raman spectra of oxidation products of lysozyme have been investigated. The protein was oxidized by N-bromosuccinimide and dimethyl sulfoxide/HCl. Depending on the experimental conditions one to six tryptophan residues are oxidized to oxindole. The most prominent difference between the spectra of lysozyme and its oxindole derivatives is the strong band at 1017 cm^?1 which displaces the tryptophan peak at 1010 cm^?1. Other tryptophan bands are also weakened corresponding to the number of the tryptophan side chains destroyed. Shifts are observed in the amide I and in the amide III regions sensitive to conformational changes. These shifts indicate conformational differences in the higher oxidized species and in the native enzyme, although the amide III maxima overlap with a strong oxindole band. Similar effects are observed in the range of the C-C stretching vibrations of the peptide backbone. If more than one tryptophan side chain is oxidized changes have also been found in the S-S stretching range. The evaluation of this effect is difficult because of the strong oxindole vibration appearing in this region. In species oxidized by great excess of N-bromosuccinimide the tyrosine vibrations can no longer be detected, indicating the modification of this amino acid too.     

Characterization of millisecond time-scale dynamics in the molten globule state of alpha-lactalbumin by NMR

The motional dynamics of the molten globule (MG) state of alpha-lactalbumin have been characterized using (15)N transverse relaxation rates (R2). A modified version of the Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) R2 pulse sequence is proposed in order to overcome the loss of sensitivity that arises from extreme line broadening due to complex dynamics on the millisecond time-scale. Using this pulse sequence, chemical exchange rates were extracted by examining the (15)N transverse relaxation rates as a function of CPMG delay values. The results clearly illustrate that pervasive conformational exchange of 0.2-0.5 ms in the (15)N backbone resonances of the molten globule state of alpha-lactalbumin. The temperature dependence of the conformational exchange rates display standard Arrhenius kinetic behavior between 10 and 30 degrees C. Estimates of the activation energies range from 0.8 to 4. 4 kcal/mol, indicating a low energetic barrier to conformational fluctuations relative to native state proteins. The fluctuations and low energetic barriers may be critical for directing the search for contacts that will result in the transition from the MG state to the native state.