Chondrogenesis in mouse limb buds in vitro: Effects of dibutyryl cyclic AMP treatment

We studied the effects of dibutyryl cyclic AMP (dbcAMP) on mouse limb-bud chondrogenesis at three stages of embryonic development. After 24 h of culture, limb buds with or without a covering of ectoderm were treated with 1 mM dbcAMP for 48 h and were then compared with untreated cultured limb buds. Treatment with dbcAMP enhanced cartilaginous differentiation in organ cultures of stage-17 and -19 (according to Theiler's) limb buds, although the presence of ectoderm reduced the level of dbcAMP stimulation. By stage 20, treatment with dbcAMP irreversibly inhibited cartilaginous differentiation. These results suggest that the responsiveness of mesenchymal limb-bud cells to dbcAMP is stage related. The results of histological studies as well as of analyses of DNA content and sulphated glycosaminoglycan accumulation supported the hypothesis that dbcAMP treatment induces recruitment of initially non-chondrogenic cells whose commitment explains the enhancement of cartilaginous differentiation. Limb-bud competence for chondrogenesis throughout the three developmental stages studied is also discussed.     

Chondrogenesis in mouse limb bud in vitro. I. Effect of the ectoderm

The role of the ectoderm in the chondrogenesis of mouse limb bud mesoderm was investigated in vitro at several developmental stages by analysis of the evolution of DNA content, the accumulation of sulfated glycosaminoglycans and histochemical procedures. Young limb buds or the undifferentiated apex of older buds (stages 17 and 19 of Theiler's table) from which the ectoderm had been removed with trypsin treatment initiated a large chondrogenesis but not morphogenesis. When the ectoderm was present, these limb buds showed a polarized proximal to distal outgrowth and differentiated skeletal primordia. Mesodermal cells of stage 20 limb bud apex were able to differentiate autopodial skeletons with or without the presence of the ectoderm: cartilaginous areas of the limb skeleton seem determined at this developmental stage. These results, which show the importance of the ectoderm in limb bud morphogenesis, are compared with results obtained using other methods with mouse or bird buds.     

Heterogeneity of proteoglycans in developing chick limb cartilage.

Proteoglycan heterogeneity was studied during the maturation of embryonic-chick limb cartilage in vivo. The results suggest that during the differentiation of limb-bud cartilage the aggregated forms of proteoglycans increase between stages 24 and 35, whereas the non-aggregated or monomeric forms decrease. Only one link protein is found in stage-24 limb buds, whereas two are present at stage 35. Evidence suggests that the synthesis of link proteins may be a regulatory factor in limb chondrogenesis.     

Inhibitory and stimulatory effects of limb ectoderm on in vitro chondrogenesis

Previous studies have indicated possible dual effects of the limb ectoderm in cartilage differentiation. On one hand, explants from early (stage 15) wing buds are dependent on contact with the limb ectoderm for cartilage differentiation (Gumpel-Pinot, J. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 59:157-173, 1980). On the other hand, limb ectoderm from stage 23/24 wing buds inhibits cartilage differentiation by cultured limb mesenchyme cells even without direct contact (Solursh et al., Dev. Biol. 86:471-482, 1981). In the present study, ectoderms from both stage 15/16 and stage 23/24 wings are cultured under the same conditions, and ectoderms from each source are shown to have two effects. Each stimulates chondrogenesis in stage 15 wing bud mesenchyme, and each inhibits chondrogenesis in older wing mesenchyme. The results suggest that the limb ectoderm has at least dual effects on cartilage differentiation, depending on the stage of the mesenchyme. One effect involves an early mesenchymal dependence on the ectoderm. This effect requires contact between the ectoderm and mesoderm (Gumpel-Pinot, J. Embryol. Exp. Morphol. 59:157-173, 1980) but also can be observed at a distance from the ectoderm. Later, the ectoderm can act without direct contact between the ectoderm and mesoderm to inhibit chondrogenesis over some distance.     

The morphology and hormonal responsiveness of developing skeletal elements in chick limb buds

While parathyroid hormone (PTH), calcitonin (CT), and certain prostaglandins (PGs) are known to regulate the metabolism of both osteogenic and osteolytic cells of the adult skeleton through an adenosine 3', 5'-monophosphate-dependent mechanism, little is known about the development of this hormonally mediated response in embryonic skeletal tissues. In the present study, the responsiveness of embryonic skeletal elements to PTH and PGE2 was examined during various stages of development utilizing cAMP concentrations as an indicator of hormone-receptor interaction. The cytology of the limb skeletal system was examined also at each stage tested in order to compare the differentiated cellular phenotypes with their hormonal responsiveness. Prior to differentiation of cartilaginous elements in developing limb buds (stage 20-21), cells were responsive to PGE2 and epinephrine (EPI) but not to PTH. The first consistent response to PTH occurred coincident with the initial differentiation of the cartilage phenotype in limb buds (stage 24-25). A responsiveness to both PTH and PGE2 was progressively increased as maturation of cartilaginous and osteogenic elements occurred (stage 26-35). The initial response to CT was detected within cartilage rods in which osteogenic cells had differentiated (stage 33-35). The results of this study indicate that PGE2-sensitive cells exist within the developing limb prior to cytodifferentiation. The development of PTH responsiveness within embryonic chick limb buds is correlated with the onset of both chondrogenesis and osteogenesis in vivo.     

Temporal and spatial analysis of hyaluronidase activity during development of the embryonic chick limb bud

The glycosaminoglycan hyaluronate (HA) appears to play an important role in limb cartilage differentiation. The large amount of extracellular HA accumulated by prechondrogenic mesenchymal cells may prevent the cell-cell and/or cell-matrix interactions necessary to trigger chondrogenesis, and the removal of extracellular HA may be essential to initiate the crucial cellular condensation process that triggers cartilage differentiation. It has generally been assumed that HA turnover during chondrogenesis is controlled by the activity of the enzyme hyaluronidase (HAase). In the present study we have performed a temporal and spatial analysis of HAase activity during the progression of limb development and cartilage differentiation in vivo. We have separated embryonic chick wing buds at several stages of development into well-defined regions along the proximodistal axis in which cells are in different phases of differentiation, and we have examined HAase activity in each region. We have found that HAase activity is clearly detectable in undifferentiated wing buds at stage 18/19, which is shortly following the formation of a morphologically distinct limb bud rudiment, and remains relatively constant throughout subsequent stages of development through stage 27/28, at which time well-differentiated cartilage rudiments are present. Moreover, HAase activity in the prechondrogenic distal subridge regions of the limb at stages 22/23 and 25 is just as high as, or even slightly higher than, it is in proximal central core regions where condensation and cartilage differentiation are progressing. We have also found that limb bud HAase is active between pH 2.2 and 4.5 and is inactive above pH 5.0. This suggests that limb HAase is a lysosomal enzyme and that extracellular HA would have to be internalized to be degraded. These results indicate that the onset of chondrogenesis is not associated with the appearance or increase in activity of HAase. We suggest that possibility that HA turnover may be regulated by the binding and endocytosis of extracellular HA in preparation for its intracellular degradation by lysosomal HAase. Finally, we have found that the apical ectodermal ridge (AER)-containing distal limb bud ectoderm possesses a relatively high HAase activity. We suggest the possibility that a high HAase activity in the AER may ensure a rapid turnover and remodeling of the disorganized HA-rich basal lamina of the AER that might be essential for limb outgrowth.     

Platelet-derived growth factor A modulates limb chondrogenesis both in vivo and in vitro

Cartilage formation in the chick limb follows rapid proliferation, condensation and differentiation of limb mesenchyme. The control of these early events is poorly understood. Platelet-derived growth factor receptor alpha (PDGFR-alpha) is present throughout the mesenchyme of early chick limb buds, while its ligand, PDGF-A, is expressed in the surrounding epithelium. PDGFR-alpha is down-regulated in areas that will not give rise to cartilage and is then lost from cartilage forming areas after they begin to differentiate. PDGF-A increases chondrogenesis in micromass cultures of stage-20-24 limb buds, but not stage 25, where it inhibits chondrogenesis. Ectopic PDGF-A in the chick wing can lead to either a localized increase in cartilage formation, or an inhibition. Inhibition of PDGF signalling in the chick limb results in the loss of cartilage. These data demonstrate that PDGF-A functions to promote chondrogenesis at early stages of limb development and suggest that it inhibits chondrogenesis at later stages.     

Two distinct classes of prechondrogenic cell types in the embryonic limb bud

Differences are demonstrated in the chondrogenic potential of cells derived from the distal and proximal halves of chick wing buds from as early as stage 23, prior to the appearance of overt cartilage differentiation. In high cell density cultures, cells obtained from the distal portions of stage 23 or 24 limb buds are spontaneously chondrogenic in micromass cultures. Cells obtained from the proximal portions, however, become blocked in their differentiation as protodifferentiated cartilage cels, since these cells in micromass cultures make detectable type II collagen, but fail to synthesize significant levels of cartilage proteoglycan or to accumulate an extracellular matrix that will stain for sulfated glycosaminoglycans. Such cultures of proximal limb bud cells can be stimulated to form alcian blue staining nodules by the addition of 1 mM dbcAMP or 50 micrograms/ml ascorbate, or by mixing proximal cells with small numbers of distal cells (1 distal cell to 10 proximal cells). These results demonstrate the existence of two distinct stages among prechondrogenic mesenchyme cells. The earlier stage appears to be able to provide a chondrogenic stimulus to proximal cells.     

Extracellular matrix mediates epithelial effects on chondrogenesis in vitro

It has been previously observed that single chick embryonic limb mesenchymal cells can differentiate into chondrocytes without cell-cell interactions when cultured in collagen or agarose gels. In the present study, limb ectoderm, but not dermis, inhibits chondrogenesis when placed on such collagen gel cultures. The inhibitory influence can be transmitted extensive distances in the gel, even when the ectoderm is placed on a porous filter. Collagen gels, preconditioned with limb ectoderms, are also inhibitory to chondrogenesis. On the other hand, chondrogenesis is less inhibited by ectoderm when the mesenchymal cells are placed in agarose. These results suggest that the antichondrogenic effect of limb ectoderm is mediated through alterations of the collagenous extracellular matrix and support the idea that the extracellular matrix must be considered as an organized, functional unit capable of regulating cell differentiation.     

Specific effects of retinoic acid on the skeletal morphogenesis of the 11-day mouse embryo forelimb bud in vitro

Using our improved method for culturing 11-day mouse forelimb buds in vitro, we have investigated the effects of a local application of all-trans-retinoic acid (RA) on growth, cartilaginous differentiation and skeletal patterning in the mammalian limb bud. Carrier implants of catgut impregnated with DMSO or various doses of RA in DMSO were inserted at the apex of the buds in the proximo-distal axis just beneath the apical ectodermal ridge. After 6 days of culture, cartilaginous skeletons were stained and explants were processed for morphological analysis and quantitative study using computerized optical image analysis. Buds treated with low doses of RA exhibited stimulated growth and chondrogenesis. Moreover, hypertrophied and fused metacarpals were seen within explants treated with the lowest dose. High doses strongly inhibited growth and skeletal morphogenesis. An intermediate dose sustained cartilaginous differentiation at the same level as low doses, but concomitantly disturbed the skeletal pattern. These results are discussed considering reported RA effects on other experimental systems including avian limb bud as an in vivo model or cell cultures as an in vitro simplified model.     

Spatial and temporal changes in the pattern of glycosylation of the developing chick limb tissue components as revealed by fluorescent conjugated lectin probes

The changing pattern of expression of glycoconjugates during the differentiation of the chick leg bud between stages 17 to 34 (days 3 to 8 of incubation) was studied using fluorochrome-labelled plant lectins. Limb buds were fixed in cold acetic-alcohol and wax-embedded. Agglutinins of peanut (PNA), soybean (SBA) and succinylated wheat germ (WGAs) revealed a specific binding pattern in the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) between Hamburger and Hamilton stages 19-32. These stages coincide with the period of elevation of the AER. This specific binding pattern was absent from the adjacent dorsal and ventral ectoderm. Prechondrogenic cells were positive for WGA and for PNA, and the PNA-binding capacity was intensified after neuraminidase treatment. Premyogenic cells at stage 23 can be identified as negative to PNA after neuraminidase, while the blood vessels became positive. PNA, SBA, WGA, WGAs and, in addition, Ricinus communis (RCA-I) lectins stained the basal membrane. Strands of extracellular matrix which connect with the basal membrane and cross the limb transversely between dorsal and ventral ectoderm were stained by RCA-I, SBA and PNA after neuraminidase.     

Identification of Five Developmental Processes during Chondrogenic Differentiation of Embryonic Stem Cells

Background

Chondrogenesis is the complex process that leads to the establishment of cartilage and bone formation. Due to their ability to differentiate in vitro and mimic development, embryonic stem cells (ESCs) show great potential for investigating developmental processes. In this study, we used chondrogenic differentiation of ESCs as a model to analyze morphogenetic events during chondrogenesis.

Methodology/Principal Findings

ESCs were differentiated into the chondrocyte lineage, forming small cartilaginous aggregates in suspension. Differentiated ESCs showed that chondrogenesis was typically characterized by five overlapping stages. During the first stage, cell condensation and aggregate formation was observed. The second stage was characterized by differentiation into chondrocytes and fibril scaffold formation within spherical aggregates. Deposition of cartilaginous extracellular matrix and cartilage formation were hallmarks of the third stage. Apoptosis of chondrocytes, hypertrophy and/or degradation of cartilage occurred during the fourth stage. Finally, during the fifth stage, bone replacement with membranous calcified tissues took place.

Conclusions/Significance

We demonstrate that ESCs show the chondrogenic differentiation pathway from the pluripotent stem cell to terminal skeletogenesis through these five stages in vitro. During each stage, morphological changes acquired in preceding stages played an important role in further development as a scaffold or template in subsequent stages. The study of chondrogenesis via ESC differentiation may be informative to our further understanding of skeletal growth and regeneration.     

Epithelial effects on limb chondrogenesis involve extracellular matrix and cell shape

Collagen gel cultures of limb bud mesenchymal cells are normally permissive for chondrogenesis but become inhibitory for chondrogenesis when they are preconditioned by limb ectoderm. This inhibition is specific for cartilage differentiation, inasmuch as myoblast differentiation is unaffected and flattened, fibroblastic cells are more numerous on conditioned gels. The antichondrogenic effect of ectoderm-conditioned gels is not blocked by agents that elevate intracellular cyclic AMP levels and that promote chondrogenesis under other conditions. In contrast, the inhibitory effect of the ectoderm is alleviated when cultures are treated with cytochalasin D, a cytoskeleton-disrupting agent that causes the cells to remain spherical. These results suggest that ectoderm-conditioned collagen gels inhibit chondrogenesis through an effect on cell shape.     

Effects of prostaglandins on cyclic AMP levels in isolated cells from developing chick limbs

Effects of prostaglandins (PGs) on accumulation of cyclic AMP (cAMP) in the presence of a phosphodiesterase inhibitor were investigated in cells isolated from avian limb buds at various stages of development. Cells were responsive to PGE2 at the earliest stage investigated (stage 20-21) which was well in advance of specific cytodifferentiation of limb tissues. At three later stages (24-25; 26-28; 30-32), the responsiveness of cells isolated from the developing skeletal anlagen of the limb progressively increased coincident with the differentiation and maturation of the cartilage phenotype. Cells isolated from stage 26-28 cartilage rods were responsive also to prostacyclin (PGI2); however, the response produced was only about 50% of the response to an equivalent concentration of PGE2. Cells were not responsive to either PGF2 alpha or 6-keto PGF1 alpha, at concentrations of 30-33 micrograms/ml demonstrating a degree of specificity for PGE2 and PGI2. In the absence of the phosphodiesterase inhibitor, PGE2 increased cAMP accumulation two-fold over the controls and produced a concentration-dependent response between 0.3-30 micrograms/ml. The results demonstrate that PGs are capable of modulating cAMP levels of undifferentiated limb mesenchymal cells as well as embryonic cartilage cells and suggest a role for these compounds in limb chondrogenesis.     

Selective stimulation of in vitro limb-bud chondrogenesis by retinoic acid

Embryonic exposure to pharmacologic doses of vitamin A analogs (retinoids) is a well-known cause of limb-skeletal deletions, limb truncation and other skeletal malformations. The exclusively inhibitory effect of retinoic acid (RA) on chondrogenesis in standard serum-containing cultures of limb-bud mesenchymal cells is equally well known and has provided a means to explore the cellular basis for RA-mediated skeletal teratogenesis. Recent studies showing that lower RA concentrations can cause skeletal duplication when applied directly to the anterior border of a developing limb, suggest that RA may have a role in normal limb development as a diffusible morphogen capable of regulating skeletal pattern. While RA treatment causes both, skeletal deletions and duplications are clearly different (if not opposing) effects, the latter of which is difficult to reconcile with RA's heretofore exclusively inhibitory effect on in vitro chondrogenesis. In the present study. RA's effects on chondrogenesis and myogenesis were examined in serum-free cultures of chick limb-bud mesenchymal cells and compared with its effects on similar cultures grown in serum-containing medium. When added to serum-free medium, concentrations of RA known to cause skeletal duplication in vivo dramatically enhanced in vitro chondrogenesis (to over 200% of control values) as judged by both Alcian-blue staining and [35S]sulfate incorporation, while having little effect on myogenesis. Higher concentrations inhibited both chondrogenesis and myogenesis. The results indicate that at physiological concentrations. RA can selectively modulate chondrogenic expression and suggest that at higher concentrations, RA's inhibitory effects are less specific.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Retinoic acid promotes proliferation and chondrogenesis in the distal mesodermal cells of chick limb bud

Distal and proximal mesoderm of chick limb bud was respectively dissociated and cultured in the medium containing various concentrations of retinoic acid (RA). At low concentrations (5-50 ng/ml), RA promoted proliferation and chondrogenesis in the distal mesodermal cells. The distal cells of stage 20-24 limb buds were responsive to RA, although those of stages 25-27 were unresponsive. Both the cells of anterior and posterior regions of the distal mesoderm were responsive to RA, while the cells of proximal mesoderm were unresponsive. At higher concentrations, the growth-promoting effect of RA was reduced and chondrogenesis in the distal cells was rather inhibited. These results were discussed in relation to the role of RA as the morphogen in normal limb development and experimental duplicate formation.     

The patterns on chondrogenesis of cells from facial primordia of chick embryos in micromass culture

Chondrogenesis of mesenchymal cells from the frontonasal mass, mandibles and maxillae of stage-24 chick embryos has been investigated in micromass (high-density) cultures. Distinct differences in the amount and pattern of cartilage differentiation are found. In cultures of frontonasal mass cells, a central sheet of cartilage develops; in cultures of mandible cells, less cartilage differentiates and nodules form; while in cultures of maxillae cells, virtually no chondrogenesis takes place. The same patterns of cartilage are found in cultures established from stage-20 embryos. At stage 28, frontonasal mass cultures form cartilage nodules and the number of nodules in mandible cultures is markedly decreased. There are striking parallels between the chondrogenic patterns of cells from the face and limb buds in micromass culture. The frontonasal mass cell cultures of stage-20 and -24 chick embryos resemble those established from the progress zone of limb buds. The progress zone is an undifferentiated region of the limb in which positional cues operate. Cultures established from the frontonasal mass of stage-28 chick embryos and from the mandibles of all stages resemble cultures of whole limb buds. These contain a mixture of committed and uncommitted cells. Ectoderm from facial primordia locally inhibits chondrogenesis in micromass cultures and this could provide a positional cue. The differences in chondrogenic potential of cells from facial primordia may underlie the specific retinoid effects on the frontonasal mass.     

Ethanol Exposure Stimulates Cartilage Differentiation by Embryonic Limb Mesenchyme Cells

Studies of neural, hepatic, and other cells have demonstrated thatin vitroethanol exposure can influence a variety of membrane-associated signaling mechanisms. These include processes such as receptor-kinase phosphorylation, adenylate cyclase and protein kinase C activation, and prostaglandin production that have been implicated as critical regulators of chondrocyte differentiation during embryonic limb development. The potential for ethanol to affect signaling mechanisms controlling chondrogenesis in the developing limb, together with its known ability to promote congenital skeletal deformitiesin vivo,prompted us to examine whether chronic alcohol exposure could influence cartilage differentiation in cultures of prechondrogenic mesenchyme cells isolated from limb buds of stage 23–25 chick embryos. We have made the novel and surprising finding that ethanol is a potent stimulant ofin vitrochondrogenesis at both pre- and posttranslational levels. In high-density cultures of embryonic limb mesenchyme cells, which spontaneously undergo extensive cartilage differentiation, the presence of ethanol in the culture medium promoted increased Alcian-blue-positive cartilage matrix production, a quantitative rise in³⁵SO₄incorporation into matrix glycosaminoglycans (GAG), and the precocious accumulation of mRNAs for cartilage-characteristic type II collagen and aggrecan (cartilage proteoglycan). Stimulation of matrix GAG accumulation was maximal at a concentration of 2% ethanol (v/v), although a significant increase was elicited by as little as 0.5% ethanol (approximately 85 mM). The alcohol appears to directly influence differentiation of the chondrogenic progenitor cells of the limb, since ethanol elevated cartilage formation even in cultures prepared from distal subridge mesenchyme of stage 24/25 chick embryo wing buds, which is free of myogenic precursor cells. When limb mesenchyme cells were cultured at low density, which suppresses spontaneous chondrogenesis, ethanol exposure induced the expression of high levels of type II collagen and aggrecan mRNAs and promoted abundant cartilage matrix formation. These stimulatory effects were not specific to ethanol, since methanol, propanol, and tertiary butanol treatments also enhanced cartilage differentiation in embryonic limb mesenchyme cultures. Further investigations of the stimulatory effects of ethanol onin vitrochondrogenesis may provide insights into the mechanisms regulating chondrocyte differentiation during embryogenesis and the molecular basis of alcohol's teratogenic effects on skeletal morphogenesis.     

Chick endogenous lectin enhances chondrogenesis of cultured chick limb bud cells

We have studied the effect of β-d-galactoside-specific lectin purified from 14-day-old chick embryos on the differentiation of the mesenchymal cells dissociated from the limb buds of stage 24 chick embryos, using the micro-mass culture method described previously. When the cells were incubated with the lectin during the initial 12 hr of culture, cell proliferation became slightly activated. The lectin-treated cells formed a greater number of cartilage nodules and incorporated about twice as much as [³⁵S]sulfate per cell than the control cultures. The results of this study show that the chick endogenous lectin promotes cartilage differentiation in vitro and that endogenous lectin may possibly be involved in chondrogenesis in vivo.