Lens regeneration in axolotl: new evidence of developmental plasticity

Background

Among vertebrates lens regeneration is most pronounced in newts, which have the ability to regenerate the entire lens throughout their lives. Regeneration occurs from the dorsal iris by transdifferentiation of the pigment epithelial cells. Interestingly, the ventral iris never contributes to regeneration. Frogs have limited lens regeneration capacity elicited from the cornea during pre-metamorphic stages. The axolotl is another salamander which, like the newt, regenerates its limbs or its tail with the spinal cord, but up until now all reports have shown that it does not regenerate the lens.

Results

Here we present a detailed analysis during different stages of axolotl development, and we show that despite previous beliefs the axolotl does regenerate the lens, however, only during a limited time after hatching. We have found that starting at stage 44 (forelimb bud stage) lens regeneration is possible for nearly two weeks. Regeneration occurs from the iris but, in contrast to the newt, regeneration can be elicited from either the dorsal or the ventral iris and, occasionally, even from both in the same eye. Similar studies in the zebra fish concluded that lens regeneration is not possible.

Conclusions

Regeneration of the lens is possible in the axolotl, but differs from both frogs and newts. Thus the axolotl iris provides a novel and more plastic strategy for lens regeneration.

     

Expression of complement 3 and complement 5 in newt limb and lens regeneration

Some urodele amphibians possess the capacity to regenerate their body parts, including the limbs and the lens of the eye. The molecular pathway(s) involved in urodele regeneration are largely unknown. We have previously suggested that complement may participate in limb regeneration in axolotls. To further define its role in the regenerative process, we have examined the pattern of distribution and spatiotemporal expression of two key components, C3 and C5, during limb and lens regeneration in the newt Notophthalmus viridescens. First, we have cloned newt cDNAs encoding C3 and C5 and have generated Abs specifically recognizing these molecules. Using these newt-specific probes, we have found by in situ hybridization and immunohistochemical analysis that these molecules are expressed during both limb and lens regeneration, but not in the normal limb and lens. The C3 and C5 proteins were expressed in a complementary fashion during limb regeneration, with C3 being expressed mainly in the blastema and C5 exclusively in the wound epithelium. Similarly, during the process of lens regeneration, C3 was detected in the iris and cornea, while C5 was present in the regenerating lens vesicle as well as the cornea. The distinct expression profile of complement proteins in regenerative tissues of the urodele lens and limb supports a nonimmunologic function of complement in tissue regeneration and constitutes the first systematic effort to dissect its involvement in regenerative processes of lower vertebrate species.     

A System for Culturing Iris Pigment Epithelial Cells to Study Lens Regeneration in Newt

Salamanders like newt and axolotl possess the ability to regenerate many of its lost body parts such as limbs, the tail with spinal cord, eye, brain, heart, the jaw ¹. Specifically, newts are unique for its lens regeneration capability. Upon lens removal, IPE cells of the dorsal iris transdifferentiate to lens cells and eventually form a new lens in about a month ^2,3. This property of regeneration is never exhibited by the ventral iris cells. The regeneration potential of the iris cells can be studied by making transplants of the in vitro cultured IPE cells. For the culture, the dorsal and ventral iris cells are first isolated from the eye and cultured separately for a time period of 2 weeks (Figure 1). These cultured cells are reaggregated and implanted back to the newt eye. Past studies have shown that the dorsal reaggregate maintains its lens forming capacity whereas the ventral aggregate does not form a lens, recapitulating, thus the in vivo process (Figure 2) ^4,5. This system of determining regeneration potential of dorsal and ventral iris cells is very useful in studying the role of genes and proteins involved in lens regeneration.     

A critical role for thrombin in vertebrate lens regeneration

Lens regeneration in urodele amphibians such as the newt proceeds from the dorsal margin of the iris where pigment epithelial cells (PEC) re-enter the cell cycle and transdifferentiate into lens. A general problem in regeneration research is to understand how the events of tissue injury or removal are coupled to the activation of plasticity in residual differentiated cells or stem cells. Thrombin, a pivotal regulator of the injury response, has been implicated as a regulator of cell cycle re-entry in newt myotubes, and also in newt iris PEC. After removal of the lens, thrombin was activated on the dorsal margin for 5-7 days. Inactivation of thrombin by either of two different inhibitors essentially blocked S-phase re-entry by PEC at this location. The axolotl, a related species which can regenerate its limb but not its lens, can activate thrombin after amputation but not after lens removal. These data support the hypothesis that thrombin is a critical signal linking injury to regeneration, and offer a new perspective on the evolutionary and phylogenetic questions about regeneration.     

Selective activation of thrombin is a critical determinant for vertebrate lens regeneration

The regeneration of structures in adult animals depends on a mechanism for coupling the acute response to tissue injury or removal with the local activation of plasticity in residual differentiated cells or stem cells. Many potentially relevant signals are generated after injury, and the nature of this mechanism has not been elucidated for any instance of regeneration. Lens regeneration in adult vertebrates always occurs at the pupillary margin of the dorsal iris, where pigmented epithelial cells (PEC) reenter the cell cycle and transdifferentiate into the lens, but the basis of this striking preference for the dorsal margin over the ventral is unknown. In this study, we report that a critical early event after lentectomy in the newt is the transient and selective activation of thrombin at the dorsal margin. The thrombin activity was blocked with two different irreversible inhibitors and was shown to be strictly required for cell cycle reentry at this location. The axolotl, a related urodele species, can regenerate its limb, but not its lens, and thrombin is activated in the former context, but not the latter. Our results indicate that selective activation of thrombin is the pivotal signal linking tissue injury to the initiation of vertebrate regeneration.     

Regulated lens regeneration from isolated pigmented epithelial cells of newt iris in culture in response to FGF2/4

When a lens is removed from the newt eye, a new lens is regenerated from the pigmented epithelial cells of the dorsal iris, whereas the ventral iris never shows such an ability. It is important to clarify the nature of signaling molecules which act directly on the iris cells to accomplish lens regeneration from the iris and also to gain insight into the mechanism of dorso-ventral difference of the regeneration potential. To examine the effects of exogenous factors, we established an in vitro culture of reaggregates made from dissociated pigmented epithelial cells of dorsal or ventral halves of newt iris. Foci of depigmented cells appeared within the cell reaggregates, regardless of their origins, when the cell reaggregates were cultured with FGF2 or FGF4. In contrast, only the depigmented cells in the dorsal iris cell reaggregates underwent extensive proliferation and developed a lens with the synthesis of lens-specific crystallins, recapitulating the normal lens regeneration. On the other hand, neither FGF8, FGF10, EGF, VEGF, nor IGF promoted lens development from iris cell reaggregates. Consistent with the FGF-specific action, FGFR-specific inhibitor SU5402 suppressed the lens development from the cultured cell reaggregates. These results demonstrated that FGF2 or FGF4 is essential for the in vitro lens regeneration from the pigmented cells of the dorsal iris. In addition, these findings indicated that unequal competence in the dorsal and ventral iris to FGF2/4 contributes to the difference in lens forming ability between them.     

Tissue factor expression in newt iris coincides with thrombin activation and lens regeneration

Lens regeneration in adult salamanders occurs at the pupillary margin of the mid-dorsal iris where pigmented epithelial cells (PEC) re-enter the cell cycle and transdifferentiate into lens. It is not understood how the injury caused by removal of the lens (lentectomy) in one location is linked to initiating the response in a different spatial location (dorsal iris) and to this particular sector. We propose that the blood provides a link between the localised coagulation and signal transduction pathways that lead to regeneration. A transmembrane protein (tissue factor) is expressed in a striking patch-like domain in the dorsal iris of the newt that localises coagulation specifically to this location, but is not expressed in the axolotl, a related species that does not show thrombin activation after lentectomy and cannot regenerate its lens. Our hypothesis is that tissue factor expression localises the initiation of regeneration through the activation of thrombin and the recruitment of blood cells, leading to local growth factor release. This is the first example of gene expression in a patch of cells that prefigures the location of a regenerative response, and links the immune system with the initiation of a regenerative program.     

Pax-6 and Prox 1 expression during lens regeneration from Cynops iris and Xenopus cornea: evidence for a genetic program common to embryonic lens development

Lens regeneration from non-lens ocular tissues has been well documented in amphibians, from the dorsal iris in the newt and from the outer cornea in Xenopus. To understand the early molecular events which govern lens regeneration, we examined the expression of two early marker genes of normal lens development, Pax-6 and Prox 1. In both Cynops (newt) iris and Xenopus cornea, Pax-6 is expressed soon after lentectomy in a region broader than that giving rise to the regenerating lens, indicative of an important role for Pax-6 in determination of the regeneration potential. Then Prox 1 expression begins within the Pax-6-expressing tissue, and these Prox 1-expressing cells give rise to the regenerating lens. This sequence of events also takes place in the lens placode of the embryo, indicating that the presence of the same genetic program operates in both embryonic lens development and lens regeneration, at least partly. In the Cynops iris, Pax-6 expression occurs initially in the entire marginal region of the iris after lentectomy but then becomes restricted to the dorsal region. Further studies are expected to elucidate the mechanism of this long-standing problem of the dorsal-restriction of lens regeneration from the newt iris.     

Molecular signatures that correlate with induction of lens regeneration in newts: lessons from proteomic analysis

Background

Amphibians have the remarkable ability to regenerate missing body parts. After complete removal of the eye lens, the dorsal but not the ventral iris will transdifferentiate to regenerate an exact replica of the lost lens. We used reverse-phase nano-liquid chromatography followed by mass spectrometry to detect protein concentrations in dorsal and ventral iris 0, 4, and 8 days post-lentectomy. We performed gene expression comparisons between regeneration and intact timepoints as well as between dorsal and ventral iris.

Results

Our analysis revealed gene expression patterns associated with the ability of the dorsal iris for transdifferentiation and lens regeneration. Proteins regulating gene expression and various metabolic processes were enriched in regeneration timepoints. Proteins involved in extracellular matrix, gene expression, and DNA-associated functions like DNA repair formed a regeneration-related protein network and were all up-regulated in the dorsal iris. In addition, we investigated protein concentrations in cultured dorsal (transdifferentiation-competent) and ventral (transdifferentiation-incompetent) iris pigmented epithelial (IPE) cells. Our comparative analysis revealed that the ability of dorsal IPE cells to keep memory of their tissue of origin and transdifferentiation is associated with the expression of proteins that specify the dorso-ventral axis of the eye as well as with proteins found highly expressed in regeneration timepoints, especially 8 days post-lentectomy.

Conclusions

The study deepens our understanding in the mechanism of regeneration by providing protein networks and pathways that participate in the process.

     

Lens formation by pigmented epithelial cell reaggregate from dorsal iris implanted into limb blastema in the adult newt

In newt lens regeneration, the dorsal iris has lens forming ability and the ventral iris has no such capability, whereas there is no difference in the morphological criteria. To investigate the real aspects of this characteristic lens regeneration in the newt at the cellular level, a useful model system was constructed by transplanting the dorsal and ventral reaggregate derived from singly dissociated pigmented epithelial cells of the iris into the blastema of the forelimb in the newt. The lens was formed from the dorsal reaggregate with high efficiency, but not from the ventral one. No lens formation was observed in the implantation of the reaggregate into the tissue of the intact limbs. In detailed examination of the process of lens formation from the reaggregate, it was shown that tubular formation was the first step in the rearrangement of cells within the reaggregate. This was followed by depigmentation, vesicle formation with active cell growth, and the final step was lens fiber formation by transdifferentiation of epithelial cells composing the lens vesicle. The process was almost the same as in situ lens regeneration except the reconstitution of the two-layered epithelial structure was embodied as flattened tubular formation in the first step. The present study made it possible for the first time to examine lens forming ability in the reaggregate mixed with dorsal and ventral cells, because the formation of a reaggregate was started from singly dissociated cells of the dorsal and ventral cells of the iris. Mixed reaggregate experiments indicated that the existence of the dorsal cells in a cluster within the reaggregate is important in lens formation, and ventral cells showed an inhibitory effect on the formation. The present study demonstrated that the limb system thus constructed was effective for the analysis of lens formation at the cellular level and made it possible to examine the role of dorsal and ventral cells in lens regeneration.     

Determinative role of Wnt signals in dorsal iris-derived lens regeneration in newt eye

We have previously shown that lens regeneration from the pigmented epithelium of the dorsal iris in the adult newt eye proceeds in two steps after lens removal or intraocular FGF2 injection. The FGF2-dependent proliferation of iris pigmented epithelium and activation of early lens genes that occur over the entire circumference of the iris comprise the first step, while subsequent dorsally confined lens development marks the second step. Here, we investigated the expression of Wnt and Wnt receptor Frizzled genes in lens-regenerating iris tissues. Wnt2b and Frizzled4 were activated only in the dorsal half of the iris in synchrony with the occurrence of the second step, whereas Wnt5a and Frizzled2 were activated in both halves throughout the period of the first and second steps. Cultured explants of the iris-derived pigmented epithelium in the presence of FGF2 underwent dorsal-specific lens development fully recapitulating the in vivo lens regeneration process. Under these conditions, Wnt inhibitors Dkk1, which specifically inhibits the canonical signal pathway, and/or sFRP1 repressed the lens development, while exogenous Wnt3a, which generally activates the canonical pathway like Wnt2b, stimulated lens development from the dorsal iris epithelium and even caused lens development from the ventral iris epithelium, albeit at a reduced rate. Wnt5a did not elicit lens development from the ventral epithelium. These observations indicate that dorsal-specific activation of Wnt2b determines the dorsally limited development of lens from the iris pigmented epithelium.     

Determinative roles of FGF and Wnt signals in iris-derived lens regeneration in newt eye

Total regeneration of experimentally excised lens from the dorsal part of the iris-pigmented epithelium of newts has been a key model of tissue regeneration via cells originating from a foreign tissue. Due to the strict spatial restriction of the lens origin in the newt iris, it has often been assumed that only the dorsal iris cells are endowed with an intrinsic potential to give rise to lens tissues. However, our reinvestigation of the process revealed completely different mechanisms underlying lens regeneration and its spatial restriction, comprising the following two steps: (i) Fibroblast growth factor (FGF) 2-dependent proliferation of iris-pigmented epithelium and activation of early lens genes ( Pax6, Sox2, MafB ) over the entire circumference of the iris; and (ii) dorsal iris-restricted activation of the canonical Wnt signals (involving Wnt2b and Frizzeld4) that leads to localized expression of late lens genes ( Prox1, Sox1, β-crystallin ). Injection of FGF2 into normal eyes specifically elicited the second lens development from the dorsal iris, and the administration of recombinant Wnt3a to the cultured iris-pigmented epithelium caused even ventral iris-derived lens development. Thus, it is concluded that the regulation of FGF2 and Wnt signals is a determinative of the iris-derived lens regeneration in the newt eye.     

Hyaluronic acid production and hyaluronidase activity in the newt iris during lens regeneration

The process of lens regeneration in newts involves the dedifferentiation of pigmented iris epithelial cells and their subsequent conversion into lens fibers. In vivo this cell-type conversion is restricted to the dorsal region of the iris. We have examined the patterns of hyaluronate accumulation and endogenous hyaluronidase activity in the newt iris during the course of lens regeneration in vivo. Accumulation of newly synthesized hyaluronate was estimated from the uptake of [3H]glucosamine into cetylpyridinium chloride-precipitable material that was sensitive to Streptomyces hyaluronidase. Endogenous hyaluronidase activity was determined from the quantity of reducing N-acetylhexosamine released upon incubation of iris tissue extract with exogenous hyaluronate substrate. We found that incorporation of label into hyaluronate was consistently higher in the regeneration-activated irises of lentectomized eyes than in control irises from sham-operated eyes. Hyaluronate labeling was higher in the dorsal (lens-forming) region of the iris than in ventral (non-lens-forming) iris tissue during the regeneration process. Label accumulation into hyaluronate was maximum between 10 and 15 days after lentectomy, the period of most pronounced dedifferentiation in the dorsal iris epithelium. Both normal and regenerating irises demonstrated a high level of endogenous hyaluronidase activity with a pH optimum of 3.5-4.0. Hyaluronidase activity was 1.7 to 2 times higher in dorsal iris tissue than in ventral irises both prior to lentectomy and throughout the regeneration process. We suggest that enhanced hyaluronate accumulation may facilitate the dedifferentiation of iris epithelial cells in the dorsal iris and prevent precocious withdrawal from the cell cycle. The high level of hyaluronidase activity in the dorsal iris may promote the turnover and remodeling of extracellular matrix components required for cell-type conversion.     

Transformation of Iris into Lens in vitro and its Dependency on Neural Retina

Upon lentectomy of adult newt eyes, the dorsal iris epithelium produces a cell population that develops into a new lens. The tissue transformation can be completed not only in the isolated lentectomized eye cultured as a whole, but also in the isolated newt normal dorsal iris combined with the retina of frog larvae in vitro. In this study, 93% of such cultures produced lens tissue made up of newt cells. Well-differentiated lens fibre cells were formed which showed positive immunofluorescence for gamma crystallins. When the isolated dorsal iris epithelium was cultured under the same conditions, well-differentiated lens tissue was again formed in 95% of the cases, suggesting that iris epithelial cells and not iris stromal cells are responsible for lens formation. In contrast, the combination of newt ventral iris with frog retina did not produce any newt lens tissue. No lens tissue was produced when the dorsal iris was cultured with newt spleen or lung, although a considerable number of iris epithelial cells became depigmented. Isolated normal dorsal iris or normal dorsal iris epithelium cultured alone infrequently produced a population of depigmented cells but failed to form lens tissue. On the basis of the present and earlier data, it is concluded that in Wolffian lens regeneration in situ , interaction of the iris epithelial cells with the retina plays a decisive role. However, it is suggested that the iris epithelial cells may have an inherent tendency towards lens formation, and that the factor(s) from the retina facilitates the realization of this tendency, rather than instructing the cells to produce lens. The reported experiments provide the first direct evidence for the existence of cellular metaplasia by demonstrating transformation of fully differentiated iris epithelial cells into lens cells.     

Difference between dorsal and ventral iris in lens producing potency in normal lens regeneration is maintained after dissociation and reaggregation of cells from the adult newt, Cynops pyrrhogaster

In Wolffian lens regeneration, lentectomized newt eye can produce a new lens from the dorsal marginal iris, but the ventral iris has never shown such capabilities. To investigate the difference of lens regenerating potency between dorsal and ventral iris epithelium at the cellular level, a transplantation system using cell reaggregates was developed. Two methods were devised for preparing the reaggregates from pigmented iris epithelial cells. One was rotating cells in an agar-coated multiplate on a gyratory shaker and the other was incubating cells in a microcentrifuge tube after slight centrifugation. Reaggregates made of dorsal iris cells that had been completely dissociated into single cells were phenotypically transformed into a lens when placed in the pupillary region of the lentectomized host eye. None of the ventral reaggregates produced a lens. Even dorsal reaggregates could not transdifferentiate into lens when they were placed away from the pupil. The produced lenses from the reaggregates were morphologically and immunohistochemically identified. To obtain evidence whether produced lenses really originated from singly dissociated cells, we labeled dissociated cells with a fluorescent dye (PKH26) before reaggregate formation and then traced it in the produced lens.     

miRNAs in Newt Lens Regeneration: Specific Control of Proliferation and Evidence for miRNA Networking

Background

Lens regeneration in adult newts occurs via transdifferentiation of the pigment epithelial cells (PECs) of the dorsal iris. The same source of cells from the ventral iris is not able to undergo this process. In an attempt to understand this restriction we have studied in the past expression patterns of miRNAs. Among several miRNAs we have found that mir-148 shows an up-regulation in the ventral iris, while members of the let-7 family showed down-regulation in dorsal iris during dedifferentiation.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We have performed gain- and loss-of–function experiments of mir-148 and let-7b in an attempt to delineate their function. We find that up-regulation of mir-148 caused significant decrease in the proliferation rates of ventral PECs only, while up-regulation of let-7b affected proliferation of both dorsal and ventral PECs. Neither miRNA was able to affect lens morphogenesis or induction. To further understand how this effect of miRNA up-regulation is mediated we examined global expression of miRNAs after up-regulation of mir148 and let-7b. Interestingly, we identified a novel level of mirRNA regulation, which might indicate that miRNAs are regulated as a network.

Conclusion/Significance

The major conclusion is that different miRNAs can control proliferation in the dorsal or ventral iris possibly by a different mechanism. Of interest is that down-regulation of the let-7 family members has also been documented in other systems undergoing reprogramming, such as in stem cells or oocytes. This might indicate that reprogramming during newt regeneration shares common molecular signatures with reprogramming in stem or germ cells. On the other hand that miRNAs can regulate the levels of other miRNAs is a novel level of regulation, which might provide new insights on their function.     

Thrombin activation of S-phase reentry by cultured pigmented epithelial cells of adult newt iris

Following local injury or tissue removal, regeneration in urodele amphibians appears to be dependent on cell cycle reentry and dedifferentiation of postmitotic, terminally differentiated cells in the remaining tissues. Regeneration of the lens of the eye occurs by the dedifferentiation of pigmented epithelial cells (PEC) of the iris and their subsequent transdifferentiation into lens cells. A key question is how cell cycle reentry is regulated. Here we demonstrate that thrombin activates S-phase reentry of newt PEC in vitro. Based on these findings, and on previous experiments showing that newt skeletal myotubes reenter the cell cycle following thrombin stimulation, we suggest that thrombin is a critical signal for initiation of vertebrate regeneration.