A dual function for SecA in the assembly of single spanning membrane proteins in Escherichia coli

The assembly of bacterial membrane proteins with large periplasmic loops is an intrinsically complex process because the SecY translocon has to coordinate the signal recognition particle-dependent targeting and integration of transmembrane domains with the SecA-dependent translocation of the periplasmic loop. The current model suggests that the ATP hydrolysis by SecA is required only if periplasmic loops larger than 30 amino acids have to be translocated. In agreement with this model, our data demonstrate that the signal recognition particle- and SecA-dependent multiple spanning membrane protein YidC becomes SecA-independent if the large periplasmic loop connecting transmembrane domains 1 and 2 is reduced to less than 30 amino acids. Strikingly, however, we were unable to render single spanning membrane proteins SecA-independent by reducing the length of their periplasmic loops. For these proteins, the complete assembly was always SecA-dependent even if the periplasmic loop was reduced to 13 amino acids. If, however, the 13-amino acid-long periplasmic loop was fused to a downstream transmembrane domain, SecA was no longer required for complete translocation. Although these data support the current model on the SecA dependence of multiple spanning membrane proteins, they indicate a novel function of SecA for the assembly of single spanning membrane proteins. This could suggest that single and multiple spanning membrane proteins are processed differently by the bacterial SecY translocon.     

Identification of two interaction sites in SecY that are important for the functional interaction with SecA

The motor protein SecA drives the translocation of (pre-)proteins across the SecYEG channel in the bacterial cytoplasmic membrane by nucleotide-dependent cycles of conformational changes often referred to as membrane insertion/de-insertion. Despite structural data on SecA and an archaeal homolog of SecYEG, the identity of the sites of interaction between SecA and SecYEG are unknown. Here, we show that SecA can be cross-linked to several residues in cytoplasmic loop 5 (C5) of SecY, and that SecA directly interacts with a part of transmembrane segment 4 (TMS4) of SecY that is buried in the membrane region of SecYEG. Mutagenesis of either the conserved Arg357 in C5 or Glu176 in TMS4 interferes with the catalytic activity of SecA but not with binding of SecA to SecYEG. Our data explain how conformational changes in SecA could be directly coupled to the previously proposed opening mechanism of the SecYEG channel.     

SecYEG proteoliposomes catalyze the Deltaphi-dependent membrane insertion of FtsQ

In Escherichia coli, the insertion of most inner membrane proteins is mediated by the Sec translocase. Ribosome-bound nascent chains of Sec-dependent inner membrane proteins are targeted to the SecYEG complex via the signal recognition particle pathway. We now demonstrate that the signal recognition particle-dependent co-translational membrane targeting and membrane insertion of FtsQ can be reconstituted with proteoliposomes containing purified SecYEG. SecA and a transmembrane electrical potential are essential for the translocation of the large periplasmic domain of FtsQ, whereas co-reconstituted YidC has an inhibitory effect. These data demonstrate that membrane protein insertion can be reconstituted with a minimal set of purified Sec components.     

Biotinylation in vivo as a sensitive indicator of protein secretion and membrane protein insertion.

Escherichia coli biotin ligase is a cytoplasmic protein which specifically biotinylates the biotin-accepting domains from a variety of organisms. This in vivo biotinylation can be used as a sensitive signal to study protein secretion and membrane protein insertion. When the biotin-accepting domain from the 1.3S subunit of Propionibacterium shermanii transcarboxylase (PSBT) is translationally fused to the periplasmic proteins alkaline phosphatase and maltose-binding protein, there is little or no biotinylation of PSBT in wild-type E. coli. Inhibition of SecA with sodium azide and mutations in SecB, SecD, and SecF, all of which slow down protein secretion, result in biotinylation of PSBT. When PSBT is fused to the E. coli inner membrane protein MalF, it acts as a topological marker: fusions to cytoplasmic domains of MalF are biotinylated, and fusions to periplasmic domains are generally not biotinylated. If SecA is inhibited by sodium azide or if the SecE in the cell is depleted, then the insertion of the MalF second periplasmic domain is slowed down enough that PSBT fusions in this part of the protein become biotinylated. Compared with other protein fusions that have been used to study protein translocation, PSBT fusions have the advantage that they can be used to study the rate of the insertion process.     

Indecisive M13 procoat protein mutants bind to SecA but do not activate the translocation ATPase

The M13 procoat protein serves as the paradigm for the Sec-independent membrane insertion pathway. This protein is inserted into the inner membrane of Escherichia coli with two hydrophobic regions and a central periplasmic loop region of 20 amino acid residues. Extension of the periplasmic loop region renders M13 procoat membrane insertion Sec-dependent. Loop regions with 118 or more residues required SecA and SecYEG and were efficiently translocated in vivo. Two mutants having loop regions of 80 and 100 residues, respectively, interacted with SecA but failed to activate the membrane translocation ATPase of SecA in vitro. Similarly, a procoat mutant with two additional glutamyl residues in the loop region showed binding to SecA but did not stimulate the ATPase. The three mutants were also defective for precursor-stimulated binding of SecA to the membrane surface. Remarkably, the mutant proteins act as competitive inhibitors of the Sec translocase. This suggests that the region to be translocated is sensed by SecA but the activation of the SecA translocation ATPase is only successful for substrates with a minimum length of the translocated region.     

Functionally significant mobile regions of Escherichia coli SecA ATPase identified by NMR

SecA, a 204-kDa homodimeric protein, is a major component of the cellular machinery that mediates the translocation of proteins across the Escherichia coli plasma membrane. SecA promotes translocation by nucleotide-modulated insertion and deinsertion into the cytoplasmic membrane once bound to both the signal sequence and portions of the mature domain of the preprotein. SecA is proposed to undergo major conformational changes during translocation. These conformational changes are accompanied by major rearrangements of SecA structural domains. To understand the interdomain rearrangements, we have examined SecA by NMR and identified regions that display narrow resonances indicating high mobility. The mobile regions of SecA have been assigned to a sequence from the second of two domains with nucleotide-binding folds (NBF-II; residues 564-579) and to the extreme C-terminal segment of SecA (residues 864-901), both of which are essential for preprotein translocation activity. Interactions with ligands suggest that the mobile regions are involved in functionally critical regulatory steps in SecA.     

SecA-dependence of the translocation of a large periplasmic loop in the Escherichia coli MalF inner membrane protein is a function of sequence context

We have analysed the translocation of a large periplasmic loop in the Escherichia coli MalF Inner membrane protein when placed in different sequence contexts and under conditions when the function of the SecA protein is Inhibited. The results show that the degree of SecA-dependence varies with sequence context: while translocation of the large loop In its normal context Is only minimally affected by SecA Inhibition, translocation is much more sensitive to SecA inhibition when the loop is placed in the context of other inner membrane proteins. Conversely, when the large MalF loop is replaced by segments from other proteins, translocation of those segments is again very sensitive to SecA inhibition. Thus, SecA-dependence is not an all-or-none phenomenon and Is not only a simple function of, e.g. the length of a translocated segment or the hydrophobicity of the flanking transmembrane segments.     

Sec-translocase mediated membrane protein biogenesis

Alpha-helical transmembrane proteins in bacteria are localized within the plasma membrane. The membrane assembly of these proteins requires protein devices for insertion into the lipid bilayer. In E. coli, membrane proteins require the SRP pathway components Ffh, 4.5S RNA and FtsY for membrane targeting and the SecYEGDF translocase and, in some cases, SecA, for translocation of hydrophilic domains. In addition, YidC, a recently discovered membrane protein, mediates the membrane integration and folding of hydrophobic domains of membrane proteins. In this review, we will describe the current status of the protein targeting and membrane integration pathways.     

Distinct domains of an oligotopic membrane protein are Sec-dependent and Sec-independent for membrane insertion.

Leader peptidase of Escherichia coli spans the plasma membrane twice with its amino terminus on the periplasmic surface of the membrane and its large carboxyl-terminal domain protruding into the periplasm. To monitor the transfer of the amino terminus of leader peptidase to the periplasm, we have constructed a fusion protein between the 18-residue amino-terminal periplasmic domain of Pf3 bacteriophage coat protein and the beginning of leader peptidase. We find that neither the SecA or SecY proteins nor a transmembrane electrochemical potential is required for insertion of the amino terminus, while the transfer of the carboxyl-terminal domain of leader peptidase has these requirements. The first 35 residues of leader peptidase, which include the first hydrophobic domain and the carboxyl-terminal positively charged cluster, are sufficient to insert the amino terminus. When positively charged residues are introduced before the first transmembrane segment, translocation of the amino terminus is abolished. These studies in protein membrane topogenesis, showing that there are different requirements for amino and carboxyl termini insertion, indicate that multiple mechanisms exist even within the same protein.     

Coupled structure change of SecA and SecG revealed by the synthetic lethality of the secAcsR11 and ΔsecG::kan double mutant

An Escherichia coli strain carrying either the secAcsR11 or Δ secG :: kan mutation is unable to grow at low temperature owing to cold-sensitive protein translocation but grows normally at 37°C. However, introduction of the two mutations into the same cells caused a severe defect in protein translocation and the cells were unable to grow at any temperature examined, indicating that secG is essential for the secAcsR11 mutant. The mutant SecA (csSecA) was found to possess a single amino acid substitution in the precursor-binding region and was defective in the interaction with the precursor protein. Furthermore, the membrane insertion of SecA and the membrane topology inversion of SecG, both of which took place upon the initiation of protein translocation, were significantly retarded even at 37°C, when csSecA was used instead of the wild-type SecA. The insertion of the wild-type SecA was also significantly defective when SecG-depleted membrane vesicles were used in place of SecG-containing ones. No insertion of csSecA occurred into SecG-depleted membrane vesicles. Examination of in vitro protein translocation at 37°C revealed that SecG is essential for csSecA-dependent protein translocation. We conclude that SecG and SecA undergo a coupled structure change, that is critical for efficient protein translocation.     

Competitive binding of the SecA ATPase and ribosomes to the SecYEG translocon

During co-translational membrane insertion of membrane proteins with large periplasmic domains, the bacterial SecYEG complex needs to interact both with the ribosome and the SecA ATPase. Although the binding sites for SecA and the ribosome overlap, it has been suggested that these ligands can interact simultaneously with SecYEG. We used surface plasmon resonance and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy to examine the interaction of SecA and ribosomes with the SecYEG complex present in membrane vesicles and the purified SecYEG complex present in a detergent-solubilized state or reconstituted into nanodiscs. Ribosome binding to the SecYEG complex is strongly stimulated when the ribosomes are charged with nascent chains of the monotopic membrane protein FtsQ. This binding is competed by an excess of SecA, indicating that binding of SecA and ribosomes to SecYEG is mutually exclusive.     

A mutation in secY that causes enhanced SecA insertion and impaired late functions in protein translocation

A cold-sensitive secY mutant (secY125) with an amino acid substitution in the first periplasmic domain causes in vivo retardation of protein export. Inverted membrane vesicles prepared from this mutant were as active as the wild-type membrane vesicles in translocation of a minute amount of radioactive preprotein. The mutant membrane also allowed enhanced insertion of SecA, and this SecA insertion was dependent on the SecD and SecF functions. These and other observations suggested that the early events in translocation, such as SecA-dependent insertion of the signal sequence region, is actually enhanced by the SecY125 alteration. In contrast, since the mutant membrane vesicles had decreased capacity to translocate chemical quantity of pro-OmpA and since they were readily inactivated by pretreatment of the vesicles under the conditions in which a pro-OmpA translocation intermediate once accumulated, the late translocation functions appear to be impaired. We conclude that this periplasmic secY mutation causes unbalanced early and late functions in translocation, compromising the translocase's ability to catalyze multiple rounds of reactions.     

Export of beta-lactamase is independent of the signal recognition particle

In Escherichia coli, three different types of proteins engage the SecY translocon of the inner bacterial membrane for translocation or insertion: 1) polytopic membrane proteins that prior to their insertion into the membrane are targeted to the translocon using the bacterial signal recognition particle (SRP) and its receptor; 2) secretory proteins that are targeted to and translocated across the SecY translocon in a SecA- and SecB-dependent reaction; and 3) membrane proteins with large periplasmic domains, requiring SRP for targeting and SecA for the translocation of the periplasmic moiety. In addition to its role as a targeting device for membrane proteins, a function of the bacterial SRP in the export of SecB-independent secretory proteins has also been postulated. In particular, beta-lactamase, a hydrolytic enzyme responsible for cleavage of the beta-lactam ring containing antibiotics, is considered to be recognized and targeted by SRP. To examine the role of the SRP pathway in beta-lactamase targeting and export, we performed a detailed in vitro analysis. Chemical cross-linking and membrane binding assays did not reveal any significant interaction between SRP and beta-lactamase nascent chains. More importantly, membrane vesicles prepared from mutants lacking a functional SRP pathway did block the integration of SRP-dependent membrane proteins but supported the export of beta-lactamase in the same way as that of the SRP-independent protein OmpA. These data demonstrate that in contrast to previous results, the bacterial SRP is not involved in the export of beta-lactamase and further suggest that secretory proteins of Gram-negative bacteria in general are not substrates of SRP.     

Reconstitution of Sec-dependent membrane protein insertion: nascent FtsQ interacts with YidC in a SecYEG-dependent manner

The inner membrane protein YidC is associated with the preprotein translocase of Escherichia coli and contacts transmembrane segments of nascent inner membrane proteins during membrane insertion. YidC was purified to homogeneity and co-reconstituted with the SecYEG complex. YidC had no effect on the SecA/SecYEG-mediated translocation of the secretory protein proOmpA; however, using a crosslinking approach, the transmembrane segment of nascent FtsQ was found to gain access to YidC via SecY. These data indicate the functional reconstitution of the initial stages of YidC-dependent membrane protein insertion via the SecYEG complex.     

The sensor protein KdpD inserts into the Escherichia coli membrane independent of the Sec translocase and YidC.

KdpD is a sensor kinase protein in the inner membrane of Escherichia coli containing four transmembrane regions. The periplasmic loops connecting the transmembrane regions are intriguingly short and protease mapping allowed us to only follow the translocation of the second periplasmic loop. The results show that neither the Sec translocase nor the YidC protein are required for membrane insertion of the second loop of KdpD. To study the translocation of the first periplasmic loop a short HA epitope tag was genetically introduced into this region. The results show that also the first loop was translocated independently of YidC and the Sec translocase. We conclude that KdpD resembles a new class of membrane proteins that insert into the membrane without enzymatic assistance by the known translocases. When the second periplasmic loop was extended by an epitope tag to 27 amino acid residues, the membrane insertion of this loop of KdpD depended on SecE and YidC. To test whether the two periplasmic regions are translocated independently of each other, the KdpD protein was split between helix 2 and 3 into two approximately equal-sized fragments. Both constructed fragments, which contained KdpD-N (residues 1-448 of KdpD) and the KdpD-C (residues 444-894 of KdpD), readily inserted into the membrane. Similar to the epitope-tagged KdpD protein, only KdpD-C depended on the presence of the Sec translocase and YidC. This confirms that the four transmembrane helices of KdpD are inserted pairwise, each translocation event involving two transmembrane helices and a periplasmic loop.     

Function of YidC for the insertion of M13 procoat protein in Escherichia coli: translocation of mutants that show differences in their membrane potential dependence and Sec requirement.

The membrane insertion of the Sec-independent M13 Procoat protein in bacteria requires the membrane electrochemical potential and the integral membrane protein YidC. We show here that YidC is involved in the translocation but not in the targeting of the Procoat protein, because we found the protein was partitioned into the membrane in the absence of YidC. YidC can function also to promote membrane insertion of Procoat mutants that insert independently of the membrane potential, proving that the effect of YidC depletion is not due to a dissipation of the membrane potential. We also found that YidC is absolutely required for Sec-dependent translocation of a long periplasmic loop of a mutant Procoat in which the periplasmic region has been extended from 20 to 194 residues. Furthermore, when Sec-dependent membrane proteins with large periplasmic domains were overproduced under YidC-limited conditions, we found that the exported proteins pro-OmpA and pre-peptidoglycan-associated lipoprotein accumulated in the cytoplasm. This suggests for Sec-dependent proteins that YidC functions at a late stage in membrane insertion, after the Sec translocase interacts with the translocating membrane protein. These studies are consistent with the understanding that YidC cooperates with the Sec translocase for membrane translocation and that YidC is required for clearing the protein-conducting channel.     

Flexibility in targeting and insertion during bacterial membrane protein biogenesis

The biogenesis of Escherichia coli inner membrane proteins (IMPs) is assisted by targeting and insertion factors such as the signal recognition particle (SRP), the Sec-translocon and YidC with translocation of (large) periplasmic domains energized by SecA and the proton motive force (pmf). The use of these factors and forces is probably primarily determined by specific structural features of an IMP. To analyze these features we have engineered a set of model IMPs based on endogenous E. coli IMPs known to follow distinct targeting and insertion pathways. The modified model IMPs were analyzed for altered routing using an in vivo protease mapping approach. The data suggest a facultative use of different combinations of factors.     

An elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) resistant to the EF-Tu inhibitor GE2270 in the producing organism Planobispora rosea

SecA protein, the ATPase promoting translocation of proteins across the Escherichia coli inner membrane, contains two ATP-binding domains that differ greatly in their affinity for bound nucleotide. In order to define more precisely the location of the high-affinity nucleotide-binding site, oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis was used to introduce cysteine residues into the SecA sequence, and a cysteine-specific cleavage reagent was employed to generate defined peptides of SecA protein after photocross-linking with [α-³²P]-ATP. This analysis revealed that the nucleotide was cross-linked between amino acid residues 75 and 97 of SecA protein. The biochemical function of the high affinity ATP-binding domain was explored by subcellular fractionation studies which demonstrated that SecA proteins defective in this region were found almost exclusively in their integral membrane form, while SecA proteins with defects in the low-affinity ATP-domain showed a normal distribution of cytosolic, peripheral and integral membrane forms. Interestingly, the SecA51(Ts) protein that has a Leu to Pro substitution at amino acid residue 43 bound ATP with high affinity, but its fractionation pattern and translocation ATPase activity were similar to those of proteins with defects in the high-affinity ATP-binding site. These results delimit more precisely the high-affinity ATP-binding domain of SecA, indicate the importance of the early amino-terminal region of SecA protein in the functioning of this domain, and demonstrate the role of this domain in regulating penetration of SecA protein into the inner membrane. Our results lead to a simple model for the regulation of a cycle of SecA insertion into, and de-insertion from, the inner membrane by the activity of the high-affinity ATP-binding domain.     

In vivo membrane topology of Escherichia coli SecA ATPase reveals extensive periplasmic exposure of multiple functionally important domains clustering on one face of SecA

The Sec-dependent protein translocation pathway promotes the transport of proteins into or across the bacterial plasma membrane. SecA ATPase has been shown to be a nanomotor that associates with its protein cargo as well as the SecYEG channel complex and to undergo ATP-driven cycles of membrane insertion and retraction that promote stepwise protein translocation. Previous studies have shown that both the 65-kDa N-domain and 30-kDa C-domain of SecA appear to undergo such membrane cycling. In the present study we performed in vivo sulfhydryl labeling of an extensive collection of monocysteine secA mutants under topologically specific conditions to identify regions of SecA that are accessible to the trans side of the membrane in its membrane-integrated state. Our results show that distinct regions of five of six SecA domains were labeled under these conditions, and such labeling clusters to a single face of the SecA structure. Our results demarcate an extensive face of SecA that interacts with SecYEG and is in fluid contact with the protein-conducting channel. The observed domain-specific labeling patterns should also provide important constraints on model building efforts in this dynamic system.     

An inner membrane protein N-terminal signal sequence is able to promote efficient localisation of an outer membrane protein in Escherichia coli

To test the importance of N-terminal pre-sequences in translocation of different classes of membrane proteins, we exchanged the normal signal sequence of an Escherichia coli outer membrane protein, OmpF, for the pre-sequence of the inner membrane protein, DacA. The DacA-OmpF hybrid was efficiently assembled into the outer membrane in a functionally active form. Thus the pre-sequence of DacA, despite its relatively low hydrophobicity compared with that of OmpF, contains all the essential information necessary to initiate the translocation of OmpF to the outer membrane. Since processing of DacA was also shown to be dependent upon SecA we conclude that the initiation of translocation of this inner membrane polypeptide across the envelope occurs by the same mechanism as outer membrane and periplasmic proteins. The N-terminal 11 amino acids of mature OmpF, which in the hybrid are replaced by the N-terminal nine amino acids of DacA, carry no essential assembly signals since the hybrid protein is apparently assembled with equal efficiency to OmpF.