Immunologic unresponsiveness of mouse spleen sensitized to allogenic tumors.

CS7BL/6 mice were sensitized with an ip injection of allogeneic P-815 mastocytoma cells. Fifteen days later the spleen cells of the tumor allosensitized mice were cultured and tested for their responsiveness to mitogens and alloantigens, and for their ability to generate cytotoxic cells in vitro. The results indicate that 15 day tumor-sensitized spleen cells are hypo-responsive in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) with DBA/2 or AKR as stimulating spleen cells. The cells which are hypo-responsive in MLC can proliferate in response to mitogens and they also can generate cytotoxic cells in vitro. MLC reactivity recovers in about 2–3 months which is $\text{1}\text{1}\text{2}\text{–2}\text{1}\text{2}$ months after the mice have rejected their tumors. The mechanism of MLC hypo-responsiveness was investigated. The results suggest the presence of a suppressor cell which does not appear to be a macrophage or a B-cell. The suppressor cell can be separated from the cytotoxic cell and therefore appears to be a noncytotoxic T-cell.     

Soluble factors from BCG-induced suppressor cells inhibit in vitro PFC responses but not cytotoxic responses.

A macrophage-like suppressor cell is present in the spleens of BCG-infected C57BL/6 mice. This suppressor cell is capable of suppressing both in vitro cytotoxic and PFC responses of normal C57BL/6 spleen cells. Suppression was not caused by changes in the kinetics of the responses or in the quantities of antigen required for stimulation. Suppression of the in vitro cytotoxic response could not be linked to any soluble mediator. In contrast, supernatants obtained from BCG spleen cell cultures, which failed to inhibit alloantigen-induced cytotoxic responses, suppressed the in vitro PFC response to SRBC by normal C57BL/6 spleen cells. It is postulated that either BCG-induced macrophage-like suppressor cells inhibit these in vitro responses via different mechanism(s) or these responses are regulated by different suppressor cell subpopulations within the monocyte/macrophage compartment of BCG spleen cells.     

Further studies on suppressor cell activity in the spleen of neonatal mice.

Spleen cells from newborn BDF₁ and C57BL/6 mice are tested for suppressor activity in mixed lymphocyte culture. The added spleen cells, treated with mitomycin, suppress both cell proliferation and the generation of cytotoxic cells. Thymus cells from newborn mice have little suppressor activity. Suppressor cells act across an allogeneic barrier, are cortisone-resistant, XR-resistant, T-cells and their activity is inversely correlated to the MLC reactivity in the spleen of the young animal. Incubation of neonatal suppressor cells on macrophage monolayers reduces suppressor cell activity and points to the possible importance of the macrophage in controlling immunological maturation.     

Suppressor factor produced by neonatal mouse spleen cells

Spleen cells from 5- to 6-day- old BDF₁ mice produce a soluble suppressor factor (SF) when cultured for 2–4 days in the presence of 10% fetal calf serum. This suppressor factor inhibits the mixed lymphocyte reactivity of adult mouse spleen cells as well as the in vitro generation of cytotoxic cells. The SF which is not H₂-restricted or antigen specific is most effective when added in the early phase of the culture period. The SF is resistant to heat and uv treatment and appears to consist of a large and small component. It is resistant to treatment with pronase or trypsin. The SF appears to be produced by neonatal spleen cells which are not adherent to plastic or Sephadex G-10 and are insensitive to treatment with anti-Thy 1.2 and complement. Incubation of SF with peritoneal exudate cells reduces suppressor activity.     

Studies of thymopoietin pentapeptide (TP5) on experimental tumors: I. TP5 relieves immunosuppression in tumor-bearing mice

The allogeneic and syngeneic immune responses of tumor-bearing mice (C57BL/6 mice bearing 3LL and DBA mice bearing P815) were evaluated by the cytotoxic lymphocyte precursor unit (CLP-U) and MLC. In general, tumor-bearing mice showed slightly enhanced immune responses 4 days after tumor inoculation. This enhanced immune response rapidly declined and about 7–10 days after tumor inoculation, both allogeneic and syngeneic responses were markedly lower than normal. Mice treated with TP5, starting 2 weeks before tumor inoculation, retained normal or enhanced allogeneic and syngeneic responses up to 3 weeks after tumor inoculation. When this tumor-induced suppressive effect was studied in cell transfer experiments, spleen cells from tumor-bearing mice enhanced the growth of tumors in syngeneic recipients whereas spleen cells from TP5-treated mice inhibited the growth of tumors in syngeneic recipients. Moreover, the spleen cells from TP5-treated mice also showed enhanced cytotoxic activity against tumor cells in vitro. These findings suggest that the tumors, after a transient stimulatory phase, induced immune suppressive mechanisms in the hosts' immune defenses. Treatment with TP5 prevented the development of these immune suppressive effects and spleen cells from TP5-treated tumor-bearing mice inhibited tumor growth in freshly tumor-inoculated recipients.     

Proliferative and cytotoxic immune functions in aging mice. II. Decreased generation of specific suppressor cells in alloreactive cultures

The ability of spleen cells from aged C57BL/6 mice to generate specific suppressor cells in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) against allogeneic H-2 antigens was investigated. The suppressor cells from young and old mice were assayed in parallel for their ability to inhibit the proliferative response and the generation of cytotoxicity in fresh MLC. Suppressor cell generation was found to be significantly decreased in 41% of aged mice (23 to 28 mo) as compared to young controls (3-8 mo). The suppressor cells were H-2-specific, radiation-resistant (1000 R), and Thy-1+; they did not function by lysing the fresh stimulators or responder cells, or by absorbing the interleukin 2 in the fresh cultures. Suppression required very small numbers of cells to be effective. It was concluded that the effect of aging was less marked on specific suppressor cell generation than on generation of cytotoxic T cells in the MLC. However, a third type of response studied, the proliferative response, was affected earliest and most severely.     

Transplantation antigen expression on murine trophoblast detection by induction of specific alloimmunity

Cell-mediated immune responses to murine embryonic trophoblast cells were investigated using lymphocyte trophoblast cultures (LTC) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML). Spleen cells from CBA (H-2^k) or C57BL/6 (H-2^b) mice hyperimmunized with 3.5-day-old Balb/c (H-2^d) blastocysts did not undergo DNA synthesis after in vitro exposure to Balb/c blastocyst outgrowths nor were cytotoxic lymphocytes (CTL) generated against H-2^d alloantigens. Splenocytes from Balb/c mice presensitized with semiallogeneic (Balb/c female × C57BL/6 male) trophoblast cells derived from 17- to 20-day placental tissue expressed a weak proliferative response in the presence of semiallogeneic placental trophoblast and produced a moderate number of CTL against H-2^b (paternal strain) alloantigens when compared to mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) between Balb/c responder and semiallogeneic (stimulator) spleen cells. CTL were also generated in vitro after splenocytes from Balb/c mice hyperimmunized with semiallogeneic spleen cells were restimulated in vitro with placental trophoblast cells. These studies showing that early-stage trophoblast cells fail to evoke transplantation immunity and placental trophoblast is capable of generating alloimmunity only after combined in vivo hyperimmunization with in vitro restimulation suggest that these trophoblast cells are poorly immunogenic due in part to the relatively weak functional expression of major transplantation antigens.     

Inhibition of rat mixed lymphocyte cultures by suppressor macrophages.

Normal rat spleens contain suppressor cells which can inhibit proliferative and cytotoxic responses of lymphocytes to alloantigens in vitro. The suppressor cells are adherent, phagocytic, resistant to treatment with ATS and C, radioresistant, resistant to treatment with mitomycin C, apparently absent from the thymus, and found in very high concentrations in peritoneal exudates. These characteristics indicate that the suppressor cell is a macrophages and not a T cell. When suppressor cells were removed from spleen cell suspensions, strong in vitro proliferative and cytotoxic responses to alloantigens could consistently be observed.     

Proliferative and cytotoxic immune functions in aging mice. IV. Effects of suppressor cell populations from aged and young mice

The changes with age in three splenic suppressor cell populations were studied in C57BL/6 mice. Allospecific Ts cells and nonspecific non-T suppressor cells were both generated in vitro in allogeneic MLC. The presence of "pre-existing" suppressor cells in fresh spleen cells from normal mice was examined. Suppressor cell activities were assayed for their ability to suppress proliferation in a fresh allogeneic MLC after treatment to prevent their own proliferation. The ability to generate both specific and nonspecific suppressor cells decreased with age, whereas pre-existing suppressor cells were detected in spleens from the majority of the aged animals but not in spleens from young animals. The decrease in suppressor cell activity was not due to any requirement for age matching between donors of suppressor and target cells. The specific and nonspecific MLC-generated suppressor cells inhibited both the proliferative response in the assay MLC and the generation of cytotoxic cells. The pre-existing suppressor cells only suppressed the proliferative response and not the generation of cytotoxic cells. The changes seen with age in these suppressor cell populations suggest that the ability to generate suppression (both allospecific and nonspecific) to newly encountered Ag declines with age, whereas a resident splenic suppressor cell population accumulates over the lifetime of the animals.     

In vitro sensitization to transplantation antigens. VII. Enhanced graft-vs-host activity of in vitro allosensitized lymphoid cells

We have previously demonstrated that C57BL/6J lymphoid cells sensitized in vitro to C3H/He transplantation antigens, present on macrophage monolayers, can transfer an accelerated C3H allograft response to recipient C57 mice. The present report indicates that C57 lymphoid cells sensitized to C3H alloantigens, present on macrophage monolayers, can also mediate a graft-versus-host (GVH) reaction in (C3H × C57) F₁ newborn mice. This GVH reaction is of greater magnitude than that produced by noncultured C57 cells. The magnitude of the augmented GVH reaction produced by cultured C57 cells is dependent on the source of lymphoid cells: lymph node, spleen, and bone marrow cells are consistently more active than cultured thymus cells—the reduced capability of cultured thymus cells to mediate the GVH reaction parallels their reduced ability to transfer allograft immunity. To test whether monolayers, other than macrophages, can sensitize lymphoid cells in vitro we incubated C57 lymphoid cells on C3H-derived L cells. Lymph node cells incubated with L cells demonstrate an increased GVH reaction in newborn mice. The in vitro sensitization of spleen and bone marrow cells on L cells is less consistent. Thymus cannot be sensitized by L cells. Monolayers of L cells are therefore not as efficient a sensitizing source as macrophages.     

Cell-mediated immune response to syngeneic UV induced tumors: I. The presence of tumor associated macrophages and their possible role in the in Vitro generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes

A primary in vitro sensitization system employing a chromium release assay was utilized to investigate reactivity of murine spleen cells toward syngeneic ultraviolet (uv) light induced fibrosarcomas. These tumors are immunologically rejected in vivo when implanted into normal syngeneic mice but grow progressivly when implanted into syngeneic mice that had previously been irradiated with subcarcinogenic levels of uv light. Following appropriate sensitization, spleen cells from both normal and uv irradiated mice are capable of developing cytotoxic lymphocytes in vitro against the uv induced tumors. It was subsequently discovered that in situ uv induced tumors all contained macrophages of host origin that became demonstrable only after enzymatic dissociation of the tumor tissue. These macrophages were immunologically active in vitro as their presence in the stimulator cell population was necessary to achieve an optimum anti-tumor cytotoxic response following in vitro sensitization. Anti-tumor reactivity generated by mixing spleen cells and tumor cells in the absence of tumor derived macrophages could be greatly enhanced by the addition of normal syngeneic peritoneal macrophages. When in vitro anti-tumor reactivity of spleen cells from normal and uv treated mice was compared under these conditions we again found no significant difference in the magnitude of the responses. In addition, the cytotoxic cells generated in response to uv induced tumors appeared to be highly cross reactive with respect to their killing potential. Cross reactive killing was observed between all uv induced tumors tested as well as with a syngeneic benz[a]pyrene (BP) induced fibrosarcoma. No cytotoxicity was observed against normal syngeneic PEC's even through these cells were shown to be susceptible to lysis by anti-H-2^k effector cells. It was concluded that: (a) A significant number of host-derived macrophages are present in uv tumor tissue. (b) These macrophages are important for the in vitro generation of tumor specific cytotoxicity. (c) Spleen cells from uv treated mice are capable of recognizing and responding against uv tumor associated antigens in vitro. Cytotoxic effector cells generated in response to uv induced tumors appear to have specificity for tumor associated antigens (TAA) present on all uv tumors tested as well as a syngeneic BP induced tumor. The relationship between in vivo and in vitro reactivity against uv tumors is discussed.     

Adherent cells (macrophages?) in tumor-bearing mice suppress MLC responses

The spleens of mice bearing transplanted methylcholanthrene (MCA)-induced fibrosarcomas (MCA-1425 and MCA-1460) were shown to contain cells capable of suppressing the generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) in mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC). The suppressive activity was first detected 21 days after tumor transplantation. No suppression was seen with lymph node cells taken at the same time as the spleen cells. The cells responsible for the suppressive activity were adherent to nylon wool and plastic dishes and they were not lysed by anti-T-cell serum plus complement. The suppressor cells were phagocytic and were resistant to irradiation (3000 rads) in vitro. Spleen cells from tumor-bearing nude mice were as suppressive as were spleen cells from tumor-bearing conventional mice. We conclude from these findings that T cells were not involved either as inducers or as effectors of the suppression observed, although the responsible adherent cells may have exerted their effect by interacting with a T-suppressor cell population in the MLC mixtures. While spleen cells of tumor-bearing mice were suppressive when added at any time during the first 4 days of a 5-day MLC, they showed no effect on the cytotoxicity of fully differentiated CTL. Indomethacin reversed suppression, suggesting that prostaglandins may have been involved.     

Immunologic significance of nonspecific suppressor cells in spleens of tumor-bearing mice.

Spleen cells from mice bearing a progressively growing syngeneic tumor failed to respond to stimulation with mitogens in vitro. This lack of reactivity was due to the presence of nylon wool-adherent cells in the population that could inhibit the mitogen response of normal lymphocytes. Paradoxically, at times when strong suppressor cell activity could be detected in tumor-bearing mice, the animals responded normally to in vivo immunization with sheep erythrocytes and allogeneic tumors, and to in vitro sensitization with allogeneic tumor cells. Regression of a highly antigenic syngeneic tumor also was unaffected by the presence of these suppressor cells. Thus, the occurrence of nonspecific suppressor cells in the spleens of tumor-bearing mice did not influence the overall immunologic competence of these animals.     

Identification and characterization of a soluble suppressor factor(s) in the serum of AKR mice bearing lymphocytic leukemia

Leukemia in AKR mice was found to be associated with the presence of a serum factor(s) termed AKR leukemic suppressor factor (AKR-LSF). Suppression was quantitated by measuring the inhibition of PHA-stimulated [³H]thymidine incorporation by normal AKR spleen cells at various dilutions of leukemic mouse serum (LMS). AKR-LSF activity was expressed as units per milliliter, which is the reciprocal of the LMS dilution that inhibited [³H]thymidine uptake by 50% with respect to fetal calf serum control cultures. The amount of activity in the serum directly correlated to the rate of tumor cell growth. Mice receiving 10⁷ BW5147 transplanted leukemia cells had 130 ± 12 units of AKR-LSF activity/ml of serum compared to 40 ± 8 units/ ml for mice with spontaneous leukemia. Normal mouse serum contained 33 ± 11 units/ml. The leukemic serum exhibited no strain specificity in either phytohemagglutinin or lipopolysaccharide assays, but was found to be twofold more inhibitory against mouse spleen cells than that against rat spleen cells. Human lymphocyte blastogenesis was not inhibited by the leukemic serum. LMS did not inhibit the growth of L929 fibroblasts or murine tumor cells in vitro. Further work is necessary to determine what role the suppressor factor may play in the regulation of antitumor cell immunity.     

Prostaglandin-mediated regulation of the mixed lymphocyte culture and generation of cytotoxic cells

We examined the role of prostaglandins or prostaglandin-producing cells in the regulation of proliferation and generation of specific cytotoxicity in one-way mixed lymphocyte cultures of mouse spleen cells. Cultures treated with indomethacin or other prostaglandin synthesis inhibitors resulted in enhanced proliferation and cytotoxicity. The level of prostaglandins produced in vitro, as measured by RIA, was 10^?8M and was found to be completely blocked by indomethacin. Adding back 10^?8M PG restored baseline (control) proliferative responses. Kinetics of the enhanced MLC response were unchanged from controls as were the specificities of the cytotoxic cells. Cells from indomethacin-treated cultures were more efficient at killing targets than those from control cultures. Prostaglandins appear to have a preferential effect on the induction of cytotoxic cells.     

Inhibition of memory cell-mediated cytotoxic response by systemic administration of Corynebacterium parvum.

Intravenous administration of Corynebacterium parvum to mice during a developing immune response to alloantigens resulted in the marked inhibition of the generation and expression of memory cell-mediated cytotoxic response in the spleen. The inhibition was observed following rechallenge in vivo or by in vitro culturing with the same alloantigen. The impairment in vitro was due, in part, to the generation of regulatory cells which were non-T phagocytic cells, probably macrophages activated by C. parvum administration. These suppressor macrophages appear to act by inhibiting proliferation and clonal expansion of memory cytotoxic cells.     

Detection of nonspecific cytotoxicity in graft-versus-host reaction as a function of target cell type

The cytotoxic activity of spleen cells from mice undergoing graft-versus-host (GVH) reaction on ⁵¹Cr-labeled target cells was studied under in vitro conditions. Among normal tissues used as target cells, skin fibroblasts proved to be most sensitive to the nonspecific cytotoxic effects of spleen cells from mice undergoing GVH reaction, whereas kidney cells or macrophages were insensitive to these nonspecific cytotoxic effects. Of the two murine neoplastic target cells used, Sarcoma 1 cells were susceptible to these nonspecific cytotoxic effects whereas mastocyoma cells were resistant. However, the target cells which were insensitive to the nonspecific cytolytic effects, were lysed specifically by the spleen cells from animals specifically sensitized. Therefore, both specific and nonspecific cytotoxic effects of spleen cells from mice undergoing GVH reaction could be detected with appropriate targets. These results provide a basis for reconciliation of several apparently contradictory results, reported in the literature, concerning the specificity of the cytotoxic effects of specifically sensitized lymphocytes.     

A nonspecific inhibitor of leukocyte migration in serum from rats bearing large fibrosarcomata.

A 3 M KCl crude extract of the syngeneic benzpyrene-induced fibrosarcoma termed BP 238 specifically inhibits migration out of glass capillary tubes of immune spleen cells from tumor amputee and small tumor-bearing rats, as does supernatant medium from tumor cells grown in culture. Serum from rats bearing small (< 2 cm³) tumors does not inhibit migration of immune spleen cells, while serum from rats with larger tumors (>4 cm³) nonspecifically inhibits migration of both immune and nonimmune spleen cells, thoracic duct lymphocytes, and thymocytes. This nonspecific inhibition increases with increasing tumor size, does not correlate with the presence of bacterial infection, and is presumably due to a circulating factor produced in vivo during tumor growth. Production of macrophage inhibitory-like factor (MILF) by neoplasms in vivo may offer a mechanism for tumors to escape immunosurveillance by systemic immobilization of cytotoxic lymphocytes. From Sephadex and ultrafiltration fractionation experiments, the molecular weight of MILF in serum is polydisperse (30,000–100,000 daltons), and is heat and chymotrypsin resistant, in contrast with the properties reported for LIF (leukocyte inhibitory factor) and MIF (macrophage migration inhibitory factor) produced in vitro.     

The multicellular tumor spheroid model: I. Characterization of the allograft response in sensitized mice

Intraperitoneal implants of multicellular spheroids of EMT6 mammary sarcoma cells into specifically sensitized allogeneic mice have been used as a model to study in situ immunity to solid tumor allografts. Morphological examination of the spheroids recovered from sensitized mice revealed massive infiltration by host cells. There was an early but apparently nonspecific infiltration by large numbers of polymorphonuclear leukocytes followed by the infiltration of large numbers of macrophages and smaller numbers of lymphocytes. The later infiltration correlated with tumor cell killing as determined by a cloning assay for surviving EMT6 cells, and with the presence of cells with cytotoxic activity in in vitro assays. The kinetics of tumor cell killing indicated that tumor cell survival decreased within a few hours of spheroid implantation and less than 1% of the tumor cells survived after 48 h. Purification of the infiltrating cells by nylon wool fractionation and by treatment with anti-T-cell serum and complement indicated that the primary cytotoxic cell is a T lymphocyte.     

Regulation of the in vitro anamnestic antibody response by cyclic AMP. II. Antigen-dependent enhancement by exogenous prostaglandins of the E series.

The spleen cells from CFW/D mice injected with dimethylbenzanthracene-induced leukemia virus exhibited a progressive decline in the in vitro response to heterologous erythrocyte antigens in parallel with tumor growth. Cell transfer experiments revealed that this immunodepressed state may involve a B-cell defect rather than extrinsic factors in the cellular environment since: (i) nonresponsiveness could be transferred to irradiated non-tumor-bearing mice with spleen cells, and (ii) T cells from tumorbearing mice cooperated with normal bone marrow cells, but bone marrow from tumorbearing mice did not cooperate with normal T cells. In addition, T cells from the thymic tumor could cooperate with normal bone marrow cells upon transfer to irradiated recipients. TL 485-2 cells, a T-cell line derived from the tumor, could be specifically activated with SRBC thereby indicating that the virus transformed T cells were immunocompetent. Suppressor cells, which appeared in the spleen concomitant with immunodepression and tumor development, may directly raise B-cell thresholds for T-dependent triggering signals since the antibody response of spleen cells from tumor-bearing mice could be restored by adding agents such as LPS, 2 mercaptoethanol, or T cells exogenously preactivated in normal animals. The suppressor cell could be enriched by adherence to plastic and was removed by treatment with carbonyl iron. In addition, it was unlikely that the suppressor cell was a virus-infected cell since transformed, virus-infected cells from the tumor or TL 485-2 cells were not suppressive when added to spleen cells in vitro but rather resulted in a marked, polyclonal enhancement of the PFC response. The interaction of TL 485-2 cells and normal spleen cells resulted in the release of a stimulatory factor which increased DNA synthesis in resting cells as well as increasing PFC. The role of these enhancing factors and suppressor cells in controlling tumor growth remains to be elucidated.