Embryogenesis and metamorphosis in a haplosclerid demosponge: gastrulation and transdifferentiation of larval ciliated cells to choanocytes

Abstract. Early development and metamorphosis of Reniera sp., a haplosclerid demosponge, have been examined to determine how gastrulation occurs in this species, and whether there is an inversion of the primary germ layers at metamorphosis. Embryogenesis occurs by unequal cleavage of blastomeres to form a solid blastula consisting micro- and macromeres; multipolar migration of the micromeres to the surface of the embryo results in a bi-layered embryo and is interpreted as gastrulation. Polarity of the embryo is determined by the movement of pigment-containing micromeres to one pole of the embryo; this pole later becomes the posterior pole of the swimming larva. The bi-layered larva has a fully differentiated monociliated outer cell layer, and a solid interior of various cell types surrounded by dense collagen. The pigmented cells at the posterior pole give rise to long cilia that are capable of responding to environmental stimuli. Larvae settle on their anterior pole. Fluorescent labeling of the monociliated outer cell layer with a cell-lineage marker (CMFDA) demonstrates that the monociliated cells resorb their cilia, migrate inwards, and transdifferentiate into the choanocytes of the juvenile sponge, and into other amoeboid cells. The development of the flagellated choanocytes and other cells in the juvenile from the monociliated outer layer of this sponge's larva is interpreted as the dedifferentiation of fully differentiated larval cells—a process seen during the metamorphosis of other ciliated invertebrate larvae—not as inversion of the primary germ layers. These results suggest that the sequences of development in this haplosclerid demosponge are not very different than those observed in many cnidarians.     

Three‐dimensional fate mapping of larval tissues through metamorphosis in the glass sponge Oopsacas minuta

The tissue of glass sponges (Class Hexactinellida) is unique among metazoans in being largely syncytial, a state that arises during early embryogenesis when blastomeres fuse. In addition, hexactinellids are one of only two poriferan groups that already have clearly formed flagellated chambers as larvae. The fate of the larval chambers and of other tissues during metamorphosis is unknown. One species of hexactinellid, Oopsacas minuta, is found in submarine caves in the Mediterranean and is reproductive year round, which facilitates developmental studies; however, describing metamorphosis has been a challenge because the syncytial nature of the tissue makes it difficult to trace the fates using conventional cell tracking markers. We used three‐dimensional models to map the fate of larval tissues of O. minuta through metamorphosis and provide the first detailed account of larval tissue reorganization at metamorphosis of a glass sponge larva. Larvae settle on their anterior swimming pole or on one side. The multiciliated cells that formed a belt around the larva are discarded during the first stage of metamorphosis. We found that larval flagellated chambers are retained throughout metamorphosis and become the kernels of the first pumping chambers of the juvenile sponge. As larvae of O. minuta settle, larval chambers are enlarged by syncytial tissues containing yolk inclusions. Lipid inclusions at the basal attachment site gradually became smaller during the six weeks of our study. In O. minuta, the flagellated chambers that differentiate in the larva become the post‐metamorphic flagellated chambers, which corroborate the view that internalization of these chambers during embryogenesis is a process that resembles gastrulation processes in other animals.     

The metamorphosis of the parenchymula-larva of Ephydatia fluviatilis (Porifera,Spongillidae)

Summary The sexual development of Ephydatia fluviatilis involves a ciliated parenchymula-larva. The mature larva leaves the body of the mother sponge through the excurrent canal system and arrives eventually in the outside world by way of the osculum. At this stage the types of cells found in the adult sponge are already present in the larva. The released larva swims around for a while and then, after a period of between 3 and 48 hours, it attaches, usually with the anterior, larval cavity-bearing pole, onto the substratum. While it is attaching and spreading itself out, the larva undergoes a metamorphosis. The most notable stages of this metamorphosis are as follows: (a) disintegration of the ciliated epithelium from the anterior pole of the larva and its substitution by a pinacocyte epithelium, (b) splitting of the larval cavity and (c) integration of the remains into the developing canal system together with the creation and further development of the organic features of a functioning sponge.     

The bases for and timing of regional specification during larval development in Phoronis

A fate map has been constructed for Phoronis vancouverensis. The animal pole of the egg gives rise to the apical plate in the hood of the actinotroch larva. The vegetal pole of the egg marks the site of gastrulation. During the initiation of gastrulation the cells of the animal pole of the embryo are directly opposite those at the vegetal pole of the embryo. The plane of the first cleavage always goes through the animal-vegetal pole of the egg. In about 70% of the cases the plane of the first cleavage is perpendicular to the future anterior-posterior axis of the actinotroch larva; in the remaining cases the plane of the first cleavage is either oblique with reference to, or occurs along, the future anterior-posterior axis of the larva. Following gastrulation catecholamine-containing cells first make their appearance in the apical plate and gut cells first produce esterase. The timing of regional specification in these embryos has been examined by isolating animal or vegetal, anterior or posterior, or lateral regions at different time periods between the initiation of cleavage and gastrulation and examining their ability to differentiate. Animal halves isolated from early cleavage through late blastula stages do not gastrulate and do not form catecholamine-containing cells. When animal halves are isolated with endoderm during gastrulation, they differentiate catecholamine-containing cells. Vegetal halves isolated at the 8- to 16-cell stage gastrulate and form normal actinotroch larvae with esterase-positive gut and catecholamine-containing apical plate cells. When this same region is isolated at blastula stages it does not gastrulate and does not differentiate these cell types. Vegetal halves isolated during gastrulation subsequently form esterase-positive gut cells, but they do not form catecholamine-containing apical plate cells. When presumptive anterior, posterior, or lateral halves are isolated from early cleavage through blastula stages, each half forms a normal actinotroch larva. Lateral halves isolated during gastrulation also form normal larvae. Anterior halves isolated during late gastrulation differentiate only the anterior end of the actinotroch larva. These isolates have a hood with catecholamine-containing apical plate cells and the first part of an esterase-positive gut but lack the anlagen of the intestine and protonephridia. Posterior halves isolated during late gastrulation differentiate only the posterior end of the actinotroch which lacks a hood with catecholamine-containing cells but has an esterase-positive gut, protonephridia, and the anlagen of the intestine.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Metamorphosis of cinctoblastula larvae (Homoscleromorpha, porifera)

The metamorphosis of the cinctoblastula of Homoscleromorpha is studied in five species belonging to three genera. The different steps of metamorphosis are similar in all species. The metamorphosis occurs by the invagination and involution of either the anterior epithelium or the posterior epithelium of the larva. During metamorphosis, morphogenetic polymorphism was observed, which has an individual character and does not depend on either external or species specific factors. In the rhagon, the development of the aquiferous system occurs only by epithelial morphogenesis and subsequent differentiation of cells. Mesohylar cells derive from flagellated cells after ingression. The formation of pinacoderm and choanoderm occurs by the differentiation of the larval flagellated epithelium. This is possibly due to the conservation of cell junctions in the external surface of the larval flagellated cells and of the basement membrane in their internal surface. The main difference in homoscleromorph metamorphosis compared with Demospongiae is the persistence of the flagellated epithelium throughout this process and even in the adult since exo- and endopinacoderm remain flagellated. The antero-posterior axis of the larva corresponds to the baso-apical axis of the adult in Homoscleromorpha.     

Fates and states of determination of single vegetal pole blastomeres of X. laevis

Vegetal pole cells of Xenopus morulae contribute progeny to all three germ layers, but from the midblastula stage onward they contribute only to the endoderm. We have investigated whether this restriction in fate reflects cell determination by implanting labeled vegetal pole cells into the blastocoels of host embryos and asking which structures later include labeled progeny. Single vegetal pole cells from the morula and also from the midblastula stage can contribute progeny to all germ layers. At the early gastrula stage the cells can contribute only to the endoderm. Thus the restriction of fate in the midblastula does not reflect cell determination. However, the cells do become determined by the beginning of gastrulation.     

Ultrastructure of mesoderm formation and development in Membranipora membranacea (Bryozoa: Gymnolaemata)

Mesoderm origin in Bryozoa is largely unknown. In this study, embryonic and early larval stages of Membranipora membranacea, a bryozoan exhibiting a planktotrophic cyphonautes larva, are investigated using mainly ultrastructural techniques. Shortly after the onset of gastrulation, an ectodermal cell, which is situated centrally at the prospective anterior pole of the larva, can be recognized by its constricted apical surface and enlarged basal part. It is also distinct from other ectodermal cells by the composition of its cytoplasm. In later stages, it has left the epidermis, lost its epithelial character, and is situated subepithelially, between the basal sides of the ectodermal and endodermal sheets. A blastocoelic cavity is not present at this stage. This cell divides and gives rise to a group of cells forming a muscular and neuronal strand at the anterior side of the larva. The majority of the larval musculature originates from this ingression. Despite this evidence for an ectodermal origin, additional sources of mesoderm can so far not be excluded. The literature on mesoderm origin in Bryozoa is reviewed and the results are compared to known data from other metazoan taxa.     

Ultraviolet irradiation of eggs and blastomere isolation experiments suggest that gastrulation in the direct developing ascidian, Molgula pacifica, requires localized cytoplasmic determinants in the egg and cell signaling beginning at the two-cell stage

Gastrulation in the maximum direct developing ascidian Molgula pacifica is highly modified compared with commonly studied "model" ascidians in that endoderm cells situated in the vegetal pole region do not undergo typical invagination and due to the absence of a typical blastopore the involution of mesoderm cells is highly modified. At the gastrula stage, embryos are comprised of a central cluster of large yolky cells that are surrounded by a single layer of ectoderm cells in which there is only a slight indication of an inward movement of cells at the vegetal pole. As a consequence, these embryos do not form an archenteron. In the present study, ultraviolet (UV) irradiation of fertilized eggs tested the possibility that cortical cytoplasmic factors are required for gastrulation, and blastomere isolation experiments tested the possibility that cell signaling beginning at the two-cell stage may be required for the development of the gastrula. Irradiation of unoriented fertilized eggs with UV light resulted in late cleavage stage embryos that failed to undergo gastrulation. When blastomeres were isolated from two-cell embryos, they developed into late cleavage stage embryos; however, they did not undergo gastrulation and subsequently develop into juveniles. These results suggest that cytoplasmic factors required for gastrulation are localized in the egg cortex, but in contrast to previously studied indirect developers, these factors are not exclusively localized in the vegetal pole region at the first stage of ooplasmic segregation. Furthermore, the inability of embryos derived from blastomeres isolated at the two-cell stage to undergo gastrulation and develop into juveniles suggests that important cell signaling begins as early as the two-cell stage in M. pacifica. These results are discussed in terms of the evolution of maximum direct development in ascidians.     

Fine structure of the doliolaria larva of the feather star Florometra serratissima (Echinodermata: Crinoidea), with special emphasis on the nervous system

The epidermis of the doliolaria larva of the Florometra serratissima is differentiated into distinct structures including an apical organ, adhesive pit, ganglion, ciliary bands, nerve plexus, and vestibular invagination. All these structures possess unique cell-types, suggesting that they are functionally specialized in the larva, except the vestibular invagination that becomes the postmetamorphic stomodeum. The epidermis also contains yellow cells, amoeboid-like cells, and secretory cells. The enteric sac, hydrocoel, axocoel, and somatocoels have differentiated but are probably not functional in the doliolaria stage. Mesenchymal cells, around the enteric sac and coeloms, appear to be actively secreting the endoskeleton and connective tissue fibers. The nervous system is composed of a nerve plexus, ganglion, and sensory receptor cells in the apical organ. The apical organ is a larval specialization of the anterior end; the ganglion is located in the base of the epidermis at the anterior dorsal end of the larva. The nerve plexus underlies most of the epidermis, although it is more prominent in the anterior region. Here, processes from sensory receptor cells of the apical organ, as well as those from nerve cells, contribute to the plexus. These processes contain one or a combination of organelles including vesicles, vacuoles, microtubules, and mitochondria. The configuration of glyoxylic acid-induced fluorescence, revealing catecholamine activity, correlates to the apical organ, nerve cells, and nerve plexus. Morphological evidence suggests that the nervous system may function in initiation and control of settlement, attachment, and metamorphosis. The crinoid larval nervous system is discussed and compared to that found in other larval echinoderms.     

Regionalized Cell Division during Sea Urchin Gastrulation Contributes to Archenteron Formation and Is Correlated with the Establishment of Larval Symmetry

During gastrulation of the sea urchin, Lytechinus variegutus there is localized proliferation of cells in the vegetal plate region prior to its invagination. Cell counts show that during gastrulation the number of cells per embryo increases 60% from 1025 to 1640. Measurements of cell volumes suggest that some growth may follow these divisions. Feulgen staining shows that the greatest mitotic activity throughout gastrulation occurs in the vegetal plate region. Labelling embryos with 3H-thymidine reveals that incorporation in the vegetal plate is confined to cells that encircle the base of the archenteron. Pulse-chase experiments indicate that these labelled cells contribute descendants to the vegetal half of the archenteron. Additionally, 3-dimensional reconstructions of vegetal regions at different stages reveal that by the end of gastrulation two bilateral clusters of labelled cells lie at the future sites of the post-oral arms of the pluteus larva, thus marking the axes of bilateral and dorso-ventral symmetry. Our findings suggest that two of the principal events of sea urchin gastrulation — the formation of the archenteron and the establishment of symmetry in the larva — are accompanied by distinct patterns of cell division.     

Homeobox gene expression in Brachiopoda: the role of Not and Cdx in bodyplan patterning, neurogenesis, and germ layer specification

The molecular control that underlies brachiopod ontogeny is largely unknown. In order to contribute to this issue we analyzed the expression pattern of two homeobox containing genes, Not and Cdx, during development of the rhynchonelliform (i.e., articulate) brachiopod Terebratalia transversa. Not is a homeobox containing gene that regulates the formation of the notochord in chordates, while Cdx (caudal) is a ParaHox gene involved in the formation of posterior tissues of various animal phyla. The T. transversa homolog, TtrNot, is expressed in the ectoderm from the beginning of gastrulation until completion of larval development, which is marked by a three-lobed body with larval setae. Expression starts at gastrulation in two areas lateral to the blastopore and subsequently extends over the animal pole of the gastrula. With elongation of the gastrula, expression at the animal pole narrows to a small band, whereas the areas lateral to the blastopore shift slightly towards the future anterior region of the larva. Upon formation of the three larval body lobes, TtrNot expressing cells are present only in the posterior part of the apical lobe. Expression ceases entirely at the onset of larval setae formation. TtrNot expression is absent in unfertilized eggs, in embryos prior to gastrulation, and in settled individuals during and after metamorphosis. Comparison with the expression patterns of Not genes in other metazoan phyla suggests an ancestral role for this gene in gastrulation and germ layer (ectoderm) specification with co-opted functions in notochord formation in chordates and left/right determination in ambulacrarians and vertebrates. The caudal ortholog, TtrCdx, is first expressed in the ectoderm of the gastrulating embryo in the posterior region of the blastopore. Its expression stays stable in that domain until the blastopore is closed. Thereafter, the expression is confined to the ventral portion of the mantle lobe in the fully developed larva. No TtrCdx expression is detectable in the juvenile after metamorphosis. This expression of TtrCdx is congruent with findings in other metazoans, where genes belonging to the Cdx/caudal family are predominantly localized in posterior domains during gastrulation. Later in development this gene will play a fundamental role in the formation of posterior tissues.     

When does the anterior endomesderm meet the anterior-most neuroectoderm during Xenopus gastrulation?

During amphibian gastrulation, the anterior endomesoderm is thought to move forward along the inner surface of the blastocoel roof toward the animal pole where it comes into physical contact with the anterior-most portion of the prospective head neuroectoderm (PHN), and it is also believed that this physical interaction occurs during the mid-gastrula stage. However, using Xenopus embryos we found that the interaction between the anterior endomesoderm and the PHN occurs as early as stage 10.25 and the blastocoel roof ectoderm at this stage contributed only to the epidermal tissue. We also found that once the interaction was established, these tissues continued to associate in register and ultimately became the head structures. From these findings, we propose a new model of Xenopus gastrulation. The anterior endomesoderm migrates only a short distance on the inner surface of the blastocoel roof during very early stages of gastrulation (by stage 10.25). Then, axial mesoderm formation occurs, beginning dorsally (anterior) and progressing ventrally (posterior) to complete gastrulation. This new view of Xenopus gastrulation makes it possible to directly compare vertebrate gastrulation movements.     

Zur fortpflanzung und entwicklung der macrodasyoidea (Gastrotricha)

Comparative investigations of the reproduction and development of the Macrodasyoidea are made on the species Turbanella cornuta, Macrodasys caudatus, Cephalodasys muximus, Dactylopodalia baltica and some others.The Macrodasyoidea have a direct development. The divisions of the best studied species, Turbanella cornuta, is total, equal and bilateral. The cell-lineage produces a 30-cell stage in which gastrulation by invagination of two entoderm cells followed by mesodermal cells occurs. Two compact mesodermal strands segregate the germ cells and give rise to the muscular system and the y-organ. Agreements in the embryology of the gastrotrichs and the nematodes support the postulation of a close relationship between them.     

Regional specification during embryogenesis in the craniiform brachiopod Crania anomala

A fate map has been constructed for the embryo of Crania. The animal half of the egg forms the ectodermal epithelium of the larva's apical lobe. The vegetal half of the egg forms endoderm, mesoderm, and the ectoderm of the mantle lobe. The vegetal pole is the site of gastrulation; this site becomes the posterior ventral region of the mantle lobe of the larva. The plane of the first cleavage goes through the animal-vegetal axis of the egg; it bears no relationship to the future plane of bilateral symmetry of the larva. The timing of regional specification was examined by isolating animal, vegetal, or meridional halves from oocytes, eggs, or embryos from prior to germinal vesicle breakdown through gastrulation. Animal halves isolated from oocytes formed either the epithelium of the apical lobe or a larva with all three germ layers. Animal halves isolated from unfertilized eggs and eight-cell embryos formed only apical lobe epithelium. Beginning at the blastula stage, animal halves formed mantle in addition to apical lobe epithelium. In animal halves isolated after gastrulation, the mantle lobe was always truncated. Vegetal halves isolated at all stages prior to gastrulation gastrulated and formed apical and mantle lobes with endoderm and mesoderm; however, the relative size of the apical lobe that formed decreased substantially when vegetal halves were isolated at later developmental stages. When meridional halves were isolated from unfertilized eggs and two- to four-cell embryos, both halves frequently formed normally proportioned larvae. Beginning at the blastula stage, a number of pairs frequently had a member that lacked dorsal setae on its mantle lobe while the other member of the pair formed setae, indicating that the dorsoventral axis had been set up. The process of regional specification in Crania is compared to those of Discinisca and Glottidia in the brachiopod subphylum Linguliformea and Phoronis in the phylum Phoronida.     

Pattern of cell proliferation in embryogenesis and planula development ofHydractinia echinata predicts the postmetamorphic body pattern

Summary During embryogenesis and planula development of the colonial hydroidHydractinia echinata cell proliferation decreases in a distinct spatio-temporal pattern. Arrest in S-phase activity appears first in cells localized at the posterior and then subsequently at the anterior pole of the elongating embryo. These areas do not resume S-phase activity, even during the metamorphosis of the planula larva into the primary polyp. Tissue containing the quiescent cells gives rise to the terminal structures of the polyp. The posterior area of the larva becomes the hypostome and tentacles, while the anterior part of the larva develops into the basal plate and stolon tips. In mature planulae only a very few cells continue to proliferate. These cells are found in the middle part of the larva. Labelling experiments indicate that the prospective material of the postmetamorphic tentacles and stolon tips originates from cells which have exited from the cell cycle in embryogenesis or early in planula development. Precursor cells of the nematocytes which appear in the tentacles of the polyp following metamorphosis appear to have ceased cycling before the 38th hour of embryonic development. The vast majority of the cells that constitute the stolon tips of the primary polyp leave the cell cycle not later than 58 h after the beginning of development. We also report the identification of a cell type which differentiates in the polyp without passing through a post-metamorphic S-phase. The cell type appears to be neural in origin, based upon the identification of a neuropeptide of the FMRFamide type.     

Generation of the germ layers along the animal-vegetal axis in Xenopus laevis

After completion of gastrulation, typical vertebrate embryos consist of three cell sheets, called germ layers. The outer layer, the ectoderm, which produces the cells of the epidermis and the nervous system; the inner layer, the endoderm, producing the lining of the digestive tube and its associated organs (pancreas, liver, lungs etc.) and the middle layer, the mesoderm, which gives rise to several organs (heart, kidney, gonads), connective tissues (bone, muscles, tendons, blood vessels), and blood cells. The formation of the germ layers is one of the earliest embryonic events to subdivide multicellular embryos into a few compartments. In Xenopus laevis, the spatial domains of three germ layers are largely separated along the animal-vegetal axis even before gastrulation; ectoderm in the animal pole region; mesoderm in the equatorial region and endoderm in the vegetal pole region. In this review, we summarise the recent advances in our understanding of the formation of the germ layers in Xenopus laevis.     

Larval morphology of the Nemertean Carcinonemertes epialti (Nemertea: Hoplonemertea)

The morphology of the newly hatched larva of Carcinonemertes epialti Coe has been examined by light and electron microscopy. The newly hatched larva is covered with cilia and measures about 110 μm in length. Four types of epidermal cells are recognizable: (1) Multiciliated cells, (2) vacuolated cells, (3) mucous cells, and (4) “knob cells”. The knob cells protrude from the posterior end of the larva and contain granules and bundles of microfilaments. The gut is incomplete and is located ventral to the bipartite proboscis. A bilobed brain and two subepidermal ocelli are found in the anterior end of the larva. The anterior and posterior cirri are composed of long, tightly appressed cilia that arise from an invagination of the epidermis at each end of the larva. The anterior cirrus is surrounded by two types of glandular cells. It is proposed that the knob cells have a role in larval attachment, combining the functions of the adhesive cells and anchor cells described in the duo-gland system of turbellarians. The cirri are believed to be larval sensory structures that function in substrate selection. Histological and ultrastructural observations suggest that the larvae of Carcinonemertes are relatively long lived and develop into juveniles without a drastic metamorphosis.     

Primary Invagination of the Vegetal Plate During Sea Urchin Gastrulation

The initial phase of echinoid gastrulation, primary invagination,involves an inpocketing of a monolayered epithelium. To gaininformation about the nature of the mechanical forces that areresponsible for primary invagination, several experimental approacheshave been taken, using the transparent embryos of the sea urchin,Lytechinus pictus, as the principal material. Vegetal platesisolated microsurgically well before the onset of gastrulationwill invaginate normally, demonstrating that the forces responsiblefor primary invagination are generated by the cells in the vegetal to of the embryo. As shown by serial reconstructions of L.pictus embryos, relatively few cells (about 100) take part inprimary invagination. Both the number of cells and the totalvolume of tissue in the wall of the archenteron increase withtime. Even so, it can be shown that very little movement ofcells over the lip of the blastopore takes place during primaryinvagination, and this process is best viewed as a simple inpocketingof the vegetal epithelium. The cells in the wall of the archenteronhave a distinctive shape; they are elongated along their apico-basalaxes and frequently have enlarged, rounded, basal ends. However,they do not undergo any dramatic changes in shape during primaryinvagination. In particular, there is only a slight decreasein the height of the cells (length along the apico-basal axis),a result that is inconsistent with the hypothesis that invaginationis due to cell rounding (Gustafson and Wolpert, 1967). Examinationof L. pictus and Strongylocentrotus purpuratus gastrulae bytransmission electron microscopy reveals that cells in the wallof the archenteron continue to be joined by typical junctionalcomplexes during primary invagination. In addition, the morphologyof the junctional complex at the gastrula stage is more elaboratethan previously described. Sparse bands of micronlaments areassociated with the plasma membrane at the level of the junctionalcomplexes in both endodermal and ectodermal cells. These andother relevant data on early echinoid gastrulation are discussedin relation to several possible mechanisms of epithelial morphogenesis.