Conserved form and function of the germinal epithelium through 500 million years of vertebrate evolution

The germinal epithelium, i.e., the site of germ cell production in males and females, has maintained a constant form and function throughout 500 million years of vertebrate evolution. The distinguishing characteristic of germinal epithelia among all vertebrates, males, and females, is the presence of germ cells among somatic epithelial cells. The somatic epithelial cells, Sertoli cells in males or follicle (granulosa) cells in females, encompass and isolate germ cells. Morphology of all vertebrate germinal epithelia conforms to the standard definition of an epithelium: epithelial cells are interconnected, border a body surface or lumen, are avascular and are supported by a basement membrane. Variation in morphology of gonads, which develop from the germinal epithelium, is correlated with the evolution of reproductive modes. In hagfishes, lampreys, and elasmobranchs, the germinal epithelia of males produce spermatocysts. A major rearrangement of testis morphology diagnoses osteichthyans: the spermatocysts are arranged in tubules or lobules. In protogynous (female to male) sex reversal in teleost fishes, female germinal epithelial cells (prefollicle cells) and oogonia transform into the first male somatic cells (Sertoli cells) and spermatogonia in the developing testis lobules. This common origin of cell types from the germinal epithelium in fishes with protogynous sex reversal supports the homology of Sertoli cells and follicle cells. Spermatogenesis in amphibians develops within spermatocysts in testis lobules. In amniotes vertebrates, the testis is composed of seminiferous tubules wherein spermatogenesis occurs radially. Emerging research indicates that some mammals do not have lifetime determinate fecundity. The fact emerged that germinal epithelia occur in the gonads of all vertebrates examined herein of both sexes and has the same form and function across all vertebrate taxa. Continued study of the form and function of the germinal epithelium in vertebrates will increasingly clarify our understanding of vertebrate reproduction. J. Morphol. 277:1014–1044, 2016. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Germ cells are not the primary factor for sexual fate determination in goldfish

The presence of germ cells in the early gonad is important for sexual fate determination and gonadal development in vertebrates. Recent studies in zebrafish and medaka have shown that a lack of germ cells in the early gonad induces sex reversal in favor of a male phenotype. However, it is uncertain whether the gonadal somatic cells or the germ cells are predominant in determining gonadal fate in other vertebrate. Here, we investigated the role of germ cells in gonadal differentiation in goldfish, a gonochoristic species that possesses an XX-XY genetic sex determination system. The primordial germ cells (PGCs) of the fish were eliminated during embryogenesis by injection of a morpholino oligonucleotide against the dead end gene. Fish without germ cells showed two types of gonadal morphology: one with an ovarian cavity; the other with seminiferous tubules. Next, we tested whether function could be restored to these empty gonads by transplantation of a single PGC into each embryo, and also determined the gonadal sex of the resulting germline chimeras. Transplantation of a single GFP-labeled PGC successfully produced a germline chimera in 42.7% of the embryos. Some of the adult germline chimeras had a developed gonad on one side that contained donor derived germ cells, while the contralateral gonad lacked any early germ cell stages. Female germline chimeras possessed a normal ovary and a germ-cell free ovary-like structure on the contralateral side; this structure was similar to those seen in female morphants. Male germline chimeras possessed a testis and a contralateral empty testis that contained some sperm in the tubular lumens. Analysis of aromatase, foxl2 and amh expression in gonads of morphants and germline chimeras suggested that somatic transdifferentiation did not occur. The offspring of fertile germline chimeras all had the donor-derived phenotype, indicating that germline replacement had occurred and that the transplanted PGC had rescued both female and male gonadal function. These findings suggest that the absence of germ cells did not affect the pathway for ovary or testis development and that phenotypic sex in goldfish is determined by somatic cells under genetic sex control rather than an interaction between the germ cells and somatic cells.     

Testicular structure and spawning cycle in the silvery croaker, <Emphasis Type="Italic">Otolithes ruber</Emphasis> (Perciformes: Sciaenidae) in the Kuwaiti waters of the Arabian Gulf

The structure of the testes and maturity stages in the male silvery croaker, Otolithes ruber were investigated from March 1999 to March 2000. Based on the location of spermatogonia within the germinal epithelium, the testis structure is classified as the unrestricted spermatogonial testicular type. Germ cells proliferate through mitotic divisions of spermatogonia, giving rise to primary and secondary spermatocytes, which through meiotic divisions transform into spermatids. As spermatogenesis progresses, an elongation of the testicular lobules takes place. During final spermiogenesis, spermatids are arranged in clusters, with heads in one direction and tails in the opposite. Spermatozoa are then liberated from these structures into the lobula lumina. The testicular lobules further elongate, and many of them form a continuum within the germinal epithelium, extending toward the periphery. The walls of the other lobules fuse, producing anastomosing sperm-filled lobular compartments. A main sperm duct is formed into which spermatozoa from the lobules are voided. A time lapse between sexual maturity and onset of spawning was observed, thus supporting the existing view that the anastomosing compartments are used for sperm storage during the latter part of the maturation process. Six maturity stages of the testis are delineated during the annual reproductive cycle based on macroscopic and histological characteristics. Results show that male O. ruber spawns from March through April in Kuwaiti waters.     

Involvement of the gonadal germinal epithelium during sex reversal and seasonal testicular cycling in the protogynous swamp eel,Synbranchus marmoratus Bloch 1795 (Teleostei,Synbranchidae)

The swamp eel, Synbranchus marmoratus, is a protogynous, diandric species. During sex reversal, the ovarian germinal epithelium, which forms follicles containing an oocyte and encompassing follicle cells during the female portion of the life cycle, produces numerous invaginations, or acini, into the ovarian stroma. Within the acini, the gonia that formerly produced oocytes become spermatogonia, enter meiosis, and produce sperm. The acini are bounded by the basement membrane of the germinal epithelium. Epithelial cells of the female germinal epithelium, which formerly became follicle (granulosa) cells, now become Sertoli cells in the developing testis. Subsequently, lobules and testicular ducts form. The swamp eel testis has a lobular germinal compartment in both primary and secondary males, although the germinal compartment in testes of secondary males resides within the former ovarian lamellae. The germinal compartment, supported by a basement membrane, is composed of Sertoli and germ cells that give rise to sperm. Histological and immunohistochemical techniques were used to describe the five reproductive classes that were observed to occur during the annual reproductive cycle: regressed, early maturation, mid-maturation, late maturation, and regression. These classes are differentiated by the presence of continuous or discontinuous germinal epithelia and by the types of germ cells present. Synbranchus marmoratus has a permanent germinal epithelium. Differences between the germinal compartment of the testes of primary and secondary males were not observed.     

An overview of cell renewal in the testis throughout the reproductive cycle of a seasonal breeding teleost, the gilthead seabream (Sparus aurata L)

The gilthead seabream is a protandrous hermaphrodite seasonal breeding teleost with a bisexual gonad that offers an interesting model for studying the testicular regression process that occurs in both seasonal testicular involution and sex change. Insofar as fish reproduction is concerned, little is known about cell renewal and elimination during the reproductive cycle of seasonal breeding teleosts with asynchronous spermatogenesis. We have previously described how acidophilic granulocytes infiltrate the testis during postspawning where, surprisingly, they produce interleukin-1beta, a known growth factor for mammalian spermatogonia, rather than being directly involved in the elimination of degenerative germ cells. In this study, we are able to discriminate between spermatogonia stem cells and primary spermatogonia according to their nuclear and cytoplasmic diameters and location in the germinal epithelium, finding that these two cell types, together with Sertoli cells, proliferate throughout the reproductive cycle with a rate that depends on the reproductive stage. Thus, during spermatogenesis the spermatogonia stem cells, the Sertoli cells, and the developing germ cells (primary spermatogonia, A and B spermatogonia, and spermatocytes) in the germinal compartment, and cells with fibroblast-shaped nuclei in the interstitial tissue proliferate. However, during spawning, the testis shows few proliferating cells. During postspawning, the resumption of proliferation, the occurrence of apoptotic spermatogonia, and the phagocytosis of nonshed spermatozoa by Sertoli cells lead to a reorganization of both the germinal compartment and the interstitial tissue. Finally, the proliferation of spermatogonia increases during resting when, unexpectedly, both oogonia and oocytes also proliferate. This proliferative pattern was correlated with the gonadosomatic index, testicular morphology, and testicular and gonad areas, suggesting that complex mechanisms operate in the regulation of gonocyte proliferation in hermaphrodite fish.     

Meiotic germ cells antagonize mesonephric cell migration and testis cord formation in mouse gonads

The developmental fate of primordial germ cells in the mammalian gonad depends on their environment. In the XY gonad, Sry induces a cascade of molecular and cellular events leading to the organization of testis cords. Germ cells are sequestered inside testis cords by 12.5 dpc where they arrest in mitosis. If the testis pathway is not initiated, germ cells spontaneously enter meiosis by 13.5 dpc, and the gonad follows the ovarian fate. We have previously shown that some testis-specific events, such as mesonephric cell migration, can be experimentally induced into XX gonads prior to 12.5 dpc. However, after that time, XX gonads are resistant to the induction of cell migration. In current experiments, we provide evidence that this effect is dependent on XX germ cells rather than on XX somatic cells. We show that, although mesonephric cell migration cannot be induced into normal XX gonads at 14.5 dpc, it can be induced into XX gonads depleted of germ cells. We also show that when 14.5 dpc XX somatic cells are recombined with XY somatic cells, testis cord structures form normally; however, when XX germ cells are recombined with XY somatic cells, cord structures are disrupted. Sandwich culture experiments suggest that the inhibitory effect of XX germ cells is mediated through short-range interactions rather than through a long-range diffusible factor. The developmental stage at which XX germ cells show a disruptive effect on the male pathway is the stage at which meiosis is normally initiated, based on the immunodetection of meiotic markers. We suggest that at the stage when germ cells commit to meiosis, they reinforce ovarian fate by antagonizing the testis pathway.     

Testis structure and symplastic spermatid formation during spermatogenesis of pipefishes

The pipefishes Syngnathus abaster and S. acus have paired testes of atypical organization. Each testis is a hollow tube consisting of a single germinal compartment of the tubular type. During the reproductive period, the germinal epithelium consists of small spermatocysts containing spermatogonia or primary spermatocytes. Cysts of older germ cells, such as secondary spermatocytes and spermatids were never observed. Developing symplastic spermatids were found in the lumen of the tubule together with mature sperm and large droplet-containing cells. Most of the spermatids were giant cells with four nuclei at the same developmental stage. Symplastic spermatids, which presumably form by nuclear division not followed by cytokinesis, are a stage of spermatogenesis in pipefishes.     

Ultrastructure of the early ovary and testis in pig embryos.

Pig embryos aged 26-27 days were used for an ultrastructural study of the early ovary and testis. Sex was identified by both chromosomal analysis and gonadal histology, with consistent results. The gonads occupied their original site in the medial coelomic angles in both sexes. The female gonad was composed of three tissues: the surface epithelium, the gonadal blastema and the mesenchyme. The gonadal structure was similar to that seen earlier at the age of 24 days. At 26 days the testis had distinctly differentiated into four tissues. The new components were the testicular cords and the interstitium, both derived from the gonadal blastema. The testicular cords resembled anastomosing sheets more than cords. The ultrastructure of the tissues and their cell types are described and compared to the previous indifferent stage at the age of 24 days. The cells of the surface epithelium, of the primitive cords, of the mesenchyme, and the primordial germ cells had an ultrastructure that was similar in both sexes. The sustentacular cells of the testicular cords resembled the primitive cord cells and the spermatogonia were similar to the primordial germ cells. No Leydig cells were present yet. The process of testicular differentiation is described on the basis of the present and a previous study, and a new hypothesis, based on the vascular organization, is presented.     

Development of the germinal epithelium and early folliculogenesis during ovarian morphogenesis in the cichlid fish Cichlasoma dimerus (Teleostei,Perciformes)

Formation of the germinal epithelium and folliculogenesis during ovarian development in Cichlasoma dimerus were described at the light‐ and electron‐microscopic levels. Prior to gonadal differentiation, germ cells and enveloping support cells reside within an inpocketing of the coelomic epithelium. Separation of the germinal and interstitial compartments of the gonad by a basement membrane is apparent from early gonadal development. Upon ovarian differentiation, oogonia undergo cyst‐forming divisions leading to the formation of clusters of interconnected cystocytes that synchronously enter meiosis, becoming oocytes. At the pachytene step, each oocyte becomes individualized by cytoplasmic extensions of prefollicle cells, thereby developing as an ovarian follicle. Subsequent somatic reorganization leads to the formation of the ovarian lumen in a cephalo‐caudal gradient. As a result, the germinal epithelium becomes internalized and lines the ovarian lumen. As defined by its origin from the germinal epithelium, the ovarian follicle is composed of an oocyte and the surrounding follicle cells. Thecal cells derived from the stroma encompass the basement membrane outside the follicle, thus forming a follicle complex. A common basement membrane is shared by the germinal epithelium and the follicle complex along a small portion of its surface. This point of attachment represents the site at which the oocyte would be released to the ovarian lumen during ovulation.     

Sex-specific apoptosis regulates sexual dimorphism in the Drosophila embryonic gonad

Sexually dimorphic development of the gonad is essential for germ cell development and sexual reproduction. We have found that the Drosophila embryonic gonad is already sexually dimorphic at the time of initial gonad formation. Male-specific somatic gonadal precursors (msSGPs) contribute only to the testis and express a Drosophila homolog of Sox9 (Sox100B), a gene essential for testis formation in humans. The msSGPs are specified in both males and females, but are only recruited into the developing testis. In females, these cells are eliminated via programmed cell death dependent on the sex determination regulatory gene doublesex. Our work furthers the hypotheses that a conserved pathway controls gonad sexual dimorphism in diverse species and that sex-specific cell recruitment and programmed cell death are common mechanisms for creating sexual dimorphism.     

Cultivation in vitro of the testis cord of the newt, Triturus pyrrhogaster

Testis cords of Triturus pyrrhogaster were cultivated in vitro on (a) medium with chick embryo extract and calf serum, (b) medium with newt gonad extract, (c) Trowell 's medium T8 and (d) liquid synthetic medium 199. Of the four media utilized, medium 199 gave the best result for long-term maintenance of the normal histological structures of the testis cords. Addition of insulin (5 μ/ml) to medium 199 resulted in a remarkable improvement for the maintenance of the testis cord and the migration of columnar cells of the peritoneal epithelium into the primordial germinal tissue occurred as in the intact testis of this animal. Trowell 's medium T8 was proved inadequate. Medium with chick embryo extract and calf serum retained most of the germ cells healthy but caused gradual decrease in height of the columnar cells. Testis cords cultivated on the same medium in combination with Xenopus testis maintained normal histological structure for 18 days, whereas, those kept in contact with Xenopus ovary showed involution within the same period. Newt testis extract brought about transformation of somatic elements of the germinal tissue into fibroblastlike cells which was followed by the disintegration of germ cells. Ovary extract did not cause selective destruction on the somatic or germinal elements.     

Involvement of vasa homolog in germline recruitment from coelomic stem cells in budding tunicates

We investigated the mechanism by which germline cells are recruited in every asexual reproductive cycle of the budding tunicate Polyandrocarpa misakiensis using a vasa homolog (PmVas) as the germline-specific probe. A presumptive gonad of Polyandrocarpa arose as a loose cell aggregate in the ventral hemocoel of a 1-week-old developing zooid. It developed into a compact clump of cells and then separated into two lobes, each differentiating into the ovary and the testis. The ovarian tube that was formed at the bottom of the ovary embedded the oogonia and juvenile oocytes, forming the germinal epithelium. PmVas was expressed strongly by loose cell aggregates, compact clumps, and peripheral germ cells in the testis and germinal epithelium. No signals were detected in growing buds and less than 1-week-old zooids, indicating that germ cells arise de novo in developing zooids of P. misakiensis. Cells of the loose cell aggregates were 5–6 μm in diameter. They looked like undifferentiated hemoblasts in the hemocoel. To examine the involvement of PmVas in the germline recruitment at postembryonic stages, both growing buds and 1-week-old developing zooids were soaked with double-stranded PmVas RNA. The growing buds developed into fertile zooids expressing PmVas, whereas the 1-week-old zooids developed into sterile zooids that did not express PmVas. In controls (1-week-old zooids) soaked with double-stranded lacZ RNA, the gonad developed normally. These results strongly suggest that in P. misakiensis, PmVas plays a decisive role in switching from coelomic stem cells to germ cells.     

The interstitial origin of germinal cells in the testis of the stickleback

The brook stickleback, Culaea inconstans (Kirtland), in common with other bony fishes, lacks a germinal epithelium in the tubules of the testis, and the tubule wall is composed of a thin, discontinuous layer of myoid cells and collagenous fibers. Labelling of germ cells with tritiated thymidine has shown that the germ cells are derived from clumps of spermatogonia in the interstitial area. Large companion cells within the lumina of the tubules extend their processes to engulf spermatogonia from the interstitium which then enter the lumen of the tubule. Subsequent development of the germ cells takes place within individual compartments formed by folds of the plasma membrane of a companion cell. The companion cell, together with its complement of germ cells, constitutes a cyst. A companion cell may surround spermatogonia in the interstitium and at the same time encompass residual sperm of the previous season within the lumen. The plasma membranes of the germ cells and the companion cells remain discrete. Mature sperm are released into the lumen of the tubule and the companion cell again extends its processes into the interstitium and engulfs more spermatogonia for the following year. Companion cells may be homologous to the Sertoli cells of higher vertebrates although their processes penetrate the interstitium during the initial stages of spermatogenesis and they do not contain a permanent stock of spermatogonia.     

Derived sperm morphology in the interstitial sea cucumber Rhabdomolgus ruber,with observations on oogenesis and spawning behavior

Some life history features of the interstitial sea cucumber Rhabdomolgus ruber are described from intertidal specimens collected from the northern coast of Maine. Histological studies suggest that the population consists of hermaphrodites with gametogenesis being initiated in April and reproduction beginning in May and continuing through the summer months. Sexually mature adults possess a single, blind‐ended gonadal tubule that functions as an ovotestis by producing both eggs and sperm. The ovotestis wall consists of an outer peritoneum composed of flagellated epithelial cells and muscles; an inner germinal epithelium of germ and somatic cells; and a middle connective tissue (hemal) compartment bounded by the basal laminas of the peritoneum and germinal epithelium. During the reproductive season, the gonadal tubule contains all stages of oocyte development. Vitellogenesis appears to involve the biosynthetic activities of the Golgi complex and rough endoplasmic reticulum. A few specimens had transitional ovotestes with mature sperm in the gonad lumen and asynchronously developing oocytes and a small number of spermatocytes within the germinal epithelium. The mature spermatozoon is an ent‐aquasperm with ultrastructural features significantly different from those described from other echinoderm classes including a highly elongated acrosome, a large periacrosomal region between the acrosome and nucleus, numerous unfused mitochondria in the midpiece, and a cytoplasmic sleeve or collar extending posteriorly along the proximal portion of the flagellum. The sperm head reaches 11.5 μm in length (combined midpiece, nucleus, periacrosomal region, acrosome), making it the longest yet reported from the Holothuroidea and among the longest in the Echinodermata. Some elements of this derived morphology could be attributed to fertilization biology, but others may have phylogenetic significance. Spawning behavior was observed in which two individuals appeared to pseudocopulate by intertwining their oral tentacles for several minutes before one of them abruptly secreted an egg mass containing three eggs.     

Ontogenetic testicular development and spermatogenesis in rays: the Cownose Ray,Rhinoptera bonasus,as a model

An understanding of testicular anatomy, development, and seasonality has implications for studies of morphology, behavior, physiology, and bioenergetics of males. Ontogenetic testicular development and spermatogenesis is essentially unknown for chondrichthyans. We examined embryo, juvenile, and adult male Cownose Rays (Rhinoptera bonasus) during development and throughout the annual reproductive cycle. Spermatogonia and Sertoli cells originated from germ cells and somatic cells, respectively, in the embryonic testicular germinal epithelium. In embryos and small juveniles, discrete regions of spermatocyst production appeared within a series of papillae that projected from the dorsal surface of each testis. Because these papillary germinal zones appeared to proliferate through ontogeny, we hypothesize that (1) the germinal zones of juvenile and adult testes are derived from embryonic testicular papillae that form from the germinal epithelium and (2) the papillae become the dorso-central portion of the distinct testicular lobes that form at maturation due to increased spermatocyst production. Our observations indicate that testicular development and the process of spermatogenesis began during embryonic development and increased in scale through ontogeny until maturation, when distinct testicular lobes formed and began enlarging or shrinking based on the annual reproductive cycle. Gonadosomatic indices peaked corresponding to seasonal increased sperm production between January and April, just prior to the April–June mating period. In all life stages, spermatocysts had efferent ducts associated with them from their formation through all stages of development. Year-round presence in the Charlotte Harbor estuarine system, Florida made R. bonasus a good model for beginning to understand ontogenetic gonad development and spermatogenesis in chondrichthyans, especially viviparous rays.