Rescue of Xrcc1 knockout mouse embryo lethality by transgene-complementation

Xrcc1 knockout embryos show increased DNA breakage and apoptosis in tissues of the embryo proper prior to death at embryonic day E6.5. An additional deficiency in Trp53 allows Xrcc1(-/-) embryos to enlarge slightly and initiate gastrulation although ultimately death is delayed by less than 24h. Death presumably results from DNA damage that reaches toxic levels in the post-implantation mouse embryo. To investigate the level of XRCC1 protein needed for successful mouse development, we derived Xrcc1 transgene-complemented Xrcc1(-/-) mice that express Xrcc1 within the normal range or at a greatly reduced level (<10% normal). The greatly reduced XRCC1 protein level destabilized the XRCC1 partner protein DNA ligase III (LIG3) but still allowed for successful mouse development and healthy, fertile adults. Fibroblasts from these animals exhibited almost normal alkylation sensitivity measured by differential cytotoxicity. Thus, a large reduction of both XRCC1 and DNA ligase III has no observable effect on mouse embryogenesis and post-natal development, and no significant effect on cellular sensitivity to DNA alkylation. The presence of XRCC1, even at reduced levels of expression, is therefore capable of supporting mouse development and DNA repair.     

A role for Xrcc2 in the early stages of mouse development

Xrcc2 is one of a family of five Rad51-like genes with important roles in the repair of DNA damage by homologous recombination (HR) in mammals. We have shown previously that loss of Xrcc2 in mice results in severe but variable developmental defects and embryonic lethality, potentially linked to excessive apoptosis. To look at the causes of lethality, and possibly to allow Xrcc2-/- mice to survive to birth, we have produced double knockout mice deficient in either the p53 oncoprotein or Ataxia telangiectasia mutated (Atm). Overall we show that the excessive apoptosis observed in Xrcc2-/- embryos is p53-dependent, and that loss of p53 can restore growth capacity to Xrcc2-/- fibroblasts in culture, but that it cannot rescue the embryonic lethality. Additionally, although the Xrcc2-/- Trp53-/- embryos show a near-normal morphology they remain relatively small in size. Loss of Atm in an Xrcc2-/- embryo has little effect, suggesting that response to loss of HR capacity is not mediated through the Atm kinase in the early stages of mouse development. Further, as seen by reduced expression of the early developmental marker, Delta-like1, the normal developmental programme is perturbed in Xrcc2-/- embryonic tissues, particularly during neurogenesis and somitogenesis. Taken together our data suggest that the accumulation of spontaneous damage in HR-deficient embryos has severe consequences for the development and survival of mammals due to the unregulated loss of cells important to the developmental programme.     

Xrcc2 is required for genetic stability, embryonic neurogenesis and viability in mice

Repair of DNA damage by homologous recombination has only recently been established as an important mechanism in maintaining genetic stability in mammalian cells. The recently cloned Xrcc2 gene is a member of the mammalian Rad51 gene family, thought to be central to homologous recombination repair. To understand its function in mammals, we have disrupted Xrcc2 in mice. No Xrcc2(-/-) animals were found alive, with embryonic lethality occurring from mid-gestation. Xrcc2(-/-) embryos surviving until later stages of embryogenesis commonly showed developmental abnormalities and died at birth. Neonatal lethality, apparently due to respiratory failure, was associated with a high frequency of apoptotic death of post- mitotic neurons in the developing brain, leading to abnormal cortical structure. Embryonic cells showed genetic instability, revealed by a high level of chromosomal aberrations, and were sensitive to gamma-rays. Our findings demonstrate that homologous recombination has an important role in endogenous damage repair in the developing embryo. Xrcc2 disruption identifies a range of defects that arise from malfunction of this repair pathway, and establishes a previously unidentified role for homologous recombination repair in correct neuronal development.     

Midgestation lethality in mice deficient for the RecA-related gene, Rad51d/Rad51l3

Homologous recombination (HR) occurs in all organisms, and is important for repair of DNA damage, chromosome segregation during meiosis, and genetic diversification. Genes critical for recombinational DNA repair and meiotic recombination include members of the RecA/RAD51 family, of which seven have been identified in mammals. Here, we describe the disruption of Rad51d (recently designated Rad51l3) in mice and its phenotypic consequences. Rad51d-deficient mice die between 8.5 and 11.5 dpc. The affected embryos are smaller than littermates, posteriorly truncated, and developmentally delayed. Embryonic fibroblasts from mutant embryos could not be propagated more than one generation in culture. Rad51d-deficient blastocysts were not sensitive to gamma radiation or methylmethanesulfonate (MMS) in blastocyst outgrowth experiments. The variable and generalized developmental progression defects in Rad51d-deficient embryos suggests that mutant cells may undergo delayed or suboptimal repair of DNA damage, resulting in accumulated degrees of mutation and/or cell cycle perturbation that are incompatible with normal embryonic development. genesis 26:167-173, 2000.     

Inactivation of Cdc7 kinase in mouse ES cells results in S-phase arrest and p53-dependent cell death

Cdc7-related kinases play essential roles in the initiation of yeast DNA replication. We show that mice lacking murine homologs of Cdc7 (muCdc7) genes die between E3.5 and E6.5. We have established a mutant embryonic stem (ES) cell line lacking the muCdc7 genes in the presence of a loxP-flanked transgene expressing muCdc7 cDNA. Upon removal of the transgene by Cre recombinase, mutant ES cells cease DNA synthesis, arresting growth with S-phase DNA content, and generate nuclear Rad51 foci, followed by cell death with concomitant increase in p53 protein levels. Inhibition of p53 leads to partial rescue of muCdc7(-/-) ES cells from cell death. muCdc7(-/-)p53(-/-) embryos survive up to E8.5, and their blastocysts generate inner cell mass of a significant size in vitro, whereas those of the muCdc7(-/-)p53(+/-) embryos undergoes complete degeneration. These results demonstrate that, in contrast to cell cycle arrest at the G(1)/S boundary observed in yeasts, loss of Cdc7 in ES cells results in rapid cessation of DNA synthesis within S phase, triggering checkpoint responses leading to recombinational repair and p53-dependent cell death.     

The vav proto-oncogene is required early in embryogenesis but not for hematopoietic development in vitro.

Previous studies have suggested that the vav protooncogene plays an important role in hematopoiesis. To study this further, we have ablated the vav protooncogene by homologous recombination in embryonic stem (ES) cells. Homozygous vav (-/-) ES clones differentiate normally in culture and generate cells of erythroid, myeloid and mast cell lineages. Mice heterozygous for the targeted vav allele do not display any obvious abnormalities. However, homozygous embryos die very early during development. Crosses of vav (+/-) heterozygous mice yield apparently normal vav (-/-) E3.5 embryos but not post-implantation embryos (> or = E7.5). Furthermore, homozygous vav (-/-) blastocysts do not hatch in vitro. These results indicate that vav is essential for an early developmental step(s) that precedes the onset of hematopoiesis. Consistent with the phenotypic analysis of vav (-/-) embryos, we have identified Vav immunoreactivity in the extra-embryonic trophoblastic cell layer but not in the inner embryonic cell mass of E3.5 preimplantation embryos or in the egg cylinder of E6.5 and E7.5 post-implantation embryos. These results suggest that the vav gene is essential for normal trophoblast development and for implantation of the developing embryo.     

The novel surveillance mechanism of the Trp53-dependent s-phase checkpoint ensures chromosome damage repair and preimplantation-stage development of mouse embryos fertilized with x-irradiated sperm

Cell cycle checkpoints and apoptosis function as surveillance mechanisms in somatic tissues. However, some of these mechanisms are lacking or are restricted during the preimplantation stage. Previously, we reported the presence of a novel Trp53-dependent S-phase checkpoint that suppresses pronuclear DNA synthesis in mouse zygotes fertilized with X-irradiated sperm (sperm-irradiated zygotes) (Shimura et al., Mol. Cell. Biol. 22, 2220-2228, 2002). Here we studied the role of the Trp53-dependent S-phase checkpoint in the early stage of development of sperm-irradiated zygotes. In the Trp53(+/+) genetic background, all of the sperm-irradiated zygotes cleaved successfully to the two-cell stage despite the fact that half of them carried a sub-2N amount of DNA. These zygotes progressed normally to the eight-cell stage and then implanted, but the subsequent fetal development was suppressed in a dose-dependent manner. In contrast, sperm-irradiated Trp53(-/-) embryos lacking an S-phase checkpoint exhibited an abnormal segregation of chromosomes at the first cleavage, even though they carried an apparently normal 2N amount of DNA. They were morphologically abnormal with numerous micronuclei, and they degenerated before reaching the eight-cell stage. As a consequence, no implants were observed for sperm-irradiated Trp53(-/-) embryos. These results suggest that the Trp53-dependent S-phase checkpoint is a surveillance mechanism involved in the repair of chromosome damage and ensures the preimplantation-stage development of sperm-irradiated embryos.     

Mutations in the Trp53 gene of UV-irradiated Xpc mutant mice suggest a novel Xpc-dependent DNA repair process

Mutational hot spots in the human p53 gene are well established in tumors in the human population and are frequently negative prognosticators of the clinical outcome. We previously developed a mouse model of skin cancer with mutations in the xeroderma pigmentosum group C gene (Xpc). UVB radiation-induced skin cancer is significantly enhanced in these mice when they also carry a mutation in one copy of the Trp53 gene (Xpc-/-Trp53+/-). Skin tumors in these mice often contain inactivating mutations in the remaining Trp53 allele and we have previously reported a novel mutational hot spot at a non-dipyrimidine site (ACG) in codon 122 of the Trp53 gene in the tumors. Here we show that this mutation is not a hot spot in Xpa or Csa mutant mice. Furthermore, the mutation in codon T122 can be identified in mouse skin DNA from (Xpc-/-Trp53+/-) mice as early as 2 weeks after exposure to UVB radiation, well before histological evidence of dysplastic or neoplastic changes. Since this mutational hot spot is not at a dipyrimidine site and is apparently Xpc-specific, we suggest that some form of non-dipyrimidine base damage is normally repaired in a manner that is distinct from conventional nucleotide excision repair, but that requires XPC protein.     

Defective nucleotide excision repair in xpc mutant mice and its association with cancer predisposition

Mice that are genetically engineered are becoming increasingly more powerful tools for understanding the molecular pathology of many human hereditary diseases, especially those that confer an increased predisposition to cancer. We have generated mouse strains defective in the Xpc gene, which is required for nucleotide excision repair (NER) of DNA. Homozygous mutant mice are highly prone to skin cancer following exposure to UVB radiation, and to liver and lung cancer following exposure to the chemical carcinogen acetylaminofluorene (AAF). Skin cancer predisposition is significantly augmented when mice are additionally defective in Trp53 (p53) gene function. We also present the results of studies with mice that are heterozygous mutant in the Apex (Hap1, Ref-1) gene required for base excision repair and with mice that are defective in the mismatch repair gene Msh2. Double and triple mutant mice mutated in multiple DNA repair genes have revealed several interesting overlapping roles of DNA repair pathways in the prevention of mutation and cancer.     

p53-Independent apoptosis disrupts early organogenesis in embryos lacking both ataxia-telangiectasia mutated and Prkdc

The ataxia-telangiectasia mutated (ATM) protein and the nonhomologous end-joining (NHEJ) pathway play crucial roles in sensing and repairing DNA double-strand breaks in postnatal cells. However, each pathway is dispensable for early embryogenesis. Loss of both ATM and Prkdc/Ku is synthetically lethal, but neither the developmental processes perturbed nor the mechanisms of lethality have been determined by previous reports. Here, we show that ATM and Prkdc collaborate to maintain genomic stability during gastrulation and early organogenesis, a period of rapid proliferation and hypersensitivity to DNA damage. At E7.5 to E8.5, ATM(-/-)Prkdcscid/scid embryos displayed normal proliferation indices but exhibited excessive apoptosis and elevated expression of Ser15-phosphorylated p53. Thus, this crucial regulatory residue of p53 can be phosphorylated in the absence of ATM or Prkdc. However, loss of p53 did not abrogate or delay embryonic lethality, revealing that apoptosis is p53 independent in these in ATM(-/-)Prkdcscid/scid embryos. Because mice with combined disruptions of ATM and other NHEJ components (ligase IV, Artemis) are viable, our data suggest a novel NHEJ-independent function for Prkdc/Ku that is required to complete early embryogenesis in the absence of ATM.     

Homologous recombination is necessary for normal lymphocyte development

Primary immunodeficiencies are rare but serious diseases with diverse genetic causes. Accumulating evidence suggests that defects in DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair can underlie many of these syndromes. In this context, the nonhomologous end joining pathway of DSB repair is absolutely required for lymphoid development, but possible roles for the homologous recombination (HR) pathway have remained more controversial. While recent evidence suggests that HR may indeed be important to suppress lymphoid transformation, the specific relationship of HR to normal lymphocyte development remains unclear. We have investigated roles of the X-ray cross-complementing 2 (Xrcc2) HR gene in lymphocyte development. We show that HR is critical for normal B-cell development, with Xrcc2 nullizygosity leading to p53-dependent early S-phase arrest. In the absence of p53 (encoded by Trp53), Xrcc2-null B cells can fully develop but show high rates of chromosome and chromatid fragmentation. We present a molecular model wherein Xrcc2 is important to preserve or restore replication forks during rapid clonal expansion of developing lymphocytes. Our findings demonstrate a key role for HR in lymphoid development and suggest that Xrcc2 defects could underlie some human primary immunodeficiencies.     

Decreased DNA repair efficiency by loss or disruption of p53 function preferentially affects removal of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers from non-transcribed strand and slow repair sites in transcribed strand

The tumor suppressor protein p53 plays a central role in modulating the cellular responses to DNA damage. Several recent studies, undertaken with the whole genomic DNA or full-length gene segments, have shown that p53 is involved in nucleotide excision repair and it selectively influences the adduct removal from the non-transcribed strand in the genome. In this study, we have analyzed the damage induction at nucleotide resolution by ligase-mediated polymerase chain reaction and compared the repair of ultraviolet radiation-induced cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers within exon 8 of p53 gene in normal and Li-Fraumeni syndrome fibroblasts as well as in normal and human papillomavirus 16 E6 and E7 protein-expressing human mammary epithelial cells. The results demonstrate that (i) loss or disruption of p53 function decreases efficiency of DNA repair, by preferentially affecting the repair of non-transcribed strand and of intrinsically slow repair sites in transcribed strand; (ii) mutant p53 protein affects DNA repair, at least of non-transcribed strand, in a dominant negative manner; and (iii) pRb does not have an effect on the repair of DNA damage within transcribed or non-transcribed strand. The overall data suggest that p53 could regulate excision repair or related events through direct protein-protein interaction.     

Mdm4 (Mdmx) regulates p53-induced growth arrest and neuronal cell death during early embryonic mouse development

We report here the characterization of a mutant mouse line with a specific gene trap event in the Mdm4 locus. Absence of Mdm4 expression results in embryonic lethality (10.5 days postcoitum [dpc]), which was rescued by transferring the Mdm4 mutation into a Trp53-null background. Mutant embryos were characterized by overall growth deficiency, anemia, improper neural tube closure, and dilation of lateral ventricles. In situ analysis demonstrated increased levels of p21(CIP1/Waf1) and lower levels of Cyclin E and proliferating cell nuclear antigen expression. Consistent with lack of 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine incorporation, these data suggest a block of mutant embryo cells in the G(1) phase of the cell cycle. Accordingly, Mdm4-deficient mouse embryonic fibroblasts manifested a greatly reduced proliferative capacity in culture. Moreover, extensive p53-dependent cell death was specifically detected in the developing central nervous system of the Mdm4 mutant embryos. These findings unambiguously assign a critical role for Mdm4 as a negative regulator of p53 and suggest that Mdm4 could contribute to neoplasias retaining wild-type Trp53. Finally, we provide evidence indicating that Mdm4 plays no role on cell proliferation or cell cycle control that is distinct from its ability to modulate p53 function.     

Mitochondrial DNA ligase III function is independent of Xrcc1

Hamster EM9 cells, which lack Xrcc1 protein, have reduced levels of DNA ligase III and are defective in nuclear base excision repair. The Xrcc1 protein stabilizes DNA ligase III and may even play a direct role in catalyzing base excision repair. Since DNA ligase III is also thought to function in mitochondrial base excision repair, it seemed likely that mitochondrial DNA ligase III function would also be dependent upon Xrcc1. However, several lines of evidence indicate that this is not the case. First, western blot analysis failed to detect Xrcc1 protein in mitochondrial extracts. Second, DNA ligase III levels present in mitochondrial protein extracts from EM9 cells were indistinguishable from those seen in similar extracts from wild-type (AA8) cells. Third, the mitochondrial DNA content of both cell lines was identical. Fourth, EM9 cells displayed no defect in their ability to repair spontaneous mitochondrial DNA damage. Fifth, while EM9 cells were far more sensitive to the cytotoxic effects of ionizing radiation due to a defect in nuclear DNA repair, there was no apparent difference in the ability of EM9 and AA8 cells to restore their mitochondrial DNA to pre-irradiation levels. Thus, mitochondrial DNA ligase III function is independent of the Xrcc1 protein.     

Neural tube development requires the cooperation of p53- and Gadd45a-associated pathways

BACKGROUND: Numerous genetically engineered mouse models for neural tube defects (NTDs) exist, and some of the implicated proteins are functionally related. For example, the growth arrest and DNA damage-inducible protein Gadd45a and tumor suppressor p53 are functionally similar, and both are involved in neural tube development (Gadd45a- and Trp53-null embryos show low levels of exencephaly). To assess their roles in neural tube development, we generated double-null mice from Gadd45a- and Trp53-null mice, as well as from cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor (Cdkn1a) (p21)-null and xeroderma pigmentosum group C (XPC)-null mice that do not show spontaneous exencephaly. METHODS: Gadd45a-, Trp53-, Cdkn1a-, and XPC-null mice were crossed to generate several double-null mouse models. Embryos (embryonic day [ED] 16-18) from the single- and double-null crosses were scored for NTDs. RESULTS: Deletion of both Gadd45a and Trp53 in mice increased exencephaly frequencies compared to the deletion of either single gene (34.0% in Gadd45a/Trp53-null compared to 8.4% and 9.1% in the Gadd45a- and Trp53-null embryos, respectively). Furthermore, although deletion of another p53-regulated gene, Cdkn1a, is not associated with exencephaly, in conjunction with Gadd45a deletion, the exencephaly frequencies are increased (30.5% in the Gadd45a/Cdkn1a-null embryos) and are similar to those in the Gadd45a/Trp53-null embryos. Although XPC deletion increased exencephaly frequencies in Trp53-null embryos, XPC deletion did not increase the exencephaly frequencies in Gadd45a-null embryos. CONCLUSIONS: The increased genetic liability to exencephaly in the Gadd45a/Trp53- and Gadd45a/Cdkn1a-null embryos may be related to the disruption of multiple cellular pathways associated with Gadd45a and p53.     

Early embryonic death in mice lacking the beta-catenin-binding protein Duplin

The Wnt signaling pathway plays a pivotal role in vertebrate early development and morphogenesis. Duplin (axis duplication inhibitor) interacts with beta-catenin and prevents its binding to Tcf, thereby inhibiting downstream Wnt signaling. Here we show that Duplin is expressed predominantly from early- to mid-stage mouse embryogenesis, and we describe the generation of mice deficient in Duplin. Duplin(-/-) embryos manifest growth retardation from embryonic day 5.5 (E5.5) and developmental arrest accompanied by massive apoptosis at E7.5. The mutant embryos develop into an egg cylinder but do not form a primitive streak or mesoderm. Expression of beta-catenin target genes, including those for T (brachyury), Axin2, and cyclin D1, was not increased in Duplin(-/-) embryos, suggesting that the developmental defect is not simply attributable to upregulation of Wnt signaling caused by the lack of this inhibitor. These results suggest that Duplin plays an indispensable role, likely by a mechanism independent of inhibition of Wnt signaling, in mouse embryonic growth and differentiation at an early developmental stage.     

Ser18 and 23 phosphorylation is required for p53-dependent apoptosis and tumor suppression

Mouse p53 is phosphorylated at Ser18 and Ser23 after DNA damage. To determine whether these two phosphorylation events have synergistic functions in activating p53 responses, we simultaneously introduced Ser18/23 to Ala mutations into the endogenous p53 locus in mice. While partial defects in apoptosis are observed in p53S18A and p53S23A thymocytes exposed to IR, p53-dependent apoptosis is essentially abolished in p53S18/23A thymocytes, indicating that these two events have critical and synergistic roles in activating p53-dependent apoptosis. In addition, p53S18/23A, but not p53S18A, could completely rescue embryonic lethality of Xrcc4(-/-) mice that is caused by massive p53-dependent neuronal apoptosis. However, certain p53-dependent functions, including G1/S checkpoint and cellular senescence, are partially retained in p53(S18/23A) cells. While p53(S18A) mice are not cancer prone, p53S18/23A mice developed a spectrum of malignancies distinct from p53S23A and p53(-/-) mice. Interestingly, Xrcc4(-/-)p53S18/23A mice fail to develop tumors like the pro-B cell lymphomas uniformly developed in Xrcc4(-/-) p53(-/-) animals, but exhibit developmental defects typical of accelerated ageing. Therefore, Ser18 and Ser23 phosphorylation is important for p53-dependent suppression of tumorigenesis in certain physiological context.