Effects of very low fluences of high-energy protons or iron ions on irradiated and bystander cells

In space, astronauts are exposed to radiation fields consisting of energetic protons and high atomic number, high-energy (HZE) particles at very low dose rates or fluences. Under these conditions, it is likely that, in addition to cells in an astronaut's body being traversed by ionizing radiation particles, unirradiated cells can also receive intercellular bystander signals from irradiated cells. Thus this study was designed to determine the dependence of DNA damage induction on dose at very low fluences of charged particles. Novel techniques to quantify particle fluence have been developed at the NASA Space Radiation Biology Laboratory (NSRL) at Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL). The approach uses a large ionization chamber to visualize the radiation beam coupled with a scintillation counter to measure fluence. This development has allowed us to irradiate cells with 1 GeV/nucleon protons and iron ions at particle fluences as low as 200 particles/cm(2) and quantify biological responses. Our results show an increased fraction of cells with DNA damage in both the irradiated population and bystander cells sharing medium with irradiated cells after low fluences. The fraction of cells with damage, manifest as micronucleus formation and 53BP1 focus induction, is about 2-fold higher than background at doses as low as ～0.47 mGy iron ions (～0.02 iron ions/cell) or ～70 μGy protons (～2 protons/cell). In the irradiated population, irrespective of radiation type, the fraction of damaged cells is constant from the lowest damaging fluence to about 1 cGy, above which the fraction of damaged cells increases with dose. In the bystander population, the level of damage is the same as in the irradiated population up to 1 cGy, but it does not increase above that plateau level with increasing dose. The data suggest that at fluences of high-energy protons or iron ions less than about 5 cGy, the response in irradiated cell populations may be dominated by the bystander response.     

The Cosmic Silence experiment: on the putative adaptive role of environmental ionizing radiation

Previously we reported that yeast and Chinese hamster V79 cells cultured under reduced levels of background environmental ionizing radiation show enhanced susceptibility to damage caused by acute doses of genotoxic agents. Reduction of environmental radiation dose rate was achieved by setting up an underground laboratory at Laboratori Nazionali del Gran Sasso, central Italy. We now report on the extension of our studies to a human cell line. Human lymphoblastoid TK6 cells were maintained under identical in vitro culture conditions for six continuous months, at different environmental ionizing radiation levels. Compared to “reference” environmental radiation conditions, we found that cells cultured in the underground laboratories were more sensitive to acute exposures to radiation, as measured both at the level of DNA damage and oxidative metabolism. Our results are compatible with the hypothesis that ultra-low dose rate ionizing radiation, i.e. environmental radiation, may act as a conditioning agent in the radiation-induced adaptive response.     

A model relating cell survival to DNA fragment loss and unrepaired double-strand breaks

The model of radiation action that is presented relates the surviving fraction of irradiated cells to unrepaired DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). The following assumptions are made in the model: (i) A DNA fragment created by the induced DSBs may move out of its chromosome (become lost), and the probability of that process depends on the fragment size. (ii) An irradiated cell will lose its proliferative capacity if it has an unrepaired DSB (including DNA fragments) at certain points in the cell cycle. Mathematical expressions of the model yield the dose and time dependencies of the surviving fraction, the number of unrepaired DSBs, and the number of prematurely condensed chromosome fragments. Radiobiological phenomena described include effects of low dose rate, delayed plating, hypertonic solution, araA, and high-LET radiation. The calculated dose dependence of the residual number of unrepaired DSBs for ataxia telangiectasia and normal fibroblast cells is very close to the experimentally obtained [M. N. Cornforth and J. S. Bedford, Radiat. Res. 111, 385-405 (1987)] total number of chromosomal aberrations. This leads to the conclusion that each unrepaired DSB becomes a chromosomal aberration. Analysis in terms of the model shows that the radiosensitivity of various cell lines is predominantly due to the different amounts of time available for DSB repair in these cells.     

Time effects in molecular radiation Biology

Summary Radiation action occurs over a broad timescale which extends from the very early physical processes associated with energy absorption to the very late biological effects, such as carcinogenesis which may not become apparent until many years later. The various temporal stages of radiation action are classified and their interrelationships described. Experimental projects in cellular radiation chemistry, including pulse radiolysis, are discussed, together with some applications of the techniques in this general area.The paper also deals with some aspects of the oxygen effect in radiobiology and the mechanisms of its action. Various studies employing fast response techniques have been useful in verifying the role of fast free radical reactions in the oxygen effects and examples are given of some applications. Investigations with other hypoxic cell sensitizers, the electron affinic agents, are also briefly discussed, with an account of how studies of the timescale of radiation sensitization can be valuable in understanding mechanisms. Possible mechanisms of action of radiation sensitization by oxygen and other agents, including radical fixation and direct action processes, are considered in the light of evidence from some model systems.Invited paper, presented at the 14th Annual Meeting of European Society of Radiation Biology, Jülich, Germany, October 8–14, 1978     

DNA strand breaks are not induced in human cells exposed to 2.1425 GHz band CW and W-CDMA modulated radiofrequency fields allocated to mobile radio base stations

We conducted a large-scale in vitro study focused on the effects of low level radiofrequency (RF) fields from mobile radio base stations employing the International Mobile Telecommunication 2000 (IMT-2000) cellular system in order to test the hypothesis that modulated RF fields may act as a DNA damaging agent. First, we evaluated the responses of human cells to microwave exposure at a specific absorption rate (SAR) of 80 mW/kg, which corresponds to the limit of the average whole body SAR for general public exposure defined as a basic restriction in the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP) guidelines. Second, we investigated whether continuous wave (CW) and Wideband Code Division Multiple Access (W-CDMA) modulated signal RF fields at 2.1425 GHz induced different levels of DNA damage. Human glioblastoma A172 cells and normal human IMR-90 fibroblasts from fetal lungs were exposed to mobile communication frequency radiation to investigate whether such exposure produced DNA strand breaks in cell culture. A172 cells were exposed to W-CDMA radiation at SARs of 80, 250, and 800 mW/kg and CW radiation at 80 mW/kg for 2 and 24 h, while IMR-90 cells were exposed to both W-CDMA and CW radiations at a SAR of 80 mW/kg for the same time periods. Under the same RF field exposure conditions, no significant differences in the DNA strand breaks were observed between the test groups exposed to W-CDMA or CW radiation and the sham exposed negative controls, as evaluated immediately after the exposure periods by alkaline comet assays. Our results confirm that low level exposures do not act as a genotoxicant up to a SAR of 800 mW/kg.     

Photoprotection of DNA (in vitro) by acyclothymidine dinucleosides

Excessive exposure to sunlight is primarily implicated in ultraviolet (UV) induced skin cancers worldwide. Direct absorption of UV radiation by DNA leads to the formation of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs) resulting in DNA damage. The molecular mechanisms involved in the mutagenicity of CPDs are well established. Photoprotection of the skin from the detrimental effects of UV is essential in preventing skin damage. A variety of formulations, which essentially contain UV filters have been used as photoprotective agents of the skin. These comprise aromatic and inorganic molecules, whose mechanism of action involves either absorption, reflection, or scattering of UV radiation. However, the downstream photoproducts of some of these molecules have undesirable characteristics which compromise their utility. A biomimetic approach involving structural analogs of nucleic acids can help overcome these limitations. Herein, we show the photoprotective action of acyclothymidine dinucleosides on both plasmid and cellular DNA.     

Characterizing the DNA Damage Response by Cell Tracking Algorithms and Cell Features Classification Using High-Content Time-Lapse Analysis

Traditionally, the kinetics of DNA repair have been estimated using immunocytochemistry by labeling proteins involved in the DNA damage response (DDR) with fluorescent markers in a fixed cell assay. However, detailed knowledge of DDR dynamics across multiple cell generations cannot be obtained using a limited number of fixed cell time-points. Here we report on the dynamics of 53BP1 radiation induced foci (RIF) across multiple cell generations using live cell imaging of non-malignant human mammary epithelial cells (MCF10A) expressing histone H2B-GFP and the DNA repair protein 53BP1-mCherry. Using automatic extraction of RIF imaging features and linear programming techniques, we were able to characterize detailed RIF kinetics for 24 hours before and 24 hours after exposure to low and high doses of ionizing radiation. High-content-analysis at the single cell level over hundreds of cells allows us to quantify precisely the dose dependence of 53BP1 protein production, RIF nuclear localization and RIF movement after exposure to X-ray. Using elastic registration techniques based on the nuclear pattern of individual cells, we could describe the motion of individual RIF precisely within the nucleus. We show that DNA repair occurs in a limited number of large domains, within which multiple small RIFs form, merge and/or resolve with random motion following normal diffusion law. Large foci formation is shown to be mainly happening through the merging of smaller RIF rather than through growth of an individual focus. We estimate repair domain sizes of 7.5 to 11 µm² with a maximum number of ~15 domains per MCF10A cell. This work also highlights DDR which are specific to doses larger than 1 Gy such as rapid 53BP1 protein increase in the nucleus and foci diffusion rates that are significantly faster than for spontaneous foci movement. We hypothesize that RIF merging reflects a "stressed" DNA repair process that has been taken outside physiological conditions when too many DSB occur at once. High doses of ionizing radiation lead to RIF merging into repair domains which in turn increases DSB proximity and misrepair. Such finding may therefore be critical to explain the supralinear dose dependence for chromosomal rearrangement and cell death measured after exposure to ionizing radiation.     

Relative biological effectiveness of accumulated 125IdU and 125I-estrogen decays in estrogen receptor-expressing MCF-7 human breast cancer cells

The therapeutic potential for delivering a cytotoxic dose of radiation (using the decay of Auger-electron emitters) to the cell nucleus of cancer cells that express estrogen receptors (ERs) by radiolabeled estrogen was investigated in the ER-expressing human breast cancer cell line, MCF-7. The radiolabeled estrogen/ER complex irradiates the cell nucleus by binding specific DNA sequences called estrogen response elements (EREs). Cell clonogenicity and induction of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) by gamma radiation or accumulation of (125)I-iododeoxyuridine ((125)IdU) or E-17alpha[(125)I]iodovinyl-11betamethoxyestradiol ((125)IVME2) decays were determined. MCF-7 cells were efficiently killed by accumulation of (125)IdU (D(0) = 30 decays per cell) and (125)IVME2 decays (D(0) = 28 decays per cell). DNA DSBs were induced by the accumulation of (125)IdU (approximately 3750 decays per cell required to reduce the mean value of the elution profile to 50%) or (125)IVME2 decays (approximately 465 decays per cell required to reduce the mean value to 50%). For survival of MCF-7 cells after gamma irradiation, the D(0) was 1 Gy, and approximately 65 Gy was required to reduce the mean value to 50% for induction of DSBs. The RBE values for cell killing and induction of DSBs by (125)IVME2 relative to gamma radiation were 4.8 and 18.8, respectively. The RBE values for cell killing and induction of DSBs by (125)IdU relative to gamma radiation were 4.5 and 2.3, respectively. Cell killing in a manner similar to that induced by high-LET radiation and the high RBE for induction of DSBs by (125)IVME2 in the ER-expressing MCF-7 cells provide a biological rationale for the use of Auger electron-emitting radionuclides covalently bound to estrogen to deliver a cytotoxic dose of radiation to ER-positive cancers.     

Radioadaptive response revisited

Radiation-induced adaptive response belongs to the group of non-targeted effects that do not require direct exposure of the cell nucleus by radiation. It is described as the reduced damaging effect of a challenging radiation dose when induced by a previous low priming dose. Adaptive responses have been observed in vitro and in vivo using various indicators of cellular damage, such as cell lethality, chromosomal aberrations, mutation induction, radiosensitivity, and DNA repair. Adaptive response can be divided into three successive biological phenomena, the intracellular response, the extracellular signal, and the maintenance. The intracellular response leading to adaptation of a single cell is a complex biological process including induction or suppression of gene groups. An extracellular signal, the nature of which is unknown, may be sent by the affected cell to neighbouring cells causing them to adapt as well. This occurs either by a release of diffusible signalling molecules or by gap-junction intercellular communication. Adaptive response can be maintained for periods ranging from of a few hours to several months. Constantly increased levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS) or nitric oxide (NO) have been observed in adapted cells and both factors may play a role in the maintenance process. Although adaptive response seems to function by an on/off principle, it is a phenomenon showing a high degree of inter- and intraindividual variability. It remains to be seen to what extent adaptive response is functional in humans at relevant dose and dose-rate exposures. A better understanding of adaptive response and other non-targeted effects is needed before they can be confirmed as risk estimate factors for the human population at low levels of ionising radiation.     

Mutation induction by inhaled radon progeny modeled at the tissue level

The observable responses of living systems to ionizing radiation depend on the level of biological organization studied. Understanding the relationships between the responses characteristic of the different levels of organization is of crucial importance. The main objective of the present study is to investigate how some cellular effects of radiation manifest at the tissue level by modeling mutation induction due to chronic exposure to inhaled radon progeny. For this purpose, a mathematical model of the bronchial epithelium was elaborated to quantify cell nucleus hits and cell doses. Mutagenesis was modeled considering endogenous as well as radiation-induced DNA damages and cell cycle shortening due to cell inactivation. The model parameters describing the cellular effects of radiation are obtained from experimental data. Cell nucleus hits, cell doses, and mutation induction were computed for the activity hot spots of the large bronchi at different exposures. Results demonstrate that the mutagenic effect of densely ionizing radiation is dominated by cell cycle shortening due to cell inactivation and not by DNA damages. This suggests that radiation burdens of non-progenitor cells play a significant role in mutagenesis in case of protracted exposures to densely ionizing radiation. Mutation rate as a function of dose rate exhibits a convex shape below a threshold. This threshold indicates the exhaustion of the tissue regeneration capacity of local progenitor cells. It is suggested that progenitor cell hyperplasia occurs beyond the threshold dose rate, giving a possible explanation of the inverse dose-rate effect observed in the epidemiology of lung cancer among uranium miners.     

The radiation dose to cells in vitro from intracellular indium-111

Most of the radionuclides used in nuclear medicine emit low energy Auger electrons following radioactive decay. These emissions, if intracellular, could irreparably damage the radiosensitive structures of the cell. The resulting radiation dose, which is a measure of biological damage in the affected cell, could be many times the average radiation dose to the associated organ. In this series of experiments, the radiation dose to the nucleus of a chinese hamster V79 cell was determined for the intracellular radiopharmaceutical 111indium-oxine. Assuming the cell nucleus to be the radiosensitive volume, the radiation dose would be primarily due to the low energy Auger electrons. A much smaller dose would be absorbed from the penetrating X- and gamma-rays and internal conversion electrons released from other radiolabelled cells in the culture. The radiation dose to the cell from the intranuclear decay of 111In was empirically established from cell survival studies to be 3.5 mGy/decay, using cobalt-60 as a reference radiation. The average dose to V79 cells from extracellular 111In (i.e., from 111In located outside the target cell) was calculated to be 5.8 pGy/decay. This suggests that for an intracellular radiopharmaceutical, the radiation dose of consequence would be delivered by the low energy Auger electrons. In contrast, Auger electrons from an extracellular radiopharmaceutical could not directly damage the cell nucleus and therefore would not contribute to the radiation dose.     

A Model of Photon Cell Killing Based on the Spatio-Temporal Clustering of DNA Damage in Higher Order Chromatin Structures

We present a new approach to model dose rate effects on cell killing after photon radiation based on the spatio-temporal clustering of DNA double strand breaks (DSBs) within higher order chromatin structures of approximately 1–2 Mbp size, so called giant loops. The main concept of this approach consists of a distinction of two classes of lesions, isolated and clustered DSBs, characterized by the number of double strand breaks induced in a giant loop. We assume a low lethality and fast component of repair for isolated DSBs and a high lethality and slow component of repair for clustered DSBs. With appropriate rates, the temporal transition between the different lesion classes is expressed in terms of five differential equations. These allow formulating the dynamics involved in the competition of damage induction and repair for arbitrary dose rates and fractionation schemes. Final cell survival probabilities are computable with a cell line specific set of three parameters: The lethality for isolated DSBs, the lethality for clustered DSBs and the half-life time of isolated DSBs.By comparison with larger sets of published experimental data it is demonstrated that the model describes the cell line dependent response to treatments using either continuous irradiation at a constant dose rate or to split dose irradiation well. Furthermore, an analytic investigation of the formulation concerning single fraction treatments with constant dose rates in the limiting cases of extremely high or low dose rates is presented. The approach is consistent with the Linear-Quadratic model extended by the Lea-Catcheside factor up to the second moment in dose. Finally, it is shown that the model correctly predicts empirical findings about the dose rate dependence of incidence probabilities for deterministic radiation effects like pneumonitis and the bone marrow syndrome. These findings further support the general concepts on which the approach is based.     

Cell to Cell Variability of Radiation-Induced Foci: Relation between Observed Damage and Energy Deposition

Most studies that aim to understand the interactions between different types of photon radiation and cellular DNA assume homogeneous cell irradiation, with all cells receiving the same amount of energy. The level of DNA damage is therefore generally determined by averaging it over the entire population of exposed cells. However, evaluating the molecular consequences of a stochastic phenomenon such as energy deposition of ionizing radiation by measuring only an average effect may not be sufficient for understanding some aspects of the cellular response to this radiation. The variance among the cells associated with this average effect may also be important for the behaviour of irradiated tissue. In this study, we accurately estimated the distribution of the number of radiation-induced γH2AX foci (RIF) per cell nucleus in a large population of endothelial cells exposed to 3 macroscopic doses of gamma rays from ⁶⁰Co. The number of RIF varied significantly and reproducibly from cell to cell, with its relative standard deviation ranging from 36% to 18% depending on the macroscopic dose delivered. Interestingly, this relative cell-to-cell variability increased as the dose decreased, contrary to the mean RIF count per cell. This result shows that the dose effect, in terms of the number of DNA lesions indicated by RIF is not as simple as a purely proportional relation in which relative SD is constant with dose. To analyse the origins of this observed variability, we calculated the spread of the specific energy distribution for the different target volumes and subvolumes in which RIF can be generated. Variances, standard deviations and relative standard deviations all changed similarly from dose to dose for biological and calculated microdosimetric values. This similarity is an important argument that supports the hypothesis of the conservation of the association between the number of RIF per nucleus and the specific energy per DNA molecule. This comparison allowed us to calculate a volume of 1.6 μm³ for which the spread of the specific energy distribution could explain the entire variability of RIF counts per cell in an exposed cell population. The definition of this volume may allow to use a microdosimetric quantity to predict heterogeneity in DNA damage. Moreover, this value is consistent with the order of magnitude of the volume occupied by the hydrated sugar-phosphate backbone of the DNA molecule, which is the part of the DNA molecule responsible for strand breaks.     

A global perspective of radiation-induced signal transduction pathways in cancer therapeutics

Radiation is a well established therapeutic modality for the treatment of solid tumors. By merging molecular biological approaches with radiation biology, a significant number of signaling events elicited by ionizing radiation have been delineated. These signaling pathways include events leading to cell cycle arrest, apoptosis or cell survival. There are two major signaling events that affect radiation response. One is the intrinsic/constitutive pro-survival signaling event that is present in proliferating tumor cells while the other is "induced pro-survival event" in response to radiation, both of these events confer resistance to the killing effects of radiation. In this review, signaling pathways that lead to either apoptosis or survival of cells following ionizing radiation are discussed in detail. In addition, mechanisms of action for gene/drug based inhibitors that modulate the expression and function of various genes and gene products involved in pro-survival signaling pathways are described. Further, novel strategies to abrogate the "induced radiation resistance" leading to enhanced therapeutic efficacy of ionizing radiation have been proposed. These novel strategies include the use of radio-gene therapy, low dose fractionated radiation therapy as a chemopotentiator and therapeutic utility of high radiation dose induced bystander effect. The complete understanding of the molecular pathways leading to apoptosis/survival of cells following ionizing radiation will help in tailoring more effective novel strategies and treatment modalities for complete eradication of cancer.     

Use of the γ-H2AX Assay to Investigate DNA Repair Dynamics Following Multiple Radiation Exposures

Radiation therapy is one of the most common and effective strategies used to treat cancer. The irradiation is usually performed with a fractionated scheme, where the dose required to kill tumour cells is given in several sessions, spaced by specific time intervals, to allow healthy tissue recovery. In this work, we examined the DNA repair dynamics of cells exposed to radiation delivered in fractions, by assessing the response of histone-2AX (H2AX) phosphorylation (γ-H2AX), a marker of DNA double strand breaks. γ-H2AX foci induction and disappearance were monitored following split dose irradiation experiments in which time interval between exposure and dose were varied. Experimental data have been coupled to an analytical theoretical model, in order to quantify key parameters involved in the foci induction process. Induction of γ-H2AX foci was found to be affected by the initial radiation exposure with a smaller number of foci induced by subsequent exposures. This was compared to chromatin relaxation and cell survival. The time needed for full recovery of γ-H2AX foci induction was quantified (12 hours) and the 1:1 relationship between radiation induced DNA double strand breaks and foci numbers was critically assessed in the multiple irradiation scenarios.     

Application of Bayesian inference to characterize risks associated with low doses of low-LET radiation

Improved risk characterization for stochastic biological effects of low doses of low-LET radiation is important for protecting nuclear workers and the public from harm from radiation exposure. Here we present a Bayesian approach to characterize risks of stochastic effects from low doses of low-LET radiation. The stochastic effect considered is neoplastic transformation of cells because it relates closely to cancer induction. We have used a published model of neoplastic transformation called NEOTRANS1. It is based on two different classes of cellular sensitivity for asynchronous, exponentially growing populations (in vitro). One sensitivity class is the hypersensitive cell; the other is the resistant cell. NEOTRANS1 includes the effects of genomic damage accumulation, DNA repair during cell cycle arrest, and DNA misrepair (non-lethal repair errors). The model-associated differential equations are solved for conditions of in vitro irradiation at a fixed rate. Previously published solutions apply only to high dose rates and were incorrectly assumed to apply to only high-LET radiation. Solutions provided here apply to any fixed dose rate and to both high- and low-LET radiations. Markov chain Monte Carlo methods are used to carry out the Bayesian inference of the low-dose risk for neoplastic transformation of aneuploid C3H 10T1/2 cells for X-ray doses from 0 to 1000 mGy. We have assumed that for this low-dose range only the hypersensitive fraction of the cells are affected. Our results indicate that the initial slope of the risk vs dose relationship for neoplastic transformation is as follows: (1) directly proportional to the fraction, f1, of hypersensitive cells; (2) directly proportional to the radiosensitivity of the genomic target; and (3) inversely proportional to the rate at which hypersensitive cells with radiation-induced damage are committed to undergo correct repair of genomic damage. Further, our results indicate that very fast molecular events are associated with the commitment of cells to the correct repair pathway. Results also indicate a relatively large probability for misrepair that leads to genomic instability. Our results are consistent with the view that for very low doses, dose rate is not an important variable for characterizing low-LET radiation risks so long as age-related changes in sensitivity do not occur during irradiation.     

Cellular kinetics, dosimetry, and radiobiology of alpha-particle radioimmunotherapy: induction of apoptosis.

Though clinical results for radioimmunoconjugate therapy of most common epithelial tumors have been disappointing, dramatic responses have been observed repeatedly in the treatment of high- and low-grade malignant lymphomas. This high clinical responsiveness after radioimmunoconjugate therapy sometimes appears to be out of proportion to the calculated radiation dose absorbed by the lymphoma tissue. Here we describe some key aspects of the kinetics, dosimetry, and cellular radiobiology of murine lymphoma cells exposed to 212Bi-radiolabeled alpha-particle-emitting immunoconjugates specific for the differentiation antigen Thy 1.2. Approximately 25 cell-bound alpha-particle-emitting immunoconjugates per target cell were required to reduce clonogenic survival by 90% (the radiobiological D10). Serial kinetic analyses of the antibody and radioisotope components of the immunoconjugates revealed significant levels of dechelation and up to 7.5% cellular internalization of the isotope. Cellular radiation dosimetry performed by Monte Carlo computer simulation of alpha-particle energy deposition patterns based on the observed radiopharmacokinetics showed that the D10 resulted from approximately four alpha-particle traversals through the nucleus, corresponding to an absorbed radiation dose of approximately 0.95 Gy to the cell nucleus. Electron micrographs and DNA gel studies of murine lymphoma cells undergoing radioimmunoconjugate therapy in vivo and in vitro demonstrated bizarre blebbing patterns, condensation of chromosomal material, and internucleosomal DNA fragmentation patterns characteristic of programmed cell death (apoptosis). We conjecture that the efficacy of radioimmunoconjugates against responsive cell types may be the result of passive DNA damage by ionizing radiation and the initiation of apoptosis in response to radioimmunotherapy.