ATP Synthases in the Year 2000: Defining the Different Levels of Mechanism and Getting a Grip on Each

ATP synthases are unusually complex molecules, which fractionate most readily into two major units, one a water soluble unit called F₁ and the other a detergent soluble unit called F₀. In almost all known species the F₁ unit consists of 5 subunit types in the stoichiometric ratio ₃₃ while the F₀ unit contains 3 subunit types (a, b, and c) in E. coli, and at least 10 subunit types (a, b, c, and others) in higher animals. It is now believed by many investigators that during the synthesis of ATP, protons derived from an electrochemical gradient generated by an electron transport chain are directed through the F₀ unit in such a way as to drive the rotation of the single subunit, which extends from an oligomeric ring of at least 10 c subunits in F₀ through the center of F₁. It is further believed by many that the rotating subunit, by interacting sequentially with the 3 pairs of F₁ (360° cycle) in the presence of ADP, P_i, and Mg⁺⁺, brings about via power strokes conformational/binding changes in these subunits that promote the synthesis of ATP and its release on each pair. In support of these views, studies in several laboratories either suggest or demonstrate that F₀ consists in part of a proton gradient driven motor while F₁ consists of an ATP hydrolysis driven motor, and that the subunit does rotate during F₁ function. Therefore, current implications are that during ATP synthesis the former motor drives the latter in reverse via the subunit. This would suggest that the process of understanding the mechanism of ATP synthases can be subdivided into three major levels, which include elucidating those chemical and/or biophysical events involved in (1) inducing rotation of the subunit, (2) coupling rotation of this subunit to conformational/binding changes in each of the 3 pairs, and (3) forming ATP and water (from ADP, P_i, and Mg⁺⁺) and then releasing these products from each of the 3 catalytic sites. Significantly, it is at the final level of mechanism where the bond breaking/making events of ATP synthesis occur in the transition state, with the former two levels of mechanism setting the stage for this critical payoff event. Nevertheless, in order to get a better grip in this new century on how ATP synthases make ATP and then release it, we must take on the difficult challenge of elucidating each of the three levels of mechanism.     

Frontiers in ATP synthase research: Understanding the relationship between subunit movements and ATP Synthesis

How biological systems make ATP has intrigued many scientists for well over half the 20th century, and because of the importance and complexity of the problem it seems likely to continue to be a source of fascination to both senior and younger investigators well into the 21st century. Scientific battles fought to unravel the vast secrets by which ATP synthases work have been fierce, and great victories have been short-lived, tempered with the realization that more structures are needed, additional subunits remain to be conquered, and that during ATP synthesis, not one, but several subunits may undergo either significant conformational changes, repositioning, or perhaps even physical rotation similar to bacterial flagella^(1,2). In this introductory article, the author briefly summarizes our current knowledge about the complex substructure of ATP synthases, what we have learned from X-ray crystallography of the F₁ unit, and current evidence for subunit movements.     

Role of alphaPhe-291 residue in the phosphate-binding subdomain of catalytic sites of Escherichia coli ATP synthase

The role of αPhe-291 residue in phosphate binding by Escherichia coli F₁F₀-ATP synthase was examined. X-ray structures of bovine mitochondrial enzyme suggest that this residue resides in close proximity to the conserved βR246 residue. Herein, we show that mutations αF291D and αF291E in E. coli reduce the ATPase activity of F₁F₀ membranes by 350-fold. Yet, significant oxidative phosphorylation activity is retained. In contrast to wild-type, ATPase activities of mutants were not inhibited by MgADP-azide, MgADP-fluoroaluminate, or MgADP-fluoroscandium. Whereas, 7-chloro-4-nitrobenzo-2-oxa-1,3-diazole (NBD-Cl) inhibited wild-type ATPase essentially completely, ATPase in mutants was inhibited maximally by ∼75%, although reaction still occurred at residue βTyr-297, proximal to αPhe-291 in the phosphate-binding pocket. Inhibition characteristics supported the conclusion that NBD-Cl reacts in βE (empty) catalytic sites, as shown previously by X-ray structure analysis. Phosphate protected against NBD-Cl inhibition in wild-type but not in mutants. In addition, our data suggest that the interaction of αPhe-291 with phosphate during ATP hydrolysis or synthesis may be distinct.     

The Catalytic Transition State in ATP Synthase

The catalytic transition state of ATP synthase has been characterized and modeled by combined use of (1) Mg-ADP–fluoroaluminate, Mg-ADP–fluoroscandium, and corresponding Mg-IDP–fluorometals as transition-state analogs; (2) fluorescence signals of -Trp331 and -Trp148 as optical probes to assess formation of the transition state; (3) mutations of critical catalytic residues to determine side-chain ligands required to stabilize the transition state. Rate acceleration by positive catalytic site cooperativity is explained as due to mobility of -Arg376, acting as an arginine finger residue, which interacts with nucleotide specifically at the transition state step of catalysis, not with Mg-ATP- or Mg-ADP-bound ground states. We speculate that formation and collapse of the transition state may engender catalytic site / subunit-interface conformational movement, which is linked to -subunit rotation.     

ATP synthases—Structure of the F1-moiety and its relationship to function and mechanism

A great deal of progress has been made in understanding both the structure and the mechanism of F₁-ATPase. The primary structure is now fully known for at least five species. Sequence comparison between chloroplast, photobacteria, aerobic bacteria, and mitochondrial representatives allow us to infer more general functional relationships and evolutionary trends. Although the F₁ moiety is the most studied segment of the H⁺-ATPase complex, there is not a full understanding of the mechanism and regulation of its hydrolytic activity. The subunit is now known to contain one and probably two nucleotide binding domains, one of which is believed to be a catalytic site. Recently, two similar models have been proposed to attempt to describe the active part of the subunits. These models are mainly an attempt to use the structure of adenylate kinase to represent a more general working model for nucleotide binding phosphotransferases. Labelling experiments seem to indicate that several critical residues outside the region described by the adenylate kinase part of this model are also actively involved in the ATPase activity. New models will have to be introduced to include these regions. Finally, it seems that a consensus has been reached with regard to a broad acceptance of the asymmetric structure of the F₁-moiety. In addition, recent experimental evidence points toward the presence of nonequivalent subunits to describe the functional activity of the F₁-ATPase. A summary diagram of the conformational and binding states of the enzyme including the nonequivalent subunit is presented. Additional research is essential to establish the role of the minor subunits—and of the asymmetry they introduce in F₁—on the physiological function of the enzyme.     

Kinetic studies of ATP synthase: The case for the positional change mechanism

The mitochondrial ATP synthases shares many structural and kinetic properties with bacterial and chloroplast ATP synthases. These enzymes transduce the energy contained in the membrane's electrochemical proton gradients into the energy required for synthesis of high-energy phosphate bonds. The unusual three-fold symmetry of the hydrophilic domain, F₁, of all these synthases is striking. Each F₁ has three identical subunits and three identical subunits as well as three additional subunits present as single copies. The catalytic site for synthesis is undoubtedly contained in the subunit or an , interface, and thus each enzyme appears to contain three identical catalytic sites. This review summarizes recent isotopic and kinetic evidence in favour of the concept, originally proposed by Boyer and coworkers, that energy from the proton gradient is exerted not directly for the reaction at the catalytic site, but rather to release product from a single catalytic site. A modification of this binding change hypotheses is favored by recent data which suggest that the binding change is due to a positional change in all three subunits relative to the remaining subunits of F₁ and F₀ and that the vector of rotation is influenced by energy. The positional change, or rotation, appears to be the slow step in the process of catalysis and it is accelerated in all F₁F₀ ATPases studied by substrate binding and by the proton gradient. However, in the mammalian mitochondrial enzyme, other types of allosteric rate regulation not yet fully elucidated seem important as well.     

TMEM70 protein — A novel ancillary factor of mammalian ATP synthase

An increasing number of patients with nuclear genetic defects of mitochondrial ATP synthase have been identified in recent years. They are characterized by early onset, lactic acidosis, 3-methylglutaconic aciduria, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy and encephalopathy and most cases have a fatal outcome. Patient tissues show isolated defect of the ATP synthase complex and its content decreases to ≥ 30% of normal due to altered enzyme biosynthesis and assembly. Gene mapping and complementation studies have identified mutations in TMEM70 gene encoding a 30kD mitochondrial protein of unknown function as the cause of the disease. An altered synthesis of this new ancillary factor in ATP synthase biogenesis was found in most of the known patients with decreased ATP synthase content. As revealed by phylogenetic analysis, TMEM70 is specific for higher eukaryotes.     

Proton ATPase of rat liver mitochondria: A rapid procedure for purification of a stable, reconstitutively active F1 preparation using a modified chloroform method

A method is described for the purification of rat liver F1-ATPase by a modification of the chloroform extraction procedure originally described by Beechey et al. (Biochem. J. (1975) 148, 533). Purified liver membrane vesicles are extracted with chloroform in the presence of ATP and EDTA. The procedure yields pure F1 in only 2-3 h without the necessity of ion-exchange chromatography. The enzyme exhibits the alpha, beta, gamma, delta, and epsilon bands characteristic of F1-ATPase. It has a high ATPase specific activity, and is reconstitutively active, catalyzing high rates of ATP synthesis. Significantly, it can be readily crystallized. If desired, the enzyme can be passed over a gel filtration column to place it in a stabilizing phosphate-EDTA buffer, lyophilized and stored indefinitely at -20 degrees C.     

The molecular mechanism of ATP synthesis by F1F0-ATP synthase

ATP synthesis by oxidative phosphorylation and photophosphorylation, catalyzed by F₁F₀-ATP synthase, is the fundamental means of cell energy production. Earlier mutagenesis studies had gone some way to describing the mechanism. More recently, several X-ray structures at atomic resolution have pictured the catalytic sites, and real-time video recordings of subunit rotation have left no doubt of the nature of energy coupling between the transmembrane proton gradient and the catalytic sites in this extraordinary molecular motor. Nonetheless, the molecular events that are required to accomplish the chemical synthesis of ATP remain undefined. In this review we summarize current state of knowledge and present a hypothesis for the molecular mechanism of ATP synthesis.     

A sensitive, simple assay of mitochondrial ATP synthesis of cultured mammalian cells suitable for high-throughput analysis

A new assay has been developed to measure mitochondrial ATP synthesis of cultured mammalian cells. Cells in a microplate are exposed to streptolysin O to make plasma membranes permeable without damaging mitochondrial function and ATP synthesis is monitored by luciferase. Addition of inhibitors of F_oF₁-ATP synthase (F_oF₁), respiratory chain, TCA cycle and ATP/ADP translocator, as well as knockdown of β-subunit of F_oF₁, resulted in loss of ATP synthesis. Compared with the conventional procedures that need mitochondria fractionation and detergent, this assay is simple, sensitive and suitable for high-throughput analysis of genes and drugs that could affect mitochondrial functional integrity as represented by ATP synthesis activity.     

gammaepsilon Sub-complex of thermophilic ATP synthase has the ability to bind ATP

The isolated epsilon subunit of F(1)-ATPase from thermophilic Bacillus PS3 (TF(1)) binds ATP [Y. Kato-Yamada, M. Yoshida, J. Biol. Chem. 278 (2003) 36013]. The obvious question is whether the ATP binding concern with the regulation of ATP synthase activity or not. If so, the epsilon subunit even in the ATP synthase complex should have the ability to bind ATP. To check if the ATP binding to the epsilon subunit within the ATP synthase complex may occur, the gammaepsilon sub-complex of TF(1) was prepared and ATP binding was examined. The results clearly showed that the gammaepsilon sub-complex can bind ATP.     

Coupling Proton Movement to ATP Synthesis in the Chloroplast ATP Synthase

The chloroplast F₀F₁-ATP synthase-ATPase is a tiny rotary motor responsible for coupling ATP synthesis and hydrolysis to the light-driven electrochemical proton gradient. Reversible oxidation/reduction of a dithiol, located within a special regulatory domain of the γ subunit of the chloroplast F₁ enzyme, switches the enzyme between an inactive and an active state. This regulatory mechanism is unique to the ATP synthases of higher plants and its physiological significance lies in preventing nonproductive depletion of essential ATP pools in the dark. The three-dimensional structure of the chloroplast F₁ gamma subunit has not yet been solved. To examine the mechanism of dithiol regulation, a model of the chloroplast gamma subunit was obtained through segmental homology modeling based on the known structures of the mitochondrial and bacterial γ subunits, together with de novo construction of the unknown regulatory domain. The model has provided considerable insight into how the dithiol might modulate catalytic function. This has, in turn, suggested a mechanism by which rotation of subunits in F₀, the transmembrane proton channel portion of the enzyme, can be coupled, via the ε subunit, to rotation of the γ subunit of F₁ to achieve the 120° (or 90°+30°) stepping action that is characteristic of F₁ γ subunit rotation.     

A 40-kDa polypeptide from papain digestion of the rabbit intestinal Na+/phosphate cotransporter retains Na+ and phosphate cotransport

We searched for new fluorescent probes of catalytic-site nucleotide binding in F(1)F(0)-ATP synthase by introducing Cys mutations at positions in or close to catalytic sites and then reacting Cys-mutant F(1) with thiol-reactive fluorescent probes. Four suitable mutant/probe combinations were identified. beta F410C labeled by 7-fluorobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazole-4-sulfonamide (ABD-F) gave very large signal changes in response to nucleotide, allowing facile measurement of fluorescence and nucleotide-binding parameters, not only in F(1) but also in F(1)F(0). The results are consistent with the presence of three asymmetric catalytic sites of widely different affinities, with similar properties in both enzymes, and revealed a unique probe environment at the high-affinity site 1. beta Y331C F(1) labeled by ABD-F gave a large signal which monitored catalytic site polarity changes that occur along the ATP hydrolysis pathway. Two other mutant/probe combinations with significant nucleotide-responsive signals were beta Y331C labeled by 5-((((2-iodoacetyl)amino)ethyl)amino)naphthaline-1-sulfonic acid and alpha F291C labeled by 2-4'-(iodoacetamido)anilino)naphthalene-6-sulfonic acid. The signal of the latter responds differentially to nucleoside diphosphate versus triphosphate bound in catalytic sites.     

Low resolution structure of subunit b (b (22-156)) of Escherichia coli F(1)F(O) ATP synthase in solution and the b-delta assembly

The first low resolution solution structure of the soluble domain of subunit b (b _22–156) of the Escherichia coli F₁F_O ATPsynthase was determined from small-angle X-ray scattering data. The dimeric protein has a boomerang-like shape with a total length of 16.2 ± 0.3 nm. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) shows that the protein binds effectively to the subunit δ, confirming their described neighborhood. Using the recombinant C-terminal domain (δ_91–177) of subunit δ and the C-terminal peptides of subunit b, b _120–140 and b _140–156, FCS titration experiments were performed to assign the segments involved in δ–b assembly. These data identify the very C-terminal tail b _140–156 to interact with δ_91–177. The novel 3D structure of this peptide has been determined by NMR spectroscopy. The molecule adopts a stable helix formation in solution with a flexible tail between amino acid 140 to 145.     

Inhibitory and Anchoring Domains in the ATPase Inhibitor Protein IF1 of Bovine Heart Mitochondrial ATP Synthase

The inhibitor protein IF1 is a basic protein of 84 residues which inhibits the ATPase activity of the mitochondrial FoF1-ATP synthase complex without having any effect on ATP synthesis. Results of cross-linking and limited proteolysis experiments are presented showing that in the intact FoF1 complex "in situ," in the inner membrane of bovine heart mitochondria, the central segment of IF1 (residues 42-58) binds to the alpha and beta subunits of F1 in a pH dependent process, and inhibits the ATPase activity. The C-terminal region of IF1 binds, simultaneously, to the OSCP subunit of Fo in a pH-independent process. This binding keeps IF1 anchored to the complex, both under inhibitory conditions, at acidic pH, and noninhibitory conditions at alkaline pH.     

Structural and functional analysis of the coupling subunit F in solution and topological arrangement of the stalk domains of the methanogenic A1AO ATP synthase

The first low-resolution shape of subunit F of the A₁A_O ATP synthase from the archaeon Methanosarcina mazei Gö1 in solution was determined by small angle X-ray scattering. Independent to the concentration used, the protein is monomeric and has an elongated shape, divided in a main globular part with a length of about 4.5 nm, and a hook-like domain of about 3.0 nm in length. The subunit-subunit interaction of subunit F inside the A₁A_O ATP synthase in the presence of 1-ethyl-3-(dimethylaminopropyl)-carbodiimide EDC was studied as a function of nucleotide binding, demonstrating movements of subunits F relative to the nucleotide-binding subunit B. Furthermore, in the intact A₁A_O complex, crosslinking of subunits D-E, A-H and A-B-D was obtained and the peptides, involved, were analyzed by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry. Based on these data the surface of contact of B-F could be mapped in the high-resolution structure of subunit B of the A₁A_O ATP synthase.     

Notes on the Mechanism of ATP Synthesis

The most commonly quoted mechanism of the coupling between the electrochemical proton gradient and the formation of ATP from ADP and P_i assumes that all states of the F₁ portion of the ATP synthase have subunits in tight, loose, and open conformations. Models based on this assumption are inconsistent with some of the available experimental evidence. A mechanism that includes an additional subunit conformation, closed, observed in the rat liver structure overcomes these difficulties.     

ATP Synthases With Novel Rotor Subunits: New Insights into Structure,Function and Evolution of ATPases

ATPases with unusual membrane-embedded rotor subunits were found in both F₁F₀ and A₁A₀ ATP synthases. The rotor subunit c of A₁A₀ ATPases is, in most cases, similar to subunit c from F₀. Surprisingly, multiplied c subunits with four, six, or even 26 transmembrane spans have been found in some archaea and these multiplication events were sometimes accompanied by loss of the ion-translocating group. Nevertheless, these enzymes are still active as ATP synthases. A duplicated c subunit with only one ion-translocating group was found along with “normal” F₀ c subunits in the Na⁺ F₁F₀ ATP synthase of the bacterium Acetobacterium woodii. These extraordinary features and exceptional structural and functional variability in the rotor of ATP synthases may have arisen as an adaptation to different cellular needs and the extreme physicochemical conditions in the early history of life.     

Improved purification for thermophilic F1F0 ATP synthase using n-dodecyl beta-D-maltoside

Here we report a fast, simple purification for thermophilic F1F0 ATP synthase (TF1F0) that utilizes a cocktail of stabilizing reagents and the detergent n-dodecyl beta-D-maltoside to yield enzyme with an ATPase activity of 41 micromol/min/mg, 2.5-fold higher than that previously reported. ATPase activity was 80% inhibited by the F0-reactive reagent dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, indicating that F1-F0 interactions were largely intact. To measure ATP-driven proton pumping activity, purified TF1F0 was incorporated into liposomes, and the ATP-induced change in internal pH was measured using the fluorescent probe pyranine. In the presence of valinomycin, a maximum ATP-driven deltapH of 0.8 units was obtained. To measure ATP synthesis activity, TF1F0 was incorporated into liposomes with the light-dependent proton pump bacteriorhodopsin. Proteoliposomes were illuminated to generate an electrochemical gradient, after which ADP and inorganic phosphate were added to initiate ATP synthesis. A steady state ATP synthesis activity of 490 nmol/min/mg was achieved after an initial approximately 30-min lag phase.     

Vanadyl as a Probe of the Function of the F1-ATPase-Mg2+ Cofactor

The Mg²⁺ dependent asymmetry of the F₁-ATPase catalytic sites leads to the differences in affinity for nucleotides and is an essential component of the binding-change mechanism. Changes in metal ligands during the catalytic cycle responsible for this asymmetry were characterized by vanadyl (V ^IV + O)²⁺, a functional surrogate for Mg²⁺. The ⁵¹V-hyperfine parameters derived from EPR spectra of VO²⁺ bound to specific sites on F₁ provide a direct probe of the metal ligands. Site-directed mutations of metal ligand residues cause measurable changes in the ⁵¹V-hyperfine parameters of the bound VO²⁺, thereby providing a means to identification. Initial binding of the metal–nucleotide to the low-affinity catalytic site conformation results in metal coordination by hydroxyl groups from the P-loop threonine and catch-loop threonine. Upon conversion to the high-affinity conformation, carboxyl groups from the Walker homology B aspartate and MF₁E197 become ligands in lieu of the hydroxyl groups.