Selection, biological properties and fitness of resistance-breaking strains of Tomato spotted wilt virus in pepper

In glasshouse tests, infective sap from plants infected with 17 different isolates of Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) from four Australian states was inoculated to three Capsicum chinense accessions (PI 152225, PI 159236 and C00943) carrying single genes that confer hypersensitive resistance to TSWV. The normal response to inoculation was development of necrotic (hypersensitive) local lesions in inoculated leaves without systemic invasion, but 3/1386 infected plants also developed systemic susceptible reactions in addition to hypersensitive ones. Similarly when two isolates were inoculated to C. chinense backcross progeny plants, 1/72 developed systemic susceptible reactions in addition to localised hypersensitive ones. Using cultures from the four plants with susceptible reactions and following three to five further cycles of serial subculture in TSWV‐resistant C. chinense plants, four isolates were obtained that gave systemic susceptible type reactions in the three TSWV‐resistant accessions, and in TSWV‐resistant cultivated pepper (C. annuum). When three of these isolates were inoculated to tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) breeding lines with single gene resistance to TSWV, resistance was not overcome. Similarly, none of the four isolates overcame partial resistance to TSWV in Lactuca virosa. When TSWV isolates were inoculated to tomato breeding lines carrying partial resistance from L. chilense, systemic infection developed which was sometimes followed by ‘recovery’. After four successive cycles of serial passage in susceptible cultivated pepper of a mixed culture of a resistance‐breaking isolate with the non resistance‐breaking isolate from which it came, the resistance‐breaking isolate remained competitive as both were still found. However, when the same resistance‐ breaking isolate was cultured alone, evidence of partial reversion to wild‐type behaviour was eventually obtained after five but not four cycles of long term serial subculture in susceptible pepper, as by then the culture had become a mixture of both types of strain. This work suggests that resistance‐breaking strains of TSWV that overcome single gene hypersensitive resistance in pepper are relatively stable. The findings have important implications for situations where resistant pepper cultivars are deployed widely in the field without taking other control measures as part of an integrated TSWV management strategy.     

Transmission of Tomato spotted wilt virus isolates able and unable to overcome tomato or pepper resistance by its vector Frankliniella occidentalis

Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) causes serious diseases of many economically important crops. Disease control has been achieved by breeding tomato and pepper cultivars with the resistance genes Sw‐5 and Tsw, respectively. However, TSWV isolates overcoming these genetic resistances have appeared in several countries. To evaluate the risk of spread of these resistance‐breaking isolates, we tested their ability of transmission by the main vector of TSWV, the thrips Frankliniella occidentalis. We compared the transmission rate by thrips of six TSWV isolates of different biotype (able or unable to overcome this resistance in pepper and tomato), and with divergent genotype (A and B). Our results indicate that the transmission rate was related to the amount of virus accumulated in thrips but not to virus accumulation in the source plants on which thrips acquired the virus. No correlation was found between transmission efficiency by thrips and the genotype or between transmission efficiency and the ability of overcoming both resistances. This result suggests that resistance‐breaking isolates have the same potential to be transmitted as the isolates unable to infect resistant tomato and pepper cultivars.     

Selection of resistance breaking strains of tomato spotted wilt tospovirus

In glasshouse tests, sap from plants infected with 15 different isolates of tomato spotted wilt tospovirus (TSWV) from three Australian states was inoculated to nine genotypes of tomato carrying TSWV resistance gene Sw-5 or one of its alleles. A further two resistant tomato genotypes were inoculated with four isolates each. The normal response in resistant genotypes was development of necrotic local lesions in inoculated leaves without systemic invasion, but 22/752 plants also developed systemic reactions in addition to local hypersensitive ones. Using cultures from two of these systemically infected plants and following four cycles of subculture in TSWV resistant tomato plants, two isolates were obtained that gave susceptible type systemic reactions but no necrotic spots in inoculated leaves of resistant tomatoes. When these two isolates, Da_WA-1d and To_TAS-1d, were maintained by repeated subculture for 10 successive cycles in Nicotiana glutinosa or a susceptible tomato genotype, they still induced susceptible type systemic reactions when inoculated to resistant tomato plants. They were therefore stable resistance breaking isolates as regards overcoming gene Sw-5. When resistance-breaking isolate Da_WA^-1ld multiplied together with original isolate Da_WA-l in susceptible tomato, it was fully competitive with the original isolate. However, when Da_WA-ld and To_TAS-ld were inoculated to TSWV resistant Lycopersicon peruvianum lines PI 128660R and PI 128660S and to TSWV resistant Capsicum chinense lines PI 152225, PI 159236 and AVRDC CO0943, they failed to overcome the resistance, producing only necrotic local lesions without systemic infection. Thus, although the ease of selection, stability and competitive ability of resistance breaking isolates of TSWV is cause for concern, L. peruvianum and C. chinense lines are available which are effective against them. The effectiveness of the resistance to TSWV in nine tomato genotypes was examined in a field experiment. Spread was substantial in the susceptible control genotype infecting 42% of plants. Resistance was ineffective in cv. Bronze Rebel, 26% of plants developing infection. In contrast, it held up well in the other eight resistant genotypes with only 1–3 or no plants of each becoming infected. Accumulated numbers of Thrips tabaci, Frankliniella occidentalis and F. schultzei were closely correlated with TSWV spread.     

Screening Capsicum germplasm for resistance to tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV)

Resistance conferred by the Tsw locus from Capsicum chinense against Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) has been widely used in breeding programmes. Nevertheless, this resistance depends on inoculation conditions, and isolates able to overcome it have already been detected. In this work 29 accessions of several Capsicum species have been mechanically inoculated with TSWV to identify new sources of resistance. Five accessions showed variable percentages of resistant plants, two of which did not show local lesions on inoculated leaves, suggesting that the response was not mediated through hypersensitivity. Two of these accessions also had a remarkable reduced viral accumulation compared to susceptible control. ECU‐973., a C. chinense accession, showed the best performance against TSWV, with 100% resistant plants. This response was confirmed after mechanical inoculation with three different TSWV isolates. The resistance was maintained when the accession was inoculated with TSWV using a high pressure of viruliferous thrips. These results open new possibilities in the development of a durable resistance to TSWV in pepper.     

Identification and comparative mapping of a dominant potyvirus resistance gene cluster in Capsicum

The dominant gene Pvr7 from Capsicum chinense Jacq. ’PI159236’ confers resistance to the pepper mottle potyvirus (PepMoV) Florida (V1182) strain. This gene is tightly linked to the dominant potyvirus resistance gene Pvr4 with observed recombination frequencies of 0.012 to 0.016. A cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence (CAPS) marker linked to Pvr4 was used to localize Pvr4 and, by extension, Pvr7, to linkage group 10 on an interspecific map of pepper. Our results indicated that Pvr4, Pvr7, and Tsw, a gene conferring resistance to tomato spotted wilt virus, comprise the first identified cluster of dominant disease resistance genes in Capsicum L. This position does not correspond to the locations of dominant potyvirus resistance genes in potato or to the positions of any other mapped solanaceous resistance genes or resistance gene homologues. Received: 20 September 1999 / Accepted: 21 March 2000     

Comparison of resistance to potyviruses within Solanaceae: infection of potatoes with tobacco etch potyvirus and peppers with potato A and Y potyviruses

The reaction of several cultivated potato varieties (Solarium tuberosum L.) to three strains of tobacco etch potyvirus (TEV-F, TEV-Mex21 and TEV-ATCC) and the reaction of several pepper lines (Capsicum annuum L. and C. chinense L.) to two strains of potato Y potyvirus (PVY^O and PVY^N) and one strain of potato A potyvirus (PVA-M) was tested. The potato varieties included in this study carried resistance genes against PVY, PVA and potato V potyvirus, but all were susceptible to TEV and developed mottle and mosaic symptoms. TEV was readily transmitted by mechanical inoculation from tobacco and potato to potato, whereas transmission from pepper to potato occurred infrequently. TEV was transmitted through potato tubers, and from pepper to potato plants by aphids. Lack of detectable systemic infection following graft-inoculation indicated extreme resistance to PVY^O and PVA in several pepper lines. No pepper line was systemically infected with PVY^N following mechanical inoculation (graft-inoculation was not carried out with PVY^N). The development of necrotic lesions following mechanical and graft-inoculation indicated hypersensitive response to PVY^O in several pepper lines which resembled the resistance responses to these potyvirus strains in potato. Results of this study together with previous work indicate that C. annuum cv. Avelar is resistant to four potyviruses [PVY, PVA, pepper mottle potyvirus (PepMoV) and some isolates of TEV]; C. annuum cv. Criollo de Morelos and C. chinense PI 152225 and PI 159236 are resistant to three potyviruses (PVY, PepMoV and PVA; and PVY, PepMoV and TEV, respectively); C. annuum 9093–1 and 92016–1 are resistant to PVY and PepMoV; and C. annuum cv. Jupiter and C. annuum cv. RNaky are resistant to PVY^N and PVA.     

Tsw gene-based resistance is triggered by a functional RNA silencing suppressor protein of the Tomato spotted wilt virus

As a result of contradictory reports, the avirulence (Avr) determinant that triggers Tsw gene-based resistance in Capsicum annuum against the Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) is still unresolved. Here, the N and NSs genes of resistance-inducing (RI) and resistance-breaking (RB) isolates were cloned and transiently expressed in resistant Capsicum plants to determine the identity of the Avr protein. It was shown that the NSs^RI protein triggered a hypersensitive response (HR) in Tsw-containing Capsicum plants, but not in susceptible Capsicum, whereas no HR was discerned after expression of the N^RI/RB protein, or when NSs^RB was expressed. Although NSs^RI was able to suppress the silencing of a functional green fluorescence protein (GFP) construct during Agrobacterium tumefaciens transient assays on Nicotiana benthamiana, NSs^RB had lost this capacity. The observation that RB isolates suppressed local GFP silencing during an infection indicated a recovery of RNA silencing suppressor activity for the NSs protein or the presence of another RNA interference (RNAi) suppressor. The role of NSs as RNA silencing suppressor and Avr determinant is discussed in the light of a putative interplay between RNAi and the natural Tsw resistance gene.     

Analysis of Tomato spotted wilt virus NSs protein indicates the importance of the N‐terminal domain for avirulence and RNA silencing suppression

Recently, Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) nonstructural protein NSs has been identified unambiguously as an avirulence (Avr) determinant for Tomato spotted wilt (Tsw)‐based resistance. The observation that NSs from two natural resistance‐breaking isolates had lost RNA silencing suppressor (RSS) activity and Avr suggested a link between the two functions. To test this, a large set of NSs mutants was generated by alanine substitutions in NSs from resistance‐inducing wild‐type strains (NSs^RI), amino acid reversions in NSs from resistance‐breaking strains (NSs^RB), domain deletions and swapping. Testing these mutants for their ability to suppress green fluorescent protein (GFP) silencing and to trigger a Tsw‐mediated hypersensitive response (HR) revealed that the two functions can be separated. Changes in the N‐terminal domain were found to be detrimental for both activities and indicated the importance of this domain, additionally supported by domain swapping between NSs^RI and NSs^RB. Swapping domains between the closely related Tospovirus Groundnut ringspot virus (GRSV) NSs and TSWV NSs^RI showed that Avr functionality could not simply be transferred between species. Although deletion of the C‐terminal domain rendered NSs completely dysfunctional, only a few single‐amino‐acid mutations in the C‐terminus affected both functions. Mutation of a GW/WG motif (position 17/18) rendered NSs completely dysfunctional for RSS and Avr activity, and indicated a putative interaction between NSs and Argonaute 1 (AGO1), and its importance in TSWV virulence and viral counter defence against RNA interference.     

Allelic relationships between genes for resistance to tomato spotted wilt tospovirus in Capsicum chinense

Pepper (Capsicum chinense Jacq.) has been reported to be an important reservoir of resistance genes to tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV). The genes for TSWV resistance present in three C. chinense lines (PI 152225, PI 159236 and Panca) were investigated for allelism. All resistant lines were crossed with each other. Parents, F₁, backcrosses and F₂ populations (including reciprocals) developed from those crosses were mechanically inoculated with a highly virulent TSWV isolate. Susceptible C. annuum cv Magda was used to check inoculum virulence. Fifty plants of the F₁ hybrids; Magda x PI 152225, Magda x PI 159236, and Magda x 'Panca, were also inoculated with the TSWV isolate. The resistance response in all C. chinense sources was associated with a localized, hypersensitive-like reaction that was phenotypically expressed as a prompt formation of large local lesions accompanied by premature leaf abscission. All F₁ generations presented a final score of resistant; indicating that the expression of resistance to TSWV is conditioned by a dominant gene regardless of the source. The absence of segregation for resistance to TSWV that was observed in all generations of the crosses between C. chinense lines indicated that either a tightly linked group of genes exists or that the resistance is governed by the same single major gene (probably the already described Tsw gene). Previous reports have indicated that the Tsw gene is not effective against tospovirus members of serogroup II, i.e. tomato chlorotic spot virus (TCSV) and groundnut ring spot virus (GRSV). In the assay described here, all of the C. chinense lines showed, after mechanical inoculation, an identical susceptibility response to the TCSV and GRSV isolates.     

The Tomato spotted wilt virus cell‐to‐cell movement protein (NSM) triggers a hypersensitive response in Sw‐5‐containing resistant tomato lines and in Nicotiana benthamiana transformed with the functional Sw‐5b resistance gene copy

Although the Sw‐5 gene cluster has been cloned, and Sw‐5b has been identified as the functional gene copy that confers resistance to Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV), its avirulence (Avr) determinant has not been identified to date. Nicotiana tabacum ‘SR1‘ plants transformed with a copy of the Sw‐5b gene are immune without producing a clear visual response on challenge with TSWV, whereas it is shown here that N. benthamiana transformed with Sw‐5b gives a rapid and conspicuous hypersensitive response (HR). Using these plants, from all structural and non‐structural TSWV proteins tested, the TSWV cell‐to‐cell movement protein (NS_M) was confirmed as the Avr determinant using a Potato virus X (PVX) replicon or a non‐replicative pEAQ‐HT expression vector system. HR was induced in Sw‐5b‐transgenic N. benthamiana as well as in resistant near‐isogenic tomato lines after agroinfiltration with a functional cell‐to‐cell movement protein (NS_M) from a resistance‐inducing (RI) TSWV strain (BR‐01), but not with NS_M from a Sw‐5 resistance‐breaking (RB) strain (GRAU). This is the first biological demonstration that Sw‐5‐mediated resistance is triggered by the TSWV NS_M cell‐to‐cell movement protein.     

Phytophthora Root Rot of Pepper Influence of Host Genotype and Pathogen Strain on the Inoculum Density-Disease Severity Relationships

The relationship between inoculum density and mortality or infection was studied for various pepper varieties (Capsicum annuum L.) inoculated with zoospores of two P. capsici isolates. The inoculum concentrations required for 50% mortality (LD 50) varied greatly between pepper varieties and P. capsici isolates: with one isolate, LD 50 was 40 zoospores/ml for a susceptible variety and reached 4,380 to 97,300 zoospores/ml for resistant varieties. For another isolate, LD 50 for the, same varieties ranged from 26 to 800 zoospores/ml. Comparisons between LD 50 and inoculum doses required for 50 % Infection (ID 50) also revealed differences between varieties but not between isolates. After multiple infection correction, regression slopes of infections/inoculum concentration were low for resistant varieties (0.28 to 0.50) but higher for susceptible varieties (0.72 to 0.94), indicating strong competition between spores for infection of resistant plants, but not for infection of susceptible plants. This analysis provided many criteria which can be used to differentiate susceptible from resistant varieties and to evaluate with precision the resistance level of the different resistance genitors used in our breeding program.     

Preference of the vector thrips Frankliniella occidentalis for plants infected with thrips‐non‐transmissible Tomato spotted wilt virus

The effect of a thrips‐non‐transmissible Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) on insect–host interactions between thrips and Arabidopsis thaliana was analysed. A wild‐type TSWV virulent isolate and a TSWV isolate that induces mild symptoms on inoculated plants (TSWV‐Mo) were used in this study, and TSWV‐Mo isolate was obtained by single local lesion isolation using Petunia x hybrid after several passages on Nicotiana rustica plants. In transmission test, although wild‐type TSWV (TSWV‐wt) was transmitted by two thrips species (transmission ratio; Frankliniella occidentalis, 25%; Thrips tabaci, 10%; and T. palmi, 0%), none of the thrips transmitted TSWV‐Mo. Feeding damage by F. occidentalis in A. thaliana plants was more extensive on TSWV‐wt‐infected plants than on TSWV‐Mo‐infected plants, despite comparable preference. Among the markers of plant defences, salicylic acid‐regulated genes were upregulated threefold to sixfold by TSWV‐wt or TSWV‐Mo infection. In contrast, jasmonate‐regulated genes and jasmonate/ethylene‐regulated genes were not affected by the infections. Pull assays showed that adjacent TSWV‐Mo‐infected plants were preferred over uninfected plants. In conclusion, our results showed that the transmissibility by thrips of TSWV is not related to preference of vector thrips and suggested that TSWV‐Mo‐infected plants may be used as attractants for behaviour control of thrips.     

Multi‐targeting of viral RNAs with synthetic trans‐acting small interfering RNAs enhances plant antiviral resistance

RNA interference (RNAi)‐based tools are used in multiple organisms to induce antiviral resistance through the sequence‐specific degradation of target RNAs by complementary small RNAs. In plants, highly specific antiviral RNAi‐based tools include artificial microRNAs (amiRNAs) and synthetic trans‐acting small interfering RNAs (syn‐tasiRNAs). syn‐tasiRNAs have emerged as a promising antiviral tool allowing for the multi‐targeting of viral RNAs through the simultaneous expression of several syn‐tasiRNAs from a single precursor. Here, we compared in tomato plants the effects of an amiRNA construct expressing a single amiRNA and a syn‐tasiRNA construct expressing four different syn‐tasiRNAs against Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV), an economically important pathogen affecting tomato crops worldwide. Most of the syn‐tasiRNA lines were resistant to TSWV, whereas the majority of the amiRNA lines were susceptible and accumulated viral progenies with mutations in the amiRNA target site. Only the two amiRNA lines with higher amiRNA accumulation were resistant, whereas resistance in syn‐tasiRNA lines was not exclusive of lines with high syn‐tasiRNA accumulation. Collectively, these results suggest that syn‐tasiRNAs induce enhanced antiviral resistance because of the combined silencing effect of each individual syn‐tasiRNA, which minimizes the possibility that the virus simultaneously mutates all different target sites to fully escape each syn‐tasiRNA.     

Decreased preference and reproduction, and increased mortality of Frankliniella occidentalis on thrips-resistant pepper plants

The effect of thrips resistance in pepper (Capsicum annuum L.) – previously shown to result in impeded thrips population development (Maris PC, Joosten NN, Goldbach RW & Peters D (2003a) Restricted spread of Tomato spotted wilt virus in thrips‐resistant pepper. Phytopathology 93: 1223–1227. Maris PC, Joosten NN, Goldbach RW & Peters D (2003b) Spread of Tomato spotted wilt virus and population development of Frankliniella occidentalis in pepper resistant to thrips. Proceedings of the Section Experimental and Applied Entomology Netherlands Entomological Society (NEV) Amsterdam 14: 95–101.) – on thrips’[Frankliniella occidentalis Pergande (Thysanoptera: Thripidae)] reproduction, mortality, host preference, and behaviour was investigated. Reproduction, studied by oviposition and larval survival, was negatively affected by the thrips‐resistant (TR) phenotype, whereas the offspring's developmental rate did not differ on TR and the thrips‐susceptible (TS) phenotype. While thrips’ behaviour was hardly affected by thrips resistance, a significant preference for TS plants over the TR plants was found in different tests. When released on either a TR or a TS plant, thrips dispersed at significantly higher rates from the TR plants, demonstrating that not only an impeded reproduction, but also a reduced residence time adds to the reported lower thrips numbers on TR plants.     

The movement protein (NSm) of Tomato spotted wilt virus is the avirulence determinant in the tomato Sw‐5 gene‐based resistance

The avirulence determinant triggering the resistance conferred by the tomato gene Sw‐5 against Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) is still unresolved. Sequence comparison showed two substitutions (C118Y and T120N) in the movement protein NSm present only in TSWV resistance‐breaking (RB) isolates. In this work, transient expression of NSm of three TSWV isolates [RB1 (T120N), RB2 (C118Y) and non‐resistance‐breaking (NRB)] in Nicotiana benthamiana expressing Sw‐5 showed a hypersensitive response (HR) only with NRB. Exchange of the movement protein of Alfalfa mosaic virus (AMV) with NSm supported cell‐to‐cell and systemic transport of the chimeric AMV RNAs into N. tabacum with or without Sw‐5, except for the constructs with NBR when Sw‐5 was expressed, although RB2 showed reduced cell‐to‐cell transport. Mutational analysis revealed that N120 was sufficient to avoid the HR, but the substitution V130I was required for systemic transport. Finally, co‐inoculation of RB and NRB AMV chimeric constructs showed different prevalence of RB or NBR depending on the presence or absence of Sw‐5. These results indicate that NSm is the avirulence determinant for Sw‐5 resistance, and mutations C118Y and T120N are responsible for resistance breakdown and have a fitness penalty in the context of the heterologous AMV system.     

QTL mapping of anthracnose (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Colletotrichum</Emphasis> spp.) resistance in a cross between <Emphasis Type="Italic">Capsicum annuum</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">C. chinense</Emphasis>

Anthracnose fruit rot is an economically important disease that affects pepper production in Indonesia. Strong resistance to two causal pathogens, Colletotrichum gloeosporioides and C. capsici, was found in an accession of Capsicum chinense. The inheritance of this resistance was studied in an F₂ population derived from a cross of this accession with an Indonesian hot pepper variety (Capsicum annuum) using a quantitative trait locus (QTL) mapping approach. In laboratory tests where ripe fruits were artificially inoculated with either C. gloeosporioides or C. capsici, three resistance-related traits were scored: the infection frequency, the true lesion diameter (averaged over all lesions that actually developed), and the overall lesion diameter (averaged over all inoculation points, including those that did not develop lesions). One main QTL was identified with highly significant and large effects on all three traits after inoculation with C. gloeosporioides and on true lesion diameter after inoculation with C. capsici. Three other QTL with smaller effects were found for overall lesion diameter and true lesion diameter after inoculation with C. gloeosporioides, two of which also had an effect on infection frequency. Interestingly, the resistant parent carried a susceptible allele for a QTL for all three traits that was closely linked to the main QTL. The results with C. capsici were based on less observations and therefore less informative. Although the main QTL was shown to have an effect on true lesion diameter after inoculation with C. capsici, no significant QTL were identified for overall lesion diameter or infection frequency.     

Developmentally regulated Arabidopsis thaliana susceptibility to tomato spotted wilt virus infection

Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) is one of the most devastating plant viruses and often causes severe crop losses worldwide. Generally, mature plants become more resistant to pathogens, known as adult plant resistance. In this study, we demonstrated a new phenomenon involving developmentally regulated susceptibility of Arabidopsis thaliana to TSWV. We found that Arabidopsis plants become more susceptible to TSWV as plants mature. Most young 3-week-old Arabidopsis were not infected by TSWV. Infection of TSWV in 4-, 5-, and 6-week-old Arabidopsis increased from 9%, 21%, and 25%, respectively, to 100% in 7- to 8-week-old Arabidopsis plants. Different isolates of TSWV and different tospoviruses show a low rate of infection in young Arabidopsis but a high rate in mature plants. When Arabidopsis dcl2/3/4 or rdr1/2/6 mutant plants were inoculated with TSWV, similar results as observed for the wild-type Arabidopsis plants were obtained. A cell-to-cell movement assay showed that the intercellular movement efficiency of TSWV NSm:GFP fusion was significantly higher in 8-week-old Arabidopsis leaves compared with 4-week-old Arabidopsis leaves. Moreover, the expression levels of pectin methylesterase and β-1,3-glucanase, which play critical roles in macromolecule cell-to-cell trafficking, were significantly up-regulated in 8-week-old Arabidopsis leaves compared with 4-week-old Arabidopsis leaves during TSWV infection. To date, this mature plant susceptibility to pathogen infections has rarely been investigated. Thus, the findings presented here should advance our knowledge on the developmentally regulated mature host susceptibility to plant virus infection.