Mutants of thermotaxis in Dictyostelium discoideum

Amoebae of Dictyostelium discoideum, strain HL50 were mutagenized with N-methyl-N′-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine, cloned, allowed to form pseudoplasmodia and screened for aberrant positive and negative thermotaxis. Three types of mutants were found. Mutant HO428 exhibits only positive thermotaxis over the entire temperature range (no negative thermotaxis). HO596 and HO813 exhibit weakened positive thermotaxis and normal negative thermotaxis. The weakened positive thermotactic response results in a shift toward warmer temperatures in the transition temperature from negative to positive thermotaxis. Mutant HO209 exhibits weakened positive and negative thermotactic responses and has a transition temperature similar to the ‘wild type’ (HL50). The two types of mutants represented by HO428, HO596 and HO813 support the model that positive and negative thermotaxis have separate pathways for temperature sensing. The type of mutants which contains HO209 suggests that those two pathways converge at some point before the response.     

Steepness of thermal gradient is essential to obtain a unified view of thermotaxis in C. elegans

One of the adaptive behaviors of animals in their environment is thermotaxis, by which they migrate toward a preferred temperature. This sensorimotor integration is accomplished by choosing one of two behaviors depending on the surrounding temperature, namely thermophilic or cryophilic movement. Caenorhabditis elegans exhibits thermotaxis and its migration behavior has been analyzed experimentally at both the population and individual levels. However, some experimental data are inconsistent especially for thermophilic movement, which is expected to be observed in lower than favorable temperatures. There are no experimental analyzes that find thermophilic tendencies in the individual behavior of worms, despite multiple reports supporting thermophilic movement of the population. Although theoretical methods have been used to study thermotaxis of C. elegans, no mathematical model provides a consistent explanation for this discrepancy. Here we develop a simple biased random walk model, which describes population behavior, but which is based on the results of individual assays. Our model can integrate all previous experiments without any contradiction. We regenerate all the population patterns reported in past studies and give a consistent explanation for the conflicting results. Our results suggest that thermophilic movement is observed, even in individual movements, when the thermal gradient is sufficiently slight. On the contrary, thermophilic movement disappears when the thermal gradient is too steep. The thermal gradient is thus essential for a comprehensive understanding of the experimental studies of thermotaxis in C. elegans. Our model provides insight into an integrative understanding of the neural activity and thermotactic behavior in C. elegans.     

Thermal limits and chemotaxis in mutants of the nematodeCaenorhabditis elegans defective in thermotaxis

Summary Four mutant strains of the nematodeCaenorhabditis elegans previously isolated as defective in thermotaxis (Hedgecock and Russell, 1975) were compared to the wild type in tests of their thermal range of activity and chemotaxis. The cold side of the temperature-activity curves of all four strains were different from wild type. The curves of the two cryophilic strains (EH65 and EH67) were shifted to colder temperatures. The curves of the other two mutant strains were shifted to warmer temperatures. In tests of chemotaxis to a variety of stimuli, strain EH61 made no response to any, EH71 made weak responses to all, and the remaining two strains made responses equal to wild type except for weaker responses to three chemical stimuli. It is concluded that thermotaxis shares specific gene requirements with processes controlling both thermal limits and sensory reception.     

A Mechanism for Precision-Sensing via a Gradient-Sensing Pathway: A Model of Escherichia coli Thermotaxis

Thermotaxis is the phenomenon where an organism directs its movement toward its preferred temperature. So far, the molecular origin for this precision-sensing behavior remains a puzzle. We propose a model of Escherichia coli thermotaxis and show that the precision-sensing behavior in E. coli thermotaxis can be carried out by the gradient-sensing chemotaxis pathway under two general conditions. First, the thermosensor response to temperature is inverted by its internal adaptation state. For E. coli, chemoreceptor Tar changes from a warm sensor to a cold sensor on increase of its methylation level. Second, temperature directly affects the adaptation kinetics. The adapted activity in E. coli increases with temperature in contrast to the perfect adaptation to chemical stimuli. Given these two conditions, E. coli thermotaxis is achieved by the cryophilic and thermophilic responses for temperature above and below a critical temperature T_c, which is encoded by internal pathway parameters. Our model results are supported by both experiments with adaptation-disabled mutants and the recent temperature impulse response measurements for wild-type cells. T_c is predicted to decrease with the background attractant concentration. This mechanism for precision sensing in an adaptive gradient-sensing system may apply to other organisms, such as Dictyostelium discoideum and Caenorhabditis elegans.     

Behavioural responses of freshwater phytoplanktonic flagellates to a temperature gradient

Photoresponses of motile phytoplanktonic flagellates have been widely studied, whereas the behavioural responses of these organisms to temperature, and their potential ecological consequences, have rarely been considered. This study investigated the population responses and individual swimming trajectories of five phylogenetically contrasting species of freshwater flagellates exposed to a gradient of temperature in micro-scale preference chambers. Population responses demonstrated a species-dependent diversity in thermoresponsive behaviour. Across a gradient of 9.8 to 15.1°;C which simulated the typical range of temperature across a thermocline in a temperate monomictic lake, Ceratium furcoides, Chlamydomonas moewusii, Dinobryon sertularia and Plagioselmis nannoplanctica all preferred the highest temperatures. In contrast, Euglena gracilis preferred the lowest temperature. Analysis of the swimming behaviour of individual cells confirmed preferences and demonstrated that, in all species, a combination of tactic and kinetic reactions was responsible for these accumulations. For the first time, controlled positive and negative thermotaxes towards a temperature preference were identified. This thermotactic orientation, in conjunction with a reduction in directionality of response in the preference zone and with ortho- and klino-thermokinesis, enabled cells to maintain position at preferred temperatures. Specifically, in all species apart from P. nannoplanctica, significant ortho-kinetic increases in swimming speed permitted rapid movement of cells away from unfavourable conditions, while a reduction in speed and a klino-kinetic increase in rate of turning (in all five species) maintained position within favoured temperatures. This ability to detect, orientate and accumulate within a temperature gradient may be triggered by physiological processes and presents ecological advantages. Behavioural response to temperature may optimize growth, influence the spatial and temporal distribution of flagellates, particularly the diel position of cells during migration, and contribute to the delineation of niche separation.     

Distinct thermal migration behaviors in response to different thermal gradients in Caenorhabditis elegans

The nematode Caenorhabditis elegans exhibits a complex behavior called thermotaxis in response to temperature. This behavior is defined as a form of associative learning, in which temperature pairs with the presence or absence of food. Different interpretations have been drawn from the diverse results obtained by several groups, mainly because of the application of different methodologies for the analysis of thermotaxis. To clarify the discrepancies in behavioral observations and subsequent interpretations by different laboratories, we attempted to systematize several parameters to observe thermotaxis behavior as originally defined by Hedgecock and Russell in 1975. In this study, we show clearly how C. elegans can show a conditioned migration toward colder or warmer areas on a thermal gradient, given certain criteria necessary for the observation of thermotaxis. We thus propose to distinguish thermotaxis from other temperature-related behaviors, such as the warm avoidance response displayed at temperature gradients of 1°C/cm and steeper.     

Sensitivity of Paramecium Thermotaxis to Temperature Change

SYNOPSIS. The relationship to swimming velocity of the critical temperature gradient necessary for inducing thermotaxis in Paramecium caudatum was analyzed at various temperatures and viscosities. Since the critical temperature gradient was linearly proportional to the inverse of the swimming velocity, it is concluded that P. caudatum detects temperature changes by locomotion through space and thus exhibits thermotaxis, provided the rate of change is > 0.055 C/sec. The swimming velocity jump was observed when the ciliates were subjected to a stepwise temperature change toward an optimum with a rate > 0.05 C/sec; the jump was not observed, however, when they were subjected to a change toward an unpreferred temperature with the same rate. Hence, thermotaxis can be explained partly by the swimming velocity jump brought about when the cells are swimming toward an optimum temperature in a spatial gradient. It is suggested that thermotaxis might be a direct manifestation of the dynamic properties of membrane as a receptor.     

Simulation of C. elegans thermotactic behavior in a linear thermal gradient using a simple phenomenological motility model

The nematode Caenorhabditis elegans has been reported to exhibit thermotaxis, a sophisticated behavioral response to temperature. However, there appears to be some inconsistency among previous reports. The results of population-level thermotaxis investigations suggest that C. elegans can navigate to the region of its cultivation temperature from nearby regions of higher or lower temperature. However, individual C. elegans nematodes appear to show only cryophilic tendencies above their cultivation temperature. A Monte-Carlo style simulation using a simple individual model of C. elegans provides insight into clarifying apparent inconsistencies among previous findings. The simulation using the thermotaxis model that includes the cryophilic tendencies, isothermal tracking and thermal adaptation was conducted. As a result of the random walk property of locomotion of C. elegans, only cryophilic tendencies above the cultivation temperature result in population-level thermophilic tendencies. Isothermal tracking, a period of active pursuit of an isotherm around regions of temperature near prior cultivation temperature, can strengthen the tendencies of these worms to gather around near-cultivation-temperature regions. A statistical index, the thermotaxis (TTX) L-skewness, was introduced and was useful in analyzing the population-level thermotaxis of model worms.     

Genetic control of temperature preference in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans

Animals modify behavioral outputs in response to environmental changes. C. elegans exhibits thermotaxis, where well-fed animals show attraction to their cultivation temperature on a thermal gradient without food. We show here that feeding-state-dependent modulation of thermotaxis is a powerful behavioral paradigm for elucidating the mechanism underlying neural plasticity, learning, and memory in higher animals. Starved experience alone could induce aversive response to cultivation temperature. Changing both cultivation temperature and feeding state simultaneously evoked transient attraction to or aversion to the previous cultivation temperature: recultivation of starved animals with food immediately induced attraction to the temperature associated with starvation, although the animals eventually exhibited thermotaxis to the new temperature associated with food. These results suggest that the change in feeding state quickly stimulates the switch between attraction and aversion for the temperature in memory and that the acquisition of new temperature memory establishes more slowly. We isolated aho (abnormal hunger orientation) mutants that are defective in starvation-induced cultivation-temperature avoidance. Some aho mutants responded normally to changes in feeding state with respect to locomotory activity, implying that the primary thermosensation followed by temperature memory formation remains normal and the modulatory aspect of thermotaxis is specifically impaired in these mutants.     

Novel and conserved protein macoilin is required for diverse neuronal functions in Caenorhabditis elegans

Neural signals are processed in nervous systems of animals responding to variable environmental stimuli. This study shows that a novel and highly conserved protein, macoilin (MACO-1), plays an essential role in diverse neural functions in Caenorhabditis elegans. maco-1 mutants showed abnormal behaviors, including defective locomotion, thermotaxis, and chemotaxis. Expression of human macoilin in the C. elegans nervous system weakly rescued the abnormal thermotactic phenotype of the maco-1 mutants, suggesting that macoilin is functionally conserved across species. Abnormal thermotaxis may have been caused by impaired locomotion of maco-1 mutants. However, calcium imaging of AFD thermosensory neurons and AIY postsynaptic interneurons of maco-1 mutants suggest that macoilin is required for appropriate responses of AFD and AIY neurons to thermal stimuli. Studies on localization of MACO-1 showed that C. elegans and human macoilins are localized mainly to the rough endoplasmic reticulum. Our results suggest that macoilin is required for various neural events, such as the regulation of neuronal activity.     

Pulse-induced phototropisms in oat and maize coleoptiles

Phototropisms induced by a pulse (1-30 seconds) of blue light in red-light-grown coleoptiles of oats (Avena sativa L.) and maize (Zea mays L.) were investigated in terms of fluence-response relationships and time courses. Phototropic stimulation was made by a laser beam (457.9 nanometers), allowing application of high-fluence pulses. The phototropic fluence-response curves for oats and maize revealed two peaks in the positive range, thus indicating the occurrence of two separable pulse-induced positive responses. The response at low fluences corresponded to the `first positive curvature.' The response at high fluences was very small in oats, but was large in maize. Reciprocity was valid in this high-fluence response (tested only for maize), indicating that it is distinct from the so-called `second positive curvature.' In oats, the trough between the two positive responses fell into the negative range. This negative response, corresponding to the `first negative curvature,' showed time courses distinct from those of `first positive curvature:' the negative response was induced after a longer time lag and developed with a more gradual increase of the rate of bending. The maximal rate of the negative response was as high as one-half of that of first positive curvature. In maize, the trough between the two responses was in the positive range, and the time-course result revealed no apparent response counteracting the positive responses. Physiological and ecological implications of the pulse-induced phototropisms are discussed.     

Environmental-temperature and internal-state dependent thermotaxis plasticity of nematodes

Thermotaxis behavior of Caenorhabditis elegans is robust and highly plastic. A pair of sensory neurons, AFD, memorize environmental/cultivation temperature and communicate with a downstream neural circuit to adjust the temperature preference of the animal. This results in a behavioral bias where worms will move toward their cultivation temperature on a thermal gradient. Thermotaxis of C. elegans is also affected by the internal state and is temporarily abolished when worms are starved. Here I will discuss how C. elegans is able to modulate its behavior based on temperature by integrating environmental and internal information. Recent studies show that some parasitic nematodes have a similar thermosensory mechanism to C. elegans and exhibit cultivation-temperature-dependent thermotaxis. I will also discuss the common neural mechanisms that regulate thermosensation and thermotaxis in C. elegans and Strongyloides stercoralis.     

Construction of a thermotaxis chamber providing spatial or temporal thermal gradients monitored by an infrared video camera system.

A thermotaxis chamber was constructed to quantitatively study thermotaxis in eukaryotic amoeboid cells. The apparatus provided either spatial or temporal temperature gradients in an observation chamber set in an inverted microscope. With an infrared video camera system, spatial thermal gradients were monitored directly and the temperature at the actual location of the cells could be estimated accurately. This enabled a precise determination of the strength of thermal stimuli. With this apparatus, we were able to simultaneously measure temperature and observe cellular behavior directly. This feature permits quantitative studies on stimulus-response relationships. The utility of the apparatus was demonstrated by thermotaxis assay under a spatial thermal gradient in polymorphonuclear leukocytes. Since this apparatus can also provide temporal thermal gradients, it may have several applications in studies of temperature-dependent phenomena in cell biology.     

Feel the heat: The effect of temperature on development, behavior and central pattern generation in 3rd instar Calliphora vicina larvae

Like in all poikilothermic animals, higher temperatures increase developmental rate and activity in Calliphora vicina larvae. We therefore could expect temperature to have a persistent effect on the output of the feeding and crawling central pattern generators (CPGs). When confronted with a steep temperature gradient, larvae show evasive behavior after touching the substrate with the cephalic sense organs. Beside this reflex behavior the terminal- and dorsal organ might also mediate long term CPG modulation. Both organs were thermally stimulated while their response was recorded from the maxillary- or antennal nerve. The terminal organ showed a tonic response characteristic while the dorsal organ was not sensitive to temperature. Thermal stimulation of the terminal organ did not affect the ongoing patterns of fictive feeding or crawling, recorded from the antennal- or abdominal nerve respectively. A selective increase of the central nervous system (CNS) temperature accelerated the motor patterns of both feeding and crawling. We propose that temperature affects centrally generated behavior via two pathways: short term changes like thermotaxis are mediated by the terminal organ, while long term adaptations like increased feeding rate are caused by temperature sensitive neurons in the CNS which were recently shown to exist in Drosophila larvae.     

Responses of Dictyostelium discoideum to Multiple Environmental Stimuli

The movement responses of the cellular slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum to multiple stimuli were investigated. The responses were found to differ depending on the developmental stage of the organism. A novel response, positive gravitaxis, was found in Dictyostelium slugs but not in amoebae. In the presence of a simultaneous light stimulus, gravitaxis is effective only at low fluence rates. Slugs showed positive thermotaxis in a thermal gradient (0.2 °C cm^?1) and ignored the simultaneous light stimulus at low fluence rates (< 10^?3 W m^?2), while at higher fluence rates they moved toward the light source. With a combination of a thermal gradient and gravity Dictyostelium slugs clearly oriented thermotactically ignoring the gravistimulus.     

Thermal selection behaviour in the estuarine goby Gillichthys mirabilis Cooper

The estuarine goby Gillichthys mirabilis behaviorally thermoregulates when placed in a laboratory temperature gradient. Avoidance of temperatures above 23°C is the most evident component of this thermotaxis. Temperature preferences of non-acclimated fish do not vary significantly as a function of season; nor does temperature acclimation alter the preferendum. Varying the temperature range of the gradient apparently modifies thermotaxis. Negative phototaxis evidenced by this species is subjugated by thermal preferences. Temperature preference does not vary diurnally. The heat resistance of this species was determined; there is no apparent relationship between heat resistance and temperature preference.     

Persistent thermal input controls steering behavior in Caenorhabditis elegans

Motile organisms actively detect environmental signals and migrate to a preferable environment. Especially, small animals convert subtle spatial difference in sensory input into orientation behavioral output for directly steering toward a destination, but the neural mechanisms underlying steering behavior remain elusive. Here, we analyze a C. elegans thermotactic behavior in which a small number of neurons are shown to mediate steering toward a destination temperature. We construct a neuroanatomical model and use an evolutionary algorithm to find configurations of the model that reproduce empirical thermotactic behavior. We find that, in all the evolved models, steering curvature are modulated by temporally persistent thermal signals sensed beyond the time scale of sinusoidal locomotion of C. elegans. Persistent rise in temperature decreases steering curvature resulting in straight movement of model worms, whereas fall in temperature increases curvature resulting in crooked movement. This relation between temperature change and steering curvature reproduces the empirical thermotactic migration up thermal gradients and steering bias toward higher temperature. Further, spectrum decomposition of neural activities in model worms show that thermal signals are transmitted from a sensory neuron to motor neurons on the longer time scale than sinusoidal locomotion of C. elegans. Our results suggest that employments of temporally persistent sensory signals enable small animals to steer toward a destination in natural environment with variable, noisy, and subtle cues.     

Thermotaxis of human sperm cells in extraordinarily shallow temperature gradients over a wide range

On the basis of the finding that capacitated (ready to fertilize) rabbit and human spermatozoa swim towards warmer temperatures by directing their movement along a temperature gradient, sperm thermotaxis has been proposed to be one of the processes guiding these spermatozoa to the fertilization site. Although the molecular mechanism underlying sperm thermotaxis is gradually being revealed, basic questions related to this process are still open. Here, employing human spermatozoa, we addressed the questions of how wide the temperature range of thermotaxis is, whether this range includes an optimal temperature or whether spermatozoa generally prefer swimming towards warmer temperatures, whether or not they can sense and respond to descending temperature gradients, and what the minimal temperature gradient is to which they can thermotactically respond. We found that human spermatozoa can respond thermotactically within a wide temperature range (at least 29-41°C), that within this range they preferentially accumulate in warmer temperatures rather than at a single specific, preferred temperature, that they can respond to both ascending and descending temperature gradients, and that they can sense and thermotactically respond to temperature gradients as low as <0.014°C/mm. This temperature gradient is astonishingly low because it means that as a spermatozoon swims through its entire body length (46 μm) it can sense and respond to a temperature difference of <0.0006°C. The significance of this surprisingly high temperature sensitivity is discussed.     

The LIM homeobox gene ceh-14 confers thermosensory function to the AFD neurons in Caenorhabditis elegans

In Caenorhabditis elegans three pairs of neurons, AFD, AIY, and AIZ, play a key role in thermosensation. The LIM homeobox gene ceh-14 is expressed in the AFD thermosensory neurons. ceh-14 mutant animals display athermotactic behaviors, although the neurons are still present and differentiated. Two other LIM homeobox genes, ttx-3 and lin-11, function in the two interneurons AIY and AIZ, respectively. Thus, the three key thermosensory neurons are specified by three different LIM homeobox genes. ceh-14 ttx-3 lin-11 triple mutant animals have a basic cryophilic thermotaxis behavior indicative of a second thermotaxis pathway. Misexpression of ceh-14 in chemosensory neurons can restore thermotactic behavior without impairing the chemosensory function. Thus, ceh-14 confers thermosensory function to neurons.