Studies on resistance in snails: Specific resistance induced by irradiated miracidia of Echinostoma lindoense in Biomphalaria glabrata snails

In juvenile Biomphalaria glabrata snails exposed to irradiated Echinostoma lindoense miracidia, the sporocysts migrated to the heart at the same speed as did nonirradiated sporocysts in control snails. However, in each snail so exposed to irradiated miracidia, amebocyte clumps in the snail's heart destroyed the sporocysts within 2–9 days post-exposure. This process induced a strong, highly specific resistance to homologous reinfection in these previously susceptible snails. The snails remained susceptible to Schistosoma mansoni and Paryphostomum segregatum (Echinostomatidae), but were partially resistant to Echinostoma paraensei and E. liei, two echinostome species closely related to E. lindoense.     

Capacity of irradiated echinostome sporocysts to protect Schistosoma mansoni in resistant Biomphalaria glabrata

Three closely related species of Echinostoma flukes each has a distinctive pattern of protection of Schistosoma mansoni in schistosome-resistant Biomphalaria glabrata host snails. Protection of developing S. mansoni by irradiated E. paraensei sporocysts in the schistosome-resistant snail host was strong; protection induced by irradiated E. lindoense and E. liei sporocysts was weak or not measurable. The capacity of irradiated E. paraensei sporocysts to interfere with the host's innate anti-schistosome response also differed between strains of B. glabrata. Protection of S. mansoni strain Lc-1 was greater in B. glabrata strain 10-R2 than it was in strain M-RLc snails. Irradiated E. paraensei sporocysts also induced a different response to the two schistosome strains in a single host strain. Irradiated E. paraensei sporocysts induced in B. glabrata 10-R2 snails a stronger protection of S. mansoni strain PR-1 than of strain Lc-1. Exposure of each snail to the irradiated E. paraensei miracidia usually protected the following challenge schistosome infection better when 30 rather than 10 irradiated echinostome miracidia were used.     

Acquired resistance to echinostomes in four Biomphalaria glabrata strains

Four strains of Biomphalaria glabrata showed a distinctive pattern of acquired resistance to each of 3 echinostome species. Juvenile albino B. glabrata from our laboratory NIH stock developed a strong resistance to Echinostoma lindoense but only a weak one to E. paraensei and a moderate one to E. liei. Juvenile B. glabrata 10-R2 strain developed a strong acquired resistance to E. lindoense but a weak one to E. paraensei and E. liei. Juvenile B. glabrata M-RLc strain developed a strong acquired resistance to E. lindoense and a moderate one to E. paraensei and E. liei. Juvenile B. glabrata 641 strain developed a moderate acquired resistance to E. lindoense, a weak one to E. liei and no measurable resistance to E. paraensei.     

Synergism and antagonism between two trematode species in the snail Lymnaea rubiginosa

Synergism and antagonism between two trematode species in the snail Lymnaea rubiginosa. Internationaljournal for Parasitology 3: 729–733. Sporocysts of Trichobilharzia brevis in the snail exerted a synergistic effect on sporocysts of Echinostoma hystricosum: The rate of infection with E. hystricosum was much higher in snails harboring T. brevis than in control snails with no other infection. Rediae of E. hystricosum and sporocysts of T. brevis were antagonistic, the predatory rediae consuming the sporocysts and ultimately eliminating T. brevis from the snail. Once a snail was occupied by E. hystricosum it could not be superinfected by T. brevis.     

Host reactions in Biomphalaria glabrata to Schistosoma mansoni miracidia, involving variations in parasite strains, numbers and sequence of exposures

M-line Biomphalaria glabrata snails are susceptible to Puerto Rican (PR-1) strain of Schistosoma mansoni, but are resistant to a St. Lucian (LC-1) strain. 10-R2 B. glabrata snails are resistant to both strains of S. mansoni. When 10-R2 snails were exposed repeatedly to PR-1 S. mansoni miracidia for 5 consecutive days, all of the sporocysts were encapsulated and destroyed by the snails. Thirty-four per cent of sporocysts examined in M-line snails with similar exposures were also degraded. In double concurrent infections of M-line B. glabrata with [³H]leucine-labeled and unlabeled PR-1 and Lc-1 S. mansoni, the incompatible Lc-1 miracidia were selectively attacked and destroyed. This destruction occurred irrespective of the sequence of exposure of the 2 strains of miracidia, and whether or not the miracidia were labeled. Successful superinfection of M-line B. glabrata with homologous S. mansoni miracidia was obtained at least 4 days after the primary exposure to the miracidia.     

Studies on resistance in snails. 5. Tissue reactions to Echinostoma lincloense in naturally resistant Biomphalaria glabrata.

Laboratory-raised juvenile albino Biomphalaria glabrata snails show a wide range of natural resistance to a single infection with 50 or 100 miracidia of Echinostoma lindoense. In the most resistant snails all sporocysts are destroyed in peripheral tissues soon after miracidial penetration. In less resistant snails some sporocysts reach the heart where they are encapsulated. In fully susceptible snails, all sporocysts rapidly migrate to the heart, where they mature and continue to develop. The greater part of our B. glabrata colony consists of snails in which sporocysts reaching the heart will survive, but in which a varying number of sporocysts will be destroyed in the tissues. These snails are usually considered susceptible, as they do become infected. Tissue reactions induced by sporocysts following a single infection in naturally resistant snails are similar to reactions in snails with an acquired resistance. In fully susceptible snails, the amebocyte-producing organ remains small and inactive. It is slightly to moderately stimulated in partially resistant snails in which destruction of sporocysts occurs in the tissues and surviving larvae are found in the ventricle. In snails in which amebocyte aggregates or capsules develop in the ventricle, the organ becomes markedly enlarged. Migration of sporocysts in the snail appears not to be continuous, as periodic rests seem to occur. Migration follows intrusion of the sporocyst through the tissues, induced by bodily distension and contraction, and then proceeds within the arteries against the blood flow, passing from one endothelial attachment site to another, possibly aided by negative pressure during ventricular diastole.     

Specificity of natural resistance to trematode infections in Biomphalaria glabrata

The 10-R2 strain of Biomphalaria glabrata was strongly resistant to various strains of Schistosoma mansoni in its laboratory of origin (NIH) and to three strains of S. mansoni we tested against it. However, subsequent development of three inbred lines of B. glabrata 10-R2 snails, separately maintained in our San Francisco laboratory, showed slight loss of resistance in one colony, very much less resistance (or partial susceptibility) in another, and retention of the original resistance in a third to the Puerto Rico (PR-1) strain of S. mansoni. No selection for resistance to infection was involved in the breeding protocol for these 10-R2 lines, so the changes were apparently random ones that became established in the separate inbred substrains. In spite of their changed response to the PR-1 strain of S. mansoni, all three 10-R2 substrains retained only slightly diminished resistance to S. mansoni Lc-1 strain and an essentially undiminished resistance to irradiated Echinostoma lindoense, E. paraensei and E. liei sporocysts. This suggests that natural resistance to S. mansoni PR-1 in B. glabrata is specific, a response that differs from the host response to either S. mansoni Lc-1 or to the echinostomes.     

Further characterization of passively transferred resistance to Schistosoma mansoni in the snail intermediate host Biomphalaria glabrata.

A heat-labile plasma factor from genetically resistant 10-R2 Biomphalaria glabrata snails confers passively transferred resistance (PTR) to Schistosoma mansoni when injected into susceptible snails within 24-hr of exposure to miracidia. However, no additional details on PTR have emerged since the initial 1984 report, nor has the plasma resistance factor been characterized. In the present study, new information is provided on the occurrence of resistance factor in plasma of additional types of snails, effect of "priming" resistant plasma donors by prior exposure to miracidia, duration of PTR, molecular weight of resistance factor, and fate of sporocysts in snails with PTR. Susceptible NIH albino snails injected 24 hr prior to exposure to miracidia with individual samples of plasma from a different strain (Salvador B. glabrata) or a different species (B. obstructa) of nonsusceptible snail displayed infection prevalences of 49% or 59% of control levels, respectively, whereas injections of homologous plasma had no effect. PTR was not enhanced by prior exposure of resistant Salvador plasma donors to miracidia. Unexpectedly, PTR induced by injections of Salvador plasma persisted for at least 21 days. The molecular weight of the resistance factor(s) was between 10 and 30 kDa, based on results of centrifugal ultrafiltration. A significantly higher proportion of dead sporocysts occurred in histological sections of tentacles from snails injected with Salvador plasma than in tentacles of snails injected with NIH albino plasma at 7 days postexposure to miracidia. Most dead sporocysts in Salvador plasma-injected snails were undergoing gradual degeneration, rather than rapid, hemocyte-mediated destruction, as occurred in Salvador snails.     

Ribeiroia marini: Irradiated miracidia and induction of acquired resistance in Biomphalaria glabrata

Biomphalaria glabrata snails sensitized by exposure to X-irradiated miracidia of the trematode, Ribeiroia marini, acquired resistance to challenge with nonirradiated R. marini miracidia. Resistance was acquired within 1 day of sensitization; was strongest at 1 week, when infection rates of sensitized snails were 15% of the controls (i.e., $\text{S}\text{C}\text{= 0.15}$); and persisted for at least 3 weeks. By 30 days the difference between the infection rates of sensitized and control snails was no longer statistically significant. As in previous studies with echinostomes, acquired resistance to R. marini was characterized histologically by the destruction of irradiated sporocysts by host amoebocytes. Following destruction of all irradiated sporocysts, snails became resistant and encapsulated and destroyed nonirradiated challenge sporocysts within 1 day postchallenge. Associated with sporocyst destruction was an enlargement of the amoebocyte-producing organ, which showed intense mitotic activity. A proportion of the nonirradiated challenge sporocysts were also destroyed in most nonsensitized control snails, which consequently had a temporarily enlarged amoebocyte-producing organ. In contrast to acquired resistance reported to echinotomes, which is quite specific, acquired resistance to R. marini was associated with nonsusceptibility to both Echinostoma paraensei ($\text{S}\text{C}\text{= 0.19}$) and Schistosoma mansoni ($\text{S}\text{C}\text{= 0.81}$).     

Rescue of sporocysts of Schistosoma mansoni in nonsusceptible Biomphalaria by head-foot transplantation into susceptible snails

To measure the longevity of sporocysts of Schistosoma mansoni in nonsusceptible snails (13-16-R1 and Salvador strains of Biomphalaria glabrata, and Biomphalaria obstructa), the head-foot (HF) of miracidia-exposed snails was transplanted into the hemocoel of a susceptible NIH albino recipient at 1-36 days postexposure (DPE). Recipient snails which were not exposed to miracidia then were monitored for infection transferred by the implant, and infection prevalences in recipients of HF transplants from nonsusceptible donors were compared to those in snails implanted with an HF from NIH albino donors. Transplants from NIH albino snails between 1 to 15 DPE infected 98% of recipients. Similarly, at 1 DPE, 69-85% of transplants from nonsusceptible snails contained viable sporocysts, as shown by resulting patent infections in the recipients. Recipient infection prevalence, and presumably numbers of transplants containing viable sporocysts, declined as a function of DPE, and by 5-9 DPE this decrease was significant for all 3 types of nonsusceptible donors. However, viable sporocysts still occurred in B. obstructa and 13-16-R1 B. glabrata as late as 19 and 20 DPE, respectively, and in Salvador B. glabrata as late as 33 DPE. Thus, sporocysts persist in nonsusceptible snails considerably longer than suggested by results of previous histological studies.     

Schistosoma mansoni modulation of phagocytosis in Biomphalaria glabrata

Both short-term (3 hr) exposure of Biomphalaria glabrata snails (M-line and 13-16-R1) to Schistosoma mansoni (PR1) miracidia and in vitro incubation of parasite sporocysts with host hemolymph components altered host phagocytic ability. Hemocytes obtained from susceptible (M-line) snails that had been exposed to parasite miracidia for 3 hr showed reduced levels of phagocytosis of yeast cells in vitro compared to hemocytes from unexposed individuals. Incubation of whole hemolymph with sporocysts in vitro also reduced yeast phagocytosis in this susceptible strain. In contrast, resistant (13-16-R1) hemocytes showed increased levels of yeast phagocytosis after in vitro incubation with the parasite, and the opsonic properties of 13-16-R1 plasma were greater after exposure of snails to miracidia. These strain-specific effects of S. mansoni on host hemocyte phagocytosis and plasma opsonization were seen only when both plasma and hemocytes were present at the time of exposure to the parasite.     

Schistosomatium douthitti: Exposure of Lymnaea catascopium to irradiated miracidia

Irradiation of Schistosomatium douthitti miracidia (4000, 5000, or 6000 rad) did not substantially alter their behavior or ability to penetrate their snail host. Treatment with 4000 rad was not sufficient to prevent all miracidia from establishing patent infections in Lymnaea catascopium, although significantly fewer snails exposed to these miracidia shed cercariae than did controls exposed to normal miracidia. Irradiation of miracidia with either 5000 or 6000 rad totally prevented cercarial production. Although destruction of irradiated mother sporocysts by encapsulating amebocytes was occasionally observed, most expanded without concomitant multiplication of germinal cells and embryo production and then collapsed. They generally persisted in this state throughout the period of observation (32 days). Snails sensitized by exposure to irradiated miracidia and challenged 2 or 10 days later with normal miracidia were as likely to develop patent infections as were snails exposed only to normal miracidia. Double sensitization of snails with irradiated miracidia also failed to confer protection upon challenge with normal miracidia. Most challenge sporocysts developed normally, often in close proximity to collapsed irradiated sporocysts.     

Pathology and host responses induced by Schistosomatium douthitti in the freshwater snail Lymnaea catascopium.

Most Schitosomatium douthitti miracidia penetrated the esophageal wall of Lymnaea catascopium without provoking amoebocyte encapsulation responses or extensive pathological changes. Amoebocytes frequently attached to developing mother and daughter sporocysts, but did not encapsulate or destroy them. Pressure resulting from extensive growth of mother sporocysts ruptured the transverse membrane of some snails. After releasing daughter sporocysts, mother sporocysts in some snails were destroyed by amoebocytes. Many migrating cercariae became trapped in the tissues of L. catascopium, particularly in the posterior portion of the foot, and were encapsulated and destroyed. Large increases in numbers of amoebocytes in the anterior portion of the lung roof of infected snails were noted, even before cercarial production had been initiated. Atrophy of the digestive gland occurred in infected snails.     

Studies on resistance in snails. 3. Tissue reactions to Echinostoma lindoense sporocysts in sensitized and resensitized Biomphalaria glabrata.

The resistance of Biomphalaria glabrata snails that have been sensitized by various levels of irradiated or nonirradiated Echinostoma lindoense miracidia increased after a second challenge infection with nonirradiated miracidia of the same species. This was demonstrated by increased suppression of migrating capacity of invading sporocysts, an accelerated host tissue reaction, and a greater tendency of snail amebocytes to flatten while attacking the parasite. Three methods of elimination of invading sporocysts were observed: (1) encapsulation by amebocytes followed by destruction of the sporocysts; (2) expulsion of the sporocyst through the host epithelium after its encapsulation in the subepithelial tissues; (3) blockade of the parasite's entry into subepithelial tissues by a localized amebocyte aggregation. The basic mechanism of host snail response to a single or a repeated challenge infection appears to be similar, though an anamnestic reaction is evident in the accelerated response following a second challenge exposure.     

Incompatibility between miracidia of Schistosoma mansoni and Helisoma duryi occurs at two stages: penetration and intramolluscan establishment

Helisoma spp. snails are not susceptible to infection with miracidia of Schistosoma mansoni because the miracidia do not penetrate them. However, in view of the phylogenetic proximity and histocompatibility between Helisoma spp. and the normal intermediate host, Biomphalaria glabrata , schistosome miracidia conceivably could survive if experimentally introduced into the hemocoel of Helisoma spp. To test this hypothesis, schistosome-susceptible NIH albino B. glabrata, schistosome-resistant Salvador B. glabrata, and Helisoma duryi were injected with miracidia of S. mansoni, and the outcome was followed both by monitoring snails for infection for several weeks and by histological examination at 24 and 48 hr post-injection (PI). Patent infections developed in most NIH albino snails but in none of the Salvador B. glabrata or H. duryi individuals. Histological analysis showed a higher proportion of normal sporocysts in various tissues of NIH albino snails at both time periods relative to Salvador snails, which contained mostly sporocysts undergoing hemocytic encapsulation. In H. duryi , nearly all sporocysts were dead by 48 hr PI.     

Acid phosphatase in granulocytic capsules formed in strains of Biomphalaria glabrata totally and partially resistant to Schistosoma mansoni

Cheng T. C. and Garrabrant T. A. 1977. Acid phosphatase in granulocytic capsules formed in strains of Biomphalaria glabrata totally and partially resistant to Schistosoma mansoni. International Journal for Parasitology7: 467–472. Acid phosphatase (EC 3.1.3.2, orthophosphoric monoester phosphohydrolase) has been demonstrated cytochemically in isolated granulocytes from the hemolymph of three strains of Biomphalaria glabrata. This enzyme was not detected in hyalinocytes. By employing acid phosphatase as a marker, it was determined that the cells comprising the capsule surrounding Schislosoma mansoni mother sporocysts in a totally and partially resistant strain of B. glabrata are granulocytes.The process of encapsulation of S. mansoni mother sporocysts in resistant B. glabrata was traced for 72 h post-penetration by miracidia and has been ascertained to involve two stages: (1) enlargement of the granuloma around intact sporocysts, followed by (2) disintegration of the parasite and a decrease in the size of the granuloma. There is an increase in the level of acid phosphatase activity within granulocytes comprising the granuloma during the second stage.Host cellular responses to S. mansoni mother sporocysts does not occur in susceptible snails.     

Schistosomatium douthitti: effects of Lymnaea catascopium age on susceptibility to infection

Laboratory-reared Lymnaea catascopium snails (1–269 days old) were exposed individually to different numbers of Schistosomatium douthitti miracidia. Increasing the exposure dosage from 3 to 10 miracidia generally increased infection rates, in some age classes up to 100%. Successful re-exposure of snails not infected after a primary exposure was possible. Neonatal snails were least likely to become infected, primarily because miracidia were not attracted to them. Snails 12–55 days old were most susceptible to infection. Miracidia were readily attracted to these snails, and many were ingested and subsequently penetrated the host esophageal wall. Miracidial penetration of external snail surfaces was rare. Susceptibility of older snails (65–269 days) progressively declined with age. Many miracidia were entangled and immobilized in mucus produced by these snails, and fewer were ingested. No conspicuous host cellular responses to mother sporocysts were observed in any of the snails sectioned. A comparison of susceptibility of deliberately stunted snails and comparably aged controls of normal size indicated that the former were more susceptible.     

The invasion of Biomphalaria pfeifferi by Schistosoma mansoni miracidia and the development of daughter sporocysts

Laboratory experiments have been carried out to determine the susceptibility of Gezira Biomphalaria pfeifferi snails to S. mansoni miracidia and the relationship between miracidia and daughter sporocyst production at the 10–17 day development stage. The relationship between snail numbers, miracidia numbers and water volume has also been studied. Two non susceptible snails, Bulinus truncatus and Cleopatra bulimoides, both of which occur naturally in Gezira canals, were tested to see if they act as decoys for S. mansoni miracidia.The results showed that the B. pfeifferi are 100% susceptible to S. mansoni invasion, at least to the daughter sporocyst development stage. The more miracidia that penetrated the more daughter sporocysts were produced, however individual variation and overlap were great. When one miracidium was released to find one snail it succeeded in low water volumes (5 m, 50 ml), but failed in 5 litres. When 100 miracidia were released mortality of snails was high suggesting superinfection particularly when only one or five snails were available. Among survivors daughter sporocyst counts were very high. Cleopatra and Bulinus snails do have a decoy effect when present in large numbers. In their presence the number of infected snails was marginally reduced and the number of daughter sporocysts greatly reduced. However, if superinfection is reduced by decoy effect, it is conceivable that Biomphalaria may be protected by decoy snails in circumstances where miracidia counts are high.     

Schistosoma mansoni, NIH-Sm-PR-2 strain, in non-susceptible Biomphalaria glabrata: protection by Echinostoma paraensei

Sullivan J. T., Richards C. S., Lie K. J. and Heyneman D. 1981. Schistosoma mansoni, NIH-Sm-PR-2 strain, in non-susceptible Biomphalaria glabrata: Protection by Echinostoma paraensei. International journal for Parasitology11:481–484. Among seven inbred genetic stocks of Biomphalaria glabrata that are non-susceptible for the NIH-Sm-PR-2 strain of Schistosoma mansoni (PR-2), five stocks revert to nearly complete susceptibility when first infected with Echinostoma paraensei. These include both stocks in which PR-2 sporocysts are normally destroyed within 3–7 days, and stocks in which sporocysts often survive undeveloped for at least 3 weeks. Hence, these five stocks are resistant to but physiologically suitable for the development of PR-2. Of the two remaining stocks, one remains partly non-susceptible to PR-2, since less than 50 % of echinostome-infected snails revert to susceptibility, while the other stock remains completely non-susceptible to PR-2 following echinostome infection, due perhaps to a high level of residual resistance and/or unsuitability.     

Specific tyrosine phosphorylation induced in Schistosoma mansoni miracidia by haemolymph from schistosome susceptible, but not resistant, Biomphalaria glabrata

Molecular interplay during snail-schistosome interactions is poorly understood and there is much to discover concerning the effect of snail host molecules on molecular processes in schistosomes. Using the Biomphalaria glabrata - Schistosoma mansoni host-parasite system, the effects of exposure to haemolymph, derived from schistosome-resistant and susceptible snail strains, on protein tyrosine phosphorylation in miracidia have been investigated. Western blotting revealed several tyrosine phosphorylated proteins in this larval stage. Exposure of miracidia to haemolymph from susceptible snails for 60 min resulted in a striking, 5-fold, increase in the tyrosine phosphorylation of a 56 kDa (p56) S. mansoni protein. In contrast, haemolymph from resistant snails had little effect on protein tyrosine phosphorylation levels in miracidia. Confocal microscopy revealed that tyrosine phosphorylation was predominantly associated with proteins present in the tegument. Finally, treatment of miracidia with the tyrosine kinase inhibitor genistein significantly impaired their development into primary sporocysts. The results open avenues for research that focus on the potential importance of phospho-p56 to the outcome of schistosome infection in snails, and the significance of protein tyrosine kinase-mediated signalling events to the transformation of S. mansoni larvae.