Immunologic memory for Staphylococcus studied by adoptive transfer

The basic regularities of the formation and realization of immunological memory to staphylococcal corpuscular antigen were studied in adoptive transfer experiments on CBA mice. The capacity of spleen cells for generating anamnestic response to staphylococci in the body of irradiated syngeneic recipients appeared on day 3 after the immunization of donors. The formation of immunological memory to staphylococci in mice was shown to be directly related to the dose of the antigen. The study also revealed that intact splenocytes did not suppress the realization of immunological memory to staphylococci in the system of adoptive transfer. The conclusion of the absence of the "isogeneic barrier" for memory cells specific to staphylococcal corpuscular antigen was made.     

Mechanism of formation of antibody production stimulating ability of bone marrow cells of mice immunized with staphylococci

The mechanism of the increase in immune response to particular staphylococcal antigen was studied in CBA and BALB/c mice injected by primed bone marrow cells (BMC). It was found that immunostimulatory effect of immune BMC is not mediated by macrophages or T cells, but is associated with staphylococcus-specific B memory cells present in the pool of primed BMC. Splenectomy performed in donor animals prior to immunization did not abolish the induction of stimulating BMC activity. It was concluded that primed B lymphocyte migration from spleen into bone marrow is not obligatory for the induction of staphylococcus-specific immunological memory in the bone marrow.     

The mechanism of thymus-dependent antibody formation in bone marrow

During the primary immune response of mice to i.v. administered thymus-dependent antigens the spleen is the major site of localization of antibody-producing plaque-forming cells (PFC). During the secondary response, on the other hand, large numbers of PFC not only appear in the spleen, but also in the bone marrow. By inducing B memory cells with a DNP-carrier complex and activating the DNP-specific B memory cells with the same hapten conjugated to a heterologous carrier, we show in this paper that B memory cells, but not necessarily T memory cells, must be present before booster immunization for PFC to appear in the bone marrow. The origin of the PFC that appear in the bone marrow during secondary type immune response was studied in parabiotic mice consisting of members congenic for the Igh-1 locus. From analysis of the allotype of antibodies produced by PFC in the marrow of such pairs of parabionts it appeared that antibody formation in bone marrow is dependent on the immigration into the marrow of B memory cells activated in peripheral lymphoid organs. Consistent with such a migration of activated cells, radioautographic studies in guinea pigs demonstrated an influx of newly formed mononuclear cells into the bone marrow via the blood stream during the first 3 days after intravascular antigen administration.     

The role of the bone marrow in forming an immunological memory to Staphylococcus

The dynamic study of antibody formation in the bone marrow tissue of mice immunized with corpuscular staphylococcal antigen was made. A single intravenous injection of this antigen to the animals produced no essential changes in the number of antibody-forming cells in the bone marrow, their repeated immunization led to the involvement of the bone marrow in the anamnetic reaction, which was manifested by the accumulation of a great number of plasmocytes synthesizing antibodies to staphylococci in bone marrow tissue. The relative contribution of the bone marrow to systemic antibody formation essentially increased at later stages of secondary immune response. The possible biological significance of the regularities and the practical importance of the data revealed in this investigation are discussed.     

Murine bone marrow IgA responses to orally administered sheep erythrocytes

Specific immunization protocols have been established for the induction of murine bone marrow IgA responses to the T cell-dependent (TD) antigen sheep red blood cells (SRBC). Systemic immunization, either i.p. or i.v., followed by a second injection, induced splenic IgM and IgG responses and a bone marrow IgM response. No significant IgA responses were observed in either lymphoid tissue compartment. Oral immunization with SRBC by gastric intubation for 2 days, followed 1 wk later by an i.p. injection of SRBC resulted in a splenic IgA plaque-forming cell (PFC) response, but did not elicit a bone marrow IgA response. Repeated daily gastric intubation of SRBC to C3H/HeN and C3H/HeJ mice led to the previously reported pattern of systemic unresponsiveness in C3H/HeN mice and good anamnestic type IgM, IgG, and IgA splenic anti-SRBC PFC responses in the C3H/HeJ strain upon parenteral challenge. Oral administration of SRBC for 14 days to C3H/HeN mice, followed by systemic SRBC challenge, resulted in diminished splenic PFC responses of all isotypes, whereas gastric intubation of SRBC for 28 days led to complete systemic unresponsiveness to antigen in C3H/HeN mice. Interestingly, the repeated oral administration of SRBC resulted in significant bone marrow IgA PFC responses upon i.p. challenge in both C3H/HeN and C3H/HeJ mouse strains. The bone marrow IgA responses were clearly dependent upon chronic oral exposure to SRBC, because gastric intubation with SRBC for 2 consecutive days/wk for 10 wk also induced bone marrow and splenic IgA anti-SRBC PFC responses in C3H/HeN mice. These results suggest that memory B cells reside in the bone marrow of orally immunized mice and can yield anamnestic-type responses to challenge with the inducing antigen. The memory cells may arise in the Peyer's patches of the gut and migrate to the bone marrow. The possibility that the bone marrow is a component of the common mucosal immune system in mammals is suggested by this study.     

Suppressive effect of normal lymphoid cells on manifestations of immunologic memory

The authors studied the influence of the cells of normal lymphoid organs on the level of immunological response in the recipients of splenic cells from the suppressed animals. The organ cells were mixed with the suppressed ones and were administered to the recipients together with the reimmunizing dose of the antigen. Cells of the spleen, of the lymph nodes, the thymus or of the bone marrow suppressed the capacity of the memory cells to the realization of the immunological response to sheep red blood cells and egg albumin. The spleen cells of one and a half month old mice were more active than the cells of young or old animals. The suppressor activity persisted after the administration to donors of various doses of cortisone or heating of the cells transferred at 56 degrees C. Treatment with T-antiserum or heating at 80 degrees C led to reduction of the suppressor action of normal cells.     

Antigen presentation determines the fate of the T memory response in vivo after sublethal gamma-irradiation.

The survival of memory T cells is critical to vaccination strategies for infectious diseases and cancer, whereas their elimination may be crucial for treatment of autoimmune states. We examined the consequences of gamma-irradiation, which induces apoptosis of memory T cells in vitro, on the memory response to MHC class I alloantigen in vivo. Sublethal gamma-irradiation of primed mice eliminated accelerated rejection of skin allografts but failed to induce tolerance. Accelerated rejection was restored in irradiated mice by infusion of bone marrow cells expressing the priming alloantigen on immunostimulatory APCs (dendritic cells), whereas the memory response was not restored by infusion of bone marrow cells expressing the priming alloantigen on nonstimulatory APCs (B cells). Strikingly, irradiated mice infused with nonstimulatory bone marrow APCs exhibited long-term survival or tolerance to skin grafts expressing the priming MHC class I alloantigen. The mechanism of tolerance in this setting is explored.     

Bone marrow as a priming site for T-cell responses to blood-borne antigen

Although bone marrow is known as a primary lymphoid organ, its potential to serve as a secondary immune organ has hardly been explored. Here we demonstrate that naive, antigen-specific T cells home to bone marrow, where they can be primed. Antigen presentation to T cells in bone marrow is mediated via resident CD11c+ dendritic cells. They are highly efficient in taking up exogenous blood-borne antigen and processing it via major histocompatibility complex class I and class II pathways. T-cell activation correlates with dendritic cell-T cell clustering in bone marrow stroma. Primary CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell responses generated in bone marrow occur in the absence of secondary lymphoid organs. The responses are not tolerogenic and result in generation of cytotoxic T cells, protective anti-tumor immunity and immunological memory. These findings highlight the uniqueness of bone marrow as an organ important for hemato- and lymphopoiesis and for systemic T cell-mediated immunity.     

Cell transfer studies in cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance

Thymectomized, irradiated adult CBA mice were restored with various combinations of bone marrow and thymus cells from nontolerant animals and from animals made tolerant to sheep erythrocytes or to hemocyanin with the drug cyclophosphamide. Mice reconstituted with tolerant marrow and thymus responded as well as those that received nontolerant cells. Thus it is concluded that the tolerant state of the transferred marrow and thymus cells is not a significant factor in the tolerant state of the recipient, and that antigenic diversity is restored in the interaction and proliferation of bone marrow and thymus cells that follow transfer.Thymectomized irradiated mice restored with thymocytes, in contrast to unoperated animals, require multiple antigen injections to demonstrate comparable immune response, but develop tolerance normally when treated with cyclophosphamide and antigen. Reconstitution with tolerant marrow and thymus cells resembles the recovery of immune responsiveness seen after lethal irradiation of tolerant mice; in both instances a complete breakdown of immunological tolerance is observed.     

The regulation of hematopoietic stem cell proliferation and differentiation (CFU-S) during antigenic exposure

Hemopoietic stem cell (CFUs) proliferation is controlled by regulatory activities (stimulator and inhibitor) produced by bone marrow macrophages. Previously it has been shown that antigen administration stimulates CFUs proliferation. The data obtained in this study show the possible mechanism of antigen-induced stimulation of CFUs proliferation. 3-4 days after antigen injection bone marrow cells of BDF1 mice cease to produce inhibitory activity in contrast to similar cells of control animals. Therefore, increased CFUs proliferation in immunized mice can be due to decreased production of inhibitory activity and resulting abundance of stimulating factors. In BAlB/c mice CFUs proliferation is not changed after antigen injection and their bone marrow cells continue to synthesize inhibitory substances. Differentiation of CFUs into committed blood precursor cells may depend on the proliferation level in CFUs population since activation of CFUs proliferation in immunized BDF1 mice is accompanied by a decreased number of CFU-GM and CFU-M but an increased number of BFU-E. It should be noted that intact BAlB/c mice show a high level of CFUs proliferation similar to that of immunized BDF1 mice.     

Nature of T-cells resident in spleens of thymectomized,lethally irradiated,bone marrow-reconstituted mice

Adult thymectomized, lethally irradiated, bone marrow-reconstituted (ATxXB) mice that had been weakly primed with SRBC or HRBC between thymectomy and irradiation were shown to retain antigen-specific immunological memories for at least 1–5 months after bone marrow reconstitution. This could be shown by anamnestic antibody response in vivo as well as by proliferative response of the spleen cells to the test antigens in vitro. Spleen cells taken from ATxXB mice showed a reduced but significant proliferative response to nonspecific T-cell mitogens, in particular to Con A, in vitro. Treatment of the donor bone marrow cells used for reconstitution of ATxXB mice with anti-Thy 1.2 sera + C′ did not affect the generation of immunological memories nor the magnitude of the proliferative response of spleen cells to nonspecific T-cell mitogens in vitro, indicating that the cells responsible for such functions were host derived. Finally, the antibody-forming capacity of spleen cells derived from SRBC-primed ATxXB mice to the test antigen in vitro was completely abrogated by exposure to 450 R, whereas the helper function of the same cell suspension remained unaffected even after exposure to 1000 R. Implication of these findings on the nature of T cells resident in spleens of ATxXB mice was discussed.     

Specificity of suppressor cells of the delayed hypersensitivity type for Staphylococcus studied by immunoadsorption

The immunological specificity of T-suppressors obtained from mice after intravenous immunization with corpuscular antigen was shown. The splenocytes of such a mice suppressed DH to staphylococcal antigens, but not to sheep red blood cells. The suppressor cells under study were specifically adhesive to staphylococci.     

Cellular basis of genetic nonresponsiveness to egg white lysozyme

Utilizing radiation chimeras, we have investigated the cellular level at which the low immunological responsiveness to egg white lysozyme C57Bl/10 mice is expressed. Both NR----F1 (responder) and F1----NR combinations were assessed. The results demonstrate that C57Bl/10 bone marrow can give rise to hen egg white lysozyme responsive cells, but this response requires that the antigen be presented by cells derived from high responder animals.     

Immune Humanization of Immunodeficient Mice Using Diagnostic Bone Marrow Aspirates from Carcinoma Patients

Tumor xenografts in immunodeficient mice, while routinely used in cancer research, preclude studying interactions of immune and cancer cells or, if humanized by allogeneic immune cells, are of limited use for tumor-immunological questions. Here, we explore a novel way to generate cancer models with an autologous humanized immune system. We demonstrate that hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPCs) from bone marrow aspirates of non-metastasized carcinoma patients, which are taken at specialized centers for diagnostic purposes, can be used to generate a human immune system in NOD-scid IL2rγ(null) (NSG) and HLA-I expressing NSG mice (NSG-HLA-A2/HHD) comprising both, lymphoid and myeloid cell lineages. Using NSG-HLA-A2/HHD mice, we show that responsive and self-tolerant human T cells develop and human antigen presenting cells can activate human T cells. As critical factors we identified the low potential of bone marrow HSPCs to engraft, generally low HSPC numbers in patient-derived bone marrow samples, cryopreservation and routes of cell administration. We provide here an optimized protocol that uses a minimum number of HSPCs, preselects high-quality bone marrow samples defined by the number of initially isolated leukocytes and intra-femoral or intra-venous injection. In conclusion, the use of diagnostic bone marrow aspirates from non-metastasized carcinoma patients for the immunological humanization of immunodeficient mice is feasible and opens the chance for individualized analyses of anti-tumoral T cell responses.     

Mesenchymal stem cells in arthritis: role of bone marrow microenvironment

Based on their capacity to suppress immune responses, multipotent mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs) are intensively studied for regenerative medicine. Moreover, MSCs are potent immunomodulatory cells that occur through the secretion of soluble mediators including nitric oxide, transforming growth factor beta, and HLAG5. The MSCs, however, are also able to express inflammatory mediators such as prostaglandin E₂ or IL-6. MSCs in the bone marrow are in close contact with T cells and B cells, and they regulate immunological memory by organizing defined numbers of dedicated survival niches for plasma cells and memory T cells in the bone marrow. The role of MSCs in arthritis remains controversial - in some studies, murine allogeneic MSCs are able to decrease arthritis; in other studies, MSCs worsen the local inflammation. A recent paper in Arthritis Research and Therapy shows that bone marrow MSCs have decreased osteoblastic potential in rheumatoid arthritis, which may be related to chronic inflammation or to loss of expression of IL-1 receptor agonist. That article raises the importance of the bone marrow microenvironment for MSC biology.     

Multiple splenic lymphoid cell subpopulations regulate H-2 antigen expression on teratocarcinoma cells in vivo

Undifferentiated murine 402AX teratocarcinoma cells do not express MHC antigens when passaged in vitro or in vivo in genetically susceptible host mice. When passaged in vivo in genetically resistant mice, however, the tumor cells become H-2b antigen positive regardless of the H-2 haplotype of the resistant host mouse. The present studies use monoclonal anti-H-2b antibodies to corroborate these earlier findings, which were performed with conventional antisera. Previous studies have established that host bone marrow plus lymphoid cells from resistant primed donors regulate tumor cell H-2b antigen expression. Using bone marrow and mature lymphoid cell reconstitution techniques, the present studies indicate that splenic Ig- cells from genetically resistant host mice are the most efficient lymphoid cell subpopulation in tumor cell H-2b antigen induction. Ig+ spleen cells also reconstitute the capacity to induce teratocarcinoma cell H-2 antigens but are less effective than Ig- spleen cells. Tumor cell H-2 antigen induction in C57BL/6 beige mice is impaired compared to C57BL/6 hosts, which suggests that host NK cells may also be involved in tumor cell H-2 antigen induction. Reconstitution of lethally irradiated resistant hosts for teratocarcinoma cell H-2 antigen expression requires bone marrow plus resistant primed lymphoid cell subpopulations; bone marrow alone is insufficient. These results indicate that multiple splenic lymphoid cell subpopulations requiring a radiosensitive host environment and/or factor for differentiation regulate teratocarcinoma 402AX H-2b antigen expression in vivo in genetically resistant mice.     

IL-15-dependent upregulation of GITR on CD8 memory phenotype T cells in the bone marrow relative to spleen and lymph node suggests the bone marrow as a site of superior bioavailability of IL-15

CD8 memory T cells are enriched in the bone marrow, a site where these cells are thought to receive homeostatic signals. However, the primary site where CD8 memory T cells receive their cytokine-induced homeostatic signals has recently come under debate. In this study, we demonstrate that the bone marrow contains a fraction of CD8 memory phenotype T cells with elevated expression of glucocorticoid-induced TNFR-related protein (GITR). In contrast, splenic and lymph node memory phenotype T cells have GITR levels similar to those on naive T cells. The bone marrow GITR(hi) memory T cells have a phenotype indicative of cytokine activation, with higher CD122 and lower CD127 than do the GITR(basal) memory T cells. Remarkably, these bone marrow-specific GITR(hi) cells are almost completely ablated in the absence of IL-15, whereas TNFR2 and 4-1BB expression on the CD8 memory T cells are IL-15 independent. Furthermore, adoptively transferred splenic CD8 memory phenotype T cells show IL-15-dependent GITR upregulation upon entry into the bone marrow. This result implies that the selective appearance of GITR(hi) memory phenotype T cells in the bone marrow reflects the local microenvironment rather than a different subset of memory T cells. GITR(-/-) mice have a lower frequency of CD8 memory phenotype cells in the bone marrow, yet the GITR(-/-) cells hyperproliferate compared with those in wild-type mice. Taken together, these data suggest that GITR plays a role in the survival of CD8 memory phenotype T cells and that GITR upregulation represents a precise marker of cells that have responded to IL-15.     

Antibody formation in mouse bone marrow. VIII. Dependence on potentially circulating memory cells: a study with parabiotic mice.

Mouse bone marrow barely contains antibody-producing plaque-forming cells (PFC) during the primary response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC). However, during the secondary response, the number of IgM, IgG, and IgA PFC in the bone marrow can rise to a level which surpasses the number of PFC in all the other lymphoid organs together. In the present paper we investigated whether the capacity of immune mice to react upon a booster injection of SRBC with a bone marrow PFC response can be transferred from immune to nonimmune mice. Therefore, mice primed with SRBC 6 months previously and nonprimed syngeneic mice were joined for parabiosis and were separated from each other at various intervals after joining. These separated mice were subsequently immunized with SRBC. It was found that, after 3 weeks of parabiosis, the nonprimed members reacted upon an injection of SRBC with a bone marrow IgM, IgG, and IgA PFC response as high as did the previously primed members. Furthermore it could be demonstrated by means of cell transfer experiments that, after a period of parabiosis of 3 weeks, the bone marrow and spleen of the normal mice contained about as many memory cells as the bone marrow and spleen of the immune mice. These results suggest that antibody formation in mouse bone marrow is dependent on a population of potentially circulating memory cells.     

Antibody formation in mouse bone marrow. VII. Evidence against the migration of plaque-forming cells as the underlying cause for bone marrow plaque-forming cell activity: a study with parabiotic mice

After intravenous immunization of mice with Escherichia coli lipopolysaccharide (LPS) or sheep red blood cells (SRBC), the bone marrow can contain large numbers of plaque-forming cells (PFC). By means of parabiosis, it was studied whether or not this appearance of PFC in the bone marrow might be due to a migration of such cells from peripheral lymphoid organs into the marrow, as has been suggested in the literature. Using parabionts consisting of nonimmunized mice and mice immunized with LPS, only background numbers of PFC could be demonstrated in the bone marrow of the nonimmunized mice. In similar experiments, with SRBC as antigen, mice showing high anti-SRBC PFC activity in the bone marrow could only provide for minor numbers of anti-SRBC PFC in the bone marrow of affixed normal mice. These results suggest that migration of PFC can not be the main cause for bone marrow PFC activity in the mouse. This provides additional evidence for our view presented in previous papers of this series that the appearance of PFC activity in the bone marrow is dependent on local maturation of B cells into PFC rather than on immigration of PFC.     

Maintenance and amplification of cell-associated immunological memory in in vivo culture system

By employing bovine serum albumin as antigen and the capsular polysaccharide of Klebsiella pneumoniae as adjuvant, maintenance and amplification of immunological memory were analyzed in an in vivo culture system in mice. For this purpose, the double cell transfer technique was employed to minimize the influence of regulatory factors on memory expression. Memory associated with primed cells is maintained at the original level during in vivo culture for at least a month in the absence of antigen. In contrast, memory is amplified more than 30 times during this period by stimulation with antigen. This secondary increase in memory does not require the action of adjuvant. Neither the residual primary antigen nor preformed primary antibody seems to play a significant role in the maintenance and amplification of memory of the primed cells. From these results it is probable that the enduring immunological memory in actively immunized mice is conveyed by long-lived memory cells, and additional antigenic stimulating on once-established memory cells serve to amplify (not simply to maintain) memory in a secondary fashion.