DNA knotting caused by head-on collision of transcription and replication

Obtaining crystals of membrane proteins that diffract to high resolution remains a major stumbling block in structure determination. Here we present a new method for crystallizing membrane proteins from a bicelle forming lipid/detergent mixture. The method is flexible and simple to use. As a test case, bacteriorhodopsin (bR) from Halobacterium salinarum was crystallized from a bicellar solution, yielding a new bR crystal form. The crystals belong to space group P2(1) with unit cell dimensions of a=45.0 A, b=108.9 A, c=55.9 A, beta=113.58 degrees and a dimeric asymmetric unit. The structure was solved by molecular replacement and refined at 2.0 A resolution. In all previous bR structures the protein is organized as a parallel trimer, but in the crystals grown from bicelles, the individual bR subunits are arranged in an antiparallel fashion.     

Electrostatic effects influence the formation of two-dimensional crystals of bacteriorhodopsin reconstituted into dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine membranes

We examined how electrostatic shielding affects the formation of two-dimensional (2D) crystals of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) in reconstituted dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) membranes by varying the sodium chloride (NaCl) concentration. The 2D crystalline array of bR formed in the gel phase of DMPC membranes was characterized by a symmetric bipolar pattern in visible circular dichroic spectra collected around 560 nm. The amplitude of the bipolar pattern was systematically enhanced by increasing the NaCl concentration. A strong correlation between the amplitude of the bipolar pattern and the Debye constant of small ions indicated that a weakening of electrostatic repulsion by the shielding effect of small ions enhances the order of 2D bR crystals in the gel phase of DMPC membranes. Considering the 3D distribution of charged residues, we propose a model of interaction balance in reconstituted bR membranes in which effective attraction between bR molecules occurs as a result of the phase separation of the DMPC membrane in the gel phase overcoming electrostatic repulsion between bR molecules.     

An Approach to Heterologous Expression of Membrane Proteins. The Case of Bacteriorhodopsin

Heterologous overexpression of functional membrane proteins is a major bottleneck of structural biology. Bacteriorhodopsin from Halobium salinarum (bR) is a striking example of the difficulties in membrane protein overexpression. We suggest a general approach with a finite number of steps which allows one to localize the underlying problem of poor expression of a membrane protein using bR as an example. Our approach is based on constructing chimeric proteins comprising parts of a protein of interest and complementary parts of a homologous protein demonstrating advantageous expression. This complementary protein approach allowed us to increase bR expression by two orders of magnitude through the introduction of two silent mutations into bR coding DNA. For the first time the high quality crystals of bR expressed in E. Coli were obtained using the produced protein. The crystals obtained with in meso nanovolume crystallization diffracted to 1.67 Å.     

Membrane-protein stability in a phospholipid-based crystallization medium

Protein stability is a crucial factor to consider when attempting to crystallize integral membrane proteins. Cubic phase, or in meso, lipid-bilayer crystallization media are thought to provide native-like environments that should facilitate membrane protein crystallization by helping to stabilize the native protein conformation for the duration of the crystallization process. While excellent crystals of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) and other Halobacterial rhodopsins have been obtained in lipid-bilayer gels formed with monoglycerides, success remains elusive in the general application of such media to other membrane proteins. Additionally, we have noted that some mutants of bR are highly unstable in gels formed with monoolein. Phosphatidylethanolamines (PE) and derivatives of PE represent another class of lipids that can form connected-bilayer gels. When wildtype bR and a labile bR mutant were reconstituted into this phospholipid gel, spectroscopy showed that the protein is both more stable and has improved conformational homogeneity as compared to gels formed using monoolein. In addition, we demonstrate that well-diffracting crystals of bR can be grown from a PE-based crystallization medium. Since most proteins lack a stability-indicating chromophore and other structure-based analytical techniques are poorly compatible with the lipid gel, we developed a generally-applicable spectroscopic technique based on the intrinsic fluorescence of tryptophan residues. This fluorescence assay makes possible the rapid evaluation of lipid gels as media for the crystallization of membrane proteins.     

Crystallization of bacteriorhodopsin from bicelle formulations at room temperature

We showed previously that high-quality crystals of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) from Halobacterium salinarum can be obtained from bicelle-forming DMPC/CHAPSO mixtures at 37 degrees C. As many membrane proteins are not sufficiently stable for crystallization at this high temperature, we tested whether the bicelle method could be applied at a lower temperature. Here we show that bR can be crystallized at room temperature using two different bicelle-forming compositions: DMPC/CHAPSO and DTPC/CHAPSO. The DTPC/CHAPSO crystals grown at room temperature are essentially identical to the previous, twinned crystals: space group P21 with unit cell dimensions of a = 44.7 A, b = 108.7 A, c = 55.8 A, beta = 113.6 degrees . The room-temperature DMPC/CHAPSO crystals are untwinned, however, and belong to space group C222(1) with the following unit cell dimensions: a = 44.7 A, b = 102.5 A, c = 128.2 A. The bR protein packs into almost identical layers in the two crystal forms, but the layers stack differently. The new untwinned crystal form yielded clear density for a previously unresolved CHAPSO molecule inserted between protein subunits within the layers. The ability to grow crystals at room temperature significantly expands the applicability of bicelle crystallization.     

Protein, lipid and water organization in bacteriorhodopsin crystals: a molecular view of the purple membrane at 1.9 A resolution.

BACKGROUND: Bacteriorhodopsin (bR) from Halobacterium salinarum is a proton pump that converts the energy of light into a proton gradient that drives ATP synthesis. The protein comprises seven transmembrane helices and in vivo is organized into purple patches, in which bR and lipids form a crystalline two-dimensional array. Upon absorption of a photon, retinal, which is covalently bound to Lys216 via a Schiff base, is isomerized to a 13-cis,15-anti configuration. This initiates a sequence of events - the photocycle - during which a proton is transferred from the Schiff base to Asp85, followed by proton release into the extracellular medium and reprotonation from the cytoplasmic side. RESULTS: The structure of bR in the ground state was solved to 1.9 A resolution from non-twinned crystals grown in a lipidic cubic phase. The structure reveals eight well-ordered water molecules in the extracellular half of the putative proton translocation pathway. The water molecules form a continuous hydrogen-bond network from the Schiff-base nitrogen (Lys216) to Glu194 and Glu204 and includes residues Asp85, Asp212 and Arg82. This network is involved both in proton translocation occurring during the photocycle, as well as in stabilizing the structure of the ground state. Nine lipid phytanyl moieties could be modeled into the electron-density maps. Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) analysis of single crystals demonstrated the presence of four different charged lipid species. CONCLUSIONS: The structure of protein, lipid and water molecules in the crystals represents the functional entity of bR in the purple membrane of the bacteria at atomic resolution. Proton translocation from the Schiff base to the extracellular medium is mediated by a hydrogen-bond network that involves charged residues and water molecules.     

Mechanism of light-dependent proton translocation by bacteriorhodopsin.

Site-specific mutagenesis has identified amino acids involved in bR proton transport. Biophysical studies of the mutants have elucidated the roles of two membrane-embedded residues: Asp-85 serves as the acceptor for the proton from the isomerized retinylidene Schiff base, and Asp-96 participates in reprotonation of this group. The functions of Arg-82, Leu-93, Asp-212, Tyr-185, and other residues that affect bR properties when substituted are not as well understood. Structural characterization of the mutant proteins will clarify the effects of substitutions at these positions. Current efforts in the field remain directed at understanding how retinal isomerization is coupled to proton transport. In particular, there has been more emphasis on determining the structures of bR and its photointermediates. Since well-ordered crystals of bR have not been obtained, continued electron diffraction studies of purple membrane offer the best opportunity for structure refinement. Other informative techniques include solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance of isotopically labeled bR (56) and electron paramagnetic resonance of bR tagged with nitroxide spin labels (2, 3, 13, 15). Site-directed mutagenesis will be essential in these studies to introduce specific sites for derivatization with structural probes and to slow the decay of intermediates. Thus, combining molecular biology and biophysics will continue to provide solutions to fundamental problems in bR.     

The protonation-deprotonation kinetics of the protonated Schiff base in bicelle bacteriorhodopsin crystals

In the recently published x-ray crystal structure of the "bicelle" bacteriorhodopsin (bbR) crystal, the protein has quite a different structure from the native and the in cubo bacteriorhodopsin (cbR) crystal. Instead of packing in parallel trimers as do the native membrane and the cbR crystals, in the bbR crystal the protein packs as antiparallel monomers. To date, no functional studies have been performed, to our knowledge, to investigate if the photocycle is observed in this novel protein packing structure. In this study, both Raman and time-resolved transient absorption spectroscopy are used to both confirm the presence of the photocycle and investigate the deprotonation-reprotonation kinetics of the Schiff base proton in the bbR crystal. The observed rates of deprotonation and reprotonation processes of its Schiff base have been compared to those observed for native bR under the same conditions. Unlike the previously observed similarity of the rates of these processes for cbR crystals and those for native bacteriorhodopsin (bR), in bbR crystals the rate of deprotonation has increased by 300%, and the rate of reprotonation has decreased by nearly 700%. These results are discussed in light of the changes observed when native bR is delipidated or monomerized by detergents. Both the change of the hydrophobicity of the environment around the protonated Schiff base and Asp85 and Asp96 (which could change the pKa values of proton donor-acceptor pairs) and the water structure in the bbR crystal are offered as possible explanations for the different observations.     

Crystal structures of archaerhodopsin-1 and -2: Common structural motif in archaeal light-driven proton pumps

Archaerhodopsin-1 and -2 (aR-1 and aR-2) are light-driven proton pumps found in Halorubrum sp. aus-1 and -2, which share 55-58% sequence identity with bacteriorhodopsin (bR), a proton pump found in Halobacterium salinarum. In this study, aR-1 and aR-2 were crystallized into 3D crystals belonging to P4(3)2(1)2 (a = b = 128.1 A, c = 117.6 A) and C222(1) (a = 122.9 A, b = 139.5 A, c = 108.1 A), respectively. In both the crystals, the asymmetric unit contains two protein molecules with slightly different conformations. Each subunit is composed of seven helical segments as seen in bR but, unlike bR, aR-1 as well as aR-2 has a unique omega loop near the N terminus. It is found that the proton pathway in the extracellular half (i.e. the proton release channel) is more opened in aR-2 than in aR-1 or bR. This structural difference accounts for a large variation in the pKa of the acid purple-to-blue transition among the three proton pumps. All the aromatic residues surrounding the retinal polyene chain are conserved among the three proton pumps, confirming a previous argument that these residues are required for the stereo-specificity of the retinal isomerization. In the cytoplasmic half, the region surrounded by helices B, C and G is highly conserved, while the structural conservation is very low for residues extruded from helices E and F. Structural conservation of the hydrophobic residues located on the proton uptake pathway suggests that their precise arrangement is necessary to prevent a backward flow of proton in the presence of a large pH gradient and membrane potential. An empty cavity is commonly seen in the vicinity of Leu93 contacting the retinal C13 methyl. Existence of such a cavity is required to allow a large rotation of the side-chain of Leu93 at the early stage of the photocycle, which has been shown to accompany water translocation across the Schiff base.     

Effect of acid pH on the absorption spectra and photoreactions of bacteriorhodopsin.

Purple membranes (PM) from Halobacterium halobium were incorporated into 7.5% polyacrylamide gels to prevent aggregation which occurs in suspensions at low pH. At pH 7.0, the circular dichroism (CD) spectra and visible absorption spectra of light- and dark-adapted bacteriorhodopsin (bR558, respectively) and the flash photolysis cycle of bR568 in gels were essentially the same as those in PM suspensions. Titration of the gels with hydrochloric acid showed the transition to a form absorbing at 605 nm (bR605 acid) with pK = 2.9 and to a second form absorbing at 565 nm (bR565 acid) with pK = 0.5. Isosbestic points were seen for each transition in both light- and dark-adapted gels. In addition, a third isosbestic point was evident between pH 3.5 and 7. Visible CD spectra of bR568, bR605 acid, and bR565 acid all showed the bilobed pattern typical of bR568 in suspensions of PM. Flash kinetic spectrophotometry (with 40-microseconds time resolution) of bR605 acid and bR565 acid showed transient absorbance changes with at least one transiently blue-shifted form for each and an early red-shifted intermediate for bR565 acid. Chromophore extraction from membrane suspensions yielded all-trans-retinal for bR565 acid and a mixture of 13-cis and trans isomers for bR605 acid.     

Solubilization and structural stability of bacteriorhodopsin with a mild nonionic detergent, n-Octyl-β-thioglucoside

Solubilization and structural stability of a membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin (bR) with n-octyl-β-thioglucoside (OTG) was investigated in comparison with a previous study on bR solubilized with n-octyl-β-glucoside (OG). Highly efficient and stable solubilization of bR with OTG was accomplished above the OTG concentration of about 15 mM. In comparison with OG-solubilized bR, the structural stability of OTG-solubilized bR was high in the dark and under light illumination. These results indicate that OTG is a detergent superior to OG for solubilizing bR molecules.     

Effects of volatile anesthetics on bacteriorhodopsin in purple membrane, Halobacterium halobium cells and reconstituted vesicles.

In this study, we have investigated effects of volatile anesthetics on absorption spectra, proton pumping activity and decay of photointermediate M of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) in differently aggregated states. Anesthetics used in this study are ether-type general anesthetics; enflurane and sevoflurane. The observed effects on bR depend not only on variety or concentration of anesthetics but also strongly on the aggregation state of bR molecules in the membrane. In purple membrane (PM), bR having maximum light absorption at 567 nm (bR567) is formed in the presence of sevoflurane or a small amount of enflurane, while a species absorbing maximally at 480 nm (bR480) is formed upon the addition of large amounts of enflurane. X-ray diffraction studies show that the former species maintains crystallinity of PM, but the latter does not. In reconstituted vesicles where bR molecules exist as monomer, even sevoflurane forms bR480. Flash photolysis experiments show that bR567 contains a shorter-lived M intermediate absorbing maximally at 412 nm in the photoreaction cycle than bR does and that bR480 contains at least two long-lived M intermediates which seem to absorb maximally near and at lower than 380 nm. The measurements of light-induced pH changes of the whole cells and of the reconstituted vesicles in the presence of the anesthetics indicate that bR567 has a enhanced proton pumping efficiency, while bR480 has a quite low or no activity. No significant difference was observed in the anesthetic action between two inversely pumping vesicles. These observations suggest that on the formation of bR480, anesthetics enter into the membrane and affect the protein-lipid interaction.     

Effect of lipid-protein interaction on the color of bacteriorhodopsin

Detergent solubilization and subsequent delipidation of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) results in the formation of a new species absorbing maximally at 480 nm (bR480). Upon lowering the pH, its absorption shifts to 540 nm (bR540). The pK of this equilibrium is 2.6, with the higher pH favoring bR480 (Baribeau, J. and Boucher, F. (1987) Biochim. Biophysica Acta, 890, 275-278). Resonance Raman spectroscopy shows that bR480, like the native bR, contains a protonated Schiff base (PSB) linkage between the chromophore and the protein. However, the Schiff base vibrational frequency in bR480, and its shift upon deuteration, are quite different from these in the native bR, suggesting changes in the Schiff base environment upon delipidation. Infrared absorption and circular-dichroism (CD) spectral studies do not show any net change in the protein secondary structure upon formation of bR480. It is shown that deprotonation of the Schiff base is not the only mechanism of producing hypsochromic shift in the absorption maximum of bR-derived pigments, subtle changes in the protein tertiary structure, affecting the Schiff base environment of the chromophore, may play an equally significant role in the color regulation of bR-derived pigments.     

Purple membrane: color, crystallinity, and the effect of dimethyl sulfoxide

In an effort to understand the nature of chromophore-protein interactions in bacteriorhodopsin (bR), we have reinvestigated dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO)-induced changes in bR [Oesterhelt et al. (1973) Eur. J. Biochem. 40, 453-463]. We observe that dark-adapted bR (bR560) in aqueous DMSO undergoes reversible transformation to a species absorbing maximally at 480 nm (bR480). Beginning at 40% DMSO, this change results in complete conversion to bR480 at 60% DMSO. The kinetics of the reaction reveal that this transformation takes place predominantly through the all-trans isomeric form of the pigment. Thermal isomerization of the 13-cis chromophore to the all-trans form is, therefore, the rate-limiting step in the formation of bR480 from the dark-adapted bR. As in native bR, the chromophore in bR480 is linked to the protein via a protonated Schiff base, and its isomeric composition is predominantly all-trans. The formation of bR480 is associated with minor changes in the protein secondary structure, and the membrane retains crystallinity. These changes in the protein structure result in a diminished chromophore-protein interaction near the Schiff base region in bR480. Thus, we attribute the observed spectroscopic changes in bR in DMSO to structural alteration of the protein. The 13-cis chromophoric pigment appears to be resistant to this solvent-induced change. The changes in the protein structure need not be very large; displacement of the protein counterion(s) to the Schiff base, resulting from minor changes in the protein structure, can produce the observed spectral shift.     

Photovoltage kinetics of the acid-blue and acid-purple forms of bacteriorhodopsin: evidence for no net charge transfer.

Time-resolved photovoltage measurements were performed with the acid-blue (bR605A) and acid-purple (bR565A) forms of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) in the time range from 25 ns to 100 s. The bR605A and bR565A pigments were formed by titration with H2SO4 in the absence and presence of 150 mM KCI, respectively. Qualitatively the kinetics of the charge displacement in these two states are similar and consist of two fast phases in one direction (100 ns bandwidth limited and approximately 1 microsecond) followed by a decay in the opposite direction via one component for bR605A (4.4 +/- 0.6 ms) or two components for bR565A (33 +/- 8 microseconds and 3.6 +/- 0.5 ms). The transient photovoltage signal returns exactly to the initial value after several milliseconds, well before the passive discharge of the electrical measuring system at 2 s. We conclude that no net charge transfer occurs in either bR605A or bR565A. The direction of the fast components is opposite that of net proton translocation in bR at pH 7. So, if the charge that moves back and forth is due to a proton, it moves first in the direction of the cytoplasmic side of the membrane (< 1 microsecond) and returns to its initial position via the 4.4 ms (bR605A) or the 33 microseconds and 3.6 ms (bR565A) decay components. The amplitude of the charge motion in both low pH forms is too large to be due to isomerization alone and is comparable to one of the major components in bR at pH 7.2     

Decay of the tryptophan fluorescence anisotropy in bacteriorhodopsin and its modified forms.

In this work we study the decay of the polarization of the Trp fluorescence in native bacteriorhodopsin (bR), deionized bR (dlbR), and the retinal-free form of bR, bacterioopsin (bO), using picosecond laser/streak camera system. Two types of depolarization processes are observed, one around 250 ps, which is temperature independent around room temperature, and the other in the 1-3-ns range, which is sensitive to temperature and certain bR modifications. This suggests the presence of at least two different environments for the eight Trp molecules in bR. Native bR and deionized bR gave the same depolarization decay times, suggesting that the removal of metal cations does not change the microenvironment of the emitting Trp molecules. The slow component is faster in bO than in bR, suggesting a change in the environment of the Trp molecules upon the removal of the retinal chromophore. All these results are discussed in terms of the different mechanisms of Trp fluorescence depolarization. A comparison between the depolarization decay in rhodopsin and bR is made.     

Theoretical framework for octopus rhodopsin crystallization

Bacteriorhodopsin (bR) is presently a classical example of membrane protein crystallization. We are comparing the structure of bR with the homology model of octopus rhodopsin (octR), which is similar in topology to bR and as highly ordered in its native membranes as bR in purple membranes. Such comparison provides insights for optimization of present octR experimentation both for crystallization and for application in nanobiotechnology in a manner similar to bR, and possibly even superior in optical computation.     

Structure and protein environment of the retinal chromophore in light- and dark-adapted bacteriorhodopsin studied by solid-state NMR

Our previous solid-state 13C NMR studies on bR have been directed at characterizing the structure and protein environment of the retinal chromophore in bR568 and bR548, the two components of the dark-adapted protein. In this paper, we extend these studies by presenting solid-state NMR spectra of light-adapted bR (bR568) and examining in more detail the chemical shift anisotropy of the retinal resonances near the ionone ring and Schiff base. Magic angle spinning (MAS) 13C NMR spectra were obtained of bR568, regenerated with retinal specifically 13C labeled at positions 12-15, which allowed assignment of the resonances observed in the dark-adapted bR spectrum. Of particular interest are the assignments of the 13C-13 and 13C-15 resonances. The 13C-15 chemical resonance for bR568 (160.0 ppm) is upfield of the 13C-15 resonance for bR548 (163.3 ppm). This difference is attributed to a weaker interaction between the Schiff base and its associated counterion in bR568. The 13C-13 chemical shift for bR568 (164.8 ppm) is close to that of the all-trans-retinal protonated Schiff base (PSB) model compound (approximately 162 ppm), while the 13C-13 resonance for bR548 (168.7 ppm) is approximately 7 ppm downfield of that of the 13-cis PSB model compound. The difference in the 13C-13 chemical shift between bR568 and bR548 is opposite that expected from the corresponding 15N chemical shifts of the Schiff base nitrogen and may be due to conformational distortion of the chromophore in the C13 = C14-C15 bonds.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Solubilization and Structural Stability of Bacteriorhodopsin with a Mild Nonionic Detergent,n-Octyl-β-thioglucoside

Solubilization and structural stability of a membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin (bR) with n-octyl-β-thioglucoside (OTG) was investigated in comparison with a previous study on bR solubilized with n-octyl-β-glucoside (OG). Highly efficient and stable solubilization of bR with OTG was accomplished above the OTG concentration of about 15 mM. In comparison with OG-solubilized bR, the structural stability of OTG-solubilized bR was high in the dark and under light illumination. These results indicate that OTG is a detergent superior to OG for solubilizing bR molecules.