Target site mediated insecticide resistance: what questions remain?

Recent advances in the molecular genetics of insecticide resistance have identified the point mutations associated with target site insensitivity in the genes encoding the three major insecticide targets: the Rdl GABA receptor, the para voltage gated sodium channel and insect acetylcholinesterase. However central questions relating to the origin, selection and fitness of these mutations in natural populations remain. This review examines the extent to which we understand how a specific subset of potential resistance associated mutations are selected, how often they may arise and/or recombine, and whether we can explain any potential fitness disadvantages based on our knowledge of the molecular mechanisms of resistance involved.     

Antibiotic and insecticide resistance modeling--is it time to start talking?

Mathematical models have played an important part in understanding both antibiotic and insecticide resistance. However, there has been little, if any, interdisciplinary work between these two areas of active research. One primary reason for this is that bacterial population genetics differ substantially from the population genetics of diploid organisms. This article examines these differences and their effect on resistance. It explores what efforts have gone into modeling resistance mathematically in both arenas, and offers suggestions on how the two groups could work together to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the resistance phenomenon     

The evolution of insecticide resistance: Have the insects won?

While insecticides have greatly improved human health and agricultural production worldwide, their utility has been limited by the evolution of resistance in many major pests, including some that became pests only as a result of insecticide use. Insecticide resistance is both an interesting example of the adaptability of insect pests, and, in the design of resistance management programmes, a useful application of evolutionary biology. Pest susceptibility is a valuable natural resource that has been squandered; at the same time, it is becoming increasingly expensive to develop new insecticides. Pest control tactics should therefore take account of the possibility of resistance evolution. One of the best ways to retard resistance evolution is to use insecticides only when control by natural enemies fails to limit economic damage. This review summarizes the recent literature on insecticide resistance as an example of adaptation, and demonstrates how population genetics and ecology can be used to manage the resistance problem.     

Impacts of sublethal insecticide exposure on insects — Facts and knowledge gaps

The biodiversity and biomass of insects is dramatically declining due to various anthropogenic factors. One of these factors is the use of insecticides to protect plants from pests. However, apart from the targeted pest insects, thousands of non-target organisms face traces of insecticides that are not lethal but can affect numerous traits of the individual, including development, physiology, behaviour and communication. In the present review, key facts on impacts of sublethal insecticide exposure on such traits are summarised. Attributable to various abiotic and biotic processes, insecticide concentrations may become sublethal in space and time. Nevertheless, these concentrations impede insect development, reducing growth and survival, but sometimes also enhance reproductive performance. The effects are species-specific, but sensitivity also differs within species depending on the developmental stage, sex and population. Furthermore, insecticide exposure influences several immunity pathways and causes changes in behaviour. Such changes are mostly studied on the level of behavioural traits. However, also effects on the consistency of overall individual behavioural phenotypes, i.e. personalities, should be investigated, which have consequences on individual fitness and on the effectiveness of biocontrol agents. Moreover, insecticides can act as info-disruptors, impeding signal production and perception during chemical communication at various levels. Finally, microbial symbionts may modify insect responses to insecticides, being of particular interest for biotechnological approaches. Here, methodological issues are discussed and knowledge gaps and potential future research directions are highlighted. Understanding the mechanisms of dose-dependent insecticide impacts on organisms and their cascading effects on higher levels of biological organisation and on subsequent generations are of utmost importance for proper insecticide use.     

Why are there so few resistance-associated mutations in insecticide target genes?

The genes encoding the three major targets of conventional insecticides are: Rdl, which encodes a gamma-aminobutyric acid receptor subunit (RDL); para, which encodes a voltage-gated sodium channel (PARA); and Ace, which encodes insect acetylcholinesterase (AChE). Interestingly, despite the complexity of the encoded receptors or enzymes, very few amino acid residues are replaced in different resistant insects: one within RDL, two within PARA and three or more within AChE. Here we examine the possible reasons underlying this extreme conservation by looking at the aspects of receptor and/or enzyme function that may constrain replacements to such a limited number of residues.     

Can insecticide mixtures be considered to surmount neonicotinoid resistance in Bemisia tabaci?

Cotton whitefly, Bemisia tabaci is an important polyphagous pest worldwide. It is exposed to various chemical insecticides throughout the year, resulting in the rapid development of insecticide resistance. Mixtures of insecticides with distinct modes of action could enhance the toxicity of chemicals more effectively than sequences or rotations in resistant pest populations. Bioassays were conducted to study the efficacy of mixtures of neonicotinoid and ketoenol insecticides at different ratios against a laboratory susceptible (Lab-WB) and a neonicotinoid resistant (TMX-SEL) strain of B. tabaci Asia I. The results showed that mixtures of imidacloprid, acetamiprid, thiamethoxam or dinotefuran with spiromesifen at 1:1, 1:10 and 1:20 ratios and of imidacloprid, thiamethoxam or dinotefuran with spirotetramat at 1:1 ratio significantly increased (p < 0.05) toxicity to neonicotinoids in TMX-SEL strain. The combination indices of each tested neonicotinoids + ketoenols at 1:1 ratio and of acetamiprid + spiromesifen, and imidacloprid or dinotefuran + spirotetramat at 1:10 ratio for TMX-SEL strain were significantly below 1, suggesting synergistic interactions. The inhibitors PBO and DEF largely overcame resistance to the tested neonicotinoids, while none of the synergists significantly restored the susceptibility of B. tabaci to ketoenols. Increased activities of P450 monooxygenase and esterase were observed in TMX-SEL strain with an elevated 2.76 and 1.32-fold, respectively. Mixtures of neonicotinoids with spiromesifen or spirotetramat at a 1:1 ratio could be used to restore the neonicotinoid susceptibility in B. tabaci.     

SAR studies directed toward the pyridine moiety of the sap-feeding insecticide sulfoxaflor (Isoclast™ active)

Sap-feeding insect pests constitute a major insect pest complex that includes a range of aphids, whiteflies, planthoppers and other insect species. Sulfoxaflor (Isoclast™ active), a new sulfoximine class insecticide, targets sap-feeding insect pests including those resistant to many other classes of insecticides. A structure activity relationship (SAR) investigation of the sulfoximine insecticides revealed the importance of a 3-pyridyl ring and a methyl substituent on the methylene bridge linking the pyridine and the sulfoximine moiety to achieving strong Myzus persicae activity. A more in depth QSAR investigation of pyridine ring substituents revealed a strong correlation with the calculated log octanol/water partition coefficient (S log P). Model development resulted in a highly predictive model for a set of 18 sulfoximines including sulfoxaflor. The model is consistent with and helps explain the highly optimized pyridine substitution pattern for sulfoxaflor.     

Proteomic analysis of insecticide triazophos-induced mating-responsive proteins of Nilaparvata lugens Stål (Hemiptera: Delphacidae)

The brown planthopper, Nilaparvata lugens (St?l) (Hemiptera: Delphacidae), is a classic example of a resurgent pest induced by insecticides. It has been demonstrated that triazophos treatment causes an increase in the content of male accessory gland proteins (Acps) that can be transferred to females via mating, influencing female reproduction. However, the mechanism of this type of insecticide-induced Acps in males and the subsequent stimulation of reproduction in females are not well understood. To identify changes in the types of Acps and reproductive proteins in mated females, we conducted a comparative proteomic analysis. Six samples were categorized into four different groups: (1) untreated unmated males compared to treated unmated males (UUM vs TUM); (2) treated unmated males compared to treated mated males (TUM vs TMM); (3) untreated unmated females compared to treated unmated females (UUF vs TUF); (4) treated unmated females compared to treated mated females (TUF vs TMF). Protein expression changes among the four different groups were examined by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE) and liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). Of the 500-600 reproducibly detected protein spots on each gel, 107 protein spots were differentially expressed between the four different groups. Of the 63 proteins identified by LC-MS/MS analysis, 38 were up-regulated and 25 were down-regulated in the four different groups. Some novel proteins related to fecundity were observed including spermatogenesis-associated protein 5, testis development protein NYD-SP6, arginine kinase, actin-5C, vitellogenin, and ovarian serine protease nudel. The elevated expression of novel fecundity proteins in six samples of N. lugens females and males due to exposure to triazophos was confirmed by quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR). The results suggest that these proteins may participate in the reproductive process of N. lugens adult females and males. Our findings fill a gap in understanding the relationship between insecticide-treated males and the stimulated reproduction of N. lugens females.     

Effects of insecticide applications on macroinvertebrate density and biomass in rice-fields in the Rhône-delta,France

The density of 23 macroinvertebrate species and the total macroinvertebrate biomass were compared between rice-fields treated with lindane and diazinon in June and alphamethine in August and untreated controls. The macroinvertebrates could be divided into four groups: (1) Taxa, in which the densities were lower in the insecticide treatment in July and August than in the non-insecticide treatment. (2) The Culicidae which occurred in the insecticide treatment in significantly lower density in July, but in significantly higher density in August. (3) Ischnura elegans (Vander L.) which was found in July after the lindane application in significantly higher numbers in the insecticide treatments, but in significantly lower numbers in the insecticide treatment in August after the application of the pyrethroid. In these three groups, we assumed that direct effects due to the insecticides toxicity were the reason for the differences in density. (4) The fourth group included three taxa in which the densities were significantly higher in the insecticide treatment in July and August than in the control. For this, indirect effects due to reduced biotic interactions may be responsible. The biomass was higher in the insecticide treatments in July, mainly because of a high increase in gastropod density, during the rest of the season it was similar between treatments and controls.     

Re-infestation of houses by Triatoma dimidiata after intra-domicile insecticide application in the Yucatán peninsula, Mexico

In most countries, Chagas disease transmission control remains based on domestic insecticide application. We thus evaluated the efficacy of intra-domicile cyfluthrin spraying for the control of Triatoma dimidiata, the only Chagas disease vector in the Yucatán peninsula, Mexico, and monitored potential re-infestation every 15 days for up to 9 months. We found that there was a re-infestation of houses by adult bugs starting 4 months after insecticide application, possibly from sylvatic/peridomicile areas. This points out the need to take into account the potential dispersal of sylvatic/peridomestic adult bugs into the domiciles as well as continuity action for an effective vector control.     

Three years of insecticide resistance monitoring in Anopheles gambiae in Burkina Faso: resistance on the rise?

ABSTRACT: Background and methods A longitudinal Anopheles gambiae s.l. insecticide-resistance monitoring programme was established in four sentinel sites in Burkina Faso. For three years, between 2008 and 2010, WHO diagnostic dose assays were used to measure the prevalence of resistance to all the major classes of insecticides at the beginning and end of the malaria transmission season. Species identification and genotyping for target site mutations was also performed and the sporozoite rate in adults determined. RESULTS: At the onset of the study, resistance to DDT and pyrethroids was already prevalent in An. gambiae s.l. from the south-west of the country but mosquitoes from the two sites in central Burkina Faso were largely susceptible. Within three years, DDT and permethrin resistance was established in all four sites. Carbamate and organophosphate resistance remains relatively rare and largely confined to the south-western areas although a small number of bendiocarb survivors were found in all sites by the final round of monitoring. The ace-1R target site resistance allele was present in all localities and its frequency exceeded 20% in 2010 in two of the sites. The frequency of the 1014 F kdr mutation increased throughout the three years and by 2010, the frequency of 1014 F in all sites combined was 0.02 in Anopheles arabiensis, 0.56 in An. gambiae M form and 0.96 in An. gambiae S form. This frequency did not differ significantly between the sites. The 1014 S kdr allele was only found in An. arabiensis but its frequency increased significantly throughout the study (P = 0.0003) and in 2010 the 1014 S allele frequency was 0.08 in An. arabiensis. Maximum sporozoite rates (12%) were observed in Soumousso in 2009 and the difference between sites is significant for each year. CONCLUSION: Pyrethroid and DDT resistance is now established in An. gambiae s.l. throughout Burkina Faso. Results from diagnostic dose assays are highly variable within and between rounds of testing, and hence it is important that resistance monitoring is carried out on more than one occasion before decisions on insecticide procurement for vector control are made. The presence of 1014 S in An. gambiae s.l., in addition to 1014 F, is not unexpected given the recent report of 1014 S in Benin but highlights the importance of monitoring for both mutations throughout the continent. Future research must now focus on the impact that this resistance is having on malaria control in Burkina Faso.     

Could resistance to insecticides in Plutella xylostella (Lep., Plutellidae) be overcome by insecticide mixtures?

Abstract: To investigate if synergism occurs between pyrethroids, organophosphates and new insecticides, we tested representatives of these compounds (bifenthrin, chlorpyrifos, spinosad, indoxacarb and emamectin) against the diamondback moth (Plutella xylostella). Larvicidal activity of these insecticides was assessed separately and together on a susceptible strain (Lab‐UK) of P. xylostella as well as a field population collected from Multan. The field population showed significant resistance to chlorpyrifos (331 100‐fold), bifenthrin (45 200‐fold), emamectin (1800‐fold), spinosad (11‐fold) and indoxacarb (5600‐fold) when compared with the Lab‐UK population. When insecticides were mixed based on LC₅₀ and tested at serial concentrations against Lab‐UK, significant synergy (CI < 1) occurred between bifenthrin, spinosad and emamectin. In contrast, the interaction between bifenthrin and indoxacarb was additive (CI = 1). The toxicity of bifenthrin against the field population increased significantly (P < 0.01) when combined with spinosad, emamectin and indoxacarb. Synergistic effects could be attributed to the complementary modes of action by these insecticide classes acting on different components of nerve impulse transmission (which are not identical for bifenthrin and indoxacarb either). However, chlorpyrifos/bifenthrin mixture was not significantly different either from bifenthrin or chlorpyrifos alone, indicating an additive affect. In combination with spinosad and emamectin, tested against the resistant field population, the toxicity of chlorpyrifos increased significantly and even more so with indoxacarb. Mixtures could also give rise to multiple resistance that may extend across other chemical classes and thus become difficult to manage. Therefore, alternative strategies such as mosaics or rotations should be considered. That is, though synergistic effects have been found, this should not be followed up as a strategy to manage resistant field populations.     

Effect of the insecticide Tanrec® on reproduction and vital activity of Daphnia magna Straus in a 15-day test

The effect of the insecticide Tanrec® at concentrations of 3.0 × 10^?7, 3.0 × 10^?2, and 3.0 × 10^?1 mg/L (as of imidacloprid) on Daphnia magna Straus has been studied. An acute toxic effect of this insecticide at a concentration of 3.0 × 10^?1 mg/L and a depressive effect at concentrations of 3.0 × 10^?2 mg/L and 3.0 × 10^?7 have been revealed. A damaging effect of Tanrec was revealed during the stage of early development of studied crustaceans. This effect was manifested in the inhibition of the growth of oocytes, abnormal functioning of the intestine, retardation of body growth, and pathological changes in tissues.     

Differential glycosylation produces heterogeneity in elevated esterases associated with insecticide resistance in the brown planthopper Nilaparvata lugens Stål

The major insecticide resistance mechanism in the brown planthopper Nilaparvata lugens involves overproduction of esterases. Esterases purified from a resistant strain appeared as a ladder of bands on isoelectric focussing (IEF) gels from pI 4.7 to 5.0. Two-dimensional electrophoresis showed that isozymes ranged in size from 66 to 68 kDa with those of lower pI being apparently smaller. All isozymes detected by two-dimensional electrophoresis were glycosylated. N-glycosidase A reduced the number of isozymes on IEF to two, with increased pI and an increased molecular weight of 69 kDa. No O-linked glycans were detected. Deglycosylation had no effect on esterase activity, hence glycosylation is not involved in active site conformation. As N-glycosidase F completely deglycosylated the esterases, none of the glycans has an alpha1,3-bound core fucose. Reactivity with the lectins GNA, MAA and DSA, combined with differential cleavage of N-linked glycans with endoglycosidases F1 and F2, indicated that terminally linked mannose is present in high mannose and/or hybrid type glycans and that terminally linked sialic acid and galactose-beta(1-4)-N-acetylglucosamine are present in biantennary complexes. Neuraminidase treatment had the same effect on pI of isozymes as complete deglycosylation. Therefore, the majority of the heterogeneity of elevated esterases on IEF is due to differential attachment of sialic acid to glycans of the two proteins.     

Does insecticide resistance alone account for the low genetic variability of asexually reproducing populations of the peach-potato aphid Myzus persicae?

The typical life cycle of aphids includes several parthenogenetic generations and a single sexual generation (cyclical parthenogenesis), but some species or populations are totally asexual (obligate parthenogenesis). Genetic variability is generally low in these asexually reproducing populations, that is, few genotypes are spread over large geographic areas. Both genetic drift and natural selection are often invoked to account for this low genetic variability. The peach-potato aphid, Myzus persicae, which encompasses both cyclical and obligate parthenogens, has developed several insecticide resistance mechanisms as a consequence of intense insecticide use since the 1950s. We collected asexually reproducing M. persicae from oilseed rape and examined genetic variability at eight microsatellite loci and three insecticide resistance genes to determine whether their genetic structure was driven by drift and/or selection. We identified only 16 multilocus microsatellite genotypes among 255 individuals. One clone, which combined two insecticide resistance mechanisms, was frequently detected in all populations whatever their location over a large geographical area (the northern half of France). These unexpected findings suggest that drift is not the unique cause of this low variability. Instead, the intensification of both insecticide treatments and oilseed rape cultivation may have favored a few genotypes. Thus, we propose that selective pressures resulting from human activities have considerably modified the genetic structure of M. persicae populations in northern France in a relatively short period of time.     

Tératogénie des anomalies axiales induites par un insecticide organophosphoré (le parathion) chez l'embryon d'oiseau

Résumé Chez les embryons de poulet et de caille, issus d'oeufs exposés au parathion au stade non incubé ou au cours des 48 premières heures, les anomalies axiales spécifiques de ce composé apparaissent entre 4 et 5 jours chez le Poulet et après 5 jours d'incubation chez la Caille. Les premières altérations accessibles aux examens morphologiques se traduisent par un tassement de certains myotomes ainsi que par des torsions de la chorde et du tube neural. Les anomalies se développent rapidement chez le Poulet alors que chez la Caille elles se mettent en place progressivement.Chez les deux espèces, les métamérisations primaire et secondaire (provertèbres) s'effectuent normalement. Alors que les premières phases des phénomènes de chondrification sont conformes à la normale, on assiste par la suite à la généralisation de ce processus qui conduit à l'effacement de la métamérie secondaire. Chez la Caille, des soudures vertébrales (ares neuraux et corps vertébraux) affectent des zones non touchées par les plissements.Des traitements au parathion, réalisés à différents stades de l'incubation (2e et 3e tiers de la vie embryonnaire) induisent chez le Poulet et la Caille, des déformations axiales tout à fait comparables, sur le plan morphologique, à celles engendrées par les traidements précoces. Toutefois, il y a lieu de souligner que les soudures vertébrales sont d'autant plus rares que le traitement est plus tardif.Chez l'embryon de Poulet de 16 jours, les scolioses cervicales sont en place 5 heures après l'injection du toxique. L'apparition rapide de cette malformation ainsi que les résultats des études tératogéniques réalisées après des traitements précoces, conduisent à penser que les troubles morphogénétiques ne sont pour l'essentiel qu'une conséquence d'une altération de la physiologie et/ou de la différenciation du tissu musculaire ce qui est en accord avec une hypothèse précédemment émise (Meiniel Lutz-Ostertag et Lutz, 1969).

---

Teratogenesis of axial abnormalities induced by an organic phosphorus insecticide (parathion) in the bird embryo

Summary Parathion, administered before incubation or at the beginning of development (48 h) induces specific axial deformities which occur between 4 and 5 days in the chick and after 5 days of incubation in the quail. Morphological studies indicate that the teratogenic effects are first represented by myotome compressions, notochordal and neural tube distortions.The abnormalities develop quickly in the chick embryo but take place gradually in the quail embryo.In the two species, somites and primitive vertebrae undergo a normal differentiation and the perinotochordal cells differentiate into chondroblast like in the normal way. But later, the chondrogenesis extends to the intervertebral clefts and gives rise to the formation of an unsegmented vertebral column. In the quail, vertebral fusions are encountered in regions where no torsion occurs.Cervical malformations can develop in quail and chick embryo, when parathion is injected at late stages (2nd and 3rd thirds of the embryonic life).The axial deformities are morphologically similar to those observed after early treatment. But, vertebral fusions are rarer the later the embryos are treated.In chick embryos of 16 days' incubation, the cervical scoliosis occurs 5 h after the treatment. The rapid occurrence of the malformation and the results obtained after early treatment support the hypothesis advanced earlier that the disturbed morphogenesis is caused — in great part — by an abnormal physiology and/or differentiation of the muscles (Meiniel, Lutz-Ostertag et Lutz, 1969).