Bacterial comparative genomic hybridization: a method for directly identifying lateral gene transfer.

Horizontally transferred DNA is largely responsible for the dissemination of virulence traits amongst bacteria. Rapid identification of acquired DNA remains difficult as whole-genome sequencing of outbreak strains is impractical, and microarray-based approaches, while powerful, are limited to genes present only in the reference strains. Here we present a novel bacterial comparative genomic hybridization method that directly compares the genomes of related strains at sub-kilobase resolution in order to identify acquired DNA. Bacterial comparative genomic hybridization utilizes the concept of metaphase chromosome comparative genomic hybridization, and exploits the resolving power of two-dimensional DNA electrophoresis. Comparison of isogenic variants of the pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa detected a single-copy gene insertion responsible for gentamicin resistance.     

Relationship between genome similarity and DNA-DNA hybridization among closely related bacteria

DNA-DNA hybridization has been established as an important technology in bacterial species taxonomy and phylogenetic analysis. In this study, we analyzed how the efficiency with which the genomic DNA from one species hybridizes to the genomic DNA of another species (DNA-DNA hybridization) in microarray analysis relates to the similarity between two genomes. We found that the predicted DNA-DNA hybridization based on genome sequence similarity correlated well with the experimentally determined microarray hybridization. Between closely related strains, significant numbers of highly divergent genes (<55% identity) and/or the accumulation of mismatches between conserved genes lowered the DNA-DNA hybridization signal, and this reduced the hybridization signals to below 70% for even bacterial strains with over 97% 16S rRNA gene identity. In addition, our results also suggest that a DNA-DNA hybridization signal intensity of over 40% indicates that two genomes at least shared 30% conserved genes (>60% gene identity). This study may expand our knowledge of DNA-DNA hybridization based on genomic sequence similarity comparison and further provide insights for bacterial phylogeny analyses.     

Distribution of repetitive DNA sequences in eubacteria and application to fingerprinting of bacterial genomes.

Dispersed repetitive DNA sequences have been described recently in eubacteria. To assess the distribution and evolutionary conservation of two distinct prokaryotic repetitive elements, consensus oligonucleotides were used in polymerase chain reaction [PCR] amplification and slot blot hybridization experiments with genomic DNA from diverse eubacterial species. Oligonucleotides matching Repetitive Extragenic Palindromic [REP] elements and Enterobacterial Repetitive Intergenic Consensus [ERIC] sequences were synthesized and tested as opposing PCR primers in the amplification of eubacterial genomic DNA. REP and ERIC consensus oligonucleotides produced clearly resolvable bands by agarose gel electrophoresis following PCR amplification. These band patterns provided unambiguous DNA fingerprints of different eubacterial species and strains. Both REP and ERIC probes hybridized preferentially to genomic DNA from Gram-negative enteric bacteria and related species. Widespread distribution of these repetitive DNA elements in the genomes of various microorganisms should enable rapid identification of bacterial species and strains, and be useful for the analysis of prokaryotic genomes.     

Identification and localization of differences between Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium genomes by suppressive subtractive hybridization

The availability of bacterial genome sequences raises an important new problem - how can one move from completely sequenced microorganisms as a reference to the hundreds and thousands of other strains or isolates of the same or related species that will not be sequenced in the near future? An efficient way to approach this task is the comparison of genomes by subtractive hybridization. Recently we developed a sensitive and reproducible subtraction procedure for comparison of bacterial genomes, based on the method of suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH). In this work we demonstrate the applicability of subtractive hybridization to the comparison of the related but markedly divergent bacterial species Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium. Clone libraries representing sequence differences were obtained and, in the case of completely sequenced E. coli genome, the differences were directly placed in the genome map. About 60% of the differential clones identified by SSH were present in one of the genomes under comparison and absent from the other. Additional differences in most cases represent sequences that have diverged considerably in the course of evolution. Such an approach to comparative bacterial genomics can be applied both to studies of interspecies evolution - to elucidate the "strategies" that enable different genomes to fit their ecological niches - and to development of diagnostic probes for the rapid identification of pathogenic bacterial species.     

Bacterial Species Determination from DNA-DNA Hybridization by Using Genome Fragments and DNA Microarrays

Whole genomic DNA-DNA hybridization has been a cornerstone of bacterial species determination but is not widely used because it is not easily implemented. We have developed a method based on random genome fragments and DNA microarray technology that overcomes the disadvantages of whole-genome DNA-DNA hybridization. Reference genomes of four fluorescent Pseudomonas species were fragmented, and 60 to 96 genome fragments of approximately 1 kb from each strain were spotted on microarrays. Genomes from 12 well-characterized fluorescent Pseudomonas strains were labeled with Cy dyes and hybridized to the arrays. Cluster analysis of the hybridization profiles revealed taxonomic relationships between bacterial strains tested at species to strain level resolution, suggesting that this approach is useful for the identification of bacteria as well as determining the genetic distance among bacteria. Since arrays can contain thousands of DNA spots, a single array has the potential for broad identification capacity. In addition, the method does not require laborious cross-hybridizations and can provide an open database of hybridization profiles, avoiding the limitations of traditional DNA-DNA hybridization.     

Comparison of Genomes in Streptococcus thermophilus Strains of Different Origin

According to DNA hybridization data, thermophilic streptococci used in Russia as starters in the dairy industry are divided into six different genomovars, with a degree of DNA homology not exceeding 20–50%. The analysis of genomes from these genomovars using SmaI restriction endonuclease and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis revealed wide variability of the genome size. In some strains, the genome size considerably exceeded 2000 kbp. Most of the strains studied contained plasmids about 120 kbp in size.     

A new experimental approach for studying bacterial genomic island evolution identifies island genes with bacterial host-specific expression patterns

Background  

Genomic islands are regions of bacterial genomes that have been acquired by horizontal transfer and often contain blocks of genes that function together for specific processes. Recently, it has become clear that the impact of genomic islands on the evolution of different bacterial species is significant and represents a major force in establishing bacterial genomic variation. However, the study of genomic island evolution has been mostly performed at the sequence level using computer software or hybridization analysis to compare different bacterial genomic sequences. We describe here a novel experimental approach to study the evolution of species-specific bacterial genomic islands that identifies island genes that have evolved in such a way that they are differentially-expressed depending on the bacterial host background into which they are transferred.     

Characterization and application of soybean YACs to molecular cytogenetics

Yeast artificial chromosomes (YACs) are widely used in the physical analysis of complex genomes. In addition to their value in chromosome walking for map-based cloning, YACs represent excellent probes for chromosome mapping using fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). We have screened such a library for low-copy-number clones by hybridization to total genomic DNA. Four clones were chosen for chromosome tagging based upon their low or moderate signal. By using degenerate oligonucleotide-primed PCR (DOP-PCR), we were able to use relatively small amounts of soybean YAC DNA, isolated directly by preparative pulsed-field gel electrophoresis, as FISH probes for both metaphase chromosome spreads and interphase nuclei. FISH chromosomal analysis using the three of the clones as probes resulted in relatively simple hybridization patterns consistent with a single homologous locus or two homoeologous loci. The fourth YAC probe resulted in a diffuse hybridization pattern with signal on all metaphase chromosomes. We conclude that YACs represent a valuable source of probes for chromosomal analysis in soybean.     

Novel SCAR primers for specific and sensitive detection of Agrobacterium vitis strains

An Agrobacterium vitis-specific DNA fragment (pAVS3) was generated from PCR polymorphic bands amplified by primer URP 2R. A. vitis specificity of this fragment was confirmed by Southern hybridization with genomic DNA from different Agrobacterium species. Sequence-characterized amplified region (SCAR) markers were developed for A. vitis specific detection, using 24-mer oligonucleotide primers designed from the flanking ends of the 670 bp insert in pAVS3. The SCAR primers amplified target sequences only from A. vitis strains and not from other Agrobacterium species or other bacterial genera. First round PCR detected bacterial cells between 5×10² and 1×10³ cfu/ml and the detection sensitivity was increased to as few as 2 cfu/ml by nested PCR. This PCR protocol can be used to confirm the potential presence of infectious A. vitis strains in soil and furthermore, can identify A. vitis strains from naturally infected crown galls.     

Physical and genetic map of the Methanobacterium wolfei genome and its comparison with the updated genomic map of Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum Marburg

A physical and genetic map of the chromosome of Methanobacterium wolfei was constructed by using pulsed-field gel electrophoresis of restriction fragments generated by digestion with NotI and NheI. The chromosome was found to be circular and 1,729 kb in size. Twenty-eight genes were mapped to specific restriction enzyme fragments by performing hybridization experiments with gene probes from various Methanobacterium strains. The genomic map obtained was compared with the updated genomic map of Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum Marburg. In spite of major restriction pattern dissimilarities, the overall genetic organization seemed to be conserved between the genomes of the two strains. In addition, the two rRNA operons of strain Marburg were precisely mapped on the chromosome, and it was shown that they are transcribed in the same direction.     

Bacterial species determination from DNA-DNA hybridization by using genome fragments and DNA microarrays

Whole genomic DNA-DNA hybridization has been a cornerstone of bacterial species determination but is not widely used because it is not easily implemented. We have developed a method based on random genome fragments and DNA microarray technology that overcomes the disadvantages of whole-genome DNA-DNA hybridization. Reference genomes of four fluorescent Pseudomonas species were fragmented, and 60 to 96 genome fragments of approximately 1 kb from each strain were spotted on microarrays. Genomes from 12 well-characterized fluorescent Pseudomonas strains were labeled with Cy dyes and hybridized to the arrays. Cluster analysis of the hybridization profiles revealed taxonomic relationships between bacterial strains tested at species to strain level resolution, suggesting that this approach is useful for the identification of bacteria as well as determining the genetic distance among bacteria. Since arrays can contain thousands of DNA spots, a single array has the potential for broad identification capacity. In addition, the method does not require laborious cross-hybridizations and can provide an open database of hybridization profiles, avoiding the limitations of traditional DNA-DNA hybridization.     

Molecular characterization of transgenic shallots (Allium cepa L.) by adaptor ligation PCR (AL-PCR) and sequencing of genomic DNA flanking T-DNA borders

Genomic DNA blot hybridization is traditionally used to demonstrate that, via genetic transformation, foreign genes are integrated into host genomes. However, in large genome species, such as Allium cepa L., the use of genomic DNA blot hybridization is pushed towards its limits, because a considerable quantity of DNA is needed to obtain enough genome copies for a clear hybridization pattern. Furthermore, genomic DNA blot hybridization is a time-consuming method. Adaptor ligation PCR (AL-PCR) of genomic DNA flanking T-DNA borders does not have these drawbacks and seems to be an adequate alternative to genomic DNA blot hybridization. Using AL-PCR we proved that T-DNA was integrated into the A. cepa genome of three transgenic lines transformed with Agrobacterium tumefaciens EHA105 (pCAMBIA 1301). The AL-PCR patterns obtained were specific and reproducible for a given transgenic line. The results showed that T-DNA integration took place and gave insight in the number of T-DNA copies present. Comparison of AL-PCR and previously obtained genomic DNA blot hybridization results pointed towards complex T-DNA integration patterns in some of the transgenic plants. After cloning and sequencing the AL-PCR products, the junctions between plant genomic DNA and the T-DNA insert could be analysed in great detail. For example it was shown that upon T-DNA integration a 66bp genomic sequence was deleted, and no filler DNA was inserted. Primers located within the left and right flanking genomic DNA in transgenic shallot plants were used to recover the target site of T-DNA integration.     

The Use of Suppression Subtractive Hybridization to Identify Strain-Specific Sequences in Bacterial Genomes

Comparisons of bacterial genomes demonstrate that even strains of one species may strikingly differ in gene set. Strain-specific genes are of considerable interest, as they may be responsible for distinguishing features, such as virulence or drug resistance, of the strain and may be employed as markers in epidemiological or evolutionary studies. Suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) was shown to be suitable for generating a set of DNA fragments differing between two closely related bacterial strains. More than 95% DNA fragments selected by SSH proved to be specific for Staphylococcus aureus strains ZW compared with strain 29213.     

A kinetic model for subtractive hybridization.

Nucleic acid sequences that differ in abundance between two populations (target sequences) can be cloned by multiple rounds of subtractive hybridization and amplification by PCR. These sequences can be cDNAs representing up-regulated mRNAs, or genomic DNAs from deletion mutants. We have derived an equation that describes the recovery of such sequences, and have used this to simulate the outcome of up to 10 rounds of subtractive hybridization and PCR amplification. When the model was tested by comparing its predictions with the published results from genomic and cDNA subtractions, the predictions of the model were generally in good agreement with the published data. We have modelled the outcomes of genomic subtractions, for a variety of genomes, and have used it to compare various strategies for enriching targets. The model predicts that for genomes of less than 5 x 10(8) bp, deletions of as small as 1 kbp should represent > 99% of the DNA after three to six rounds of hybridization (depending on the enrichment procedure). As genomes increase in size, the kinetics of hybridization become an important limiting factor. However, even for genomes as large as 3 x 10(9) bp, it should be possible to isolate deletions of 5 kbp using the appropriate conditions. These simulations suggest that such methods offer a realistic alternative to chromosome walking for identifying genomic deletions for which there are known phenotypes, thereby considerably reducing time and effort. For cDNA subtractive hybridization, the model predicts that after six rounds of hybridization, sequences that do not differ in abundance between the tester and driver populations (the background) will represent < 1% of the subtracted population, and even quite modestly upregulated cDNAs should be successfully enriched. Where several up-regulated cDNAs are present, the predicted final representation is dependent on both the initial abundance and the degree of up-regulation.     

Rep-PCR mediated genomic fingerprinting of rhizobia and computer-assisted phylogenetic pattern analysis

A rapid and reproducible method has been developed for genomic fingerprinting of rhizobia and other soil microbes interacting with plants. The method is based on the use of oligonucleotide primers, corresponding to conserved motifs in naturally occurring interspersed repetitive DNA elements in bacteria (rep-elements), and the polymerase chain reaction (rep-PCR). Rep-PCR results in the amplification of inter-element genomic DNA fragments of characteristic lengths and thereby generates a genomic fingerprint. These fingerprints resemble UPC bar code patterns, and can be used to identify bacteria at the sub-species and strain level, as well as for phylogenetic analyses. Here we show that highly characteristic and very reproducible rep-PCR generated genomic fingerprints can be obtained not only from purified genomic DNA, but also directly from rhizobial cells derived from liquid cultures or from colonies on plates, as well as from nodule tissue. We examine the effect of growth phase of the bacterial cells, serial subculturing and other parameters on the reproducibility of the rep-PCR fingerprinting protocol. Moreover, we describe the results of mixing experiments designed to determine if individual genomic fingerprints can be recognized in mixtures of strains. Lastly, we review the use of computer-based fragment detection and phylogentic analysis packages to analyse rep-PCR generated genomic fingerprints of a collection of Rhizobium loti and Bradyrhizobium strains nodulating different Lotus spp.The authors are with the NSF Center for Microbial Ecology and the MSU-DOE Plant Research Laboratory. F. J. de Bruijn is also with the Microbiology Department and Genetics Program of Michigan State University, E. Lansing, MI 48824 USA.     

Gene identification in a complex chromosomal continuum by local genomic cross-referencing

Most higher plants have complex genomes containing large quantities of repetitive DNA interspersed with low-copy-number sequences. Many of these repetitive DNAs are mobile and have homology to RNAs in various cell types. This can make it difficult to identify the genes in a long chromosomal continuum. It was decided to use genic sequence conservation and grass genome co-linearity as tools for gene identification. A bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) clone containing sorghum genomic DNA was selected using a maize Adh1 probe. The 165 kb sorghum BAC was tested for hybridization to a set of clones representing the contiguous 280 kb of DNA flanking maize Adh1. None of the repetitive maize DNAs hybridized, but most of the low-copy-number sequences did. A low-copy-number sequence that did cross-hybridize was found to be a gene, while one that did not was found to be a low-copy-number retrotransposon that was named Reina. Regions of cross-hybridization were co-linear between the two genomes, but closer together in the smaller sorghum genome. These results indicate that local genomic cross-referencing by hybridization of orthologous clones can be an efficient and rapid technique for gene identification and studies of genome organization.     

Distribution of oxoacyl synthase homology sequences within Streptomyces DNA

Abstract A genomic DNA sequence of Streptomyces strain ISP 5485 was cloned, sequenced and compared with corresponding information from nucleic acid data banks. The DNA sequence was unique, but showed homology to DNA coding for the condensing enzyme, 2-oxoacyl synthase, of the deoxyerythronolide B synthase complex (DEBS) from Saccharopolyspora erythraea NRRL 2338. A subfragment of the sequenced DNA was used to construct a gene-specific probe that formed part of the putative 2-oxoacyl synthase gene. The PCR-amplified and labelled probe was used in hybridization experiments involving 33 streptomycete strains that produced different classes of antibiotics. The probe showed widespread homology with DNA considered to be part of analogous genes within genomes of different polyketide producers. The implications of the probe homology to bacterial chromosomal DNA are discussed.     

Molecular and cytogenetic characterization of repetitive DNA sequences from Lolium and Festuca: applications in the analysis of Festulolium hybrids

Summary A set of species-specific repetitive DNA sequences was isolated from Lolium multiflorum and Festuca arundinacea. The degree of their species specificity as well as possible homologies among them were determined by dot-blot hybridization analysis. In order to understand the genomic organization of representative Lolium and Festuca-specific repetitive DNA sequences, we performed Southern blot hybridization and in situ hybridization to metaphase chromosomes.Southern blot hybridization analysis of eight different repetitive DNA sequences of L. multiflorum and one of F. arundinacea indicated either tandem and clustered arrangements of partially dispersed localization in their respective genomes. Some of these sequences, e.g. LMB3, showed a similar genomic organization in F. arundinacea and F. pratensis, but a slightly different organization and degree of redundancy in L. multiflorum. Clones sequences varied in size between 100 bp and 1.2 kb. Estimated copy number in the corresponding haploid genomes varied between 300 and 2×10⁴. Sequence analysis of the highly species-specific sequences from plasmids pLMH2 and pLMB4 (L. multiflorum specific) and from pFAH1 (F. arundinacea specific) revealed some internal repeats without higher order. No homologies between the sequences or to other repetitive sequences were observed. In situ hybridization with these latter sequences to metaphase chromosomes from L. multiflorum, F. arundinacea and from symmetric sexual Festulolium hybrid revealed their relatively even distribution in the corresponding genomes. The in situ hybridization thus also allowed a clearcut simple identification of parental chromosomes in the Festulolium hybrid.The potential use of these species-specific clones as hybridization probes in quantitative dot-blot analysis of the genomic make-up of Festulolium (sexual and somatic) hybrids is also demonstrated.Abbreviations bp Base pair (s) - CMA chromomycin A₃ - DAPI 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole - IPTG isopropyl -D-thio-galactopyranoside - kb kilobase pair(s) - NBT nitroblue tetrazolium chloride - X-gal 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-inonyl -D-galactopyranoside     

Parental genomes are separated throughout the cell cycle in a plant hybrid

The positions of the genomes originating from each parent were analysed in root-tip nuclei of the mature, sexual F₁ hybrid plant Hordeum vulgare (barley) x Secale africanum (a wild rye). The two genomes of the hybrid were identified in both spread and sectioned material by non-radioactive DNA:DNA in situ hybridization using labelled total genomic DNA from one parent as a proble and unlabelled total genomic DNA from the other parent to block non-specific hybridization. Complete three-dimensional reconstructions of sets of labelled sections enabled detailed analysis of the position of the genomes at interphase. The parental genomes lay in various non-intermixed configurations, including lateral and concentric arrangements. On spread preparations, the two parental genomes were found to be spatially separated throughout the cell cycle; the genome originating from H. vulgare tended to be located more centrally than that from S. africanum. This results show that the nucleus is spatially organized above the level of the DNA and chromosome at the genome level.by M.F. Trendelenburg