Replicon Clusters Are Stable Units of Chromosome Structure: Evidence That Nuclear Organization Contributes to the Efficient Activation and Propagation of S Phase in Human Cells

In proliferating cells, DNA synthesis must be performed with extreme precision. We show that groups of replicons, labeled together as replicon clusters, form stable units of chromosome structure. HeLa cells were labeled with 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) at different times of S phase. At the onset of S phase, clusters of replicons were activated in each of ~750 replication sites. The majority of these replication “foci” were shown to be individual replicon clusters that remained together, as stable cohorts, throughout the following 15 cell cycles. In individual cells, the same replication foci were labeled with BrdU and 5-iododeoxyuridine at the beginning of different cell cycles. In DNA fibers, 95% of replicons in replicon clusters that were labeled at the beginning of one S phase were also labeled at the beginning of the next. This shows that a subset of origins are activated both reliably and efficiently in different cycles.

The majority of replication forks activated at the onset of S phase terminated 45–60 min later. During this interval, secondary replicon clusters became active. However, while the activation of early replicons is synchronized at the onset of S phase, different secondary clusters were activated at different times. Nevertheless, replication foci pulse labeled during any short interval of S phase were stable for many cell cycles. We propose that the coordinated replication of related groups of replicons, that form stable replicon clusters, contributes to the efficient activation and propagation of S phase in mammalian cells.

     

Nuclear matrix support of DNA replication

In higher eukaryotic cells, DNA is tandemly arranged into 10(4) replicons that are replicated once per cell cycle during the S phase. To achieve this, DNA is organized into loops attached to the nuclear matrix. Each loop represents one individual replicon with the origin of replication localized within the loop and the ends of the replicon attached to the nuclear matrix at the bases of the loop. During late G1 phase, the replication origins are associated with the nuclear matrix and dissociated after initiation of replication in S phase. Clusters of several replicons are operated together by replication factories, assembled at the nuclear matrix. During replication, DNA of each replicon is spooled through these factories, and after completion of DNA synthesis of any cluster of replicons, the respective replication factories are dismantled and assembled at the next cluster to be replicated. Upon completion of replication of any replicon cluster, the resulting entangled loops of the newly synthesized DNA are resolved by topoisomerases present in the nuclear matrix at the sites of attachment of the loops. Thus, the nuclear matrix plays a dual role in the process of DNA replication: on one hand, it represents structural support for the replication machinery and on the other, provides key protein factors for initiation, elongation, and termination of the replication of eukaryotic DNA.     

Inhibition of mammalian cell DNA synthesis by ionizing radiation

A semi-log plot of the inhibitory effect of ionizing radiation on the rate of DNA synthesis in normal mammalian cells yields a two-component curve. The steep component, at low doses, has a D0 of about 5 Gy and is the result of blocks to initiation of DNA replicons. The shallow component, at high doses, has a D0 of greater than or equal to 100 Gy and is the result of blocks to DNA chain elongation. The target size for the inhibition of DNA replicon initiation is about 1000 kb, and the target size for inhibition of DNA chain elongation is about 50 kb. There is evidence that the target for both components is DNA alone. Therefore, the target size for inhibition of DNA chain elongation is consistent with the idea that an effective radiation-induced lesion in front of the DNA growing point somehow blocks its advance. The target size for inhibition of DNA replicon initiation is so large that it must include many replicons, which is consistent with the concept that a single lesion anywhere within a large group (cluster) of replicons is sufficient to block the initiation of replication of all replicons within that cluster. Studies with radiosensitive human cell mutants suggest that there is an intermediary factor whose normal function is necessary for radiation-induced lesions to cause the inhibition of replicon initiation in clusters and to block chain elongation; this factor is not related to poly(ADP-ribose) synthesis. Studies with radiosensitive Chinese hamster cell mutants suggest that double-strand breaks and their repair are important in regulating the duration of radiation-induced inhibition of replicon initiation but have little to do with effects on chain elongation. There is no simple correlation between inhibition of DNA synthesis and cell killing by ionizing radiation.     

Selective and synchronous activation of early-S-phase replicons of Ehrlich ascites cells.

Twelve-hour exposure of G1 Ehrlich ascites cells to controlled hypoxia (200 ppm of O2 at 1 bar) suppressed replicon initiation. Synchronous cycling, beginning with a normal S phase, was released by reoxygenation immediately. The addition of cycloheximide at reoxygenation largely resuppressed, after a short initial burst, succeeding replicon initiations. Alkaline sedimentation analysis of growing daughter strand DNA, DNA fiber autoradiography, and analysis of the newly formed DNA demonstrated that normal chain growth and DNA maturation (replicon termination) in the initially activated replicons continued in the presence of cycloheximide. After 2 to 3 h, a low level of cycloheximide-insensitive background replication emerged out of the then-ebbing single surge of activity of the initially released replicons.     

Recovery from effects of heat on DNA synthesis in Chinese hamster ovary cells

The hyperthermic inhibition of cellular DNA synthesis, i.e., reduction in replicon initiation and delay in DNA chain elongation, was previously postulated to be involved in the induction of chromosomal aberrations believed to be largely responsible for killing S-phase cells. Utilizing asynchronous Chinese hamster ovary cells heated for 15 min at 45.5 degrees C, an increase in single-stranded regions in replicating DNA (as measured by BND-cellulose chromatography) persisted in heated cells for as long as replicon initiation was affected. Alkaline sucrose gradient analyses of cells pulse-labeled immediately after heating with [3H]thymidine and subsequently chased at 37 degrees C revealed that these S-phase cells can eventually complete elongation of the replicons in operation at the time of heating, but required about six times as long relative to control cells which completed replicon elongation within 4 h. DNA chain elongation into multicluster-sized molecules was prevented for up to 18 h in these heated cells, resulting in a buildup of cluster-sized molecules (approximately 120-160 S) mainly because of the long-term heat damage to the replicon initiation process. Utilizing bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU)-propidium iodide bivariate analysis on a flow cytometer to measure cell progression, control cells pulsed with BrdU and chased in unlabeled medium progressed through S and G2M with cell division starting after 2 h of chase time. In contrast, the majority of the heated S-phase cells progressed slowly and remained blocked in S phase for about 18 h before cell division was observed after 24 h postheat. Our findings suggest that possible sites for where the chromosomal aberrations may be occurring in heated S-phase cells are either (1) at the persistent single-stranded DNA regions or (2) at the regions between clusters of replicons, because this long-term heat damage to the DNA replication process might lead to many opportunities for abnormal DNA and/or protein exchanges to occur at these two sites.     

The human Tim/Tipin complex coordinates an Intra-S checkpoint response to UV that slows replication fork displacement

UV-induced DNA damage stalls DNA replication forks and activates the intra-S checkpoint to inhibit replicon initiation. In response to stalled replication forks, ATR phosphorylates and activates the transducer kinase Chk1 through interactions with the mediator proteins TopBP1, Claspin, and Timeless (Tim). Murine Tim recently was shown to form a complex with Tim-interacting protein (Tipin), and a similar complex was shown to exist in human cells. Knockdown of Tipin using small interfering RNA reduced the expression of Tim and reversed the intra-S checkpoint response to UVC. Tipin interacted with replication protein A (RPA) and RPA-coated DNA, and RPA promoted the loading of Tipin onto RPA-free DNA. Immunofluorescence analysis of spread DNA fibers showed that treating HeLa cells with 2.5 J/m(2) UVC not only inhibited the initiation of new replicons but also reduced the rate of chain elongation at active replication forks. The depletion of Tim and Tipin reversed the UV-induced inhibition of replicon initiation but affected the rate of DNA synthesis at replication forks in different ways. In undamaged cells depleted of Tim, the apparent rate of replication fork progression was 52% of the control. In contrast, Tipin depletion had little or no effect on fork progression in unirradiated cells but significantly attenuated the UV-induced inhibition of DNA chain elongation. Together, these findings indicate that the Tim-Tipin complex mediates the UV-induced intra-S checkpoint, Tim is needed to maintain DNA replication fork movement in the absence of damage, Tipin interacts with RPA on DNA and, in UV-damaged cells, Tipin slows DNA chain elongation in active replicons.     

Effects of psoralen on replicon size and mean rate of DNA synthesis in partially synchronized cells of Pisum sativum L.

We have examined by fibre autoradiography the spacing of replicons in pea root meristems during synchronized entry into S phase from arrest at the G1/S boundary. Pretreatment with the DNA cross-linking agent, psoralen, produces a marked shortening of replicon spacing, suggesting that premature arrest of the replication fork results in the recruitment of additional initiation points within a given replicon family. This is discussed in relation to models for the control of DNA replication.     

Inhibition of replicon initiation in human cells following stabilization of topoisomerase-DNA cleavable complexes.

Diploid human fibroblast strains were treated for 10 min with inhibitors of type I and type II DNA topoisomerases, and after removal of the inhibitors, the rate of initiation of DNA synthesis at replicon origins was determined. By alkaline elution chromatography, 4'-(9-acridinylamino)methanesulfon-m-anisidide (amsacrine), an inhibitor of DNA topoisomerase II, was shown to produce DNA strand breaks. These strand breaks are thought to reflect drug-induced stabilization of topoisomerase-DNA cleavable complexes. Removal of the drug led to a rapid resealing of the strand breaks by dissociation of the complexes. Velocity sedimentation analysis was used to quantify the effects of amsacrine treatment on DNA replication. It was demonstrated that transient exposure to low concentrations of amsacrine inhibited replicon initiation but did not substantially affect DNA chainelongation within operating replicons. Maximal inhibition of replicon initiation occurred 20 to 30 min after drug treatment, and the initiation rate recovered 30 to 90 min later. Ataxia telangiectasia cells displayed normal levels of amsacrine-induced DNA strand breaks during stabilization of cleavable complexes but failed to downregulate replicon initiation after exposure to the topoisomerase inhibitor. Thus, inhibition of replicon initiation in response to DNA damage appears to be an active process which requires a gene product which is defective or missing in ataxia telangiectasia cells. In normal human fibroblasts, the inhibition of DNA topoisomerase I by camptothecin produced reversible DNA strand breaks. Transient exposure to this drug also inhibited replicon initiation. These results suggest that the cellular response pathway which downregulates replicon initiation following genotoxic damage may respond to perturbations of chromatin structure which accompany stabilization of topoisomerase-DNA cleavable complexes.     

The action of ionizing radiation on DNA replication in the cells of a healthy human subject and of a patient with Down's syndrome

Using DNA fiber autoradiography we have revealed a new defect earlier unknown in Down's syndrome but analogous to that earlier shown by the authors in AT and basal cell nevus. This syndrome involves a significantly decreased number of simultaneously operating groups of replicons compared to that in normal cells., the rate of fork movement and the fusion of neighbouring units in the group being unchanged. Ionizing radiation (5 Gy) does not change the rate of DNA chain growth in the cells derived from the affected individuals, however, it significantly reduces this parameter in normal cells due to inhibition of replicon initiation in the whole clusters. Thus, radioresistant DNA synthesis in chromosomal instability syndromes may be explained by some defect in DNA replication in unirradiated cells analogous to that in irradiated normal cells.     

The effect of bleomycin on DNA synthesis in human cells: evidence for grouping of initiation of replicons in the S-period

The effect of bleomycin (Blm) on DNA synthesis has been studied in a synchronous culture of human embryonic lung cells. The data obtained suggest that in the Blm presence in a medium (20 micrograms/ml) DNA synthesis initiation in new replicons is suppressed. The Blm action at different S-phase intervals has been shown to inhibit DNA synthesis unequally. Four discrete time intervals have been singled out in the course of the 10-hr S-phase in which a grouped initiation of replicon portions can be supposed. Together with the data on DNA replication in large-size replicon units (50-500 microns), the obtained results account well for the uneven DNA synthesis in S-phase, manifested by 3 or 4 peaks of [3H]-thymidine incorporation in pulse-labelled cells.     

Effect of puromycin on DNA replication in Chinese hamster cells

We have used autoradiography to examine the effect of puromycin on DNA replication in Chinese hamster cells aligned by treatment with fluorodeoxy-uridine. In the absence of puromycin the patterns of replication are consistent with those obtained previously by others (Cairns, 1966; Huberman &; Riggs, 1968). In particular, replication occurs in tandem clusters of replicons but not all replicons in a cluster appear to be activated at the same time.Puromycin decreases the over-all rate of synthesis of DNA per cell, but does not inhibit chain elongation as visualized in autoradiograms. It is suggested that puromycin inhibits the initiation of replication of replicons not yet activated. Puromycin prevents the joining of short stretches of radioactive DNA into longer pieces. This may be due to the inability to activate a few late replicating units within a cluster of replicons.     

Checkpoint Regulation of Replication Dynamics in UV-Irradiated Human Cells

At any moment during S phase, regions of genomic DNA are in various stages of replication (i.e. initiation, chain elongation, and termination). These stages may be differentially inhibited after treatment with various carcinogens that damage DNA such as UV. We used visualization of active replication units in combed DNA fibers, in combination with quantitative analyses of the size distributions of nascent DNA, to evaluate the role of S-checkpoint proteins in UV-induced inhibition of DNA replication. When HeLa cells were exposed to a low fluence (1 J/m2) of 254 nm UV light (UVC), new initiation events were severely inhibited (5-6-fold reduction). A larger fluence of UVC (10 J/m2) resulted in stronger inhibition of the overall rate of DNA synthesis without decreasing further the frequency of replicon initiation events. Incubation of HeLa cells with caffeine and knockdown of ATR or Chk1 kinases reversed the UVC-induced inhibition of initiation of new replicons. These findings illustrate the concordance of data derived from different experimental approaches, thus strengthening the evidence that the activation of the intra-S checkpoint by UVC is dependent on the ATR and Chk1 kinases.     

Inhibition of replicon cluster ligation into chromosomal DNA at elevated temperatures

The rate-limiting enzymatic step for DNA replication in HeLa cells incubated at 43.5 degrees C was the ligation of clusters of replicons into the cell's genome. At 43.5 degrees C the reciprocal slope for inhibition of DNA chain (replicon) initiation, or of the ligation of replicon clusters into the genome, was 18 or 7 min, respectively. The failure of replicon clusters to be ligated into chromosomal DNA was not a consequence of the failure of histone proteins to be deposited onto replicating DNA, or of chromatin replicated at 43.5 degrees C to be organized into fully condensed chromatin. In addition it was not due to the failure of fully active topoisomerase II to be deposited at a normal frequency along replicating chromatin DNA. The failure of replicon clusters to be ligated into the genome resulted in the persistence of single, but not double, DNA strand breaks in the cell's genome 24 hours after cell heating.     

Recovery of DNA synthesis after ultraviolet irradiation of xeroderma pigmentosum cells depends on excision repair and is blocked by caffeine

Normal human and xeroderma pigmentosum (XP, excision-defective group A) cells (both SV40-transformed) pulse-labeled with [(3)H]thymidine at various times after irradiation with ultraviolet light showed a decline and recovery of both the molecular weights of newly synthesized DNA and the rates of synthesis per cell. At the same ultraviolet dose, both molecular weights and rates of synthesis were inhibited more in XP than in normal cells. This indicates that excision repair plays a role in minimizing the inhibition of chain growth, possibly by excision of dimers ahead of the growing point. The ability to synthesize normal-sized DNA recovered more rapidly than rates of synthesis in normal cells, but both parameters recovered in phase in XP cells. During recovery in normal cells there are therefore fewer actively replicating clusters of replicons because the single-strand breaks involved in the excision of dimers inhibit replicon initiation. XP cells have few excision repair events and therefore fewer breaks to interfere with initiation, but chain growth is blocked by unexcised dimers. In both cell types recovery of the ability to synthesize normal-sized DNA was prevented by growing cells in caffeine after irradiation, possibly because of competition between the DNA binding properties of caffeine and replication proteins.Our observations imply that excision repair and semiconservative replication interact strongly in irradiated cells to produce a complex spectrum of changes in DNA replication which may be confused with parts of alternative systems such as post-replication repair.     

Mechanisms of inhibition of DNA replication by ultraviolet light in normal human and xeroderma pigmentosum fibroblasts

The inhibition of DNA replication in ultraviolet-irradiated human fibroblasts was characterized by quantitative analysis of radiation-induced alterations in the steady-state distribution of sizes of pulse-labeled, nascent DNA. Low, noncytotoxic fluences (<1 J/m², producing less than one pyrimidine dimer per replicon) rapidly produced an inhibition of DNA synthesis in half-replicon-size replication intermediates without noticeably affecting synthesis in multi-repliconsize intermediates. With time, the inhibition produced by low fluences spread progressively to include multi-replicon-size intermediates. The results indicate that ultraviolet radiation inhibits the initiation of DNA synthesis in replicons. Higher (>1 J/m², producing more than one dimer per replicon) cytotoxic fluences inhibited DNA synthesis in operating replicons presumably because the elongation of nascent strands was blocked where pyrimidine dimers were present in template strands. Xeroderma pigmentosum fibroblasts with deficiencies in DNA excision repair exhibited an inhibition of replicon initiation after low radiation fluences. indicating the effect was not solely dependent upon operation of the nucleotidyl excision repair pathway. Owing to their inability to remove pyrimidine dimers ahead of DNA growing points, the repair-deficient cells also were more sensitive than normal cells to the ultraviolet-induced inhibition of chain elongation. Xeroderma pigmentosum cells belonging to the variant class were even more sensitive to inhibition of chain elongation than the repair-deficient strains despite their ability to remove pyrimidine dimers. This analysis suggests that normal and repair-deficient human fibroblasts either are able to rapidly bypass certain dimers or these dimers are not recognized by the chain elongation machinery.     

Oxygen dependence of nuclear DNA replication in Ehrlich ascites cells

Oxygen was excluded from cultured Ehrlich ascites cells for 5-7 h and then readmitted. During the anaerobic period and for about 1 h following reoxygenation the DNA synthesis of the cells was studied by determining the DNA synthesis rate from [3H] thymidine incorporation data, by evaluation of the thymidine (pulse labelling) index, by DNA fibre autoradiography, and by alkaline sucrose gradients in order to follow the maturation of the daughter chains. The DNA synthesis rate was found to decay to a few percent of the initial value within 5-7 h after deoxygenation. Immediately after reoxygenation it increased to exceed the control level within 0.5-1 h. The only partial process of the genome replication definitely responding to deoxygenation/reoxygenation was the initiation of new replicon units, while progress of the replication forks and maturation of the new daughter chains were not significantly affected. The coordination of replicon initiation within groups or clusters was maintained throughout. The interruption of replication at the level of initiation of clusters upon deoxygenation was interpreted as a regulatory response of the cells to ensure basic viability under unfavourable conditions.     

Decreased frequency of activation of replicon clusters in Down syndrome lymphocytes

Human blood lymphocytes from two normal and seven Down syndrome (DS) subjects were examined to determine rates of synthesis of individual replicon and adjacent clusters of replicons, using DNA fiber autoradiography. Lymphocytes in 6 of 7 DS patients were shown to have significantly slower synthesis of simultaneously active adjacent replicon clusters compared to normal controls. Rates of synthesis of individual replicons were the same in lymphocytes from all the subjects investigated. These results demonstrate differences in respect to the structural organization of clusters of replicons between DS and normal lymphocytes. A possible relation of the above phenomenon to the chromosomal radiosensitivity in DS cells is discussed.     

Inhibition of replicon initiation by 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate

To investigate the inhibition of DNA replication by tumor promoters, we incubated HeLa cells with 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA; 10^?8 to 10^?5 g/ml) and quantified DNA synthesis on alkaline sucrose gradients. TPA was found to selectively inhibit replicon initiation without affecting DNA chain elongation in replicons that had already initiated. No inhibition of DNA synthesis was seen when cells were exposed to the nonpromoting derivative of TPA, 4-α-phorbol 12,13-didecanoate. Superoxide dismutase did not prevent the TPA-induced inhibition of initiation.     

Relationship of eukaryotic DNA replication to committed gene expression: general theory for gene control.

The historic arguments for the participation of eukaryotic DNA replication in the control of gene expression are reconsidered along with more recent evidence. An earlier view in which gene commitment was achieved with stable chromatin structures which required DNA replication to reset expression potential (D. D. Brown, Cell 37:359-365, 1984) is further considered. The participation of nonspecific stable repressor of gene activity (histones and other chromatin proteins), as previously proposed, is reexamined. The possible function of positive trans-acting factors is now further developed by considering evidence from DNA virus models. It is proposed that these positive factors act to control the initiation of replicon-specific DNA synthesis in the S phase (early or late replication timing). Stable chromatin assembles during replication into potentially active (early S) or inactive (late S) states with prevailing trans-acting factors (early) or repressing factors (late) and may asymmetrically commit daughter templates. This suggests logical schemes for programming differentiation based on replicons and trans-acting initiators. This proposal requires that DNA replication precede major changes in gene commitment. Prior evidence against a role for DNA replication during terminal differentiation is reexamined along with other results from terminal differentiation of lower eukaryotes. This leads to a proposal that DNA replication may yet underlie terminal gene commitment, but that for it to do so there must exist two distinct modes of replication control. In one mode (mitotic replication) replicon initiation is tightly linked to the cell cycle, whereas the other mode (terminal replication) initiation is not cell cycle restricted, is replicon specific, and can lead to a terminally differentiated state. Aberrant control of mitotic and terminal modes of DNA replication may underlie the transformed state. Implications of a replicon basis for chromatin structure-function and the evolution of metazoan organisms are considered.