Phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate induces the membrane penetration of the FYVE domains of Vps27p and Hrs

The FYVE domain mediates the recruitment of proteins involved in membrane trafficking and cell signaling to phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate (PtdIns(3)P)-containing membranes. To elucidate the mechanism by which the FYVE domain interacts with PtdIns(3)P-containing membranes, we measured the membrane binding of the FYVE domains of yeast Vps27p and Drosophila hepatocyte growth factor-regulated tyrosine kinase substrate and their mutants by surface plasmon resonance and monolayer penetration analyses. These measurements as well as electrostatic potential calculation show that PtdIns(3)P specifically induces the membrane penetration of the FYVE domains and increases their membrane residence time by decreasing the positive charge surrounding the hydrophobic tip of the domain and causing local conformational changes. Mutations of hydrophobic residues located close to the PtdIns(3)P-binding pocket or an Arg residue directly involved in PtdIns(3)P binding abrogated the penetration of the FYVE domains into the monolayer, the packing density of which is comparable with that of biological membranes and large unilamellar vesicles. Based on these results, we propose a mechanism of the membrane binding of the FYVE domain in which the domain first binds to the PtdIns(3)P-containing membrane by specific PtdIns(3)P binding and nonspecific electrostatic interactions, which is then followed by the PtdIns(3)P-induced partial membrane penetration of the domain.     

Structural basis for endosomal targeting by FYVE domains

The FYVE domain is a conserved protein motif characterized by its ability to bind with high affinity and specificity to phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate (PI3P), a phosphoinositide highly enriched in early endosomes. The PI3P polar head group contacts specific amino acid residues that are conserved among FYVE domains. Despite full conservation of these residues, the ability of different FYVE domains to bind to endosomes in cells is highly variable. Here we show that the endosomal localization in intact cells absolutely requires structural features intrinsic to the FYVE domain in addition to the PI3P binding pocket. These features are involved in FYVE domain dimerization and in interaction with the membrane bilayer. These interactions, which are determined by non-conserved residues, are likely to be essential for the temporal and spatial control of protein associations at the membrane-cytosol interface within the endocytic pathway.     

Multivalent mechanism of membrane insertion by the FYVE domain

Targeting of a wide variety of proteins to membranes involves specific recognition of phospholipid head groups and insertion into lipid bilayers. For example, proteins that contain FYVE domains are recruited to endosomes through interaction with phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate (PtdIns(3)P). However, the structural mechanism of membrane docking and insertion by this domain remains unclear. Here, the depth and angle of micelle insertion and the lipid binding properties of the FYVE domain of early endosome antigen 1 are estimated by NMR spectroscopy. Spin label probes incorporated into micelles identify a hydrophobic protuberance that inserts into the micelle core and is surrounded by interfacially active polar residues. A novel proxyl PtdIns(3)P derivative is developed to map the position of the phosphoinositide acyl chains, which are found to align with the membrane insertion element. Dual engagement of the FYVE domain with PtdIns(3)P and dodecylphosphocholine micelles yields a 6-fold enhancement of affinity. The additional interaction of phosphatidylserine with a conserved basic site of the protein further amplifies the micelle binding affinity and dramatically alters the angle of insertion. Thus, the FYVE domain is targeted to endosomes through the synergistic action of stereospecific PtdIns(3)P head group ligation, hydrophobic insertion and electrostatic interactions with acidic phospholipids.     

Mechanistic similarities in docking of the FYVE and PX domains to phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate containing membranes

Phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate [PtdIns(3)P], a phospholipid produced by PI 3-kinases in early endosomes and multivesicular bodies, often serves as a marker of endosomal membranes. PtdIns(3)P recruits and activates effector proteins containing the FYVE or PX domain and therefore regulates a variety of biological processes including endo- and exocytosis, membrane trafficking, protein sorting, signal transduction and cytoskeletal rearrangement. Structures and PtdIns(3)P binding modes of several FYVE and PX domains have recently been characterized, unveiling the molecular basis underlying multiple cellular functions of these proteins. Here, structural and functional aspects and current mechanisms of the multivalent membrane anchoring by the FYVE and PX domains are reviewed and compared.     

Membrane-binding mechanism of the EEA1 FYVE domain revealed by multi-scale molecular dynamics simulations

Early Endosomal Antigen 1 (EEA1) is a key protein in endosomal trafficking and is implicated in both autoimmune and neurological diseases. The C-terminal FYVE domain of EEA1 binds endosomal membranes, which contain phosphatidylinositol-3-phosphate (PI(3)P). Although it is known that FYVE binds PI(3)P specifically, it has not previously been described of how FYVE attaches and binds to endosomal membranes. In this study, we employed both coarse-grained (CG) and atomistic (AT) molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to determine how FYVE binds to PI(3)P-containing membranes. CG-MD showed that the dominant membrane binding mode resembles the crystal structure of EEA1 FYVE domain in complex with inositol-1,3-diphospate (PDB ID 1JOC). FYVE, which is a homodimer, binds the membrane via a hinge mechanism, where the C-terminus of one monomer first attaches to the membrane, followed by the C-terminus of the other monomer. The estimated total binding energy is ~70 kJ/mol, of which 50–60 kJ/mol stems from specific PI(3)P-interactions. By AT-MD, we could partition the binding mode into two types: (i) adhesion by electrostatic FYVE-PI(3)P interaction, and (ii) insertion of amphipathic loops. The AT simulations also demonstrated flexibility within the FYVE homodimer between the C-terminal heads and coiled-coil stem. This leads to a dynamic model whereby the 200 nm long coiled coil attached to the FYVE domain dimer can amplify local hinge-bending motions such that the Rab5-binding domain at the other end of the coiled coil can explore an area of 0.1 μm² in the search for a second endosome with which to interact.     

The molecular basis of the differential subcellular localization of FYVE domains

This study systematically analyzed the structural and mechanistic basis of the regulation of subcellular membrane targeting using FYVE domains as a model. FYVE domains, which mediate the recruitment of signaling and membrane-trafficking proteins to phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate-containing endosomes, exhibit distinct subcellular localization despite minor structural variations within the family. Biophysical measurements, cellular imaging, and computational analysis of various FYVE domains showed that the introduction of a single cationic residue and a hydrophobic loop into the membrane binding region of the FYVE domains dramatically enhanced their membrane interactions. The results indicated that there is a threshold affinity for endosomal localization and that endosomal targeting of FYVE domains is sensitive to small changes in membrane affinity about this threshold. Collectively these studies provide new insight into how subcellular localization of FYVE domains and other membrane targeting domains can be regulated by minimal structural and environmental changes.     

Phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate recognition and membrane docking by the FYVE domain

The FYVE domain is a small zinc binding module that recognizes phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate [PtdIns(3)P], a phospholipid enriched in membranes of early endosomes and other endocytic vesicles. It is usually present as a single module or rarely as a tandem repeat in eukaryotic proteins involved in a variety of biological processes including endo- and exocytosis, membrane trafficking and phosphoinositide metabolism. A number of FYVE domain-containing proteins are recruited to endocytic membranes through the specific interaction of their FYVE domains with PtdIns(3)P. Structures and PtdIns(3)P binding modes of several FYVE domains have recently been characterized, shedding light on the molecular basis underlying multiple cellular functions of these proteins. Here, structural and functional aspects and the current mechanism of the multivalent membrane anchoring by monomeric or dimeric FYVE domain are reviewed. This mechanism involves stereospecific recognition of PtdIns(3)P that is facilitated by non-specific electrostatic contacts and modulated by the histidine switch, and is accompanied by hydrophobic insertion. Contributions of each component to the FYVE domain specificity and affinity for PtdIns(3)P-containing membranes are discussed.     

FYVE domain targets Pib1p ubiquitin ligase to endosome and vacuolar membranes

Signaling by phosphatidylinositol 3-kinases (PI3Ks) is often mediated by proteins which bind PI3K products directly and are localized to intracellular membranes rich in PI3K products. The FYVE finger domain binds with high specificity to PtdIns3P and proteins containing this domain have been shown to be important components of diverse PI3K signaling pathways. The genome of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae encodes five proteins containing FYVE domains, including Pib1p, whose function is unknown. In addition to a FYVE finger motif, the primary structure of Pib1p contains a region rich in cysteine and histidine residues that we demonstrate binds 2 mol eq of zinc, consistent with this region containing a RING structural domain. The Pib1p RING domain exhibited E2-dependent ubiquitin ligase activity in vitro, indicating that Pib1p is an E3 RING-type ubiquitin ligase. Fluorescence microscopy was used to demonstrate that a GFP-Pib1p fusion protein localized to endosomal and vacuolar membranes and deletional analysis of Pib1p domains indicated that localization of GFP-Pib1p is mediated solely by the FYVE domain. These results suggest that Pib1p mediates ubiquitination of a subset of cellular proteins localized to endosome and vacuolar membranes, and they expand the repertoire of PI3K-regulated pathways identified in eukaryotic cells.     

Membrane insertion of the FYVE domain is modulated by pH

The FYVE domain associates with phosphatidylinositol 3‐phosphate [PtdIns(3)P] in membranes of early endosomes and penetrates bilayers. Here, we detail principles of membrane anchoring and show that the FYVE domain insertion into PtdIns(3)P‐enriched membranes and membrane‐mimetics is substantially increased in acidic conditions. The EEA1 FYVE domain binds to POPC/POPE/PtdIns(3)P vesicles with a Kd of 49 nM at pH 6.0, however associates ～24 fold weaker at pH 8.0. The decrease in the affinity is primarily due to much faster dissociation of the protein from the bilayers in basic media. Lowering the pH enhances the interaction of the Hrs, RUFY1, Vps27p and WDFY1 FYVE domains with PtdIns(3)P‐containing membranes in vitro and in vivo, indicating that pH‐dependency is a general function of the FYVE finger family. The PtdIns(3)P binding and membrane insertion of the FYVE domain is modulated by the two adjacent His residues of the R(R/K)HHCRXCG signature motif. Mutation of either His residue abolishes the pH‐sensitivity. Both protonation of the His residues and nonspecific electrostatic contacts stabilize the FYVE domain in the lipid‐bound form, promoting its penetration and increasing the membrane residence time. Proteins 2009. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

A highly conserved glutamic acid in ALFY inhibits membrane binding to aid in aggregate clearance

Autophagy‐linked FYVE protein (ALFY) is a large, multidomain protein involved in the degradation of protein aggregates by selective autophagy. The C‐terminal FYVE domain of ALFY has been shown to bind phosphatidylinositol 3‐phosphate (PI(3)P); however, ALFY only partially colocalizes with other FYVE domains in cells. Thus, we asked if the FYVE domain of ALFY has distinct membrane binding properties compared to other FYVE domains and whether these properties might affect its function in vivo. We found that the FYVE domain of ALFY binds weakly to PI(3)P containing membranes in vitro. This weak binding is the result of a highly conserved glutamic acid within the membrane insertion loop in the FYVE domain of ALFY that is not present in any other human FYVE domain. In addition, not only does this glutamic acid reduce binding to membranes in vitro and inhibits its targeting to membranes in vivo, but it is also important for the ability of ALFY to clear protein aggregates.     

Structural and membrane binding analysis of the Phox homology domain of phosphoinositide 3-kinase-C2alpha

Phox homology (PX) domains, which have been identified in a variety of proteins involved in cell signaling and membrane trafficking, have been shown to interact with phosphoinositides (PIs) with different affinities and specificities. To elucidate the structural origin of diverse PI specificities of PX domains, we determined the crystal structure of the PX domain from phosphoinositide 3-kinase C2alpha (PI3K-C2alpha), which binds phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate (PtdIns(4,5)P(2)). To delineate the mechanism by which this PX domain interacts with membranes, we measured the membrane binding of the wild type domain and mutants by surface plasmon resonance and monolayer techniques. This PX domain contains a signature PI-binding site that is optimized for PtdIns(4,5)P(2) binding. The membrane binding of the PX domain is initiated by nonspecific electrostatic interactions followed by the membrane penetration of hydrophobic residues. Membrane penetration is specifically enhanced by PtdIns(4,5)P(2). Furthermore, the PX domain displayed significantly higher PtdIns(4,5)P(2) membrane affinity and specificity when compared with the PI3K-C2alpha C2 domain, demonstrating that high affinity PtdIns(4,5)P(2) binding was facilitated by the PX domain in full-length PI3K-C2alpha. Together, these studies provide new structural insight into the diverse PI specificities of PX domains and elucidate the mechanism by which the PI3K-C2alpha PX domain interacts with PtdIns(4,5)P(2)-containing membranes and thereby mediates the membrane recruitment of PI3K-C2alpha.     

Investigation of the binding geometry of a peripheral membrane protein

A growing number of modules including FYVE domains target key signaling proteins to membranes through specific recognition of lipid headgroups and hydrophobic insertion into bilayers. Despite the critical role of membrane insertion in the function of these modules, the structural mechanism of membrane docking and penetration remains unclear. In particular, the three-dimensional orientation of the inserted proteins with respect to the membrane surface is difficult to define quantitatively. Here, we determined the geometry of the micelle penetration of the early endosome antigen 1 (EEA1) FYVE domain by obtaining NMR-derived restraints that correlate with the distances between protein backbone amides and spin-labeled probes. The 5- and 14-doxyl-phosphatidylcholine spin-labels were incorporated into dodecylphosphocholine (DPC) micelles, and the reduction of amide signal intensities of the FYVE domain due to paramagnetic relaxation enhancement was measured. The vector of the FYVE domain insertion was estimated relative to the molecular axis by minimizing the paramagnetic restraints obtained in phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate (PI3P)-enriched micelles containing only DPC or mixed with phosphatidylserine (PS). Additional distance restraints were obtained using a novel spin-label mimetic of PI(3)P that contains a nitroxyl radical near the threitol group of the lipid. Conformational changes indicative of elongation of the membrane insertion loop (MIL) were detected upon micelle interaction, in which the hydrophobic residues of the loop tend to move deeper into the nonpolar core of micelles. The micelle insertion mechanism of the FYVE domain defined in this study is consistent with mutagenesis data and chemical shift perturbations and demonstrates the advantage of using the spin-label NMR approach for investigating the binding geometry by peripheral membrane proteins.     

Phosphorylation reverses the membrane association of peptides that correspond to the basic domains of MARCKS and neuromodulin.

Several groups have observed that phosphorylation causes the MARCKS (Myristoylated Alanine-Rich C Kinase Substrate) protein to move off cell membranes and phospholipid vesicles. Our working hypothesis is that significant membrane binding of MARCKS requires both hydrophobic insertion of the N-terminal myristate into the bilayer and electrostatic association of the single cluster of basic residues in the protein with acidic lipids and that phosphorylation reverses this electrostatic association. Membrane binding measurements with myristoylated peptides and phospholipid vesicles show this hydrophobic moiety could, at best, barely attach proteins to plasma membranes. We report here membrane binding measurements with basic peptides that correspond to the phosphorylation domains of MARCKS and neuromodulin. Binding of these peptides increases sigmoidally with the percent acidic lipid in the phospholipid vesicle and can be described by a Gouy-Chapman/mass action theory that explains how electrostatics and reduction of dimensionality produce apparent cooperativity. The electrostatic affinity of the MARCKS peptide for membranes containing 10% acidic phospholipids (10(4) M-1 = chi/[P], where chi is the mole ratio of peptide bound to the outer monolayer of the vesicles and [P] is the concentration of peptide in the aqueous phase) is the same as the hydrophobic affinity of the myristate moiety for bilayer membranes. Phosphorylation decreases the affinity of the MARCKS peptide for membranes containing 15% acidic lipid about 1000-fold and produces a rapid (t1/2 < 30 s) dissociation of the peptide from phospholipid vesicles.     

High-affinity binding of a FYVE domain to phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate requires intact phospholipid but not FYVE domain oligomerization.

FYVE domains are small zinc-finger-like domains found in many proteins that are involved in regulating membrane traffic and have been shown to bind specifically to phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate (PtdIns-3-P). FYVE domains are thought to recruit PtdIns-3-P effectors to endosomal locations in vivo, where these effectors participate in controlling endosomal maturation and vacuolar protein sorting. We have compared the characteristics of PtdIns-3-P binding by the FYVE domain from Hrs-1 (the hepatocyte growth factor-regulated tyrosine kinase substrate) with those of specific phosphoinositide binding by Pleckstrin homology (PH) domains. Like certain PH domains (such as that from phospholipase C-delta(1)), the Hrs-1 FYVE domain specifically recognizes a single phosphoinositide. However, while phosphoinositide binding by highly specific PH domains is driven almost exclusively by interactions with the lipid headgroup, this is not true for the Hrs-1 FYVE domain. The phospholipase C-delta(1) PH domain shows a 10-fold preference for binding isolated headgroup over its preferred lipid (phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate) in a membrane, while the Hrs-1 FYVE domain greatly prefers (more than 50-fold) intact lipid in a bilayer over the isolated headgroup (inositol 1,3-bisphosphate). By contrast with reports for certain PH domains, we find that this preference for membrane binding over interaction with soluble lipid headgroups does not require FYVE domain oligomerization.     

Similar structures but different mechanisms: Prediction of FABPs–membrane interaction by electrostatic calculation

The role of fatty acid binding proteins as intracellular fatty acid transporters may require their direct interaction with membranes. In this way different mechanisms have been previously characterized through experimental studies suggesting different models for FABPs–membrane association, although the process in which the molecule adsorbs to the membrane remains to be elucidated. To estimate the importance of the electrostatic energy in the FABP–membrane interaction, we computationally modeled the interaction of different FABPs with both anionic and neutral membranes. Free Electrostatic Energy of Binding (dE), was computed using Finite Difference Poisson Boltzmann Equation (FDPB) method as implemented in APBS (Adaptive Poisson Boltzmann Solver). Based on the computational analysis, it is found that recruitment to membranes is facilitated by non-specific electrostatic interactions. Also energetic analysis can quantitatively differentiate among the mechanisms of membrane association proposed and determinate the most energetically favorable configuration for the membrane-associated states of different FABPs. This type of calculations could provide a starting point for further computational or experimental analysis.     

Crystal structure of a phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate-specific membrane-targeting motif, the FYVE domain of Vps27p.

Phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate regulates membrane trafficking and signaling pathways by interacting with the FYVE domains of target proteins. The 1.15 A structure of the Vps27p FYVE domain reveals two antiparallel beta sheets and an alpha helix stabilized by two Zn2+-binding clusters. The core secondary structures are similar to a rabphilin-3A Zn2+-binding domain and to the C1 and LIM domains. Phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate binds to a pocket formed by the (R/K)(R/K)HHCR motif. A lattice contact shows how anionic ligands can interact with the phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate-binding site. The tip of the FYVE domain has basic and hydrophobic surfaces positioned so that nonspecific interactions with the phospholipid bilayer can abet specific binding to phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate.     

Traffic to the malaria parasite food vacuole: a novel pathway involving a phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate-binding protein

Phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate (PI3P) is a key ligand for recruitment of endosomal regulatory proteins in higher eukaryotes. Subsets of these endosomal proteins possess a highly selective PI3P binding zinc finger motif belonging to the FYVE domain family. We have identified a single FYVE domain-containing protein in Plasmodium falciparum which we term FCP. Expression and mutagenesis studies demonstrate that key residues are involved in specific binding to PI3P. In contrast to FYVE proteins in other organisms, endogenous FCP localizes to a lysosomal compartment, the malaria parasite food vacuole (FV), rather than to cytoplasmic endocytic organelles. Transfections of deletion mutants further indicate that FCP is essential for trophozoite and FV maturation and that it traffics to the FV via a novel constitutive cytoplasmic to vacuole targeting pathway. This newly discovered pathway excludes the secretory pathway and is directed by a C-terminal 44-amino acid peptide domain. We conclude that an FYVE protein that might be expected to participate in vesicle targeting in the parasite cytosol instead has a vital and functional role in the malaria parasite FV.     

Phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate-interacting domains in PIKfyve. Binding specificity and role in PIKfyve. Endomenbrane localization.

PIKfyve is a phosphatidylinositol (PtdIns) 3-phosphate (P)-metabolizing enzyme, which, in addition to a C-terminally positioned catalytic domain, harbors several evolutionarily conserved domains, including a FYVE finger. The FYVE finger domains are thought to direct the protein localization to intracellular membrane PtdIns 3-P. Recent studies with several FYVE domain proteins challenge this general concept. Here we have examined the binding of PIKfyve's FYVE domain to PtdIns 3-P in vitro and in vivo and a plausible contribution of this binding mechanism for the intracellular localization of the full-length protein. We document now a specific and high affinity interaction of a recombinantly produced PIKfyve FYVE domain peptide fragment with PtdIns 3-P-containing liposomes that requires the presence of the conservative core of basic residues within the FYVE domain. PIKfyve localization to membranes of the late endocytic pathway was found to be absolutely dependent on the presence of an intact FYVE finger. Cell treatment with PI 3-kinase inhibitor wortmannin dissociated endosome-bound PIKfyve, indicating that the protein targeted the membrane PtdIns 3-P. An enzymatically inactive peptide fragment of the PIKfyve catalytic domain was found to also specifically bind to PtdIns 3-P-containing liposomes, with residue Lys-1999 being critical in the interaction. This binding, however, was of relatively low affinity and, in the cellular context, was found ineffective in directing the molecule to PtdIns 3-P-enriched endosomes. Collectively, these results demonstrate that interaction of the FYVE domain with PtdIns 3-P is absolutely necessary for PIKfyve targeting to the membranes of the late endocytic pathway and determine PIKfyve as a downstream effector of PtdIns 3-P.     

Structural and membrane binding analysis of the Phox homology domain of Bem1p: basis of phosphatidylinositol 4-phosphate specificity

Phox homology (PX) domains, which have been identified in a variety of proteins involved in cell signaling and membrane trafficking, have been shown to interact with phosphoinositides (PIs) with different affinities and specificities. To elucidate the structural origin of the diverse PI specificity of PX domains, we determined the crystal structure of the PX domain from Bem1p that has been reported to bind phosphatidylinositol 4-phosphate (PtdIns(4)P). We also measured the membrane binding properties of the PX domain and its mutants by surface plasmon resonance and monolayer techniques and calculated the electrostatic potentials for the PX domain in the absence and presence of bound PtdIns(4)P. The Bem1p PX domain contains a signature PI-binding site optimized for PtdIns(4)P binding and also harbors basic and hydrophobic residues on the membrane-binding surface. The membrane binding of the Bem1p PX domain is initiated by nonspecific electrostatic interactions between the cationic membrane-binding surface of the domain and anionic membrane surfaces, followed by the membrane penetration of hydrophobic residues. Unlike other PX domains, the Bem1p PX domain has high intrinsic membrane penetrating activity in the absence of PtdIns(4)P, suggesting that the partial membrane penetration may occur before specific PtdIns(4)P binding and last after the removal of PtdIns(4)P under certain conditions. This structural and functional study of the PtdIns(4)P-binding Bem1p PX domain provides new insight into the diverse PI specificities and membrane-binding mechanisms of PX domains.     

Similar structures but different mechanisms: Prediction of FABPs-membrane interaction by electrostatic calculation

The role of fatty acid binding proteins as intracellular fatty acid transporters may require their direct interaction with membranes. In this way different mechanisms have been previously characterized through experimental studies suggesting different models for FABPs-membrane association, although the process in which the molecule adsorbs to the membrane remains to be elucidated. To estimate the importance of the electrostatic energy in the FABP-membrane interaction, we computationally modeled the interaction of different FABPs with both anionic and neutral membranes. Free Electrostatic Energy of Binding (dE), was computed using Finite Difference Poisson Boltzmann Equation (FDPB) method as implemented in APBS (Adaptive Poisson Boltzmann Solver). Based on the computational analysis, it is found that recruitment to membranes is facilitated by non-specific electrostatic interactions. Also energetic analysis can quantitatively differentiate among the mechanisms of membrane association proposed and determinate the most energetically favorable configuration for the membrane-associated states of different FABPs. This type of calculations could provide a starting point for further computational or experimental analysis.