Influence of divalent metal activator on the specificity of misincorporation during DNA synthesis catalyzed by DNA polymerase I of Escherichia coli

To test whether the identity of divalent metal activator affects the specificity of misincorporation during polymerization catalyzed by E. coli DNA polymerase I, we carried out the following procedure. A series of oligonucleotide primers, annealed at different positions along the lacZ region of bacteriophage M13mp9 DNA, were elongated in the presence of 3 of the 4 deoxynucleoside 5'-triphosphates (dNTPs) until one or a few misincorporations occurred in each elongated primer. The elongated primers (containing deoxynucleotide residues that had been misincorporated in the presence of either Mg2+ or Mn2+) were then isolated and sequenced by the 'dideoxy' chain termination method to determine the identity of deoxynucleoside monophosphates (dNMPs) that had been misincorporated at different template positions during the original 'minus' reactions, activated by Mg2+ or Mn2+. The results obtained by this approach revealed that both the type of misincorporation and the effect of substituting Mn2+ for Mg2+ depended on the nucleotide sequence of the template. At 40% of the template positions at which misincorporation was compared with both metal ions (8 out of 20), the identity of mispairs differed significantly for synthesis activated by Mn2+ versus Mg2+. Of these 8 sites, 4 exhibited increased transversions in the presence of Mn2+, while 4 exhibited decreased transversions with Mn2+.     

Misincorporation during DNA synthesis, analyzed by gel electrophoresis.

A method has been developed for simultaneous comparison of the propensity of a DNA polymerase to misincorporate at different points on a natural template-primer. In this method elongation of a [5'-32P] primer, annealed to a bacteriophage template strand, is carried out in the presence of only three dNTPs (highly purified by HPLC). Under these conditions the rate of primer elongation (monitored by gel electrophoresis/autoradiography) is limited by the rate of misincorporation at template positions complementary to the missing dNTP. Variations in the rate of elongation (revealed by autoradiographic banding patterns) reflect variations in the propensity for misincorporation at different positions along the template. The effect on primer elongation produced by addition of a chemically modified dNTP to 'minus' reactions reveals the mispairing potential of the modified nucleotide during DNA synthesis. By use of this electrophoretic assay of misincorporation we have demonstrated that the fidelity of E. coli DNA polymerase I varies greatly at different positions along a natural template, and that BrdUTP and IodUTP can be incorporated in place of dCTP during chain elongation catalyzed by this enzyme.     

Effect of pH on the base-mispairing properties of 5-bromouracil during DNA synthesis

We have utilized an electrophoretic assay of misincorporation to investigate the possibility that ionization of 5-bromouracil (BU) may play a role in its mispairing during DNA synthesis in vitro. We examined the effects of increasing pH on the relative rates of formation of BU.G and T.G mispairs during chain elongation catalyzed by various DNA polymerases. For the Klenow fragment of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I, increasing pH facilitated BU.G mispair formation (relative to T.G mispairing) when BU was present in the template strand. This effect showed a strong dependence on sequence context. Increasing pH had little effect on the relative rate of misincorporation of BrdUMP versus dTMP (at template G) by the Klenow polymerase. Misincorporation opposite template BU residues catalyzed by Maloney murine leukemia virus DNA polymerase and DNA polymerase beta (Novikoff hepatoma) also increased with pH, but for these two enzymes, there was no apparent dependence on sequence context. With T4 DNA polymerase and E. coli DNA polymerase III holoenzyme, a similar occurrence of BU.G and T.G mispairing during polymerization was observed, whether BU was present in the template or in the incoming nucleotide, and there was little effect of pH. The results reported here are consistent with a mispairing mechanism for template BU wherein the anionic form of the base mispairs with G.     

Measuring cation dependent DNA polymerase fidelity landscapes by deep sequencing

High-throughput recording of signals embedded within inaccessible micro-environments is a technological challenge. The ideal recording device would be a nanoscale machine capable of quantitatively transducing a wide range of variables into a molecular recording medium suitable for long-term storage and facile readout in the form of digital data. We have recently proposed such a device, in which cation concentrations modulate the misincorporation rate of a DNA polymerase (DNAP) on a known template, allowing DNA sequences to encode information about the local cation concentration. In this work we quantify the cation sensitivity of DNAP misincorporation rates, making possible the indirect readout of cation concentration by DNA sequencing. Using multiplexed deep sequencing, we quantify the misincorporation properties of two DNA polymerases - Dpo4 and Klenow exo(-) - obtaining the probability and base selectivity of misincorporation at all positions within the template. We find that Dpo4 acts as a DNA recording device for Mn(2+) with a misincorporation rate gain of ～2%/mM. This modulation of misincorporation rate is selective to the template base: the probability of misincorporation on template T by Dpo4 increases >50-fold over the range tested, while the other template bases are affected less strongly. Furthermore, cation concentrations act as scaling factors for misincorporation: on a given template base, Mn(2+) and Mg(2+) change the overall misincorporation rate but do not alter the relative frequencies of incoming misincorporated nucleotides. Characterization of the ion dependence of DNAP misincorporation serves as the first step towards repurposing it as a molecular recording device.     

Processive proofreading is intrinsic to T4 DNA polymerase.

DNA replication occurs in vivo with very high processivity, meaning that the replication complex assembles at the origin(s) of replication and then performs template-directed synthesis of DNA over virtually the entire genome without dissociation. Such processivity also characterizes reconstituted replication holoenzyme complexes in vitro. However, the isolated DNA polymerases are much less processive, especially under physiological conditions. In this paper we monitor the degree of processivity displayed by the bacteriophage T4-coded DNA polymerase while in its proofreading mode by asking whether an isolated polymerase can "edit-out" the 3'-terminal nucleotide from the primer (using the 3'----5'-exonuclease activity of the polymerase) and then switch into the synthesis mode without dissociating from the DNA template. This "switch experiment" is accomplished by using mismatched primer/template substrates as an experimental tool to mimic the situation that T4 DNA polymerase encounters after a misincorporation event has occurred. By performing experiments under single-turnover conditions (obtained using a heparin trap), we demonstrate that T4 DNA polymerase, upon encountering a misincorporated base, neither synthesizes the next base nor dissociates into solution. Instead, with a greater than 80% probability, it removes the misincorporated base and then continues synthesis in a fully processive manner. We also show that the removal of a doubly mispaired sequence from the 3'-terminus of the primer, followed by synthesis, is comparably processive. In contrast, the apparent processivity of removing a triply mispaired terminus is much reduced. Taken together, these observations are consistent with the notion that the "editing active site" of the T4 enzyme optimally accommodates only two unpaired nucleotide residues. Our results do not support the idea that the exonuclease activity of T4 DNA polymerase is highly selective for mismatched termini; they suggest instead that the dwell time at a misincorporated base determines overall editing efficiency. The integrated results of this study provide additional insight into the structure of the T4 DNA polymerase, as well as into the interactions between the polymerase and the polymerase accessory proteins that are required to provide the holoenzyme complex with full processivity.     

Template-dependent variation in the relative fidelity of DNA polymerase I of Escherichia coli in the presence of Mg2+ versus Mn2+

The fidelity of E. coli DNA polymerase I in the presence of Mg2+ vs Mn2+ was examined at many positions along natural DNA templates, by use of an electrophoretic assay of misincorporation. Although there was an overall greater tendency for misincorporation to occur in Mn2+-activated chain elongation, some specific sites on the template were more prone to misincorporation with Mg2+ and others with Mn2+. This sequence-dependent effect was seen in spite of the finding that the relative rate of incorporation of the correct nucleotide at different positions on the template was essentially the same with Mg2+ and Mn2+. In agreement with previous studies, the fidelity of E. coli pol I was higher at activating, than at inhibiting, concentrations of Mg2+. The results reveal new complexities regarding the role of divalent cation in the control of fidelity in DNA synthesis and attest to the dynamic nature of interactions between DNA polymerase, its substrates and divalent metal activator during the course of polymerization on natural templates.     

Influence of neighboring base sequence on mutagenesis induced by in vitro misincorporation in the lacI gene of Escherichia coli.

Genetic and electrophoretic assays of misincorporation were used to assess the effect of DNA sequence on mutagenesis arising from in vitro DNA synthesis within the lacI gene of Escherichia coli. The viral strand of a derivative of phage M13 containing the entire lacI gene was annealed with a series of synthetic oligonucleotides complementary to the N-terminal region of the lacI gene. Each primer-template was incubated with E. coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) under conditions favoring misincorporation, wherein one of the 4 dNTPs was lacking ('minus' reaction) or present at very low concentration ('micro' reaction). The extent of elongation of each primer was assessed by gel electrophoresis, and lacI mutants arising during the misincorporation reactions were detected by a transfection assay in which i- base substitutions within the in vitro synthesized strand were selectively recovered by the use of uracil-containing templates. Direct dideoxy sequencing of the '-A' reaction products and sequence analysis of i- mutant progeny revealed a vast predominance of single and non-tandem multiple base transitions. The addition of small quantities of dATP to a '-A' reaction increased the mutation yield and broadened the distribution of base substitutions along the template. We detected a general bias towards increased base substitution at template positions flanked by G.C base pairs or 5'-pyrimidine, 3'-purine nearest neighbors, although considerable site-to-site variation in the occurrence of base substitutions was seen, even within identical nearest neighbor contexts.     

8-Hydroxyguanine, an abundant form of oxidative DNA damage, causes G----T and A----C substitutions.

Mutations caused by oxidative DNA damage may contribute to human disease. A major product of that damage is 8-hydroxyguanine (oh8Gua). Because of differences in experimental design, the base pairing specificity of oh8G in vivo is not completely resolved. Here, oh8dGTP and DNA polymerase were used in two complementary bacteriophage plaque color assays to examine the mutagenic specificity of oh8Gua in vivo. The first is a reversion assay that detects all three single-base substitutions caused by misreading of guanine analogues inserted at a specific site. oh8Gua at that site gave a mutation frequency of 0.7%. Twenty-two of the 23 mutations were G----T substitutions. The second assay, a forward mutation assay, tests the mispairing potential of any altered nucleotide 1) during incorporation as substrate nucleotide, and 2) after multiple incorporations into a single-stranded DNA gap region of M13mp2. Substituting oh8dGTP for dGTP during polymerization produced 16% mutants; two classes of mutations were observed, both caused by pairing of oh8Gua with A. Seventy-six of 78 mutations were A----C substitutions, and two were G----T substitutions. These assays thus illustrate mutagenic replication of oh8Gua as template causing G----T substitutions and misincorporation of oh8Gua as substrate causing A----C substitutions, both caused by oh8Gua.A mispairs.     

Influence of template primary and secondary structure on the rate and fidelity of DNA synthesis

High resolution gel electrophoresis was used to monitor the successive addition of dNMP residues onto the 3'-OH ends of discrete 5'-32P-primers, during DNA synthesis on natural templates. Resulting autoradiographic banding patterns revealed considerable variation in the relative rates of incorporation at different positions along the template. The pattern of "pause sites" along the template was unique for each of three different DNA polymerases (polymerase I (the "large fragment" form of Escherichia coli), T4 polymerase (encoded by bacteriophage T4), and AMV polymerase (DNA polymerase of avian myeloblastosis virus]. Most pause sites were not caused by attenuation of polymerization at regions of local secondary structure in the template. Assays of the accuracy of incorporation at different positions along the template (in which elongation was monitored in the presence of only 3 of the 4 2'-deoxynucleoside 5'-triphosphates) strongly suggested that the relative fidelity of DNA synthesis catalyzed by different polymerases depends on the position on the template at which the comparison is made. Primer-templates were constructed that permitted comparison of elongation during synthesis on a single-stranded template with that during polymerization through a double-stranded region (wherein elongation required concomitant displacement of a strand annealed adjacent to the 5'-32P-primer). Although strand displacement DNA synthesis catalyzed by polymerase I occurred approximately ten times more slowly than synthesis in the same region of a single-stranded viral template, most of the pause sites were the same in the presence or absence of "tandem" primer. Electrophoretic assays of the fidelity of DNA synthesis suggested that an increased tendency toward misincorporational "hotspots" occurred when elongation required concomitant strand displacement.     

On the fidelity of DNA replication. Effect of the next nucleotide on proofreading

The contribution of proofreading to the fidelity by which Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I copies natural DNA has been analyzed by two independent criteria. With phi X174 am 3 DNA as a template, there is approximately a 25-fold increase in noncomplementary base substitutions at position 587 when the concentration of the next correct nucleotide, dATP, is increased. Sequence analysis indicates that the mistakes represent misincorporation of C in place of T at position 587. This mutagenic response is presumed to result from a decrease in the probability of excision by the 3' leads to 5' exonuclease of Pol I and is considered within the context of current theories on proofreading. No enhanced mutagenicity is observed with avian myeloblastosis virus DNA polymerase, which lacks a 3' leads to 5' exonuclease. Using a second approach, an enhancement in mutagenesis as large as 30-fold is observed to result from the addition of deoxynucleoside monophosphates to the Pol I reaction. This mutagenicity occurs with any of the four deoxynucleoside monophosphates and is independent of a significant inhibition of DNA synthesis, thus supporting proofreading models in which sites of excision and incorporation are independent. The results of both approaches suggest that the exonucleolytic activity of Pol I can increase fidelity by approximately 30-fold on natural DNA, a value much higher than previous estimates with polynucleotide templates. The effect of the next correct nucleotide in decreasing accuracy provides an in vitro probe for screening eukaryotic cells for putative proofreading functions.     

Fidelity of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase IV. Preferential generation of small deletion mutations by dNTP-stabilized misalignment

Escherichia coli DNA polymerase IV (pol IV), a member of the error-prone Y family, predominantly generates -1 frameshifts when copying DNA in vitro. T-->G transversions and T-->C transitions are the most frequent base substitutions observed. The in vitro data agree with mutational spectra obtained when pol IV is overexpressed in vivo. Single base deletion and base substitution rates measured in the lacZalpha gene in vitro are, on average, 2 x 10(-4) and 5 x 10(-5), respectively. The range of misincorporation and mismatch extension efficiencies determined kinetically are 10(-3) to 10(-5). The presence of beta sliding clamp and gamma-complex clamp loading proteins strongly enhance pol IV processivity but have no discernible influence on fidelity. By analyzing changes in fluorescence of a 2-aminopurine template base undergoing replication in real time, we show that a "dNTP-stabilized" misalignment mechanism is responsible for making -1 frameshift mutations on undamaged DNA. In this mechanism, a dNTP substrate is paired "correctly" opposite a downstream template base, on a "looped out" template strand instead of mispairing opposite a next available template base. By using the same mechanism, pol IV "skips" past an abasic template lesion to generate a -1 frameshift. A crystal structure depicting dNTP-stabilized misalignment was reported recently for Sulfolubus solfataricus Dpo4, a Y family homolog of Escherichia coli pol IV.     

Incorporation of 2-halogeno-2'-deoxyadenosine 5-triphosphates into DNA during replication by human polymerases alpha and beta

Extension of synthetic primers by purified human polymerase alpha (Hpol alpha) with the (+)-strand of M13mp18 DNA as template encounters numerous specific pause sites on the M13 template. Some of these are regions of template secondary structure, at others the template codes for incorporation of the same base in multiple consecutive positions, but at some the responsible feature in the sequence is not obvious. 2-Chloro-dATP (CldATP) substitutes efficiently for dATP in such chain extension, with 2-chloroadenine (ClA) incorporation into many positions coding for A. However, there are more sites where extension is interrupted than with all four normal nucleotide substrates, particularly (but not exclusively) at template secondary structure and sites of multiple consecutive ClA insertion. DNA synthesis from normal substrates by Hpol beta in this system shows less frequent and less marked pauses, but with CldATP substituted for dATP chain extension is limited because of marked slowing of extension at sites of multiple consecutive ClA insertion. With either polymerase, the rate of extension is decreased even more at such regions when bromo-dATP is used as substrate. Some misincorporation of ClA instead of G or T can occur at certain sites in absence of the corresponding normal substrate, but misincorporation as C is rare. CldATP is a very weak inhibitor of chain extension by Hpol alpha, but a somewhat better inhibitor of Hpol beta. These results may account in part for the inhibition of DNA synthesis in cells exposed to 2-chlorodeoxyadenosine or 2-bromodeoxyadenosine.     

Minimal kinetic mechanism for misincorporation by DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment).

The minimal kinetic mechanism for misincorporation of a single nucleotide (dATP) into a short DNA primer/template (9/20-mer) by the Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase I [KF(exo+)] has been previously published [Kuchta, R. D., Benkovic, P., & Benkovic, S.J. (1988) Biochemistry 27, 6716-6725]. In this paper are presented refinements to this mechanism. Pre-steady-state measurements of correct nucleotide incorporation (dTTP) in the presence of a single incorrect nucleotide (dATP) with excess KF-(exo+) demonstrated that dATP binds to the KF(exo+)-9/20-mer complex in two steps preceding chemistry. Substitution of (alpha S)dATP for dATP yielded identical two-step binding kinetics, removing nucleotide binding as a cause of the elemental effect on the rate of misincorporation. Pyrophosphate release from the ternary species [KF'(exo+)-9A/20-mer-PPi] was found to occur following a rate-limiting conformational change, with this species partitioning equally to either nucleotide via internal pyrophosphorolysis or to misincorporated product. The rate of 9A/20-mer dissociation from the central ternary complex (KF'-9A/20-mer-PPi) was shown to be negligible relative to exonucleolytic editing. Pyrophosphorolysis of the misincorporated DNA product (9A/20-mer), in conjunction with measurement of the rate of dATP misincorporation, permitted determination of the overall equilibrium constant for dATP misincorporation and provided a value similar to that measured for correct incorporation. A step by step comparison of the polymerization catalyzed by the Klenow fragment for correct and incorrect nucleotide incorporation emphasizes that the major source of the enzyme's replicative fidelity arises from discrimination in the actual chemical step and from increased exonuclease activity on the ternary misincorporated product complex owing to its slower passage through the turnover sequence.     

Error induction and correction by mutant and wild type T4 DNA polymerases. Kinetic error discrimination mechanisms.

The fidelity of DNA synthesis as determined by the misincorporation of the base analogue 2-aminopurine in competition with adenine has been measured as a function of deoxynucleoside triphosphate substrate concentrations using purified mutator (L56), antimutator (L141), and wild type (T4D) T4 DNA polymerases. Although the rates of both incorporation and turnover of aminopurine and adenine decrease as substrate concentrations are decreased, the ratio of turnover/polymerase activity is increased. Thus, the nuclease/polymerase ratio of each of these three DNA polymerases can be controlled. The misincorporation of aminopurine decreases with decreasing substrate concentrations such that all three enzymes approach nearly identical misincorporation frequencies at the lowest substrate concentration. The increased accuracy of DNA synthesis corresponds to conditions producing a high nuclease/polymerase ratio. The misinsertion frequency for aminopurine is independent of substrate concentrations and enzyme phenotype; therefore, the increased accuracy of DNA synthesis with decreasing substrate concentrations is shown to be a result of increased nuclease activity and not increased polymerase or nuclease specificity. The data are analyzed in terms of a kinetic model of DNA polymerase accuracy which proposes that discrimination in nucleotide insertion and removal is based on the free energy difference between matched and mismatched base pairs. A value of 1.1 kcal/mol free energy difference, delta G, between adenine: thymine and aminopurine:thymine base pairs is predicted by model analysis of the cocentration dependence of aminopurine misincorporation and removal frequencies. An independent estimate of this free energy difference based on the 6-fold higher apparent Km of T4 DNA polymerase for aminopurine compared to adenine also gives a value of 1.1 kcal/mol. It is shown that the aminopurine misinsertion frequency for an enzyme having either extremely low 3'-exonuclease activity, Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I, or no measurable exonuclease activity, calf thymus DNA polymerase alpha, is 12 to 15%, which is similar to that for the T4 polymerases and consistent with delta G approximately 1.1 kcal/mol.