Mechanisms of antibody formation: I. Early in vivo proliferation of mouse spleen T cells as an initial step in antibody formation

Spleen cultures prepared from mice injected 24 hr earlier with 2 × 10⁶?2 × 10⁸ sRBC and challenged in vitro with sRBC produced 10 times more anti-sRBC IgM PFC than cultures prepared from uninjected mice. The effect was specific for the particular species of foreign RBC injected in vivo. In vitro responses to TNP were also increased in spleen cultures prepared from animals injected 24 or 12 hr earlier with carrier RBC alone, directly implicating carrier-specific T cells in this process. Similar enhancements of PFC formation occurred in cultures prepared from mice which had been injected with sRBC 24 and 48 hr earlier, but which were exposed to lethal irradiation at 1 hr after injection of antigen, if their spleens were shielded extracorporeally during irradiation. This finding indicated that in vivo recruitment of antigen-reactive extrasplenic X-ray-sensitive cells from the circulating lymphocyte pool by the spleen could not account for the observed enhancement.Proliferation in the spleen of antigen-reactive T cells, commencing 12–20 hr after the administration of antigen, was demonstrated by the tritiated thymidine pulse technique. An 8-hr hot-pulse given to spleen cell cultures from normal animals at 20 hr after in vitro challenge with antigen did not affect the rate of generation of IgM-producing cells; however, administration of a similar pulse to cultures which were initiated at 12 or at 20 hr after the in vivo injection of sRBC eliminated the enhanced generation of PFC and delayed the in vitro response to sRBC by 24 hr.Spleen cell cultures were prepared from mice which had been injected in vivo with sRBC at 12, 20, and 70 hr earlier, and 8- to 10-hr hot pulses were given immediately after initiation of the cultures. The cultures were then challenged with sRBC-TNP; antibody responses to TNP were greatly reduced in hot-pulsed cultures prepared from mice injected in vivo with carrier RBC at 12 or 20 hr prior to initiation of the cultures. In contrast, antibody responses to TNP observed in hot-pulsed cultures prepared from mice which had been injected with carrier RBC at 70 hr prior to initiation of the cultures were generally similar to those of nonpulsed 70 hr control cultures. This result suggests that the onset of T helper cell proliferation begins within 12–20 hr after injection of antigen, but subsides in vivo within 70 hr. By that time, the antigen-reactive T cells have already differentiated to perform their helper function.In spite of the triggering of T-cell proliferation during the first 24 hr after injection of antigen, spleen cell cultures prepared from mice which had been injected 24 hr earlier in vivo with 2 × 10⁸ sRBC produced only minimal numbers of anti-sRBC PFC if no antigen was added to the cultures. The presence of unprocessed antigen thus appears to be a requirement for B-cell proliferation in vitro, even after T-cell division has been triggered. This finding is consistent with earlier suggestions that the function of “helper” T cells may not be limited to passive transport of antigenic determinants to B cells. Evidence is also presented to support the contention that the antigen-reactive T cell involved in this process may have to undergo cell division in order to develop “helper” capacity.     

In vitro studies of the rabbit immune system: I. Hemolytic plaque-forming response of dissociated spleen cells from normal and primed rabbits

The conditions for the in vitro generation of primary and secondary immune responses by rabbit spleen cells to sheep red blood cell (SRBC) antigen have been examined. Spleen cells from many normal and all previously immunized rabbits are capable of producing in vitro plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses when cultured as dissociated cell suspensions in the presence of antigen. Primed spleen cells generate approximately 100 times the number of PFCs obtained in normal cultures with a shorter lag period. Both types of cultures demonstrate a period of exponential increase in PFCs during which the doubling time is 12–14 hr. This increase occurs after 1 day of culture of spleen cells from primed rabbits and after 4 days of culture of spleen cells from unprimed rabbits. The PFCs which arise in cultures of primed cells appear not to be the progeny of those generated in vivo but to be derived from an increased number of PFC precursors. Repeated immunization of the spleen cell donor is required to produce significant numbers of indirect (IgG) PFC or indirect precursors; most of the PFC found after a single immunization in vivo or in vitro are direct (IgM). There is no evidence for conversion of IgM to IgG PFC in vitro. This system should provide a means for further identification of the cellular interactions involved in the immune response of the rabbit.     

Induction of an antibody response in vitro against synthetic antigens in guinea pigs. I. Culture and assay conditions

Guinea pig spleen and lymph node cells were found to produce anti-2,4-dinitrophenyl (Dnp) oligolysine PFC in vivo against 2,4-dinitrophenyl-β-alanyl glycyl glycyl (Dagg-SRBC) but not against trinitrophenyl-SRBC target indicator cells. Furthermore, when sensitized spleen cells or their purified B-cell fractions were cocultured with primed peritoneal exudate lymphocytes (PEL) but not splenic T cells they were able to generate a secondary PFC response in vitro to the synthetic antigens, Dnp oligolysines. PFC were not induced in vitro if these same cultures were pulsed with short-chain peptides (five lysines) or the complex antigen, dinitrophenyl-bovine γ-globulin (DnpBGG). Con A was able to substitute for PEL in triggering spleen cells to mount a secondary in vitro PFC response to homologous Dnp oligolysines. More importantly, the Con A-aided spleen cell cultures were not induced above background values when challenged in vitro with heterologous Dnp oligolysines. This study suggests that spleen cells may lack a nonspecific signal for the development of a secondary in vitro PFC response.     

Regulation of the immune system by synthetic polynucleotides. VII. Suppression induced by pretreatment with poly A:U.

Pretreatment of mouse spleen cells with polyadenylic-polyuridylic acid complexes (poly A:U) either in vivo or in vitro 24 hr prior to addition of antigen, resulted in a substantial time dependent decrease in anti-SRBC PFC. Enhancement was observed 6 hr after poly A:U, while inhibition did not become evident until 24 hr after pretreatment. Inhibition of the PFC response appeared to result from poly A:U activation of a nylon wool adherent, T suppressor cell, capable of diminishing the response of normal spleen cells exposed to antigen on co-culture.     

In vitro development of a primary antibody response with lymph node cells.

Utilizing a variety of lymphoid tissues from three common laboratory species, comparative studies were performed to investigate the competence of the dissociated cells to respond to a heterologous erythrocyte with the development of specific plaque-forming cells. Dissociated spleen cells harvested from BDF1 mice consistently developed specific plaque-forming cells (PFC) to sheep red blood cells (SRBC), while hamster spleen cells inconsistently developed specific antibody-forming cells to SRBC. Under identical conditions, guinea pig spleen cells did not develop significant numbers of PFC to SRBC. However, lymph node cell cultures of all three species tested yielded specific PFC. In the mouse and hamster lymph node cell cultures, the yield of PFC per culture or per 10⁶ recovered viable cells was always greater than the yield from companion spleen cell cultures. Guinea pig mesenteric lymph node cell cultures developed the major PFC response to SRBC, while both mesenteric and peripheral lymph node cell cultures from hamsters were equivalent in their response to SRBC. The data demonstrate that it is possible to develop a primary antibody response to SRBC in vitro utilizing normal endogenous hamster or guinea pig lymphoid cells, if lymph nodes are the source of cells.     

An in vitro model for induction of immunological unresponsiveness to turkey gamma-globulin in primed mouse spleen cells. I. The secondary in vitro response and induction of unresponsiveness.

Spleen cells from mice previously immunized with turkey γ-globulin (TGG) were shown to give a vigorous secondary response in vitro when challenged in Mishell-Dutton cultures with TGG covalently coupled to pig erthrocytes (TGG-PRBC). However, 90–100% of the response could be abrogated by the incorporation of soluble TGG (sTGG) into the culture medium at concentrations greater than 1 mg/ml. Unresponsiveness, as measured by the absence of plaque-forming cells (PFC) in cultures receiving sTGG, was found to be antigen specific in that these cultures were still able to give normal PFC responses to sheep or burro erythrocytes. Spleen cells incubated with sTGG for short periods of time were shown to remain unresponsive after removal of sTGG from the culture and addition of TGG-PRBC. A 1-hr exposure period resulted in greater than 70% Unresponsiveness and a complete unresponsive state required only 8 hr of exposure. In contrast to the continued Unresponsiveness of sTGG-treated cells in vitro, spleen cells incubated with sTGG for 24 hr were fully responsive to an immunogenic challenge with alum-precipitated TGG when they were transferred into irradiated syngeneic mice. These data suggest that the readily induced unresponsive state in cultures of TGG primed cells may involve either a reversible antigen blockade of antigen-sensitive lymphocytes or a peripheral inhibition of reactive cells by suppressor lymphocytes.     

Formation of heterophile antibodies by human tonsilar lymphocytes: II. In vitro stimulation with allogeneic cells

Short-term cultures of human tonsilar lymphocytes (HTL), 5 × 10⁶ cells/culture, in medium RPMI 1640 supplemented with human group AB serum were studied for the production of plaque-forming cells (PFC) against sheep (SRBC) and bovine (BRBC) red blood cells following in vitro stimulation by various allogeneic lymphoid cells. Of 55 HTL specimens examined, 48 produced a significant number (50–300/culture) of PFC against SRBC and/or BRBC following the in vitro stimulation. The optimal doses of the stimulator HTL and peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) were 10⁷ and 5 × 10⁶/culture, respectively. After the stimulation, PFC appeared in significant numbers on the third day, reached the peak number on the sixth day, and decreased sharply in number thereafter. Removal of E-rosetting cells from both stimulator and responder populations abolished the PFC formation. PFC formation against SRBC was inhibited by solubilized Forssman antigen, while PFC formation against BRBC was inhibited strongly by Hanganutziu-Deicher antigen, hardly by Paul-Bunnell antigen and not at all by Forssman antigen. Supernatants of mixed lymphocyte culture of PBL were shown to enhance PFC formation of HTL cultures stimulated by allogeneic lymphocytes. The results of this study indicated that in vivo primed B cells of the HTL were triggered in vitro by allogeneic stimulation for the heterophile antibody formation. Since these antibodies are apparently directed against Forssman and Hanganutziu-Deicher antigens, the “allo” nature of these antigens as well as their relationship to the previously described heterophile transplantation antigens have to be clarified.     

Interferon inhibition of the primary in vitro antibody response to a thymus-independent antigen

Partially purified and crude mouse L cell interferon preparations inhibited the in vitro plaque-forming cell (PFC) response of mouse C57B1/6 spleen cells to the T-cell independent lipopolysaccharide antigen of Escherichia coli 0127. PFC responses of 5-day cultures were inhibited approximately 70–90% by 100–200 NIH reference units of interferon/culture. A similar inhibitory effect was obtained with spleen cells from athymic (nude) mice homozygous for the nu/nu allele. Spleen cultures depleted of adherent cells were also inhibited in their anti-0127 PFC response by interferon. Interferon, then, appears capable of inhibiting the PFC response to E. coli 0127 via direct action on B cells. Heating experiments along with the use of interferon preparations of different specific activities suggest that the inhibition was due to the interferon in the preparations.     

Plaque-forming cells fater in vitro stimulation with theta-AKR antigen

Spleen cells of inbred mice strains carrying θ-C3H allele have been cultured in the presence of AKR thymus cells and their in vitro primary PFC response against thymic alloantigen θ-AKR was studied.The responses of a magnitude which was comparable with that obtained in previous in vivo experiments were obtained 4 days after stimulation. The strain-dependent variability of the magitude of anti-θ-AKR responses was observed in vitro. RR and C58/J spleen cells produced much more PFC than C57BL/6J and DBA/2J spleen cells. This was in agreement with previous in vivo studies on the genetic control of the anti-θ AKR responses.In the absence of AKR thymus cells, spleen cells of high responders, RR, developed in vitro PFC which released antibodies lytic to AKR thymus cells. Their number was ten-times lower than in stimulated cultures. Spleen cells of all strains tested produced also small numbers of PFC secreting antibodies against θ-identical allogenic thymus cells and even to syngenic thymus cells.     

Antigen-specific suppressor cell activity in man: I. Temporal, antigenic, and proliferative requirements

The temporal, antigenic, and proliferative requirements of antigen-specific suppression of the in vitro plaque-forming cell (PFC) response of human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBM) were studied. Suppressor cell activity (SCA) was generated by priming PBM with high doses of the T-cell-dependent antigen ovalbumin (OA) and measured by adding washed primed cells to target PFC cultures. Priming with high doses of OA was shown to induce a population of antigen-specific T lymphocytes which interfered with the anti-OA PFC response of optimally stimulated target cultures. The generation of SCA was demonstrated following as little as 24 hr of high-dose OA priming and could be abrogated by prolonged priming (72 hr) or by pretreatment with mitomycin prior to priming. The expression of optimal SCA required the addition of primed PBM at the initiation of the target culture and could be directly correlated to both the OA concentration used for priming and the number of primed cells added. Higher priming doses of OA (up to 100 μg) generated increasing numbers of cells capable of antigen-specific SCA as measured via a cell dilution protocol. Our data suggest that an antigen-driven and dose-dependent expansion of an antigen-specific T-suppressor cell pool is an early regulative event limiting the in vitro PFC response of human lymphocytes to OA.     

Development of responsiveness and incidence of bispecific cells as revealed by in vitro assessment of the maturation of mouse bone marrow cells.

The kinetics of the maturation of B cells were studied in adult thymectomized, lethally irradiated, and bone marrow-reconstituted mice. The spleen cells of the recipients were taken at various intervals after transfer and cultured in vitro with trinitrophenylated sheep erythrocytes (TNP-SRBC). The cultures were supplemented with either allogeneic culture supernatant or educated T-cell helper activity. Appearance of functional B cells in the bone marrow inoculum was assessed by the number of hemolytic plaque-forming cells (PFC) on the fourth day of culture. In a parallel series the frequency of surface Ig-bearing cells was determined by using fluorescent rabbit anti-mouse Ig serum. When helped by allogeneic culture supernatants, differentiating bone marrow cells showed a slower rate of maturation into functional B cells than when helped by specifically educated T cells. But in both cases the recovery of responsiveness reached the same level (number of PFC/10⁶ cells) as that of normal spleen cells 55 to 60 days after transfer. During the initial periods of recovery, bispecific PFC (reacting both to TNP and to native SRBC determinants) were detected regularly in numbers far exceeding their frequency in normal spleen cell cultures; in some experiments, the number of bispecific PFC amounted to as much as 30% of the total PFC, whereas, when the bone marrow cells completely recovered (sixtieth day), the frequency of bispecific PFC was similar to that found in normal spleen cell cultures. The number of surface Ig-bearing cells also reached a normal level after the fiftieth day following transfer. In general, the degree of functional maturation was better correlated with the cells bearing surface Ig in the shape of rings or caps, whereas the predominance of spot-bearing cells indicated immaturity of the population.     

LPS-induced autoantibody response. I. Ontogenic development of PFC response to bromelain-treated syngeneic erythrocytes

Normal adult mice have been shown to contain a large number of cells secreting antibodies against bromelain-treated syngeneic erythrocytes (Br.MRBC) and the numbers remarkably increase by the stimulation with LPS. In this report development of the anti-Br.MRBC response during ontogeny was examined and it was shown that on the injection of LPS suckling mice responded little to generate splenic plaque-forming cells (PFC) against Br.MRBC in vivo and in vitro. The responsiveness of suckling mice to produce anti-Br.MRBC was shown to be less developed than the anti-TNP response or the mitotic response to LPS. The low responsiveness of suckling mice was analyzed in terms of suppressor activity in the spleen cell population, proliferative capacities of the precursors of anti-Br.MRBC PFC, and their frequencies in the spleen. In the coculture experiment of suckling and adult spleen cells or culture of anti-brain-associated Thy 1-treated, macrophage-depleted spleen cell population, no evidence was obtained to show that suckling spleen cells contained suppressor cells. Kinetic profiles studied in vitro showed that anti-Br.MRBC PFC in the suckling spleen did not increase during the culture as those in the adult spleen. Studies on the precursor frequencies revealed that spleen cells of 15-day-old mice contained precursors of anti-Br.MRBC PFC amounting to 20.5% of the adult precursors whereas the PFC response in vitro by the former was only 4% of the latter. From these experimental data, it was concluded that the low responsiveness of suckling mice was partly due to the low frequency of the precursors in the spleen and, in addition, to the defective nature of the precursors in proliferating to differentiate into PFC.     

Cellular requirements for the expression of IgM. Immunological memory in vitro

In vitro culture techniques have been used to compare the direct (IgM) plaqueforming cell (PFC) response to heterologous erythrocytes (RBC) by normal mouse spleen cells and spleen cells from mice injected intravenously with 5 × 10⁴ RBC ten days previously [low dose primed (LDP)]. Although LDP mice fail to undergo a significant primary PFC response, their spleen cells are capable of a secondary or enhanced PFC response in vitro. The secondary PFC response is shown to be a function of: (A) an increase in the frequency of immunocompetent cells or units (IU) due to in vivo priming, and (B) an increased number of PFC generated per IU subsequent to in vitro stimulation. The latter increase is shown to be mediated through a shorter PFC doubling-time during logarithmic expansion of the PFC population. Analysis of nonadherent spleen cell dose response experiments indicate that two nonadherent cell types interact in the secondary response. Subsequent cocultivation experiments suggested that both of these cell types must be “primed” to allow induction of a secondary response. Although adherent cells are required for the secondary response, normal splenic adherent cells serve as equivalent substitutes for LDP adherent cells.     

Suppression of in vitro primary immune response by L1210 cells and their culture supernatant: Evidence for cytotoxic effects

L1210 cells and their culture supernatants were found to inhibit the generation of PFC in the in vitro primary immune response of spleen cells to SRBC. As few as 1% of L1210 cells and 1% of culture fluid were inhibitory. Inhibition of DNA or protein synthesis of L1210 cells did not abolish their immunosuppressive activity, excluding exhaustion of culture medium as a possible mechanism of inhibition of PFC. Heating of the supernatant completely abrogated the suppressive effect and resulted in a marked increase of PFC. Daily evaluation of cell viability in the cultures revealed that, in the presence of L1210 and supernatants, the fraction of surviving cells is markedly reduced. We conclude that a direct cytotoxic effect on splenic lymphocytes and macrophages is the predominant immunosuppressive mechanism of L1210 cells and their culture supernatants.     

In vitro immune response of primed mouse spleen cells as affected by the time of antigenic stimulation

Normal and primed spleen cells stimulated in vitro with sheep RBC showed a different behaviour in the 19 S PFC response. The immunologic capacity of primed cells, unlike that of unprimed cells, was impaired if the antigen addition to culture had been delayed for more than six hours. The requirement of primed cells for immediate reexposure to antigen varied with the time of preimmunization and was maximum when spleen cells had acquired in the donor the ability to display the highest response in vitro upon optimal restimulation. This phenomenon of antigen requirement of primed cells in vitro is at variance with the known immunologic behaviour of primed cells grown in vivo, and can be attributed to cellular changes unmasked by in vitro cultivation.     

The nature of the suppressive effect of interferon and interferon inducers on the in vitro immune response

Viral-induced interferon inhibition of the primary in vitro plaque-formong cell (PFC) response in the mouse (C57B1/6) involves a dynamic relationship between the nature of the antigen, the concentration of interferon added to antigen-stimulated cultures, and the time of addition of interferon relative to antigen addition. The PFC response to a thymus-dependent antigen (sheep red blood cells) was more easily suppressed by viral-induced interferon than was that to a thymus-independent antigen (E. coli 0127 LPS), both in terms of inhibitory concentrations of interferon and the time at which the interferon could be added to cultures after antigen and still inhibit the PFC response. These differential effects of interferon could be related to the difference in cellular requirements (B and T lymphocytes) of the two antigens. Interferon was effective in inhibiting the in vitro PFC response of antigen-primed spleen cells, indicating that it can block the response of memory lymphocytes. By using interferon inducers as inhibitors of the in vitro PFC response, it was possible to show that at least two antigenically distinct interferons may be involved in suppressing the immune response. It is known that one type of interferon is induced by virus and synthetic double-stranded polyribonucleotides. The other type is stimulated by antigen and T cell mitogens. A model is proposed to explain the nature of these interferon inhibitory effects in terms of mediation of immune suppressor cell effects.     

Soluble factors from BCG-induced suppressor cells inhibit in vitro PFC responses but not cytotoxic responses.

A macrophage-like suppressor cell is present in the spleens of BCG-infected C57BL/6 mice. This suppressor cell is capable of suppressing both in vitro cytotoxic and PFC responses of normal C57BL/6 spleen cells. Suppression was not caused by changes in the kinetics of the responses or in the quantities of antigen required for stimulation. Suppression of the in vitro cytotoxic response could not be linked to any soluble mediator. In contrast, supernatants obtained from BCG spleen cell cultures, which failed to inhibit alloantigen-induced cytotoxic responses, suppressed the in vitro PFC response to SRBC by normal C57BL/6 spleen cells. It is postulated that either BCG-induced macrophage-like suppressor cells inhibit these in vitro responses via different mechanism(s) or these responses are regulated by different suppressor cell subpopulations within the monocyte/macrophage compartment of BCG spleen cells.     

In vitro studies of the rabbit immune system: III. T-cell requirement for initiation but not maintenance of anti-sheep erythrocyte plaque-forming cells

The in vitro anti-sheep erythrocyte plaque-forming-cell (anti-SRBC PFC) response of primed rabbit spleen cells can be abrogated by prior treatment with anti-thymocyte serum plus complement (ATS + C). The direct addition of ATS without C to stimulated cultures also reduces the response 60–90%, if the antiserum is added before the initiation of antigen-stimulated PFC production. However, the PFC response becomes refractory to ATS inhibition by 48 hr. This loss of ATS sensitivity is not caused by T cells themselves becoming refractory to ATS for the following reasons: (i) ATS + C treatment or ATS addition at 48 hr causes cytotoxic effects comparable to similar treatments at 0 hr; (ii) The responsiveness of cells incubated 48 hr before the addition of SRBC remains sensitive to ATS inhibition at that time. The loss of ATS sensitivity is also not the result of soluble T-cell factors which have accumulated in the medium, because the number of PFC in stimulated cultures continues to increase after treating with ATS + C and reculturing in fresh medium at 48 hr. We conclude that T cells are required to initiate the production of antibody by B cells but are not required to maintain the later proliferative events.     

Specific antigens inhibit plasmacytoma cells bearing phosphorylcholine-binding myeloma proteins.

The influence of a synthetic adjuvant active glycopeptide, N-acetylmuramyl-l-alanyl-d-isoglutamine (MDP), and of some of its analogs on the in vitro immune response to sheep red blood cells was studied using Mishell and Dutton in vitro stimulation system. When MDP and adjuvant active analogs were incubated with normal spleen cells, increased cell recovery was observed after 3 or 4 days of culture, showing a good correlation between the adjuvant activity in vivo and the enhancement of cell viability in vitro. The analogs which were found to have an adjuvant activity in vivo were equally effective in stimulating in vitro both the background hemolytic PFC and the immune response to sheep red blood cells. However, those which were inactive in vivo were effective in vitro but only at high concentration levels.