Interactions between Saccharomyces cerevisiae and malolactic bacteria: preliminary characterization of a yeast proteinaceous compound(s) active against Oenococcus oeni

AIMS: To investigate the occurrence and extent of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Oenococcus oeni interactions. METHODS AND RESULTS: Interactions between S. cerevisiae and O. oeni were investigated by double-layer and well-plate assays showing the occurrence of specific interactions for each yeast-malolactic bacteria (MLB) coupling. Heat and protease treatments of synthetic grape juice fermented by the S. cerevisiae strain F63 indicated that the inhibitory activity exerted by this yeast on O. oeni is due to a proteinaceous factor(s) which exerts either bacteriostatic or bactericidal effect depending on concentration and affects malolactic fermentation in natural grape juice and wine. CONCLUSIONS: A proteinaceous factor(s) produced by a S. cerevisiae wine strain able to inhibit O. oeni growth and malic acid fermentation was characterized. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The individuation, characterization and exploitation of yeast proteinaceous factor(s) exerting inhibitory activity on MLB may offer new opportunities for the management of malolactic fermentation.     

Malolactic fermentation of wine: study of the influence of some physico-chemical factors by experimental design assays

The ability of selected lactic acid bacteria to carry out malolactic fermentation depends on the level of numerous wine characteristics. A Hadamard's experimental matrix was used to determine the main effects of 11 physico-chemical factors on malolactic activity of three Leuconostoc œnos strains and one Lactobacillus plantarum strain. Ethanol had the greatest inhibitory effect on the achievement of malolactic fermentation for all Leuc. œnos strains. An inhibitory effect of the L-malic acid was also found in the operating conditions. These strains show different degrees of sensitivity to pH. One of these strains was inhibited by SO₂. Malolactic activity of the Lact. plantarum strain is mainly affected by a low pH, and this strain is often less efficient than Leuc. œnos strains. This methodology could be used for the selection of strains for malolactic starters. Further work is in progress using factorial design in order to determine the interactions between influential factors.     

Quantitative study of interactions between <Emphasis Type="Italic">Saccharomyces cerevisiae</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Oenococcus </Emphasis><Emphasis Type="Italic">oeni</Emphasis> strains

This study examines the interactions that occur between Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Oenococcus oeni strains during the process of winemaking. Various yeast/bacteria pairs were studied by applying a sequential fermentation strategy which simulated the natural winemaking process. First, four yeast strains were tested in the presence of one bacterial strain leading to the inhibition of the bacterial component. The extent of inhibition varied widely from one pair to another and closely depended on the specific yeast strain chosen. Inhibition was correlated to weak bacterial growth rather than a reduction in the bacterial malolactic activity. Three of the four yeast strains were then grown with another bacteria strain. Contrary to the first results, this led to the bacterial stimulation, thus highlighting the importance of the bacteria strain. The biochemical profile of the four yeast fermented media exhibited slight variations in ethanol, SO(2) and fatty acids produced as well as assimilable consumed nitrogen. These parameters were not the only factors responsible for the malolactic fermentation inhibition observed with the first bacteria strain. The stimulation of the second has not been reported before in such conditions and remains unexplained.     

Effect of ethanol and fatty acids on malolactic activity ofLeuconostoc oenos

Medium-chain fatty acids (C₆ to C₁₂), produced by yeast metabolism during alcoholic fermentation, are known to be inhibitory to lactic acid bacteria. The purpose of this work was to clarify the effect of both ethanol and decanoic and dodecanoic acids on the growth and malolactic activity of aLeuconostoc oenos strain isolated from Portuguese red wine. Ethanol in concentrations up to 12% had no significant effect on malolactic activity but strongly inhibited cell growth. The fatty acids decanoic acid, in concentrations up to 12.5 mg l^–1, and, dodecanoic acid up to 2.5 mg l^–1 seemed to act as growth factors stimulating also malolactic activity; at higher concentrations they exerted an inhibitory effect. We found clear pH dependence between pH 3.0 and pH 6.0, between decanoic acid concentration and its effect on malolactic activity, indicating that the undissociated molecule is the active form. At pH 3.0 the results can be explained by considering that fatty acids enter the cell as protonated molecules and dissociate in the cytoplasm due to the higher internal pH, leading to increased intracellular hydrogenous concentration. This may be the basis of two different effects that contribute to the observed inhibition: decrease in the intracellular pH and dissipation of the transmembrane proton gradient, thus inhibiting intracellular enzymes and ApH-dependent transport systems.     

Simultaneous yeast–bacteria inoculum. A feasible solution for the management of oenological fermentation in red must with low nitrogen content

The simultaneous inoculum of yeasts and bacteria is a feasible solution for improving fermentation in wines with a harsh chemical composition, capable of inhibiting microbial activity. Considering the risk of wine spoilage due to lactic bacteria, co-inoculum is suggested in white wines with a low pH. However, climate change has also caused problems in achieving malolactic fermentation in red wines, due to the high concentration of ethanol and the low nutrient content. In this work, 5 pairs of commercial oenological starters were tested in simultaneous fermentation, using 4 red musts with a low nitrogen content, and compared with a traditional winemaking process. The simultaneous inoculum caused a slowdown in the activity of yeasts, although no problems in the accomplishment of alcoholic fermentations were observed. More reliable malolactic fermentation was performed in the co-inoculum trials, while, in traditional winemaking, some failures in the degradation of malic acid were observed. Microbiological analyses agreed with these observations. No differences were found in yeast density during alcoholic fermentation, demonstrating the absence of negative interaction between the yeast and the bacteria. However, simultaneous fermentation is not without risks; the highest increases of acetic acid were noted in the co-inoculum trials. The addition of yeast and bacteria to must with a serious lack of nutrients would appear to be a promising alternative to traditional fermentation; however, careful control of the chemical composition of must is mandatory to obtain reliable microbiological activity in the first stages of winemaking.     

Functional expression in Saccharomyces cerevisiae of the Lactococcus lactis mleS gene encoding the malolactic enzyme

Abstract Malolactic fermentation, a crucial step in winemaking, results mostly in degradation by lactic acid bacteria of L-malic acid into L-lactic acid. This direct decarboxylation is catalysed by the malolactic enzyme. Recently we, and others, have cloned the mleS gene of Lactococcus lactis encoding malolactic enzyme. Heterologous expression of mleS in Saccha-romyces cerevisiae was tested to perform simultaneously alcoholic and malolactic fermentations by yeast. mleS gene was cloned in a yeast multicopy vector under a strong promoter. Malolactic activity was present in crude extracts of recombinant yeasts. Malic acid degradation was tested during alcoholic fermentation in synthetic media and must. Yeasts expressing the mleS gene actually produced L-lactate from L-malate; nevertheless malate degradation was far from complete.     

Influence of phenolic compounds on the physiology of Oenococcus oeni from wine

This study shows that the growth of Oenococcus oeni CECT 4100 in a synthetic medium is affected by phenolic compounds in different ways, depending on their type and concentration. Generally they have no effects at low concentrations, but hydroxycinnamic acids are inhibitory at high concentrations. Malolactic fermentation was stimulated in the presence of catechin and quercetin, but increasingly delayed with increasing amounts of p-coumaric acid. Gallic acid appeared to delay or inhibit the formation of acetic acid from citric acid. This could lead to a better control of malolactic fermentation and suppress the increase in volatile acidity, which is undesirable in the wine-making process.     

Malolactic fermentation in Chardonnay: growth and sensory effects of commercial strains of Leuconostoc oenos

Samples of fermenting Chardonnay juice were inoculated with five commercial cultures of Leuconostoc oenos to promote malolactic fermentation. Controls were not inoculated with malolactic starter cultures; one was held under the same conditions as the juice inoculated with malolactic starter cultures and the other was held under conditions in which malolactic fermentation was inhibited. Bacterial growth and chemical composition of the wines were monitored for eight weeks after the wines were inoculated with the yeast starter culture. The five strains of L. oenos differed in growth kinetics and rates of malic acid degradation. Significant differences were detected among the finished wines subjected to sensory evaluation.     

Role of malolactic fermentation in lactic acid bacteria

Although decarboxylation of malate to lactate by malolactic enzyme does not liberate biologically available energy (e.g., ATP, NADH), the growth rate of many malolactic bacteria is greatly enhanced by malolactic fermentation. The deacidification of the medium due to malate dissipation cannot fully account for this situation. The chemiosmotic theory postulates that another form of energy could generated by translocation of protons through the membrane coupled to end-product efflux. Konings et al. showed that this theory is indeed applicable to lactate efflux in Streptococcus cremoris at pH 7.0. A similar mechanism could account for the observed increased activity in malolactic bacteria. The study in wild type and mutant strains of Streptococcus lactis unable to carry out malolactic fermentation led us to the following conclusions: (1) under glucose non-limiting conditions, malolactic fermentation helps to maintain pH of the medium at a certain level; (2) during glucose limited growth, malolactic fermentation could be coupled with an energetic process independent from that mentioned above.     

Simultaneous and sequential fermentations with yeast and lactic acid bacteria in apple juice

A complex substrate, reconstituted concentrated apple juice, was used for testing the principal processes during yeast and malolactic bacteria fermentations. Interactions between microorganisms were studied based on two controlled inoculation procedures, and at different fermentation temperatures. Temperature had a more important effect on yeast growth than the presence of malolactic bacteria in the medium. Acceleration of the death phase of the bacterial population was detected at increased temperatures. In all cases, malic acid degradation was affected by the fermentation temperature. When experiments were carried out with simultaneous inoculation, acidification of the medium took place at both temperatures tested (15°C and 22°C), that was not observed when the malolactic bacteria were inoculated after completion of alcoholic fermentation by yeasts. Received 4 August 1998/ Accepted in revised form 9 December 1998     

Wine flavor and aroma

The perception of wine flavor and aroma is the result of a multitude of interactions between a large number of chemical compounds and sensory receptors. Compounds interact and combine and show synergistic (i.e., the presence of one compound enhances the perception of another) and antagonistic (a compound suppresses the perception of another) interactions. The chemical profile of a wine is derived from the grape, the fermentation microflora (in particular the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae), secondary microbial fermentations that may occur, and the aging and storage conditions. Grape composition depends on the varietal and clonal genotype of the vine and on the interaction of the genotype and its phenotype with many environmental factors which, in wine terms, are usually grouped under the concept of “terroir” (macro, meso and microclimate, soil, topography). The microflora, and in particular the yeast responsible for fermentation, contributes to wine aroma by several mechanisms: firstly by utilizing grape juice constituents and biotransforming them into aroma- or flavor-impacting components, secondly by producing enzymes that transform neutral grape compounds into flavor-active compounds, and lastly by the de novo synthesis of many flavor-active primary (e.g., ethanol, glycerol, acetic acid, and acetaldehyde) and secondary metabolites (e.g., esters, higher alcohols, fatty acids). This review aims to present an overview of the formation of wine flavor and aroma-active components, including the varietal precursor molecules present in grapes and the chemical compounds produced during alcoholic fermentation by yeast, including compounds directly related to ethanol production or secondary metabolites. The contribution of malolactic fermentation, ageing, and maturation on the aroma and flavor of wine is also discussed.     

Metabolism of arginine and its positive effect on growth and revival of Oenococcus oeni

Oenococcus oeni is the main lactic acid bacteria species which induces malolactic fermentation during wine-making. It is able to break down arginine via the arginine deiminase pathway, a potential source of energy already considered for many bacteria. The production of ATP by starved cells from arginine was quantified with a bioluminescence assay, and efficient coupling of amino acid catabolism and cell growth was monitored. Therefore, molecular growth yield was determined after glucose exhaustion. With colony plate counting and a direct epifluorescence technique, it was shown that addition of arginine to viable but non-culturable cells obtained after nutrient starvation restored their ability to grow during its degradation. Therefore, arginine produced more than maintenance energy. It is concluded that strains which are able to metabolize arginine might take advantage of this additional energy source for growth.     

Leuconostoc oenos and malolactic fermentation in wine: a review

This review article summarizes the state of the art on Leuconostoc oenos, the bacteria responsible for malolactic fermentation in wine. Both basic and practical aspects related to the metabolism of this microorganism and malolactic fermentation in general are critically reviewed. The former examines the role of genetics for the identification and classification of L. oenos and energetic mechanisms on solute transport (malic and lactic acid). The latter includes practical information on biomass production, optimal growth conditions and stress factors, which are important in growth optimization of malolactic starter cultures. Extensive data and references on the effect of malolactic fermentation on wine composition and sensory analysis are also included. Received 06 May 1999/ Accepted in revised form 13 July 1999     

Microbial and chemical changes during the spontaneous ensilage of grape pomace

Pilot scale fermentations with grape pomace from two different wineries were investigated during the 24 weeks of the ensiling period, along with laboratory scale experiments in which the environmental temperatures were held constant at 20, 25, 30 and 35 °C. During this period, yeast and lactic acid bacteria (LAB) counts were made, after which the identity of both groups of organisms was studied, as were the major microbial metabolites present. Major microbial and chemical alterations occurred during the first 3 weeks of ensilage, leaving a more stable product differing significantly from the initial substrate. The results obtained indicated that after initial growth, yeast and LAB populations undergo progressive inactivation at environmental temperatures above 20 °C, although LAB seem to adjust better to this specific, post-fermentation environment. Homofermentative species of Lactobacillus were the dominant LAB. The initial yeast flora of non- Saccharomyces species was replaced by a typical wine yeast flora, i.e. predominantly Saccharomyces cerevisiae. At the chemical level, major alterations were due to an alcoholic fermentation and a malolactic conversion within the first 3 weeks.     

Microbiology of the malolactic fermentation: Molecular aspects

Abstract Malolactic fermentation conducted by lactic acid bacteria follows alcoholic fermentation during winemaking, and several positive effects make it indispensable for most wines. Research has focused on the growth and physiology of lactic acid bacteria in wine; resulting in the design of malolactic starter cultures. Future work on these starters will concentrate on aromatic changes as additional criteria for strain selection. Although the main features of the malolactic enzyme and its gene are known, the detailed mechanism of the malolactic reaction remains unclear. Cloning and expression of this activity in enological strains of Saccharomyces cereuisiae might be one of the next most important advances in the control of malic acid degradation in wine.     

Malolactic fermentation in wine with high densities of non-proliferating Oenococcus oeni

Five strains of Oenococcus oeni (syn. Leuconostoc oenos) under non-proliferating conditions were assessed for the performance of the malolactic fermentation in wine at various initial pH values, malic acid concentration and densities of cells. We succeeded in inducing the malolactic fermentation after inoculation of high densities of O. oeni G6 even in recalcitrant wines where the traditional malolactic fermentation was inhibited by adverse environmental conditions (low pH and high concentration of malic acid). Optimal degrading conditions in wine, under different physico-chemical environments, were determined in order to achieve rapid depletion of malic acid in red wine. Off-odour compounds were not formed under these conditions, suggesting an attractive alternative for wine production. This revised version was published online in November 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Malolactic bioconversion using a<Emphasis Type="Italic"> Oenococcus oeni</Emphasis> strain for cider production: effect of yeast extract supplementation

Yeast extract addition to reconstituted apple juice had a positive impact on the development of the malolactic starter culture used to ensure malolactic fermentation in cider, using active but non-proliferating cells. In this work, the reuse of fermentation lees from cider is proposed as an alternative to the use of commercial yeast extract products. Malolactic enzymatic assays, both in whole cells and cell-free extracts, were carried out to determine the best time to harvest cells for use as an inoculum in cider. Cells harvested at the late exponential phase, the physiological stage of growth corresponding to the maximum values of specific malolactic activity, achieved a good rate of malic acid degradation in controlled cider fermentation. Under the laboratory conditions used, malic acid degradation rates in the fermentation media turned out to be near 2.0 and 2.5 times lower, compared with the rates obtained in whole-cell enzymatic assays, as useful data applicable to industrial cider production.     

Lactic acid bacteria in the quality improvement and depreciation of wine

The winemaking process includes two main steps: lactic acid bacteria are responsible for the malolactic fermentation which follows the alcoholic fermentation by yeasts. Both types of microorganisms are present on grapes and on cellar equipment. Yeasts are better adapted to growth in grape must than lactic acid bacteria, so the alcoholic fermentation starts quickly. In must, up to ten lactic acid bacteria species can be identified. They belong to the Lactobacillus, Pediococcus, Leuconostoc and Oenococcus genera. Throughout alcoholic fermentation, a natural selection occurs and finally the dominant species is O. oeni, due to interactions between yeasts and bacteria and between bacteria themselves. After bacterial growth, when the population is over 10⁶CFU/ml, malolactic transformation is the obvious change in wine composition. However, many other substrates can be metabolized. Some like remaining sugars and citric acid are always assimilated by lactic acid bacteri a, thus providing them with energy and carbon. Other substrates such as some amino acids may be used following pathways restricted to strains carrying the adequate enzymes. Some strains can also produce exopolysaccharides. All these transformations greatly influence the sensory and hygienic quality of wine. Malic acid transformation is encouraged because it induces deacidification. Diacetyl produced from citric acid is also helpful to some extent. Sensory analyses show that many other reactions change the aromas and make malolactic fermentation beneficial, but they are as yet unknown. On the contrary, an excess of acetic acid, the synthesis of glucane, biogenic amines and precursors of ethylcarbamate are undesirable. Fortunately, lactic acid bacteria normally multiply in dry wines; moreover some of these activities are not widespread. Moreover, the most striking trait of wine lactic acid bacteria is their capacity to adapt to a hostile environment. The mechanisms for this are not yet c ompletely elucidated . Molecular biology has provided some explanations for the behaviour and the metabolism of bacteria in wine. New tools are now available to detect the presence of desirable and undesirable strains. Even if much remains unknown, winemakers and oenologists can nowadays better control the process. By acting upon the diverse microflora and grape musts, they are more able to produce healthy and pleasant wines.     

Homo- and heterofermentative lactobacilli differently affect sugarcane-based fuel ethanol fermentation

Bacterial contamination during industrial yeast fermentation has serious economic consequences for fuel ethanol producers. In addition to deviating carbon away from ethanol formation, bacterial cells and their metabolites often have a detrimental effect on yeast fermentative performance. The bacterial contaminants are commonly lactic acid bacteria (LAB), comprising both homo- and heterofermentative strains. We have studied the effects of these two different types of bacteria upon yeast fermentative performance, particularly in connection with sugarcane-based fuel ethanol fermentation process. Homofermentative Lactobacillus plantarum was found to be more detrimental to an industrial yeast strain (Saccharomyces cerevisiae CAT-1), when compared with heterofermentative Lactobacillus fermentum, in terms of reduced yeast viability and ethanol formation, presumably due to the higher titres of lactic acid in the growth medium. These effects were only noticed when bacteria and yeast were inoculated in equal cell numbers. However, when simulating industrial fuel ethanol conditions, as conducted in Brazil where high yeast cell densities and short fermentation time prevail, the heterofermentative strain was more deleterious than the homofermentative type, causing lower ethanol yield and out competing yeast cells during cell recycle. Yeast overproduction of glycerol was noticed only in the presence of the heterofermentative bacterium. Since the heterofermentative bacterium was shown to be more deleterious to yeast cells than the homofermentative strain, we believe our findings could stimulate the search for more strain-specific antimicrobial agents to treat bacterial contaminations during industrial ethanol fermentation.