Implications of new research and technologies for malolactic fermentation in wine

The initial conversion of grape must to wine is an alcoholic fermentation (AF) largely carried out by one or more strains of yeast, typically Saccharomyces cerevisiae. After the AF, a secondary or malolactic fermentation (MLF) which is carried out by lactic acid bacteria (LAB) is often undertaken. The MLF involves the bioconversion of malic acid to lactic acid and carbon dioxide. The ability to metabolise l-malic acid is strain specific, and both individual Oenococcus oeni strains and other LAB strains vary in their ability to efficiently carry out MLF. Aside from impacts on acidity, LAB can also metabolise other precursors present in wine during fermentation and, therefore, alter the chemical composition of the wine resulting in an increased complexity of wine aroma and flavour. Recent research has focused on three main areas: enzymatic changes during MLF, safety of the final product and mechanisms of stress resistance. This review summarises the latest research and technological advances in the rapidly evolving study of MLF and investigates the directions that future research may take.     

Comparative metabolic profiling to investigate the contribution of <Emphasis Type="Italic">O. oeni</Emphasis> MLF starter cultures to red wine composition

In this research work we investigated changes in volatile aroma composition associated with four commercial Oenococcus oeni malolactic fermentation (MLF) starter cultures in South African Shiraz and Pinotage red wines. A control wine in which MLF was suppressed was included. The MLF progress was monitored by use of infrared spectroscopy. Gas chromatographic analysis and capillary electrophoresis were used to evaluate the volatile aroma composition and organic acid profiles, respectively. Significant strain-specific variations were observed in the degradation of citric acid and production of lactic acid during MLF. Subsequently, compounds directly and indirectly resulting from citric acid metabolism, namely diacetyl, acetic acid, acetoin, and ethyl lactate, were also affected depending on the bacterial strain used for MLF. Bacterial metabolic activity increased concentrations of the higher alcohols, fatty acids, and total esters, with a larger increase in ethyl esters than in acetate esters. Ethyl lactate, diethyl succinate, ethyl octanoate, ethyl 2-methylpropanoate, and ethyl propionate concentrations were increased by MLF. In contrast, levels of hexyl acetate, isoamyl acetate, 2-phenylethyl acetate, and ethyl acetate were reduced or remained unchanged, depending on the strain and cultivar evaluated. Formation of ethyl butyrate, ethyl propionate, ethyl 2-methylbutryate, and ethyl isovalerate was related to specific bacterial strains used, indicating possible differences in esterase activity. A strain-specific tendency to reduce total aldehyde concentrations was found at the completion of MLF, although further investigation is needed in this regard. This study provided insight into metabolism in O. oeni starter cultures during MLF in red wine.     

Phenotypic and genotypic diversity of wine yeasts used for acidic musts

The aim of this study was to examine the physiological and genetic stability of the industrial wine yeasts Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Saccharomyces bayanus var. uvarum under acidic stress during fermentation. The yeasts were sub-cultured in aerobic or fermentative conditions in media with or without l-malic acid. Changes in the biochemical profiles, karyotypes, and mitochondrial DNA profiles were assessed after minimum 50 generations. All yeast segregates showed a tendency to increase the range of compounds used as sole carbon sources. The wild strains and their segregates were aneuploidal or diploidal. One of the four strains of S. cerevisiae did not reveal any changes in the electrophoretic profiles of chromosomal and mitochondrial DNA, irrespective of culture conditions. The extent of genomic changes in the other yeasts was strain-dependent. In the karyotypes of the segregates, the loss of up to 2 and the appearance up to 3 bands was noted. The changes in their mtDNA patterns were much broader, reaching 5 missing and 10 additional bands. The only exception was S. bayanus var. uvarum Y.00779, characterized by significantly greater genome plasticity only under fermentative stress. Changes in karyotypes and mtDNA profiles prove that fermentative stress is the main driving force of the adaptive evolution of the yeasts. l-malic acid does not influence the extent of genomic changes and the resistance of wine yeasts exhibiting increased demalication activity to acidic stress is rather related to their ability to decompose this acid. The phenotypic changes in segregates, which were found even in yeasts that did not reveal deviations in their DNA profiles, show that phenotypic characterization may be misleading in wine yeast identification. Because of yeast gross genomic diversity, karyotyping even though it does not seem to be a good discriminative tool, can be useful in determining the stability of wine yeasts. Restriction analysis of mitochondrial DNA appears to be a more sensitive method allowing for an early detection of genotypic changes in yeasts. Thus, if both of these methods are applied, it is possible to conduct the quick routine assessment of wine yeast stability in pure culture collections depositing industrial strains.     

Effect of Dipeptides on the Growth of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Oenococcus oeni</Emphasis> in Synthetic Medium Deprived of Amino Acids

Oenococcus oeni has numerous amino acid requirements for growth and dipeptides could be important for its nutrition. In this paper the individual or combined effect of dipeptides on growth of O. oeni X₂L in synthetic media deficient in one or more amino acids with L-malic acid was investigated. Utilization of dipeptides, glucose, and L-malic acid was also analyzed. Dipeptides were constituted by at least one essential amino acid for growth. Dipeptides containing two essential amino acids, except leucine, had a more favorable effect than free amino acids on the growth rate. Gly-Gly was consumed to a greater extent than Leu-Leu and a rapid exodus of glycine to the extracellular medium accompanied it. The microorganism could use glycine in exchange for other essential amino acids outside the cell, favoring growth. In the presence of Leu-Leu, the increase in glucose consumption rate could be related to the additional energy required for dipeptide uptake.     

Influence of glycosides on behavior of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Oenococcus oeni</Emphasis> in wine conditions: growth,substrates and aroma compounds

Autochthonous Oenococcus oeni strains (MS9, MS20 and MS46) with good malolactic performance and yielding adequate diacetyl levels, were selected to investigate the effect of synthetic and grape glycosides on bacterial growth, substrate utilization and β-glucosidase (βGlu), α-arabinofuranosidase (αAra) and α-rhamnopyranosidase (αRha) activities in a wine-like medium containing 6% ethanol, pH 4.0 (WBM). Then, changes in the volatile compounds profile were evaluated at the end of malolactic fermentation (MLF) carried out by the MS46 strain in WBM containing 1 mg L^?1 of natural glycoside. All strains grew and efficiently degraded l-malic acid in WBM where βGlu and αAra activities were found but not αRha. In presence of a synthetic glycoside (eriodictyol 7-O-β-rutinoside) βGlu activity was significantly enhanced for two of the cultures tested (MS20 and MS460) while a low αRha activity was induced, presenting MS46 the better performance. Glycosides extracted from fermented grape musts under different conditions allowed maximum growths, l-malic acid utilization rates and glycosidase activities in the MS46 strain. Thus, βGlu, αAra and αRha activities increased between 30–50 and 3–11% respectively. This indirectly correlated to significant changes in total esters and higher alcohols at the end of MLF, which increased by up to 140 and 30% respectively. Moreover, ethyl and acetate esters formed up to 100-fold than alcohols or esters degraded highlighted the main role of this microorganism in the esters synthesis. Results obtained encourage the potential use of selected indigenous O. oeni strains as a tool to enhance wine complexity through MLF, mainly on highly fruity aroma.     

Predominance of malolactic fermentation overd-glucose utilization inLactobacillus plantarum andLactobacillus curvatus wine strains

Summary Two selected wine strains of the genusLactobacillus (L. plantarum 197 andL. curvatus 783) were tested for their ability to complete malolactic fermentation (MLF) in a synthetic medium (PBM-broth) supplemented withL-malic acid (7.5–74.6 mM) andD-glucose (5.5–55 mM). The 24 directed fermentation assays, 12 for each bacterial strain, were carried out at 20°C and pH 3.5. MLF was completed (residualL-malic acid 0.2 mM) in eight days in 19 of the 24 fermentation assays, even in the presence of 74.6 mML-malic acid or 55.5 mMD-Glucose utilization was generally simultaneous to MLF but was completed (residual concentrations 0.2 mM) only in 6 of the 24 fermentation assays. These results support the use of these strains in directed MLF assays at the very differentL-malic acid andD-glucose concentrations tested.     

Intraspecific diversity of Oenococcus oeni strains determined by sequence analysis of target genes

Using molecular techniques and sequencing, we studied the intraspecific diversity of Oenococcus oeni, a lactic acid bacterium involved in red winemaking. A relationship between the phenotypic and genotypic characterization of 16 O. oeni strains isolated from wine with different levels of enological potential was shown. The study was based on the comparative genomic analysis by subtractive hybridization between two strains of O. oeni with opposite enological potential. The genomic sequences obtained from subtractive hybridization were amplified by polymerase chain reaction and sequenced for the 16 strains. A considerable diversity among strains of O. oeni was observed.     

Isolation and characterization of Oenococcus oeni from Aglianico wines

A technological characterization of Oenococcus oeni strains isolated from Aglianico wines was performed to select starter cultures for malolactic fermentation (MLF). One hundred and fifty six O. oeni isolates were extracted from Aglianico wines, and identified by using species-specific PCR. Malolactic activity (MLA), sulphur dioxide (SO₂) resistance, acetaldehyde metabolism and other technological characteristics were tested. Differences in the technologically relevant characteristics were observed. All O. oeni strains were able to grow at low temperature and none in presence of 14% of ethanol. About 80% of O. oeni degraded more than 80% of acetaldehyde, producing ethanol and acetic acid as final products. Among nine O. oeni chosen, four isolates were sensitive to 60 mg of SO₂ l⁻¹, while the other five had high resistance. Considering their technological characteristics, five O. oeni strains could be selected starter cultures for MLF in Aglianico.     

Cloning and characterisation of a cystathionine β/γ-lyase from two <Emphasis Type="Italic">Oenococcus oeni</Emphasis> oenological strains

Sulphur-containing compounds in wine have been extensively studied because of their effect on wine flavour and quality. In this study, an enzyme that degrades sulphur-containing amino acids was cloned and characterised from two Oenococcus oeni strains of oenological origins. The enzyme has features of a cystathionine-γ-lyase (EC 4.4.1.1), a pyridoxal-5-phosphate-dependent enzyme catalysing an α,γ-elimination reaction of l-cystathionine to produce l-cysteine, α-ketobutyrate and ammonia. Moreover, it was able to catalyse an α,β-elimination reaction producing homocysteine, pyruvate and ammonia from l-cystathionine. An elimination reaction of l-cysteine and dl-homocysteine was also efficiently catalysed by the enzyme, resulting in the formation of hydrogen sulphide. Furthermore, the ability to demethiolate methionine into methanethiol, an unfavourable volatile sulphur compound in terms of wine aroma, was observed. The findings of this work suggest that O. oeni seems to play a minor role in the production of volatile sulphur compounds during the vinification process as the optimal conditions were far from the harsh wine environment.     

A β-glucosidase from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Oenococcus oeni</Emphasis> ATCC BAA-1163 with potential for aroma release in wine: cloning and expression in <Emphasis Type="Italic">E. coli</Emphasis>

Lactic acid bacteria (LAB) are responsible for olfactory changes in wine during malolactic fermentation (MLF). A side characteristic of MLF is the release of grape derived aroma compounds from their glycosylated precursors by β-glycosidase activities of these bacteria. Apart from Oenococcus oeni, which is regarded as the most promising species for MLF, glycosidic activities have also been observed in wine related members of the genera Lactobacillus and Pediococcus. Nevertheless, information on the involved enzymes including their potential use in winemaking is limited. In this study we report that β-glucosidases with similar protein sequences can be identified in the genomes of Lactobacillus brevis, O. oeni and Leuconostoc mesenteroides. TTG serves as start codon for the glucosidase gene of O. oeni. The β-glucosidase of O. oeni ATCC BAA-1163 was expressed in E. coli and partially characterized. The enzyme displayed characteristics similar to β-glucosidases isolated from L. brevis and L. mesenteroides. A pH optimum between 5.0 and 5.5, and a K _m of 0.17 mmol L⁻¹ pNP-β-d-glucopyranoside were determined. A glycosyltransferase activity was observed in the presence of ethanol. The enzyme from O. oeni was capable to hydrolyze glycosides extracted from Muskat wine. This study also contains a report on glycosidase activities of several LAB species including Oenococcus kitaharae.     

Genotypic diversity in Oenococcus oeni by high-density microarray comparative genome hybridization and whole genome sequencing

Many bacteria display substantial intra-specific genomic diversity that produces significant phenotypic variation between strains of the same species. Understanding the genetic basis of these strain-specific phenotypes is especially important for industrial microorganisms where these characters match individual strains to specific industrial processes. Oenococcus oeni, a bacterium used during winemaking, is one such industrial species where large numbers of strains show significant differences in commercially important industrial phenotypes. To ascertain the basis of these phenotypic differences, the genomic content of ten wine strains of O. oeni were mapped by array-based comparative genome hybridization (aCGH). These strains comprised a genomically diverse group in which large sections of the reference genome were often absent from individual strains. To place the aCGH results in context, whole genome sequence was obtained for one of these strains and compared with two previously sequenced, unrelated strains. While the three strains shared a core group of conserved ORFs, up to 10% of the coding potential of any one strain was specific to that isolate. The genome of O. oeni is therefore likely to be much larger than that present in any single strain and it is these strain-specific regions that are likely to be responsible for differences in industrial phenotypes.     

Development of a New Method for Detection and Identification of Oenococcus oeni Bacteriophages Based on Endolysin Gene Sequence and Randomly Amplified Polymorphic DNA

Malolactic fermentation (MLF) is a biochemical transformation conducted by lactic acid bacteria (LAB) that occurs in wine at the end of alcoholic fermentation. Oenococcus oeni is the main species responsible for MLF in most wines. As in other fermented foods, where bacteriophages represent a potential risk for the fermentative process, O. oeni bacteriophages have been reported to be a possible cause of unsuccessful MLF in wine. Thus, preparation of commercial starters that take into account the different sensitivities of O. oeni strains to different phages would be advisable. However, currently, no methods have been described to identify phages infecting O. oeni. In this study, two factors are addressed: detection and typing of bacteriophages. First, a simple PCR method was devised targeting a conserved region of the endolysin (lys) gene to detect temperate O. oeni bacteriophages. For this purpose, 37 O. oeni strains isolated from Italian wines during different phases of the vinification process were analyzed by PCR for the presence of the lys gene, and 25 strains gave a band of the expected size (1,160 bp). This is the first method to be developed that allows identification of lysogenic O. oeni strains without the need for time-consuming phage bacterial-lysis induction methods. Moreover, a phylogenetic analysis was conducted to type bacteriophages. After the treatment of bacteria with UV light, lysis was obtained for 15 strains, and the 15 phage DNAs isolated were subjected to two randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD)-PCRs. By combining the RAPD profiles and lys sequences, 12 different O. oeni phages were clearly distinguished.     

Technological properties of Oenococcus oeni strains isolated from typical southern Italian wines

Aims: To isolate indigenous Oenococcus oeni strains suitable as starters for malolactic fermentation (MLF), using a reliable polyphasic approach. Methods and Results: Oenococcus oeni strains were isolated from Nero di Troia wines undergoing spontaneous MLF. Samples were taken at the end of alcoholic fermentation and during MLF. Wine samples were diluted in a sterile physiological solution and plated on MRS and on modified FT80. Identification of O. oeni strains was performed by a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) experiment using strain‐specific primers. Strains were further grouped using a multiplex RAPD‐PCR analysis. Then, six strains were inoculated in two wine‐like media with two different ethanol concentrations (11 and 13% vol/vol) with a view to evaluate their capacity to grow and to perform MLF. In addition, a quantitative PCR (qRT‐PCR) approach was adapted to monitor the physiological state of the strains selected. Conclusion: A positive correlation between the malolactic activity performance and the ability to develop and tolerate stress conditions was observed for two selected O. oeni strains. Significance and Impact of the Study: The results reported are useful for the selection of indigenous MLF starter cultures with desired oenological traits from typical regional wines. It should be the base for the improvement in organoleptic quality of typical red wine.     

The cytosolic pathway of l-malic acid synthesis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae: the role of fumarase

Saccharomyces cerevisiae accumulates l-malic acid but only minute amounts of fumaric acid. A ¹³C-nuclear magnetic resonance study following the label from glucose to l-malic acid indicates that the l-malic acid is synthesized from pyruvic acid via oxaloacetic acid. From this, and from previously published studies, we conclude that a cytosolic reductive pathway leading from pyruvic acid via oxaloacetic acid to l-malic acid is responsible for the l-malic acid production in yeast. The non-production of fumaric acid can be explained by the conclusion that, in the cell, cytosolic fumarase catalyzes the conversion of fumaric acid to l-malic acid but not the reverse. This conclusion is based on the following findings. (a) The cytosolic enzyme exhibits a 17-fold higher affinity towards fumaric acid than towards l-malic acid; the K _m for l-malic acid is very high indicating that l-malic acid is not an in vivo substrate of the enzyme. (b) Overexpression of cytosolic fumarase does not cause accumulation of fumaric acid (but rather more l-malic acid). (c) According to ¹³C NMR studies there is no interconversion of cytosolic l-malic and fumaric acids.     

A multiplex PCR method for simultaneous species identification and strain typification of Oenococcus oeni

Selected starter cultures of Oenococcus oeni are widely used to initiate malolactic fermentation (MLF) in wine. Nevertheless, the inoculated culture does not always develop as expected and undesired strains can grow causing wine spoilage. Therefore, methods that can reliably differentiate O. oeni strains are essential to monitor the population dynamics of MLF. This work presents a new multiplex PCR method that allows the simultaneous species identification and strain typification of O. oeni, based on the combined use of species-specific PCR primers and a Random Polymorphic DNA (RAPD)-PCR primer. This method represents an useful tool for the control of wine MLF.     

Histidine decarboxylase production by Lactobacillus hilgardii: Effect of organic acids

Histidine decarboxylase production from Lactobacillus hilgardii 5w, isolated from wine, was inhibited by the presence of l-malic acid in the basal culture medium. The inhibition was related to l-malic acid concentration. The maximal production of the enzyme at 12 h of culture incubated at 30°C was inhibited 71% by 2 g/L l-malic acid and 47% by 0.5 g/L. In these conditions l-malic acid consumption was 16% and 20% respectively. The addition of 300 mg/L citric acid to the basal medium stimulated the enzyme production from 9 to 45 nmoles/min/mg dry weight, and the increase was correlated with citric acid concentration. When different concentrations of l-malic acid were added to the basal medium plus 200 mg/L citric acid, reversion of stimulation was observed, achieving the maximum at a concentration of 2 g/L. In this case, citric acid comsumption was not modified, whereas L-malic acid utilization was higher.     

Correlation between indigenous <Emphasis Type="Italic">Oenococcus oeni</Emphasis> strain resistance and the presence of genetic markers

This study reports on monitoring Oenococcus oeni intraspecific diversity evolution during winemaking. Three different wines were monitored. The proportion of O. oeni species was determined by species-specific PCR and O. oeni strains were distinguished by multiplex PCR-RAPD. Each strain was tested by PCR for 16 significant markers revealed by a previous genetic comparison between a strong oenological potential strain and one with poor oenological potential. Population levels and diversity changed according to winemaking stages, oenological practices and the chemical properties of the wine. In all situations, O. oeni was the best-adapted species. Within the O. oeni group, intraspecific strain diversity decreased and the malolactic fermentation was the result of the most resistant strains with the highest number of markers.     

Purification of an alcohol dehydrogenase involved in the conversion of methional to methionol in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Oenococcus oeni</Emphasis> IOEB 8406

Oenococcus oeni, the major lactic acid bacteria involved in malolactic fermentation (MLF) in wine, is able to produce volatile sulfur compounds from methionine. Methional reduction is the last enzymatic step of methionol synthesis in methionine catabolism. Alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) activity was found to be present in the soluble fraction of O. oeni IOEB 8406. An NAD(P)H-dependent ADH involved in the reduction of methional was then purified to homogeneity. Sequencing of the purified enzyme and amino acid sequence comparison with the database revealed the presence of a conserved sequence motif specific to the medium-chain zinc-containing NAD(P)H-dependent ADHs. Despite the great importance of ADH activities in wine flavor modification, this is the first report of the purification of an ADH isolated from O. oeni. The purified ADH does not seem to be involved in the modification of buttery and lactic notes or to be involved in the specific formation of volatile alcohols during MLF. The enzyme was not strictly specific of methional reduction and the highest reducing activity was obtained with acetaldehyde as substrate. The function of the purified ADH remains unclear, although the role of the sulfur atom in methional molecules in the interaction between enzyme and substrate was evidenced.     

Oenococcus oeni preference for peptides: qualitative and quantitative analysis of nitrogen assimilation

Optimization of malolactic fermentation in wine depends mainly on better understanding of nitrogen nutritional requirements of Oenococcus oeni. Four widely used starter strains and the reference ATCC BAA-1163 strain were grown in media containing different N sources: free amino acids, oligopeptides (0.5–10 kDa) or polypeptides (> 10 kDa). Amino acid auxotrophies were determined by the single omission technique. The tested strains were indifferent to only two to four amino acids and two of the starter strains appeared to be particularly demanding. Nitrogen consumption was investigated and a significant level of nitrogen was consumed by O. oeni only in the free amino acid medium. In media containing complex nitrogen sources, a global balance above 5 mg N l⁻¹ was enough to ensure biomass formation of all tested strains. Moreover, for all strains, bacterial growth yield was higher in the presence of nitrogen from peptides than that from free amino acids. However, no direct relationship between the bacterial growth level and the amount of nitrogen metabolized could be established. These findings were discussed in relation to the physiology of wine malolactic bacteria.     

Growth and Arginine Metabolism of the Wine Lactic Acid Bacteria Lactobacillus buchneri and Oenococcus oeni at Different pH Values and Arginine Concentrations

During malolactic fermentation (MLF) in grape must and wine, heterofermentative lactic acid bacteria may degrade arginine, leading to the formation of ammonia and citrulline, among other substances. This is of concern because ammonia increases the pH and thus the risk of growth by spoilage bacteria, and citrulline is a precursor to the formation of carcinogenic ethyl carbamate (EC). Arginine metabolism and growth of Lactobacillus buchneri CUC-3 and Oenococcus oeni strains MCW and Lo111 in wine were investigated. In contrast to L. buchneri CUC-3, both oenococci required a higher minimum pH for arginine degradation, and arginine utilization was delayed relative to the degradation of malic acid, the main aim of MLF. This allows the control of pH increase and citrulline formation from arginine metabolism by carrying out MLF with pure oenococcal cultures and inhibiting cell metabolism after malic acid depletion. MLF by arginine-degrading lactobacilli should be discouraged because arginine degradation may lead to the enhanced formation of acids from sugar degradation. A linear relationship was found between arginine degradation and citrulline excretion rates. From this data, strain-specific arginine-to-citrulline conversion ratios were calculated that ranged between 2.2 and 3.9% (wt/wt), and these ratios can be used to estimate the contribution of citrulline to the EC precursor pool from a given amount of initial arginine. Increasing arginine concentrations led to higher rates of growth of L. buchneri CUC-3 but did not increase the growth yield of either oenococcus. These results suggest the use of non-arginine-degrading oenococci for inducing MLF.